New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Yes it is time

Now they are saying it's not about the rules on having these issues, but the co-pay. then it's about a church has the right, then it's about a hospital has a right, then it's about a college has the right, then will it go over to all the businesses that the church owns?


I'm thinking it is about a few republican Catholic members of the Church have found a knife to carve up Obama with. They don't give a shit if you have a pill or not.
 
Are there any non-third world countries besides the USA that do not have universal government health care?
 
Are there any non-third world countries besides the USA that do not have universal government health care?

Does it matter? I can point to a number of first-world countries that don't protect freedom of speech as the U.S. does, does that mean the U.S. should emulate them in that area?
 
Canada. Germany. France. England.

All contain various restrictions on speech. Canada, for example, has this in its charter dating to 1982, "The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees the rights and freedoms set out in it subject only to such reasonable limits prescribed by law as can be demonstrably justified in a free and democratic society." This not the unlimted political speech enjoyed in the U.S., but only freedom to "justified" free speech. About 8 years ago, a Canadian official set "we don't subscribe to the freem market of ideas..." (he was speaking to a case in which a journalist was put on trial over a series of magazine articles many Muslims found offensive, even though there was nothing non-factual in the articles).

Germany: In Germany "insult" is a punishable crime, as is holocaust denial (if you're a boob who doesn't believe in the Holocaust in the U.S., you can air your boobery to your heart's content).

France: In France, it is a criminal offense to punish the "positive presentation" of drug use (the editors of "High Times" magazine would be subject to up to five years in prison under French law). Publications criticizing this law have been fined for airing the criticism.

England/United Kingdom: Speech and writing can't "imagine" the death of the monarch. You can be arrested for having or writing things deemed illegal under the Terrorism Act of 2000. There are numerous other complexities based on common law.

In America, we have certain "hate speech" restrictions, and even those are controversial. Other than that you are free to speak your mind, so long as you incite no one to direct action. You can say, "X must die." You can't say "Go kill X."

So bottom line, no, I don't think America should emulate the behaviors of other countries in this regard. America has it's own system of government, a government that is supposed to consist of limited powers, recited in the U.S. Constitution. I've read that document -- I've missed, somehow, the part that empowers the government to provide universal health care, or to require that I purchase my own health care insurance.
 
if a constitution does not specifically prevent the government from doing something, then,as representatives of the majority, the government has the power to do it.
 
There are a number of ways a single-payer system could be constitutional. Interstate commerce: Precedent: government supplies mail system, railways, etc. a more relevant precedent: Medicare (essentially a single-payer system for the poor and elderly, if it's allowed for them, why not everyone else?), Social Security.

You could also make the argument that it "promotes the general welfare" but I think that's a bit shakier.

Necessary and proper clause expands the previous two clauses even further, if the government can make the case that giving health care is necessary and proper to regulating interstate commerce/promoting the general welfare
 
you know it is all about election season. Everything gets talked about and nothing gets done.
 
Back
Top