New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Wow!

Well, you have a point, too, degsme. People like me are surely guilty of “letting that faith based motivation creep into all other aspects” and perhaps, in your way of thinking, corrupting many wonderful ideas and efforts. Yes, we are surely risk takers (unlike agnostics and atheists who don’t think hard enough to get scared or feel risky at all).

And there you go again.. creating a house of straw as a shield around your "faith". No you are not remotely a "risk taker" if anything agnostics are the risk takers - putting themsleves above your putative god. As for "wonderful ideas and efforts" - your "faith" precludes you from seeing that you don't need faith for them to exist.

As to verifiable facts about the “reality” of my God, can we leave that for another day?
Not when you invoke it as part of the strawman arguement you construct. See this is my core point about the abandonment of logic (and what got the Jesuits excommunicated for a period). By permitting yourself the luxoury of dismissing the rigor of valid reasoning when it comes to your "faith" - you allow that same sort of laxity in reasoning to echo in other aspects of your "reasoning". Its not a case of you "stiffing me" (I just figured you'd get back to it when you had marshalled more resources) - its that you are bringing that sort of lax view into the rest of your discussions.


But speaking of “faith based,” a newly adopted term for the convention,
No - its not. A recognition of "faith" has been in the Dem platform for a long time as has the inclusive nature. The elimination of one sect's terms is the only thing that was new to the proposed platform. And yes it was CYNICAL POLITICS on the part of Fox News and Conservatives that essentially forced that back into the platform.
 
James Carville said that it was not Obama's best speech and following on the heels of Bill Clinton it needed to be Obama's best speech.
Yup and I think Carville was wrong. Or else he's playing a "long game"... I never quite trust Carville's statements because he has a long history of seeking to affect longer term outcomes by pushing from the margins via hyperbole.

As for the "enthusiasm gap" - again, you are looking at the convention hall. and a WELL PITCHED Obama speech would have NECESSARILY had that enthusiasm gap. Why? Because Clinton's JOB was to fire up the base with "red meat". WJC's job was to go straight into the teeth of the GOP and throw elbows and rabbit punches. To Energize the base.

Obama's job was to reach BEYOND the arean to voters on the fence and appear Presidential and to play to HIS strengths - which in the public's eye (based on polling) is his willingness to seek compromise while remaining firm in his principles - and in his defence of the middle class (call it class warfare if you want, but that has political traction).
 
And there you go again.. creating a house of straw as a shield around your "faith". No you are not remotely a "risk taker" if anything agnostics are the risk takers - putting themsleves above your putative god. As for "wonderful ideas and efforts" - your "faith" precludes you from seeing that you don't need faith for them to exist.

Well, yes, I suppose you are right in that respect; i.e. agnostics and atheists do take some unimaginable risks, themselves. But we Christians do get routinely maligned for using our beliefs to cast our votes for the common good. No doubt those reasons are impenetrable to you at this stage. What “wonderful ideas and efforts” have we thwarted by secular do-gooders? I’m sure there is one or two, I just cannot think of any at this moment.

Not when you invoke it as part of the strawman arguement you construct. See this is my core point about the abandonment of logic (and what got the Jesuits excommunicated for a period). By permitting yourself the luxoury of dismissing the rigor of valid reasoning when it comes to your "faith" - you allow that same sort of laxity in reasoning to echo in other aspects of your "reasoning". Its not a case of you "stiffing me" (I just figured you'd get back to it when you had marshalled more resources) - its that you are bringing that sort of lax view into the rest of your discussions.

No, not really, degsme. You are correct, most of my arguments and reasoning assume the premise that Jesus Christ is God and heaven and hell are realities, et al., but that premise is not established by me based on assertions without empiriacle evidence, historical facts, reasons or truths.

But if you think I am going to repost pages and pages of commentary of mine from the past every time you say I have no evidence or reasons, well, that is just an impossibility. So maybe that will cause an impasse between you and me, I suppose, but that’s the breaks. However, every now again I will send out reminders and “new miracles” to demonstrate to you that my faith is hardly based on faith alone.



No - its not. A recognition of "faith" has been in the Dem platform for a long time as has the inclusive nature. The elimination of one sect's terms is the only thing that was new to the proposed platform. And yes it was CYNICAL POLITICS on the part of Fox News and Conservatives that essentially forced that back into the platform.

Cynical or not, Fox had a point. Your party is very hypocritical when it comes to Judeo-Christian beliefs, if not values. You act as though you are their friends when your actions belie that suggestion. We all suffer for it, too.
 
. But we Christians do get routinely maligned for using our beliefs to cast our votes for the common good.
No you get maligned for imposing your BELIEFS on others. See part of the problem is that you consider your BELIEFS to be part of "the common good". Among the ideas you have thwarted by OTHER FAITHS are the right of a woman to have control of her own body, the right of a woman to determine how many children she will have and when, the ability for nations to match their population growth to their resources, the right of two individuals to love one another as they see fit (and this includes inter-racial marriage which was opposed by most christian churches for the majority of their existance), the right of individuals to be think freely and logically (Eppur si muove), the right to pray OR NOT as you would see fit... just to name a few

No, not really, degsme. You are correct, most of my arguments and reasoning assume the premise that Jesus Christ is God and heaven and hell are realities, et al., but that premise is not established by me based on assertions without empiriacle evidence, historical facts, reasons or truths.
Yes it is. You can offer no empircal evidence nor validly consistent logic to support that belief. And Kant was much more eloquent and comprehensive in this point and you have offered nothing that disputes Kant's point.

But if you think I am going to repost pages and pages of commentary of mine from the past every time you say I have no evidence or reasons, well, that is just an impossibility.
You have yet to post a single page of actual VERIFIABLE FACT or valid reasoning. And that's the key. You basically take that strawman, belief based approach into the rest of your "reasoning".

Cynical or not, Fox had a point. Your party is very hypocritical when it comes to Judeo-Christian beliefs, if not values.
Um its not my party. Dems are way too conservative for me. That said no itis not hypocritical at all. In fact it is arguably LESS hypocritical than the GOP who's claims of "values" is so noxious the Catholic Bishops issued a condemnation letter about the claims by the GOP as having their policies based in Christian Teaching. You have not seen anything similar WRT the Dems. Welcoming in the plurality of faiths IS NOT HYPOCRITICAL. It is in fact what THE CONSTITUION DEMANDS.

And Fox was being hypocritical in asking the question - particularly in light of the Bishops' letter and the fact that their candidate (and there is no question Fox is politically aligned) is considered dogmatically, by YOUR CHURCH to be someone who "speaks for the Great Deceiver"....

You act as though you are their friends when your actions belie that suggestion.
There is nothing in the actions of the Dems that "belies" the welcoming of PERSONAL Faiths. But that is a vast difference between GOVERNMENTAL POLICIES DRIVEN BY A PARTICULAR RELIGIOUS DOGMA.

And you cannot seem to distinguish that.

You seem to take a failure to give YOUR dogma preferential treatment, with hostility to that dogma. That's just what the Taliban do.
 
Under Bush 2, as a matter of fact. Increased participation in the workforce as a result of decreased governmental pressure on job creators resulted in more tax receipts and lowering the income to spending ratio. Unfortunately, Bush being the spender he was, kept increasing spending on social programs and war funding.
 
Under Bush 2, as a matter of fact. Increased participation in the workforce as a result of decreased governmental pressure on job creators resulted in more tax receipts and lowering the income to spending ratio.
Except there was no "increased participation in the workforce" as a percentage of population....
 
You like it? It's the unemployment rate under Bush.

It's a pretty blue with squiggly lines. Can you make a squiggly line?
 
You like it? It's the unemployment rate under Bush.

It's a pretty blue with squiggly lines. Can you make a squiggly line?
Ah but we were talking about workforce participation not unemployment

And you still have not sourced it and you still have not added scale to it.
 
I have never been anything but gracious to you and Min. You two are the only Liberals for whom I have any respect.

Yeah, but,you still bite and both of us are rabid Dems. I changed my mind and went back full tilt when I observed who you are running!:eek:) So be careful.
 
Well, you have a point, too, degsme. People like me are surely guilty of “letting that faith based motivation creep into all other aspects” and perhaps, in your way of thinking, corrupting many wonderful ideas and efforts. Yes, we are surely risk takers (unlike agnostics and atheists who don’t think hard enough to get scared or feel risky at all).

As to verifiable facts about the “reality” of my God, can we leave that for another day? I know I already stiffed you once on not responding and I feel sort of bad about that.

But speaking of “faith based,” a newly adopted term for the convention, I did respond to their podium declaration and your post on that about an hour ago. Notice how phony or hypocritical it struck me.

JV,I am a Christian and believe the words that Jesus spoke,"To help the least of us," so what the Democrats try to do when in office suits me just fine.

I am really tired of those who speak the words, yet back a party that is the complete opposite of what the Bible teaches us!

There were a lot of people at that Convention who do not want Religion and politics mixed. I am one of them!

Ted Strickland is the one who brought that up. Now,I voted for Ted and am sorry Kasich won by 2% in the state,but think he should have left that one alone. He is a Minister so I can understand how he felt. That does not change my feeling.

Thomas Jefferson and Roger Williams,the founder of the Baptist Church thought the same way I do. That is why they worked together to make sure Freedom of Religion was put in to the Constitution. I still feel the same although a group of Baptists think differently today. I am not one of them.
 
Yeah, but,you still bite and both of us are rabid Dems. I changed my mind and went back full tilt when I observed who you are running!:eek:) So be careful.

God love you MaryAnne, Mary will catch on sooner or later. Let's hope it's sooner.:usa2:
 
No you get maligned for imposing your BELIEFS on others. See part of the problem is that you consider your BELIEFS to be part of "the common good". Among the ideas you have thwarted by OTHER FAITHS are the right of a woman to have control of her own body, the right of a woman to determine how many children she will have and when, the ability for nations to match their population growth to their resources, the right of two individuals to love one another as they see fit (and this includes inter-racial marriage which was opposed by most christian churches for the majority of their existance), the right of individuals to be think freely and logically (Eppur si muove), the right to pray OR NOT as you would see fit... just to name a few


Yes it is. You can offer no empircal evidence nor validly consistent logic to support that belief. And Kant was much more eloquent and comprehensive in this point and you have offered nothing that disputes Kant's point.


You have yet to post a single page of actual VERIFIABLE FACT or valid reasoning. And that's the key. You basically take that strawman, belief based approach into the rest of your "reasoning".


Um its not my party. Dems are way too conservative for me. That said no itis not hypocritical at all. In fact it is arguably LESS hypocritical than the GOP who's claims of "values" is so noxious the Catholic Bishops issued a condemnation letter about the claims by the GOP as having their policies based in Christian Teaching. You have not seen anything similar WRT the Dems. Welcoming in the plurality of faiths IS NOT HYPOCRITICAL. It is in fact what THE CONSTITUION DEMANDS.

And Fox was being hypocritical in asking the question - particularly in light of the Bishops' letter and the fact that their candidate (and there is no question Fox is politically aligned) is considered dogmatically, by YOUR CHURCH to be someone who "speaks for the Great Deceiver"....


There is nothing in the actions of the Dems that "belies" the welcoming of PERSONAL Faiths. But that is a vast difference between GOVERNMENTAL POLICIES DRIVEN BY A PARTICULAR RELIGIOUS DOGMA.

And you cannot seem to distinguish that.

You seem to take a failure to give YOUR dogma preferential treatment, with hostility to that dogma. That's just what the Taliban do.

Very good points,Degsme,and you know what I am!
 
Yeah, but,you still bite and both of us are rabid Dems. I changed my mind and went back full tilt when I observed who you are running!:eek:) So be careful.

I just think you both are too smart to be Democrats. It takes such a great suspension of logic and common sense to support the Democrat agenda, platform and tactics.
 
No you get maligned for imposing your BELIEFS on others. See part of the problem is that you consider your BELIEFS to be part of "the common good". Among the ideas you have thwarted by OTHER FAITHS are the right of a woman to have control of her own body, the right of a woman to determine how many children she will have and when, the ability for nations to match their population growth to their resources, the right of two individuals to love one another as they see fit (and this includes inter-racial marriage which was opposed by most christian churches for the majority of their existance), the right of individuals to be think freely and logically (Eppur si muove), the right to pray OR NOT as you would see fit... just to name a few

Since this thread got resurrected I may as well tell you this is a bunch of baloney. First of all, your word “impose” must really give you comfort. I guess an American Christian exercising his right of free speech is impose to you. I guess when that same Christian campaigns to have other vote a certain way, or casts their own vote for a candidate because they better represent Christian values, that is impose to you. Now because the law once said that abortion was illegal that was only because Christians unconstitutionally imposed their wants upon America? I suppose because 31 states all voted against gay marriage in the last 8 years that is because Christians unfairly imposed their way upon the general population?

Where is it you can speak publicly for your wants or your laws or your discontinuation of certain laws as some secular firebrand, and this is all fine ---- but if a Christian does the exact same thing it is now an imposition? Where do you come off telling society gay marriage absolutely is constitutional and cannot be any other way? Where do you come off telling science and the rest of the world that any baby in any womb is not a human being and has no rights to life? But if we say that killing a 7 month old unborn child is wrong and should be illegal, we are now imposing?


Yes it is. You can offer no empirical evidence nor validly consistent logic to support that belief. And Kant was much more eloquent and comprehensive in this point and you have offered nothing that disputes Kant's point.

Look, I did not realize that God was born in 18th century Prussia, but we have good reason to say, sorry, but your hubris is something to behold. I have so little desire to make a lengthy case for empirical evidence for the Judeo-Christian God to you, but when you and yours stop giving me answers like “we just do not know yet” then I will stop accusing you of displaying a total lack of deduction and reasoning. It almost comes back to the argument “it looks, walks, feels, smells, and quacks like a duck,” but because you can’t be absolutely certain it’s a duck, you won’t even consider it is one until then. And you and Kant call that deploying reason.

Fatima is a miracle, empirical evidence beyond any doubt. So is the statue of Mary in Akita, Japan that wept tears of blood 101 times. But for you, because science has discovered so many things, “we just don’t know yet but it surely is no proof for God” will always be the standard response and party line. Because you could never admit to being wrong, I get it.


Um its not my party. Dems are way too conservative for me. That said no itis not hypocritical at all. In fact it is arguably LESS hypocritical than the GOP who's claims of "values" is so noxious the Catholic Bishops issued a condemnation letter about the claims by the GOP as having their policies based in Christian Teaching. You have not seen anything similar WRT the Dems. Welcoming in the plurality of faiths IS NOT HYPOCRITICAL. It is in fact what THE CONSTITUION DEMANDS.

No, haven’t seen a letter, but I have seen decades of Catholic and conservative Christians publicly campaigning against legalized abortion and gay marriage and stem cell research and the destruction of fertilized embryos and the way the word ‘God’ is treated as a four letter word in schools and public places. You don’t seem to understand that being a Christian is more about sin and salvation than it is about how do we feed the poor? You also don’t seem to realize that Christians give more of their own personal funds to charity than your secular humanist counterparts.


There is nothing in the actions of the Dems that "belies" the welcoming of PERSONAL Faiths. But that is a vast difference between GOVERNMENTAL POLICIES DRIVEN BY A PARTICULAR RELIGIOUS DOGMA.

Oh, no doubt you welcome all democrats of the Christian faith ---- providing they shut up and keep their faith to themselves. And let you secular humanists make all the decisions. You know... Obama kind of Christians. So welcome.


And you cannot seem to distinguish that. You seem to take a failure to give YOUR dogma preferential treatment, with hostility to that dogma. That's just what the Taliban do.

You see, you only sound convincing to your ambivalent followers when you speak in terms of polar extremes. Christians are not welcome because according to you we insist our “dogma receive preferential treatment.” Christians are very much like the Taliban because we come off as [my interpretation from your words] intolerant of those who do not agree with us and therefore are as dangerous or likely to behave like the Taliban.

Well, when you put it that way, degsme, I want no part of Christians either. The democrats are great thinkers.
 
Since this thread got resurrected I may as well tell you this is a bunch of baloney. First of all, your word “impose” must really give you comfort. I guess an American Christian exercising his right of free speech is impose to you.
It can be. Depends. For example - at the Ellensburg Rodeo Last monday - after ranting about Freedom of Religion, the announcer, with the Yakama Nation's sacred ritual dancers IN THE ARENA, invoked the Christian/Desert "god" as an example of it. In the process imposing his version of religion on ALL of us. And it was clearly not an inclusive "benediction" precisely because just before doing so he derided the notion of a moment of silence for EACH OF US to benedict as OUR PERSONAL traditions allowed us to.

Now sure - it was private property and he was doing so on behalf of the property owners....OTOH Township moneys go into this event every year, and I bought tickets to a rodeo - not to being preached at.

So it was his free speech RIGHT... and it also was an imposition on me and the Yakama and others.

And all that the Obama administration has done is to insure that UNLIKE in Ellensburg - PUBLIC PROTECTIONS are not used to engage in that sort of imposition.

Yes it is. You can offer no empirical evidence nor validly consistent logic to support that belief. And Kant was much more eloquent and comprehensive in this point and you have offered nothing that disputes Kant's point.


Look, I did not realize that God was born in 18th century Prussia, but we have good reason to say, sorry, but your hubris is something to behold.
Nice attempt at a deflection. The point is that SINCE 18th century Prussia NO ONE on the religious side of the aisle has refuted Kant's Critique of Pure Reason... And since you can offer ZERO independently verifiable evidence of the existance of "god" much less his/her "birth" you are basically just ducking the point.

Again you have done nothing to address Kant's comprehensively argued point that if you cannot show God's existinance rationally - and we cannot - that you must accept his existance irrationally.

Fatima is a miracle, empirical evidence beyond any doubt.
Not even close. Fatima is a story. There is no actual verifiable or negatable prediction that was made, nor is there comprehensive, independent evidence of that prediction coming true. Fatima is the quintessential case of Post Hoc Reasoning Fallacy. the Mary in Akita can be explained with basic stage magician tricks. So there is no need for "god" to exist for either of these to have occurred. QED there is not even "preponderance of evidence" to suggest these are "miracles".

In fact it is arguably LESS hypocritical than the GOP who's claims of "values" is so noxious the Catholic Bishops issued a condemnation letter about the claims by the GOP as having their policies based in Christian Teaching.
No, haven’t seen a letter,
Ah so now ignorance is an excuse for you to put YOUR BELIEFS ahead of the teachings of the leaders of your faith...INTERESTING.. http://www.washingtonpost.com/opini...88fff8-e53b-11e1-9739-eef99c5fb285_story.html You can go read the letter in the public Congressional Record.

the way the word ‘God’ is treated as a four letter word in schools and public places
Again, "god" has no business being used by people in the employ of the Government as they spend taxpayer $$... Because that is a violation of the 1st Amendment.

There is nothing in the actions of the Dems that "belies" the welcoming of PERSONAL Faiths. But that is a vast difference between GOVERNMENTAL POLICIES DRIVEN BY A PARTICULAR RELIGIOUS DOGMA
Oh, no doubt you welcome all democrats of the Christian faith ---- providing they shut up and keep their faith to themselves.
Notice you did not address the question and instead tried to redirect to a red herring. That is a LOGICAL FALLACY.. again irrationality rather than reasoning. the faithful have EQUAL VOICE to participate democratically.. but they CANNOT ask the government to use its power on the behalf of their FAITH driven BELIEFS.

Christians are very much like the Taliban because we come off as [my interpretation from your words] intolerant of those who do not agree with us and therefore are as dangerous or likely to behave like the Taliban.
Which is precisely what you do. And what your post is filled with. You are intolerant of any critical reasoning about Fatima. You are intolerant of any challenge to your efforts to prostelitize - you name call. You are intolerant of those who would question the consistency of your support for Ryan and your faith.

Yup
 
Back
Top