New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

About that 2nd amendment.

I'm anxious to see him back up that big whopper with a link. I admit I hate guns but I know you can't restrict people from owning REGULAR guns for hunting and hand guns that don't shoot umpteen bullets in a few min.

There is no technical difference between "common" firearms and the ones you want to ban. Semiautomatic rifles have been available to American hunters since about 1910. "High" capacity semiautomatic pistols have been sold in the U.S. since Browning sold its first 13-round pistol in 1935. There is no difference, at all, between these "hunting" weapons and the "assault" weapons you say you want to ban.
 
It isn't a fair example of most gun owners or most private transfers,

And I never tried to make it so. To me, it's a trade off and I'm asking if the trade-off is worth it.

I have a good reason for wanting to not have assault weapons and high volume magazines all over the place.

You can't come up with a legitimate use for them, so you just go the ever dependable "slippery slope" and "someone is coming for my guns" avenue.

Your "price of freedom" statement was clearly that you think it's a good trade-off....more victims, more mass shootings....for something for which you can't come up with a real advantage, let alone a need. Own it.

Our new member, H. Muir, has eloquently trashed your Constitutional arguments simply by citing the clauses and putting them in historical perspective.
 
wanting to restrict SOME firearms is not being anti-gun.

wanting to restrict ALL firearms is being anti-gun.

Ok, thank you for clarifying; I've mentioned in other threads that sometimes we all use similiar terms, while actually meaning very different things by those terms.
 
The original purpose of the Second Amendment was to protect the right of the several states to control their militia's, and as a limitation of the power of the federal government over state militia’s under Article I, Section 8, Clause 15. At the time of the ratification of the Second Amendment, there was no standing army, and there was very real concern that the Constitution ceded too much power to Congress. See The Federalist Papers, No. 46 (James Madison, Jan. 29, 1788). However that has been largely made obsolete by time, as the National Guard is now an adjunct component of the United States Army Reserve. (Interestingly, an argument could be made that the deployment of State National Guard Units to Iraq and Afghanistan violates the Second Amendment.)

That was not the original intent of the amendment, but if it were, it's immaterial. Let's theorize that there is no 2nd Amendment. Would that mean individuals lack the right to their own individual arms?

No, it would not. "The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people."

That's the 9th Amendment. People have all sorts of rights not mentioned in the Constitution and are assumed to retain any rights they had at the creation of the Constitution. Among the rights people certainly had at that time was the right to possess their own arms. If the 2nd Amendment referred only to state militias, the right to individual guns still would not be "denied or disparaged" by its abscence from the Constitution.
 
OK Mr. that's a DAMN LIE. I've never EVER and I doubt the others you named have spoken of restricting COMMON FIREARMS. I'm against the type of gun that Lanza and the other nuts used to kill multiple people, including kids who haven't even had a chance to live yet. I'm NOT against anyone owning a shotgun, regular hunting rifle and hand gun as long as they don't have magazines that enable someone to shoot and kill multiple PEOPLE. That's all that type of gun is made for. Nobody hunts with an assault type gun unless like Sarah Palin they have to shoot multiple times to hit their drugged target. Give me a link where I have EVER said that I think common guns should be banned. I hate guns...I admit that. But I do know that sometimes they can be used (like the woman in OK used her shotgun to stop intruders). You don't need an assault type gun for that.

Yeah, I kinda knew I was going to piss you off by using your name.... oh well.
 
zzigzzag;685111[QUOTE said:
]It isn't a fair example of most gun owners or most private transfers,

And I never tried to make it so. To me, it's a trade off and I'm asking if the trade-off is worth it.

And to me it is not. I shouldn't have to alter my activities based on the rare nutjob who goes off the beam.

I have a good reason for wanting to not have assault weapons and high volume magazines all over the place.

I disagree that you have a "good" reason. You can't show that such weapons are a significant contribution to violence in this country -- and as you know you can't make the argument based on fact, you've chose to base it on emotion, on propaganda, but continually pointing to the Newtown Massacre as a reason for restricting the rights of people like myself. It is exceptionally easy to make an emotional argument, and it's an effective means of propaganda so long as no one points out that the emperor is wearing no clothes. The weapons you think you have a good reason for restricting do not contribute to much in the way of violence. You're just scared of them.

You can't come up with a legitimate use for them, so you just go the ever dependable "slippery slope" and "someone is coming for my guns" avenue.

I don't need to have a good reason to exercise a civil right.

Your "price of freedom" statement was clearly that you think it's a good trade-off....more victims, more mass shootings....for something for which you can't come up with a real advantage, let alone a need. Own it.

More risk is part of living in a free country. If you want a safe country, check into one of the world's totalitarian states, like Singapore. You'll be "safe," (for a given value of "safe) but don't spit on the sidewalk.
 
All rights exist only by law. It is the law that defines our rights; it is the law that provides for their enforcement. To say that there are rights under the Ninth Amendment is, petitio principii, only to beg the question of their existence (and validity) under the law.

Ah, yes...I'd forgotten you completely ignore the basis for the power of government and law under the U.S. Constitution. If we had a right, by law, before the Constitution was written, and it wasn't taken away from us via the Constitution -- do we retain it or not?
 
And to me it is not. I shouldn't have to alter my activities based on the rare nutjob who goes off the beam.

What is your cut-off number for assault weapon victims killed or shot only with high volume magazines in the acceptable trade-off? Let's call "over ten" high volume, just for argument's sake. But don't try to subtract the first ten shots from the count to confuse the question....I know you. Just the casualty count from incidents using these specific tools. So what's your number?

You can't show that such weapons are a significant contribution to violence in this country

In case you missed it, I think 20 children is "significant". As a matter of fact, I think each and every one of them was "significant". I think everyone shot in Aurora is "significant". I think Giffords and the others were "significant". I think Columbine was a "significant" incident. I think the VA Tech shootings were "significant". You think calling that "propaganda" is a cogent counter argument.

If you run the numbers, airport security is to prevent a truly "insignificant" problem by your standard. Compare the cure to the casualty list and it's just ludicrous....right? The trade off for freedom is outrageous. The inconvenience of eliminating high volume magazines isn't even visible on the same scale. But that's not your pet issue. Because neither is freedom. Guns are.

And Iraq was "worth it" by your standard.

You have no standard.

I don't need to have a good reason to exercise a civil right.

High volume magazines and freely transferring guns to family members who have had no background check to own one are not "civil rights".

But thanks for demonstrating, once again, that you can't think of a legitimate use for something you're willing to sacrifice other peoples' lives for.

More risk is part of living in a free country.

Don't lecture me, gun hugger. By your own standard, I risk more by living without guns and I'm a hell of a lot freer than you are. I'm free of fear. You're controlled by it. It drips from every post.

Your version of "freedom" isn't worth risk, sure as hell isn't worth lives and won't make this a better country in any way....as if wingers care about that. The risk I take is for the kind of freedom I want. And I don't want to take your stupid guns from you....or your Teddy Bears....or your pacifier. You need them to feel "free". I know that.
 
Our rights and freedoms exist subject to the rule of law. That’s the tradeoff - the “social contract” so to speak - under the Constitution that established the United States as a nation of laws and not men.

But under American law, the legislature cannot willy-nilly pass any law it desires -- laws are subject to review, and comparison with the Constitution to determine if they fit within the legal structure of the Constitution. If they fail in that comparison, they are unconstitutional and hence (to be very precise) illegitimate.
 
It isn't a fair example of most gun owners or most private transfers,

And I never tried to make it so. To me, it's a trade off and I'm asking if the trade-off is worth it.

I have a good reason for wanting to not have assault weapons and high volume magazines all over the place.

You can't come up with a legitimate use for them, so you just go the ever dependable "slippery slope" and "someone is coming for my guns" avenue.

Your "price of freedom" statement was clearly that you think it's a good trade-off....more victims, more mass shootings....for something for which you can't come up with a real advantage, let alone a need. Own it.

Our new member, H. Muir, has eloquently trashed your Constitutional arguments simply by citing the clauses and putting them in historical perspective.

Zziggy, it wasn't his statement, it was mine. I said it, and I damn well meant it... the price of living in a free country where people have free will, and make their own choices is that sometimes, someone will freely choose to commit a horrific act; deal with it, and quit being a coward. The problem isn't semi-auto firearms, or magazines, or how these things are transfered, or whether they're registered, or any of that bullshit ya'll use to deflect from the real issues. The problem is angry and homicidal young men who are so disaffected and pissed off at the world that they go out and pull shit like this. But that is a whole lot harder to address, and would require people to start actually thinking about some uncomfortable shit, so instead, in an act of monumental cowardice, you focus on an inanimate piece of metal. [Unwelcome language removed] gutless...
As to being able to show an "advantage", or a "need", or a "legitimate use"; 1. I don't have to show you any of these things. 2. Who the hell do you think you are to presume to tell me what I do, or do not, need in order to deal with situations that you are too much of a pussy to even think about in a rational or logical manner. And every time I, or anyone else on this board, tries to discuss these things from a rational or logical viewpoint, I am immediately accused of not caring about a bunch of dead kids, an emotional tirade with absolutely no basis in fact; well, you know what? I think it's people like you who don't care about kids, because you sure as hell can't be bothered to do anything that might actually matter. You just keep going for that guns... "low hanging fruit". [Unwelcome language removed] you, you pussy...
 
[
B]And to me it is not. I shouldn't have to alter my activities based on the rare nutjob who goes off the beam.[/B]

What is your cut-off number for assault weapon victims killed or shot only with high volume magazines in the acceptable trade-off? Let's call "over ten" high volume, just for argument's sake. But don't try to subtract the first ten shots from the count to confuse the question....I know you. Just the casualty count from incidents using these specific tools. So what's your number?

I have no such cutoff number. A 20-round magazine is not a "high capacity" magazine for an AR-15. It's the magazine it is designed to use. A 12-round magazine is a high capacity magazines in a .45 ACP 1911A1, as the design capacity is 7 (and most modern magazines hold 8). I don't think limiting the number of rounds a magazine may contain serves any useful purpose.

You can't show that such weapons are a significant contribution to violence in this country

In case you missed it, I think 20 children is "significant".

And as that respresents a figure of less than 1/2 of one percent of all murders, I regard it as insignificant as a basis for legislation. It is not that their deaths are less tragic -- but they are also no more tragic than the other 11,000 deaths, fewer than 500 of which involved "assault" weapons. You want to base legislation on an emotional response to a rare event. You care about the 20 deaths in Newtown -- you seem not to care about the 10,980 more common ones.


If you run the numbers, airport security is to prevent a truly "insignificant" problem by your standard. Compare the cure to the problem and it's just ludicrous....right? The trade off for freedom is outrageous. The inconvenience of eliminating high volume magazines isn't even visible on the same scale. But that's not your pet issue. Because neither is freedom. Guns are.

Freedom in the U.S. is a package deal. I would similarly object to a restriction on my freedom of speech, or freedom of religion, or any other of my civil rights. I merely have the clear view that firearms ownership is as much a civil right as any of the others -- a view that is born out by 200 years of American jurisprudence.

And Iraq was "worth it" by your standard.

True but irrelevant to this discussion.


I don't need to have a good reason to exercise a civil right.

High volume magazines and freely transferring guns to family members who have had no background check to own one are not "civil rights".

They are part of my right to keep and bear arms. It doesn't say "you have a right to keep and bear arms (except for those with magazines holding more than 10 rounds)."

More risk is part of living in a free country.

Don't lecture me, gun hugger. By your own standard, I risk more by living without guns and I'm a hell of a lot freer than you are. I'm free of fear. You're controlled by it. It drips from every post.

I don't see how you are more free or less free through you living within our package of civil rights without exercising one of them. I haven't really used my "freedom of the press" in about a decade -- but it's still there and I still may use it as you may some day decide to use your right to firearms. I'm not lecturing you. I feel no need to lecture any more than I feel a need to restrict your civil rights.

Your version of "freedom" isn't worth risk, sure as hell isn't worth lives and won't make this a better country in any way....as if wingers care about that. The risk I take is for the kind of freedom I want. And I don't want to take your stupid guns from you....or your Teddy Bears....or your pacifier. You need them to feel "free". I know that.

You're entitled to that opinion, but that doesn't change the fact that I still have a civil right to own firearms. I'm entitled to my opinion that my rights shouldn't be judged based on the worsts abuses of those rights -- if a Nazi exercises free speech we don't attempt to restrict free speech for the rest of us. If a madman misuses a firearm we shouldn't restrict the right to firearms for the rest of us. And yes, you want to take SOME guns from me. And the next law will want to take SOME others. There will never be enough restrictions on individuals civil right to firearms, because there are people who fear all firearms.

I don't need, by the way, a teddy bear, or a pacifier, or even a firearm to feel free. That doesn't mean that the government has the right to deprive me of them.
 
Point taken, but that does not mean that all efforts to regulate guns is unconstitutional. Background checks aren't inherently unconsitutional. Restricting gun clips to 10 rounds isn't unconstitutional. A gun that inhibits fingerprints on them doesn't have to be legal.

The problem is that opponents of gun control and advocates of more control distrust one another too much, and gun manufacturers are taking advantage of that. There are people in this room and country that would make gun ownership illegal if they could, but it would be virtually impossible to do that. You know that. would you turn in your guns if they were made illegal? People that would like to make guns illegal, on the other hand, have to realise that advocating that position only makes it harder to reach agreement with Second Amendment supporters.

God Speed,
David
 
Point taken, but that does not mean that all efforts to regulate guns is unconstitutional. Background checks aren't inherently unconsitutional. Restricting gun clips to 10 rounds isn't unconstitutional. A gun that inhibits fingerprints on them doesn't have to be legal.

Those statements are not necessarily true. Background checks could be seen as an "infringement," certainly they could if they are combined with other restrictive measures. Regulating magazine capacities looks to me like a violation of my rights under the 9th Amendment. I know of no guns designed not to accept fingerprints -- professional hit men used to wrap the grips of their guns with adhesive tape to hide the fingerprints. Are we going to regulate adhesive tape?

The problem is that opponents of gun control and advocates of more control distrust one another too much, and gun manufacturers are taking advantage of that. There are people in this room and country that would make gun ownership illegal if they could, but it would be virtually impossible to do that.

All at once it would be impossible. Incrementally? I'd call that likely.

You know that. would you turn in your guns if they were made illegal? People that would like to make guns illegal, on the other hand, have to realise that advocating that position only makes it harder to reach agreement with Second Amendment supporters.

I've said many times that I'd agree to things that are anathema to me -- even firearms registration -- if I could get a "line in the sand," this is enough and no more. No one ever offers that.
 
Yeah, I kinda knew I was going to piss you off by using your name.... oh well.

It "pisses me off" when some gun freak lies about something I was supposed to have said. Now when are you going to back up your LIE with a link of me ever stating that I want ALL guns banned.
 
There is no technical difference between "common" firearms and the ones you want to ban. Semiautomatic rifles have been available to American hunters since about 1910. "High" capacity semiautomatic pistols have been sold in the U.S. since Browning sold its first 13-round pistol in 1935. There is no difference, at all, between these "hunting" weapons and the "assault" weapons you say you want to ban.
Bullshit. If there's no difference why didn't Adam Lanza and the other freaks that used weapons that can shoot 26 people in a matter of minutes take a handgun, rifle or shotgun WITHOUT A CLIP that I've stated over and over should be banned to their mayhem?? YOU PEOPLE (as Queen Ann Romney would say) have absolutely no compassion for the families who lost their children or anyone else who has suffered because of gun nuts. NADA...
 
Ok, thank you for clarifying; I've mentioned in other threads that sometimes we all use similiar terms, while actually meaning very different things by those terms.

But that's NOT what you accused us of you lying fool.
 
When you want your inalienable unlisted "rights" backed up or supported, what does one go to for evidence they exist so they may be backed up and supported, by what and by whom?

People can be walking off with you to hang you by a tree after being accused by a single person of murder and you've gotten no trial. You yell, 'but I have a right, I have a right'. A "right" by whose authority? A right backed up by whom and by what?

If it is not "listed" which the above mentioned is, who ya' gonna call?
 
It "pisses me off" when some gun freak lies about something I was supposed to have said. Now when are you going to back up your LIE with a link of me ever stating that I want ALL guns banned.

To clarify, I feel that people who believe that certain fireams should be restricted are "anti-gun". Julie and I had an exchange about the use of the term and that it means different things to different people, and your name, (among others) I cited as an example. Does that explain it?
I know you do not want ALL guns banned; were that to happen, you wouldn't be able to bitch like a screeching harpy about mine, while enjoying the protection afforded to you by the ones in your household. Hypocrite...
 
Bullshit. If there's no difference why didn't Adam Lanza and the other freaks that used weapons that can shoot 26 people in a matter of minutes take a handgun, rifle or shotgun WITHOUT A CLIP that I've stated over and over should be banned to their mayhem?? YOU PEOPLE (as Queen Ann Romney would say) have absolutely no compassion for the families who lost their children or anyone else who has suffered because of gun nuts. NADA...

The Virginia Tech killer used handguns with restricted capacity magazines (10 rounds). He was of course free to reload as often as he wanted because he was in a "gun free" zone and faced no opposition...
 
Back
Top