New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

When is enough enough???

I employed "very similar" for a reason. I don't find parsing one exact number with another exact number, to be very useful in the context of my post. In order for them to be dispositive the difference would need to be considerably greater than even your cut 'n' paste allows.


it is.
 


I hinted that I don't respect your agendized cut 'n' paste. For whatever it's worth, the honest number is 93% as to black-on-black and 87% as to white-on-white. Again, I don't find that difference to be usefully relevant.
 
I hinted that I don't respect your agendized cut 'n' paste. For whatever it's worth, the honest number is 93% as to black-on-black and 87% as to white-on-white. Again, I don't find that difference to be usefully relevant.

honest to who?

certainly not the DOJ...
 
I'm sorry. It was seven robberies, not four.
"The 911 call received by the Oakland County Dispatch Center originated from a nearby business that had been a victim , as well as its employees, of seven robberies."

And as for the walking back and forth....
"The owner of a Pontiac business that's been robbed multiple times called 911, Sheriff Michael Bouchard said. The business reported that a man had walked back and forth in front of the business with his hands in his pockets, peering in the windows."

In the video, which is McKean's perspective instead of the cop's, the cop explains the report of him walking back and forth "three or four times".

http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/2014/12/03/police-man-hands-in-pockets-michigan/19799199/

Obviously the store owner was traumatized and now suspects everyone. This is about a store owner in that state of mind, calling police because he kept seeing the same person looking in the windows. We don't know what he saw going on outside his window before the last robberies took place. We don't know that McKean being black was what prompted him to call. Or was it just that McKean was hanging around in front of the store looking in?
But the internet is making this into a story about how this guy was just stopped for walking down the street.....because it sells. That is what's becoming a national problem.

Cops have to respond to calls. It's more respectful to get out and talk to a person than just 'watch' him. But the cops are being villified for responding to the call and assessing the situation. And not for nothing, but many years ago a boyfriend of mine (white) was sitting in his car waiting for me to come out of work when two cops banged on his window and gave him the third degree about why he was there and then one came in to my job and had me verify his story. One of the homeowners across the street from my job thought it seemed odd that someone would park and not get out of their car for five minutes.

You make a good point, in many of these cases - sadly the child killed in cleveland ( where it does appear the cops overreacted) and cases like this - it is people calling the cops saying.. hey check this person out - something doesn't seem right about his behavior. Its like the cops are damned if they do, damned if they don't. Now being called isn't enough to come in guns blazing or anything but I would really like to see statistics of how many times the police response that gets national attention because it has to do with a minority person, being "harassed" or what have you by the cops comes from the cops responding to a call. Even the whole Cambridge incident came from the cops responding to a call.

And, I wonder how much the race baiting and the agitating that people like Sharpton do, make it worse. For instance, IF the professor at Cambridge didn't have a chip on his shoulder about being "harrassed" would he have calmly said, guys hey, this is my house, let me show you xyz instead of reacting with anger and escalating the incident? Right or wrong, the cops come on a scene of a call "charged up" They come suspecting the worst. When you give them an indication of the worst because you are automatically hostile assuming they profiled you - versus responding to a call from someone else - is that compounding the problem?

I have been in my parents house when the alarm went off, they were not home, and I still lived at home, and I couldn't get the alarm to go off and couldn't find the house phone to answer it when the alarm company called. And, the police rolled up. And, they came in and were pretty direct - bordering on nasty and accusatory when they questioned me. But, I knew they were coming and I knew the would suspect me of at least not being supposed to be there. So, I was prepared and I didn't take offense to it. But, if you had been encouraged to take offense would it have gone down differently? I don't know.

connie
 
The "black on black" crime rate is actually very similar to the "white on white" crime rate. I heard a wise person say that black on black crime is just......crime.

Some people seem to think the percentage rate for black victims stems all from black on black crime.
 
You make a good point, in many of these cases - sadly the child killed in cleveland ( where it does appear the cops overreacted) and cases like this - it is people calling the cops saying.. hey check this person out - something doesn't seem right about his behavior. Its like the cops are damned if they do, damned if they don't. Now being called isn't enough to come in guns blazing or anything but I would really like to see statistics of how many times the police response that gets national attention because it has to do with a minority person, being "harassed" or what have you by the cops comes from the cops responding to a call. Even the whole Cambridge incident came from the cops responding to a call.

And, I wonder how much the race baiting and the agitating that people like Sharpton do, make it worse. For instance, IF the professor at Cambridge didn't have a chip on his shoulder about being "harrassed" would he have calmly said, guys hey, this is my house, let me show you xyz instead of reacting with anger and escalating the incident? Right or wrong, the cops come on a scene of a call "charged up" They come suspecting the worst. When you give them an indication of the worst because you are automatically hostile assuming they profiled you - versus responding to a call from someone else - is that compounding the problem?

I have been in my parents house when the alarm went off, they were not home, and I still lived at home, and I couldn't get the alarm to go off and couldn't find the house phone to answer it when the alarm company called. And, the police rolled up. And, they came in and were pretty direct - bordering on nasty and accusatory when they questioned me. But, I knew they were coming and I knew the would suspect me of at least not being supposed to be there. So, I was prepared and I didn't take offense to it. But, if you had been encouraged to take offense would it have gone down differently? I don't know.

connie

A major problem is being a minority. You find out quickly how the cops usually react as opposed to a white person. Hell, live in a white community, and go jogging every morning before going to work. You'll see how exciting a morning workout can be.
 
You make a good point, in many of these cases - sadly the child killed in cleveland ( where it does appear the cops overreacted) and cases like this - it is people calling the cops saying.. hey check this person out - something doesn't seem right about his behavior. Its like the cops are damned if they do, damned if they don't. Now being called isn't enough to come in guns blazing or anything but I would really like to see statistics of how many times the police response that gets national attention because it has to do with a minority person, being "harassed" or what have you by the cops comes from the cops responding to a call. Even the whole Cambridge incident came from the cops responding to a call.

And, I wonder how much the race baiting and the agitating that people like Sharpton do, make it worse. For instance, IF the professor at Cambridge didn't have a chip on his shoulder about being "harrassed" would he have calmly said, guys hey, this is my house, let me show you xyz instead of reacting with anger and escalating the incident? Right or wrong, the cops come on a scene of a call "charged up" They come suspecting the worst. When you give them an indication of the worst because you are automatically hostile assuming they profiled you - versus responding to a call from someone else - is that compounding the problem?

I have been in my parents house when the alarm went off, they were not home, and I still lived at home, and I couldn't get the alarm to go off and couldn't find the house phone to answer it when the alarm company called. And, the police rolled up. And, they came in and were pretty direct - bordering on nasty and accusatory when they questioned me. But, I knew they were coming and I knew the would suspect me of at least not being supposed to be there. So, I was prepared and I didn't take offense to it. But, if you had been encouraged to take offense would it have gone down differently? I don't know.

connie

And you know, the thing about the Cambridge case was that everything that cop did was protocol and was the kind of stuff that saves lives.
There was a call about someone breaking into the professor's house. The cop arrives at the house and finds the professor there, verifies that it is HIS house and then asks him to come outside. IT's simple. Though they've ascertained that the person they're interviewing is the homeowner, they still have this call of someone breaking in. They don't know if there's some home invader in a room in the house with a gun to the head of someone, threatening to shoot if the professor tells on him. So they take him outside where they can ask him questions he might be afraid to answer honestly inside the house. Also, if he were to tell them that yes, someone did break in and was holding someone somewhere in the house, they've removed him from danger associated with whatever they have to do next. And if he'd just shut up and listened the cop would have been able to explain that. And our says the cop "acted stupidly". No, he acted exactly the way he should have. Lives have been saved by cops doing exactly what that cop did.

Politicians and wannabe politicians, as well as highly paid pundits exploit any incident they can for their own benefit. They manufacture angst which become platforms for themselves, and then vengeance, and sit back and draw the rewards while we fight it out. Everybody needs a savior and these guys set themselves up as just that. Watch what happens in NY. The protests will die out in NY and the riots will still be going on in Ferguson.
 
Actually the c/p says the homicide rate for black male victims was....... it did not say black on black. It only states that homicides of black male victims is 31.67 per 100,000. The death of the black man in New York, who died from a choke hold, was listed as a homicide, ergo that is one homicide of a black male. The cop was white, not black on black.

Your glaring error is that you're downplaying the stats for black on black homicides which you know are statistically extremely higher than white on black homicides, almost ridiculously so......then taking an isolated case, maybe two in the past few years of white cop on black "homicide", and blowing it up to the heavens to underline your specious point.
 
Your glaring error is that you're downplaying the stats for black on black homicides which you know are statistically extremely higher than white on black homicides, almost ridiculously so......then taking an isolated case, maybe two in the past few years of white cop on black "homicide", and blowing it up to the heavens to underline your specious point.

I'm sorry, since I supposedly made a glaring error, please show me evidence. With white on white crime at 84%, and black on black at 93%, where do you get 'statistically extremely higher'?

My point is not specious, and there are far more incidents than the 'isolated case' you claim. You really need to read the news more often, because you seem to have missed the little girl in Detroit shot by a cop while she slept on the couch. And I could mention one hell of a lot more, just to dispel your ridiculous 'isloated case'.
 
This white guy (me) has grown out of his potential criminal phase (17-28) by now. But, I can remember that even as single white male, there were certain "rules" I needed to follow in order to set myself a part from the stereotypicism of the time. Some are proud to pronounce something along the lines that IF you're convinced that you've committed no crime, you needn't stop for a cop, much less answer his questions. I don't know if that's constititutionally/legally valid or not.

Fortunately, most of understand that these little nicieties enable us to HAVE police in the first place and they're a small price for us to pay in order for us to enjoy our rights. A system in which cops and cop institutions are routinely held liable after the fact, criminally and civilly, simply isn't viable.

Finally note that when Pres. Obama spoke on this issue, he didn't "choose sides".He went specifically to the idea that "some people feel" that the system is unfair. I agree, something must be done such that these "some people" perceive law enforcement in a better light.

Nevertheless, thinks like outreach, community policing, and associated efforts on behalf of cops to insuate themselves into poorer communities CAN'T work, if we're constantly hanging this civil/criminal charge "Sword of Damocles" over their heads.
 
This white guy (me) has grown out of his potential criminal phase (17-28) by now. But, I can remember that even as single white male, there were certain "rules" I needed to follow in order to set myself a part from the stereotypicism of the time. Some are proud to pronounce something along the lines that IF you're convinced that you've committed no crime, you needn't stop for a cop, much less answer his questions. I don't know if that's constititutionally/legally valid or not.

Fortunately, most of understand that these little nicieties enable us to HAVE police in the first place and they're a small price for us to pay in order for us to enjoy our rights. A system in which cops and cop institutions are routinely held liable after the fact, criminally and civilly, simply isn't viable.

Finally note that when Pres. Obama spoke on this issue, he didn't "choose sides".He went specifically to the idea that "some people feel" that the system is unfair. I agree, something must be done such that these "some people" perceive law enforcement in a better light.

Nevertheless, thinks like outreach, community policing, and associated efforts on behalf of cops to insuate themselves into poorer communities CAN'T work, if we're constantly hanging this civil/criminal charge "Sword of Damocles" over their heads.

I understand what you're trying to convey, but respect is a two way street. A cop has to earn respect just like any other citizen, and a cop should be held to the same laws as any other citizen.
 
Denial is also bubbling up all across this nation, it comes from the same source as the affliction.

How would you know? If I asked you to support your assertion that racism is bubbling up across the nation, how would you? Will you show me pictures of Ferguson, or post links to opinion pieces?
 
How would you know? If I asked you to support your assertion that racism is bubbling up across the nation, how would you? Will you show me pictures of Ferguson, or post links to opinion pieces?

Read some of the remarks here, gigi. "Blacks commit the most crimes" etc etc etc. And what would you think people's perception of someone would be if they just heard the persons name, and what kind of future would they have based on their name alone?

http://www.clickondetroit.com/news/how-does-your-name-affect-potential-success-in-life/29640276
 
Back
Top