New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Yo Catholics...

Do you always presume what people advocate? Did I say that?






FY.... if a nation closes it's borders (which Trump has not advocated anyway ya liar ) it's because of security from disease, from enemies, from illegal entry, etc.

It's not shutting out the poor no matter how you twist it to defend the dude.

I presume nothing. I didn't see any other alternative to appease your comments, hence the question mark at the end of the sentence.

Yet the poor would be much more significantly impacted than any other group, by the wall or by suspending the immigration of Muslims from the ME. To stop maybe one or two bad people, if you're lucky? Hardly worth it to me, also seems mighty unchristian.

I still don't see the Pope's hypocrisy.
 
You would advocate for the destruction of 400 year old walls then? The popes comments were in regards to a religious practice of giving to the poor and allowing the poor to seek out a better life. Religion has little to do with a nation, however, nations have everything to do with the actual practice of religion. If a nation closes its borders, it no longer cares for the poor from another nation who may seek a better life. How Christian is that?

I think the Pope was speaking in a language that Boca, despite his name, does not understand.
 
I didn't know I was going to see him until I got inside. Then I understood why I had been wanded.

Must have been magical, and I'm not even religious.

I was in Crete that same trip and witnessed an Eastern Orthodox procession and consequent burning of Judas at a church in a small town, a huge bonfire, and it seemed so surreal to me.

Religion is strong medicine. That's for sure.
 
Last edited:
Must have been magical, and I'm not even religious.

I was in Crete that same trip and witnessed an Eastern Orthodox procession and consequent burning of Judas at a church in a small town, a huge bonfire, and it seemed so surreal to me.

Religion is strong medicine. That's for sure.

I am not Catholic, I don't get into heavy ritual. I don't do it and I'm not enthralled by it. But I do enjoy watching it sometimes. I knew the words to the songs they sang in that Mass because I had been in college and high school choirs that did that stuff. So I figured out the repetitive tune and sang along.

Processions like the one you saw are definitely surreal. Eastern Orthodox is kind of creepy to me. In Italy I watched a procession of people in black with torches on All Saint's Eve walking from the church up the mountain to the cemetery. That was a serious Halloween observation.:eek:
 
I am not Catholic, I don't get into heavy ritual. I don't do it and I'm not enthralled by it. But I do enjoy watching it sometimes. I knew the words to the songs they sang in that Mass because I had been in college and high school choirs that did that stuff. So I figured out the repetitive tune and sang along.

Processions like the one you saw are definitely surreal. Eastern Orthodox is kind of creepy to me. In Italy I watched a procession of people in black with torches on All Saint's Eve walking from the church up the mountain to the cemetery. That was a serious Halloween observation.:eek:

Well put.

Being raised Protestant I always envied my Catholic friends with their Holy Water, Hail Marys and deep, dark rituals.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
I wasn't screened, and I was able to meander about in front of the Basilica, that's an interesting plaza; I went to the Vatican Post Office and mailed some post cards then went and stood in line to enter St. Peters. I waited and entered, marveled about and took a few pictures and left for lunch, not once being accosted by anyone.

I was so moved and convinced I'd missed something I went back after lunch, and the only difference was the line being shorter.

Were you able to set up a tent in the Piazza San Pietro and declare yourself a resident? Because THAT is what the pope was advocating that we do with illegals by not protecting our border. Get back to us when you stop wanting to compare apples to oranges...
 
Were you able to set up a tent in the Piazza San Pietro and declare yourself a resident? Because THAT is what the pope was advocating that we do with illegals by not protecting our border. Get back to us when you stop wanting to compare apples to oranges...

You're smarter than this...

“A person who thinks only about building walls, wherever they may be, and not building bridges, is not Christian,"
 
your Mullah says, in so many nuanced words, the United States has no right to protect it's borders even as he lives behind walls like a 1%er from Scarsdale or Grosse Point.

What say you?

Stand up. Be counted!
Ummm, that's not what the Pope said. Heck, even Trump is soft-pedaling his response.

http://www.bbc.com/news/election-us-2016-35610126
Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump has heaped praise on Pope Francis, hours after the pontiff questioned his Christian faith.

The Pope had said Mr Trump's proposal to build a wall on the US border with Mexico was not Christian, provoking a strong response from the businessman.

But hours later, at a town hall event in South Carolina, the billionaire hotel developer was more conciliatory.

Republican voters in the US state will make their presidential choice in days.

Mr Trump leads the South Carolina polls and he took to a stage in Columbia on Thursday evening to answer questions on national television.

When asked about his row with the Pope, he said he wouldn't describe it as a fight, although he later said he didn't like fighting with him.

Analysis - Jon Sopel, North America editor
Did Mr Trump need to take on the Pope? Well, almost certainly yes.

Because in God-fearing South Carolina, the next state to vote in the primary process - to have the Pope say that he is un-Christian is potentially very damaging.

And over the course of the campaign, the billionaire property developer has been at pains to prove his religious credentials, appearing at rallies with a copy of the Bible that his mother had given him as a child.

Trump v Pope... who wins?

"I have a lot of respect for the Pope. He has a lot of personality and I think he's doing a very good job, he has a lot of energy."

He said the pontiff was misinformed when he criticised the proposed wall, because he was not aware of the drugs coming in and the other security problems that made a strong border a necessity......
 
You're smarter than this...

“A person who thinks only about building walls, wherever they may be, and not building bridges, is not Christian,"

The unfortunate fact is that open borders with a generous welfare state does not work. Look at what it's doing to the left's vaunted "Scandinavian Model:"

http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/ca036e9e-c9a6-11e5-a8ef-ea66e967dd44.html

I think you're smart enough to that. So I'm left wondering why, exactly, you think we should follow them down that rathole.
 
The unfortunate fact is that open borders with a generous welfare state does not work. Look at what it's doing to the left's vaunted "Scandinavian Model:"

http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/ca036e9e-c9a6-11e5-a8ef-ea66e967dd44.html

I think you're smart enough to that. So I'm left wondering why, exactly, you think we should follow them down that rathole.

There are no open borders. The Pope did not say do not protect borders.

Why you continue on this path is a total mystery.
 
The unfortunate fact is that open borders with a generous welfare state does not work. Look at what it's doing to the left's vaunted "Scandinavian Model:"

http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/ca036e9e-c9a6-11e5-a8ef-ea66e967dd44.html

I think you're smart enough to that. So I'm left wondering why, exactly, you think we should follow them down that rathole.
Agreed about the financial aspect. Of course, the Pope and other religious leaders are concerned about our eternal spiritual well-being, not our temporary mortal concerns.

That said, the solution to illegal immigration isn't a [Unwelcome language removed] wall at a cost of 7-10 BILLION per year. Stop the reason illegals come here: legislate and enforce laws against those supporting illegals and drawing them here. Locking up a few construction company and hotel owners will severely reduce the problem.
 
your Mullah says, in so many nuanced words, the United States has no right to protect it's borders even as he lives behind walls like a 1%er from Scarsdale or Grosse Point.

What say you?

Stand up. Be counted!

I am no fan of this Pope. He's a raving socialist whose opinions mean zero to me.

He issues these comments, all the while living in Vatican City...a veritable fortress.
 
There are no open borders. The Pope did not say do not protect borders.

Why you continue on this path is a total mystery.

Then we're left once again with one of the progressive "chase your tail" arguments where we can't do anything we want to do about the problem but you're not against us doing "something" about the problem. That's how you end up in the Nordic rathole...
 
Then we're left once again with one of the progressive "chase your tail" arguments where we can't do anything we want to do about the problem but you're not against us doing "something" about the problem. That's how you end up in the Nordic rathole...

Man...shark jumping has become your expertise.

Many people have proposed many possible solutions. I'm one of the many who wants to begin with employers...making them responsible for hiring illegals...going as far as taking away their business charters and licenses.

So...again...Vatican City is a medieval walled city comprising a scant 110 acres and has been since the 1600's. There simply is no relative comparison between the walls there...and a desire to build ONLY walls across a 2000 mile long border.

For more comparisons of scale, The White House and Ellipse cover 52 acres. So...double that to imagine the ancient city. Catholics worldwide are assisting the refugees.
 
Man...shark jumping has become your expertise.

Many people have proposed many possible solutions. I'm one of the many who wants to begin with employers...making them responsible for hiring illegals...going as far as taking away their business charters and licenses.

So...again...Vatican City is a medieval walled city comprising a scant 110 acres and has been since the 1600's. There simply is no relative comparison between the walls there...and a desire to build ONLY walls across a 2000 mile long border.

For more comparisons of scale, The White House and Ellipse cover 52 acres. So...double that to imagine the ancient city. Catholics worldwide are assisting the refugees.

Okay, that's fine for a start. But what about those who come here not to work, but rather to collect welfare? Or to engage in a criminal endeavor? Is it only the workers we should reject?
 
Okay, that's fine for a start. But what about those who come here not to work, but rather to collect welfare? Or to engage in a criminal endeavor? Is it only the workers we should reject?

For some reason...I don't concern myself with lesser issues that seem to originate from the caboose of the Xenophobia Express.

Those that come here...for nefarious purposes...will be ferreted out through time as their nefarious activities become known. The screamingly obvious question is: How do you...and I do mean YOU...determine if one is coming...to collect welfare...or commit crime?
 
For some reason...I don't concern myself with lesser issues that seem to originate from the caboose of the Xenophobia Express.

Those that come here...for nefarious purposes...will be ferreted out through time as their nefarious activities become known. The screamingly obvious question is: How do you...and I do mean YOU...determine if one is coming...to collect welfare...or commit crime?

If they are coming to stay (not visit) and cannot work, due to, say, mandatory e-verify, then I think it is a pretty clear indication that they should have to go. But if we can't control the border without being accused of being xenophobic Nazis, then we can't prevent them from coming in and getting away with it until they get caught. This isn't rocket science. Why do we have to tolerate a border control policy that doesn't, well, control the border?
 
If they are coming to stay (not visit) and cannot work, due to, say, mandatory e-verify, then I think it is a pretty clear indication that they should have to go. But if we can't control the border without being accused of being xenophobic Nazis, then we can't prevent them from coming in and getting away with it until they get caught. This isn't rocket science. Why do we have to tolerate a border control policy that doesn't, well, control the border?

Coming to stay? Exactly who are you speaking of here?

Stop acting like xenophobic nazis then...and labeling the majority of emigrees and refugees as criminals...and I'll stop considering such policies to be xenophobic.
 
Back
Top