New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Yo Catholics...

Coming to stay? Exactly who are you speaking of here?

Stop acting like xenophobic nazis then...and labeling the majority of emigrees and refugees as criminals...and I'll stop considering such policies to be xenophobic.

Well if they aren't then what are they? What exactly is your policy preference here? We can't reject them, we can't hire them, so what CAN we do with them?
 
Well if they aren't then what are they? What exactly is your policy preference here? We can't reject them, we can't hire them, so what CAN we do with them?

If they aren't criminals? If they are refugees harmed in the wars we bring to the world?

We take them in. Folks like Catholic Charities help them. Communities embrace them...
 
If they aren't criminals? If they are refugees harmed in the wars we bring to the world?

We take them in. Folks like Catholic Charities help them. Communities embrace them...

So open borders and open arms. And presumably now that they are no longer "illegal" they can get jobs, collect welfare, free healthcare, etc. You do know that this is exactly the immigration policy that is currently tearing Europe asunder and destroying even the Nordic Model of democratic socialism, right? This is why I view progressives with, well, fear and loathing. They know their policies are leading to our (eventual) destruction as a society, but they continue to advocate for them anyway out of some misguided messianic ideological instinct.
 
So open borders and open arms. And presumably now that they are no longer "illegal" they can get jobs, collect welfare, free healthcare, etc. You do know that this is exactly the immigration policy that is currently tearing Europe asunder and destroying even the Nordic Model of democratic socialism, right? This is why I view progressives with, well, fear and loathing. They know their policies are leading to our (eventual) destruction as a society, but they continue to advocate for them anyway out of some misguided messianic ideological instinct.

Nope...not "open" borders.

Open arms? Yeah, to refugees harmed by our wars and meddling and support of terrorism around the globe for years and years. It is part of our history. It is what we, as "Americans", do. Give me your tired, your poor, yearning to be free...and all that jazz.

I recall how severely you inflated the numbers...as the US is planning on accepting 10,000 Syrians...which you manged to call "millions"...

Indeed, two of the Republican candidates for President come from refugee families...and they were welcomed. Do remember, the US supported Batista...and he was no saint.

We did this just a little while back...

Truly hysterical...

"at least one poster"....becomes "our liberals"...

I don't care about country of origin; I care about the skills and talents folks bring.

This is a different category than refugees...Poor folks whose lives have been disrupted by the powers in the world. As usual, xenophobes whine incessantly about any such incursion of foreigners, (aka, The Paranoid Style) but today, we see Vietnamese and Cambodian and Laotian refugees families becoming contributors to the great US global melting pot culture.

This is why conservatives make me nervous; they do not seem to digest the world.
 
Nope...not "open" borders.

Open arms? Yeah, to refugees harmed by our wars and meddling and support of terrorism around the globe for years and years. It is part of our history. It is what we, as "Americans", do. Give me your tired, your poor, yearning to be free...and all that jazz.

I recall how severely you inflated the numbers...as the US is planning on accepting 10,000 Syrians...which you manged to call "millions"...

Indeed, two of the Republican candidates for President come from refugee families...and they were welcomed. Do remember, the US supported Batista...and he was no saint.

We did this just a little while back...



This is why conservatives make me nervous; they do not seem to digest the world.

I'm not falling for the old "honest, this is aaaaall we want" argument. Baby steps, baby steps...and before you know it we're a socialist country collapsing under the weight of welfare and unchecked immigration (like the Nordic countries are right now - you ARE aware of the progressives "we want to be just like Scandinavia" mantra, right?).

http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/ca036e9e-c9a6-11e5-a8ef-ea66e967dd44.html

That's why progressives make ME nervous; they do not seem to digest the world.
 
So open borders and open arms. And presumably now that they are no longer "illegal" they can get jobs, collect welfare, free healthcare, etc. You do know that this is exactly the immigration policy that is currently tearing Europe asunder and destroying even the Nordic Model of democratic socialism, right? This is why I view progressives with, well, fear and loathing. They know their policies are leading to our (eventual) destruction as a society, but they continue to advocate for them anyway out of some misguided messianic ideological instinct.

I can't disagree with your statements as fact, I can only argue on a moral ground. First, I am a believer in being better than your enemy, not by a bit but by a long shot. Second I was raised catholic, and am now agnostic. Third I believe in freedom and the moral principles that guide us to freedom. With those three things in mind then yes to every question you asked and every statement you made.

If we subject ourselves to the same moral misguidance our enemies do, what separates us? Even if it is a bit of a difference. With our cherished freedom comes fear and sacrifice that has to be maintained to ensure the sanctity of our freedom. Those are acceptable losses, and they have to be.
 
I can't disagree with your statements as fact, I can only argue on a moral ground. First, I am a believer in being better than your enemy, not by a bit but by a long shot. Second I was raised catholic, and am now agnostic. Third I believe in freedom and the moral principles that guide us to freedom. With those three things in mind then yes to every question you asked and every statement you made.

If we subject ourselves to the same moral misguidance our enemies do, what separates us? Even if it is a bit of a difference. With our cherished freedom comes fear and sacrifice that has to be maintained to ensure the sanctity of our freedom. Those are acceptable losses, and they have to be.

So I'm a bit confused. Are you saying that you agree that our current trajectory has us on a collision course with a Euro-style social and economic collapse, but that we should pursue it anyway because it's the "moral" thing to do? If so, count me out...
 
I certainly wasn't checked, so it was an open border for me. Perhaps your appearance caused you to be especially scrutinized.

Tough break.

They had metal detectors when I was there in like 2000. I don't remember them checking passports but I could be mistaken. It was a long time ago.
 
You would advocate for the destruction of 400 year old walls then? The popes comments were in regards to a religious practice of giving to the poor and allowing the poor to seek out a better life. Religion has little to do with a nation, however, nations have everything to do with the actual practice of religion. If a nation closes its borders, it no longer cares for the poor from another nation who may seek a better life. How Christian is that?

The United States by building a wall is trying to slow the influx of illegal immigrants not closing down legal immigration. There is a difference.
 
your Mullah says, in so many nuanced words, the United States has no right to protect it's borders even as he lives behind walls like a 1%er from Scarsdale or Grosse Point.

What say you?

Stand up. Be counted!

As far as clarifying Catholic positions, I'm your huckleberry.

The Pope certainly expressed an opinion that has people here in America charged. A few things to take into account:

1. Popes are allowed to have personal opinions, and Catholics aren't required to believe every opinion the Pope might give. Popes are infallible in dogmatic proclamations only. That being said, Popes aren't just any other layperson either by any stretch. They often challenge the Catholic community, and that's a good thing.

2. Popes deal with human souls, not state results. The Pope is speaking ideologically here obviously.

3. Popes don't live in lavish luxury. Their possessions are minimal to none. Your premise of "1%" is incorrect. American economic issues don't accurately trade into this realm.

4. The walls of the Vatican aren't the door to some massive space of immigrant housing. Vatican city is only 1/6 of a square mile. Meanwhile, viewing the Vatican separately from the global church is nothing more than an inaccurate attack. The global church houses the poor, including immigrants, more than any other organization on the planet.

So, let's properly frame things before we lash out with sarcastic assumptions that we try to fit like puzzle pieces into our comfortable American narratives.
 
your Mullah says, in so many nuanced words, the United States has no right to protect it's borders even as he lives behind walls like a 1%er from Scarsdale or Grosse Point.

What say you?

Stand up. Be counted!

First of all - I read a transcrpt of the entire conversation and I personally believe the Pope was somewhat baited into making a statement that could be turned on its head and used in the exact manner it is - so that someone could run back to Trump and say - guess what he said which is exactly what has happened.

Taken in the full context of the conversation - his pronouncement was much like any other thing you would expect him to say.... from a purely academic - theological perspective. And, that is the kind of thing I would expect to hear from the pope.

However, all that being said and this one does live more simply than the others.. sorry though if i don't take advice regarding charity from people sitting on BILLIONS of dollars, vast collections of priceless art, etc. Tell me I am to give away as much as I have while you do not do the same is hypocritical to the extreme.

Why don't they give theirs away - well because of course they know.. they could give it all away and there would still be the poor and hungry and if anything it would make a temporary dent but be gone and they would not only not be able to administer and oversee what they do - do that helps the poor and needy, they poor and needy will just end up as poor and needy. But, when *I* make that decision or my Gov't makes the decision - to not beggar ourselves - in the name of helping others - because quite honestly all that will happen is us ending up poor... we are selfish and greedy for wanting to continue and perpetuate our legacy on to the next generation and generations.


connie
 
First of all - I read a transcrpt of the entire conversation and I personally believe the Pope was somewhat baited into making a statement that could be turned on its head and used in the exact manner it is - so that someone could run back to Trump and say - guess what he said which is exactly what has happened.

Taken in the full context of the conversation - his pronouncement was much like any other thing you would expect him to say.... from a purely academic - theological perspective. And, that is the kind of thing I would expect to hear from the pope.

However, all that being said and this one does live more simply than the others.. sorry though if i don't take advice regarding charity from people sitting on BILLIONS of dollars, vast collections of priceless art, etc. Tell me I am to give away as much as I have while you do not do the same is hypocritical to the extreme.

Why don't they give theirs away - well because of course they know.. they could give it all away and there would still be the poor and hungry and if anything it would make a temporary dent but be gone and they would not only not be able to administer and oversee what they do - do that helps the poor and needy, they poor and needy will just end up as poor and needy. But, when *I* make that decision or my Gov't makes the decision - to not beggar ourselves - in the name of helping others - because quite honestly all that will happen is us ending up poor... we are selfish and greedy for wanting to continue and perpetuate our legacy on to the next generation and generations.


connie

http://thehill.com/blogs/ballot-box/270001-pope-spokesman-clarifies-trump-comment
 
we're returning to the middle ages, where the catholic church attempts to dictate national policy to various governments.

My eyes couldn't have rolled any more severely than they did now after reading that one.

I mean, if Barack Obama's presidency had to be confirmed by the Pope, then you've got me. If not, then you're ridiculous.
 

When I first heard this story then read the transcript, I thought.. what a bunch of media manipulation. He never mentioned Trump by name. He never mentioned the US or Mexico. He was asked a question and when he didn't give something the reporter could twist around, he was asked again and again in different ways until he finally said something that could be used in the way the person wanted.

I find that exceeding disingenuous.

connie
 
Taken in the full context of the conversation - his pronouncement was much like any other thing you would expect him to say.... from a purely academic - theological perspective. And, that is the kind of thing I would expect to hear from the pope.

I've noticed that the American media absolutely butchers nearly everything the Pope says... Political media is so desperate, and overall can't think on any higher spectrum than their own political agendas.

I'm so glad to be a Catholic first and then an American second.
 
So I'm a bit confused. Are you saying that you agree that our current trajectory has us on a collision course with a Euro-style social and economic collapse, but that we should pursue it anyway because it's the "moral" thing to do? If so, count me out...

Not ours as a nation, but ours as a species. Given our nature as people it is the only logical outcome, or we destroy ourselves. We are going down both paths now, and have been for some time, and are getting closer everyday to either option. That is a much larger issue than just this singular topic though.
 
Not ours as a nation, but ours as a species. Given our nature as people it is the only logical outcome, or we destroy ourselves. We are going down both paths now, and have been for some time, and are getting closer everyday to either option. That is a much larger issue than just this singular topic though.

That is sort of the point of having nations though... so that you can make sure that when the destruction of people come - it happens to someone else. You are right, unless we are all willing to accept drastically lower standards of living there will be all out war, destruction and people will die... Its the job of our Government though to make sure that happens to someone else.
 
You would advocate for the destruction of 400 year old walls then? The popes comments were in regards to a religious practice of giving to the poor and allowing the poor to seek out a better life. Religion has little to do with a nation, however, nations have everything to do with the actual practice of religion. If a nation closes its borders, it no longer cares for the poor from another nation who may seek a better life. How Christian is that?

"Giving to the poor"? When are they going to start?



pope-francis-denounces-wealth-fails-to-mention-vatican-billions.jpg

by Geoffrey Grider September 22, 2013
The Vatican Billions
“And saying, Alas, alas, that great city, that was clothed in fine linen, and purple, and scarlet, and decked with gold, and precious stones, and pearls!” Revelation 18:16

“The Vatican has large investments with the Rothschilds of Britain, France and America, with the Hambros Bank, with the Credit Suisse in London and Zurich. In the United States it has large investments with the Morgan Bank, the Chase-Manhattan Bank, the First National Bank of New York, the Bankers Trust Company, and others. The Vatican has billions of shares in the most powerful international corporations such as Gulf Oil, Shell, General Motors, Bethlehem Steel, General Electric, International Business Machines, T.W.A., etc. At a conservative estimate, these amount to more than 500 million dollars in the U.S.A. alone.


The wealth of the Vatican is nearly incalculable.

The Vatican’s treasure of solid gold has been estimated by the United Nations World Magazine to amount to several billion dollars. A large bulk of this is stored in gold ingots with the U.S. Federal Reserve Bank, while banks in England and Switzerland hold the rest. But this is just a small portion of the wealth of the Vatican, which in the U.S. alone, is greater than that of the five wealthiest giant corporations of the country. When to that is added all the real estate, property, stocks and shares abroad, then the staggering accumulation of the wealth of the Catholic church becomes so formidable as to defy any rational assessment.” source – Avro Manhattan

http://www.nowtheendbegins.com/pope...ican-billions-gives-speech-denouncing-wealth/
 
Unless of course said nation is being eaten from within by the lethargic and unmotivated.
 
Back
Top