[
B]And to me it is not. I shouldn't have to alter my activities based on the rare nutjob who goes off the beam.[/B]
What is your cut-off number for assault weapon victims killed or shot only with high volume magazines in the acceptable trade-off? Let's call "over ten" high volume, just for argument's sake. But don't try to subtract the first ten shots from the count to confuse the question....I know you. Just the casualty count from incidents using these specific tools. So what's your number?
I have no such cutoff number. A 20-round magazine is not a "high capacity" magazine for an AR-15. It's the magazine it is designed to use. A 12-round magazine is a high capacity magazines in a .45 ACP 1911A1, as the design capacity is 7 (and most modern magazines hold 8). I don't think limiting the number of rounds a magazine may contain serves any useful purpose.
You can't show that such weapons are a significant contribution to violence in this country
In case you missed it, I think 20 children is "significant".
And as that respresents a figure of less than 1/2 of one percent of all murders, I regard it as insignificant as a basis for legislation. It is not that their deaths are less tragic -- but they are also no more tragic than the other 11,000 deaths, fewer than 500 of which involved "assault" weapons. You want to base legislation on an emotional response to a rare event. You care about the 20 deaths in Newtown -- you seem not to care about the 10,980 more common ones.
If you run the numbers, airport security is to prevent a truly "insignificant" problem by your standard. Compare the cure to the problem and it's just ludicrous....right? The trade off for freedom is outrageous. The inconvenience of eliminating high volume magazines isn't even visible on the same scale. But that's not your pet issue. Because neither is freedom. Guns are.
Freedom in the U.S. is a package deal. I would similarly object to a restriction on my freedom of speech, or freedom of religion, or any other of my civil rights. I merely have the clear view that firearms ownership is as much a civil right as any of the others -- a view that is born out by 200 years of American jurisprudence.
And Iraq was "worth it" by your standard.
True but irrelevant to this discussion.
I don't need to have a good reason to exercise a civil right.
High volume magazines and freely transferring guns to family members who have had no background check to own one are not "civil rights".
They are part of my right to keep and bear arms. It doesn't say "you have a right to keep and bear arms (except for those with magazines holding more than 10 rounds)."
More risk is part of living in a free country.
Don't lecture me, gun hugger. By your own standard, I risk more by living without guns and I'm a hell of a lot freer than you are. I'm free of fear. You're controlled by it. It drips from every post.
I don't see how you are more free or less free through you living within our package of civil rights without exercising one of them. I haven't really used my "freedom of the press" in about a decade -- but it's still there and I still may use it as you may some day decide to use your right to firearms. I'm not lecturing you. I feel no need to lecture any more than I feel a need to restrict your civil rights.
Your version of "freedom" isn't worth risk, sure as hell isn't worth lives and won't make this a better country in any way....as if wingers care about that. The risk I take is for the kind of freedom I want. And I don't want to take your stupid guns from you....or your Teddy Bears....or your pacifier. You need them to feel "free". I know that.
You're entitled to that opinion, but that doesn't change the fact that I still have a civil right to own firearms. I'm entitled to my opinion that my rights shouldn't be judged based on the worsts abuses of those rights -- if a Nazi exercises free speech we don't attempt to restrict free speech for the rest of us. If a madman misuses a firearm we shouldn't restrict the right to firearms for the rest of us. And yes, you want to take SOME guns from me. And the next law will want to take SOME others. There will never be enough restrictions on individuals civil right to firearms, because there are people who fear all firearms.
I don't need, by the way, a teddy bear, or a pacifier, or even a firearm to feel free. That doesn't mean that the government has the right to deprive me of them.