New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

When were you wrong?

You're way ahead of me. I find myself surprised on a fairly regular basis.

I understand, Ark, that's why I mentioned my advantage regarding the life experience. If you had the same you'd probably be way ahead of many just like me- historical experience , the ability to analogize the situation which is not limited to a one certain place on the globe and extrapolate it to the whole humanity, your intelligence and logic .
I 100% sure , Ark, you would be right on the money always
 
The balanced budget came from Clinton and Gingrich. The VP doesn't have any power in that. But I agree that Al Gore was a priggish man. But then, Bush was a little priggish too in his own way. Many thought that Cheney was pulling the puppet strings there and maybe he was, but in my opinion......... doesn't matter who pulls the strings, the President gets the blame when things are done wrong so I rest all the mistakes of the Bush era on Bush himself.

Jen,Al Gore cut wasteful spending in the Government drastically. one of the reasons they balanced the budget. But he was a priggish man,who refused to let Clinton help him. That made the election close enough for Bush to steal
 
I was wrong a couple weeks ago when I said Bob Woodward was a legitimate journalist and not a partisan hack. And I was wrong to be against banning giant magazines used in mass shootings for ideological reasons. In the far past, I was wrong to be first a Democrat and later a Maoist.
 
I was wrong in supporting The Patriot Act 1.0 and Department of Homeland Security. I didn't bother to dig into the details. We didn't need it and we don't need it now.

I go pretty easy on those who went overboard on security issues in the immediate aftermath of 9/11. As hard as I am on most Democrats who veer right on issues like that, the first Patriot Act was arguably excusable, because it was set up as an emergency measure, in the aftermath of major attacks, with an automatic sun-setting date. For anyone who caught a case of "security fever" in the aftermath of those attacks, but then calmed down and got well, it's excusable. What bothers me more are those who never came to their senses -- who, even over a decade later, when they should have had more than enough time to get over their initial shock and learn more deeply about the issues, remain extremists. Those people disturb me.
 
Agreed the genius of buying 49 billion worth of GM stock and thinking it was a bad idea...is an error:



http://www.fool.com/investing/general/2013/03/14/will-gm-ever-repay-taxpayers.aspx

needless to say the error in thinking GM is a good investment....is none as long as you are a mouthpiece for thedemocrat party...but if you are of the political party which can do basic math...then you realize that not recouping the loss anytime soon and the interest payments accrued on the additional debt makes the buyout of GM a failed proposition....thus becoming American bailing out Democrat voter jobs again. Now that you have been shownn the error...please feel free to spin . How about you say that the loss at GM is actually debt reduction or something that inane?

I wasn't able to figure out what you were trying to say.
 
The government, using tax dollars, baling out a PRIVATE business is ALWAYS a bad idea.

It removes the fear of failure.

Too big to fail means too big to exist.

It was that moral hazard problem that had me initially opposing the GM bailout. However, the reason I switched was reading a very interesting analysis of why it was that Chinese manufacturing had developed a kind of "critical mass" that made it very hard to overcome (not just for high-wage places like the US, but low wage nations all around China). Once you locate a certain number of manufacturers within a certain small geographic area, you get network effects that make that area more attractive to businesses, and it keeps growing. But it works in reverse, too. If you lose too much manufacturing in an area, it loses the network effects and the economics can unravel for those that remain. For example, if GM dies, then a whole chain of suppliers in the area that depend on GM could die, too, which could make it no longer affordable to make Fords there, either, and so on. The economists advising Obama were understandably worried about Detroit and other US manufacturing hubs dipping below that "critical mass," creating a cascade of job destruction far beyond GM, if GM was allowed to fail. I'm not certain they were right, but it's a very serious concern, which at least arguably outweighs the moral hazard concern. Besides, the moral hazard concern wasn't as big an issue with the way the GM bailout was done. Waggoner and senior leadership were pushed out of a job and the GM shareholders took a bath, so a penalty was paid.

I share your concern about "too big to fail." It's a travesty that in the years since the bank bailouts, banks have been allowed to get even bigger than they were when they were too big to fail, and yet they're still allowed to take on huge risk. It's like "heads we win, tails you lose" for the bankers. One way this SHOULD be dealt with is criminal punishment for the actual lawbreakers, individually (and there were many). But, unfortunately, in this country wealthy people almost never get criminal penalties other than for hurting other wealthy people.
 
I was wrong a couple weeks ago when I said Bob Woodward was a legitimate journalist and not a partisan hack. And I was wrong to be against banning giant magazines used in mass shootings for ideological reasons. In the far past, I was wrong to be first a Democrat and later a Maoist.

Thanks for responding in the spirit of the exercise.
 
Mistakes of the right calls for me, depend upon the moment.

Yesterday one of my calls may have been way off, but today it's bounced back and so I could call it a good call. Normally I don't try to analyze my life by good calls or bad calls because life has taught me that what might have been a bad or good call yesterday or an hour ago or 30 years ago, could be the opposite at the moment when looking back. I feel very fortunate in life as survival seems to be about the challenge of living a relatively full life alongside lots of other people trying to do the same and figuring out how to live side by side and help one's own survival by pitching in with the survival of others who make our own lives better. Seems we're all interconnected in terms of support, yet some seem to think all they have and do has no connection, nor is supported in anyway by others or society. Good calls and bad calls politically to me are complex, since the weight is not on single incidents so much as weighing total positives against total negatives of any political, political party's or politician's "side".

I also feel a part of what may be ailing our national society and possibly the world is a lack of subjective universal values and some semblence of objective humility towards them. It seems that basic "rights" or "wrongs" are no longer objective universal values and mores that are recognized, taught and adhered to by the vast majority of humans, but have fallen into a world of subjectivity, double standards, hypocrisy and egocentric self-assured, self-righteousness, egocentric, myopic, vanity that offers the notion that since no one can be wrong in their own mind, essentially there is no wrong that cannot be dismissed, either through arrogance, denial or delusion of ourselves, the latter two or maybe all, suggesting either a mental dysfunction or an inherent dishonesty, perhaps fear, to face up to ourselves when it comes to our own failings.

I'm no different, I don't like to admit to myself my calls weren't spot on all the time, but I feel very very grateful for the balance of where the heavier weight has fallen over a fair number of decades.

I think it is a real challenge and a difficult one, to apply consistency in core universal values when the temptation to be subjective is very luring, perhaps so luring that we may be stuck in a limbo of sorts as a result. If we can simply think of ourselves as always being right and anyone we disagree with as always being wrong, even if they are doing the same thing we do (they're just doing in opposition to us, not for our benefit), there is no way for universal values to be applied, to others or to ourselves. I also believe that the more objective we are in our application of our values, both toward external situations (how we measure that others adhere to them) and our personal situations (whether we are truly honest with ourselves when we measure our own adherence to our own values) consistency looking back and going forward is found and perhaps more apt to be found in the future. It sure seems to make it easier too, when it comes to trying to twist and turn around double standards and hypocrisy.

In some ways, it may also honor all the time and energy our parents may have spent in teaching any values that would be considered universal in this day and age. Certainly, for any or all of us that may not practice it fully or even try to despite our occasional failings, honesty might be one value that most might consider universal because so many other things (most especially trust) depend upon it. If we'd lie to ourselves about ourselves, would we respect others more than we would respect ourselves that we would be more honest to others than we would be to ourselves? In short, if we'd lie to ourselves, who wouldn't we lie to?

It's a challenge and there is a lot of fear in this day and age of being wrong, yet the irony seems to be that lying to ourselves about who we are and our frailites, could suggest to anyone, that we are doing wrong, therefore wrong, the thing we fear being.

I think many people see all things in life as a competition with all others and on a base level, we all compete to survive and in an effort to rise to the level we want to achieve. Some try as hard as they can, but fate (the part we have no control over) keeps them from getting to where they want to be. Some others may not have the strength to resist some more pleasurable aspects of life (to them) that get in the way of their reaching where they want to be. Others seem to want to be on top, but there is no limit and no level of satisfaction that can be met, thus in many cases (not all) an unhappiness because enough is never enough. Others fall into becoming more than they really aspired to be and are happy to share their good fortune and wealth with others, not so fortunate. I'm not sure paradox would be the best way to describe it, but humans, as "social creatures" play dual roles in life that are at the same time contradictory to one another, but advantageous, at least in one sense, to the other. For example, I am typing on a piece of machinery and technology I did not invent and build, but it helps me compete and survive in this day and age as a tool for my work. Thus, I survive better because of the connection, networking and commerce of society as well as hopefully throw something into that "mixing pot" that does the same, but with an opposite flow.

Competition or comparing ourselves is a good way to exercise introspection, test our own honesty with ourselves and get a feel for how we're doing compared to others. We can deflate or elevate ourselves in the comparison or others will do that for us, not by deflating as much as promoting those that may appear to do better, the everlasting question being, how truly honest and objective we all are with ourselves and the self-assessments we make. At the same time, while we may compete with others for some resulting promotion or status, we also need to respect and get a long with those we compete with since they can be as or more helpful in our own survival as "beating them out" in a competition might be.
 
well, I'd start by saying "wrong" is a tad general and therefore doesn't really adequately measure what it is I think you're looking to measure with the question.

The only two things of any consequence I was "wrong" about in all my time on the internets, was thinking based on the polls, etc, that the dems might consider Bush's impeachment if they won in 2006, which Pelosi subsequently took off the table, and that Bush might bomb Iran before reality (and some military men) got in the way of that.

The point here is, there's a big difference between being "wrong" about things like that -- predictions -- where human decisions are involved, and being "wrong" about things where it's pure consideration of all the known facts regarding a particular matter, like the efficacy of Bush's tax cuts, whether he was criminally torturing and wiretapping, Iraq had wmds, or things like the reality of AGW. My record is spotless in the latter, and damn close to it on the former.

There is no shame in making an occasional mistake in judging the character of someone, etc, for example as you did with Collins and Snow, whereas there certainly should be in being a flat earther for any meaningful length of time after AGW became a major political issue. People like them can change or provide reasons why you should change your pov about them, whereas the facts that should have led one to come down on the side of AGW have never really changed so much as been added to, making it even more shameful to be a flat earther than it once was.
 
The balanced budget came from Clinton and Gingrich. The VP doesn't have any power in that. But I agree that Al Gore was a priggish man. But then, Bush was a little priggish too in his own way. Many thought that Cheney was pulling the puppet strings there and maybe he was, but in my opinion......... doesn't matter who pulls the strings, the President gets the blame when things are done wrong so I rest all the mistakes of the Bush era on Bush himself.

Oh,yes he did. Gore was put in charge of combining Departments and ending waste!
Don't you remember the loads of paper they wheeled out in the Rose Garden? Clinton said,Al was in charge of cutting the huge waste!
 
I was wrong, 30 seconds ago and then a coupla minutes before that.

But in the spirit of THIS exercise, I have no problem admitting that I was wrong about the GM/Chrysler effort, although I was 100% FOR it. I believed then and now, that it was something the United States of America simply HAD to try. Shit...remember how freaked out some were (and still are!) about our "surrenduring" the Panama Canal? Yet..virtually the SAME political demographic was four-square for out "cuttin' and runnin' " as to a couple of our greatest American assets AND symbols.

BUT...even as I believed that we had no choice but to give it a shot, I wasn't the least bit confident as to its ultimate success. In fact, I was pretty darned sure that the best we would accomplish was keeping them afloat for a few years longer - not that that was a bad thing, in the context of the Li'l Georgian Depression.

I never guessed that our GM/Chrysler effort would be such a remarkable success, and in such a short time. IMHO, the Obama Administration deserves one helluva lot of credit for that one, that they'll probably never get. Today, all we're debating is "should have", or "shouldn't have". We hear virtually nothing about what a miracle it all turned out to be.
 
Back
Top