New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Affirmative Action

Because you point out that somehow a "hispanic with no markers" somehow isn't confronting any challenges. Which means that if someone "whitifies" themselves, they have no need for Affirmative Action. which essentially is the same as saying that "if you whitify" then you eliminate the need for Affirmative Action.

That isn't what he said at all. He said that because his acquaintance appears white, he is not underprivileged in the way that you believe affirmative action would correct.

See this is where you and Trap go off the rails. You ASSUME that there is a small role in ethnic discrimination in his life

  • AFTER he has already done the work of "whitifying"... which is an effort that he has had to make that YOU did not have to make
  • .

    As described, the person didn't have to do any work to "whitify" (a term I find fairly objectionable) at all. If anything, the work he has done is to emphasize his Hispanic ethnicity, which would otherwise be unknown to others.

    [*]without actually knowing what discrimination he has and has not faced or is and is not facing.

    Affirmative action would apply to him whether he had faced high levels of discrimination, low levels of discrimination, or (as seems likely in this case) none whatsoever. So that portion is a question that the law does not answer or seek to answer.


    Rememer I addressed the issue of ECONOMIC advantages in my example of Vanessa Williams. She and I both had economic advantages over Trapdoor. What she ALSO had, was a gender and race disadvantage in COMPETING WITH ME. And Affirmative Action for her would not put her in competition with Trap but in competition with me. Same applies to YOUR example. He's not competing with you since he's coming in with a higher starting off point.

    Except that this analysis is nonsense, for the simple and obvious reason that if Vanessa Williams and I were applying for the same school, and there were only the two of us applying, she would receive the advantage of affirmative action and I would not. THE LAW DOES NOT BALANCE FOR CLASS. If it did, it would still be racist because it divides people by race and race alone without addressing their individual situations -- the law pre-judges people based on race (gee, I wish the English language contained a word for that).
 
You aren't. You aren't being penalized WRT YOUR SOCIOECONOMIC PEERs.. that's the part you don't seem to get. What's really going on is that you don't want to give up what unearned priviledges you have.

This is seemingly your sole argument, so I'm going to point out again, that the law makes no provision for this. It does not sort by class.
 
Affirmative Action is working as planned

As far as College goes it raised the bar on scholastic achievement for white kids to receive equal consideration and it has lowered the bar for minority kids to get equal consideration..
and its working especially on the lowered bar side of the equation

And folks wonder what has happened to our educational system...sheesh
 
Does it have to end?

it was established as a way to correct the sins of the past..how far back into the past do you go? its intention when established in the early 60s was to bring parity to African Americans in the workplace. it later changed to include most minorities, and ALL females..and as a result, the majority of people benefiting from it are white females from ALL economic levels.

that was not what it was intended to do. it should go the way of the quota system, {the same thing found unconstitutional and banned}
call it by whatever you want. a duck by any other name remains a duck..
to choose one over the other based on gender or race is discrimination, and in fact, is why, it was started..

figure that one out..
 
I do not disagree that some minorities in this country are economically and socially disadvantaged and we should have programs in place to help them. But, there are many whose parents took advantage of programs or did it the old fashioned way and are now no longer socially or economically disadvantaged.

But, part of the reason for the programs were not only to provide opportunties, but to diversify the workplace. The more contact you have with different ethnic groups the more likely you are to become familiar with them, see them as equals or collegues, etc. And, I do think that largely has been accomplished. YES there are still pockets of that kind of racisim of hating a black person just because they are black... but I have also seen for myself that there are plenty of blacks who just hate whites because they are white. So, in an every day, educated, middle class community - I think for the most part we all sort of rub along fine.

So, I think affirmative action has corrected maybe some of the issue of racisim in this country. But, now we are down to do we still need to give people and advantage over others. And, I honestly think, no.

I think we provide public education. And, it is sad and dispaointing that kids in inner city schools don't take advantage of that and are not poised to take advantage of it. But, does that mean then as an ill prepared student they should get preferential treatment at school? Did we not do what we were supposed to do in leveling the playing field by providing the opportunity for education? And, is it not now the parent's responsibility to make sure the child takes full advantage. And, as you noted, and is my experience too, the people who are most currently using affirmative action are those from upper middle class minority families. They themselves have not been disadvantaged and are not economically disadvantaged. But, are using it to further their careers or get promotions that many may not deserve. And, honestly I think that is unfair to minorities who have worked their tails off and have proven that they deserve promotions and advancements because I think they have to try to prove doubly that they are not a "token".

So, if we want to keep affirmative action - I think we need to take it out of the employment/business arena. End set assides for construction work which is a process I am most familiar with that is horribly abused. End, quotas. Get it out of education as well. If the issue is to bring up economically disadvantaged people -then lets offer whatever extra scholarship and and token spots we are going to offer up to people whose parents fit into the disadvantaged socio-economic ladder - across the board.
 
I do not disagree that some minorities in this country are economically and socially disadvantaged and we should have programs in place to help them. But, there are many whose parents took advantage of programs or did it the old fashioned way and are now no longer socially or economically disadvantaged.

But, part of the reason for the programs were not only to provide opportunties, but to diversify the workplace. The more contact you have with different ethnic groups the more likely you are to become familiar with them, see them as equals or collegues, etc. And, I do think that largely has been accomplished. YES there are still pockets of that kind of racisim of hating a black person just because they are black... but I have also seen for myself that there are plenty of blacks who just hate whites because they are white. So, in an every day, educated, middle class community - I think for the most part we all sort of rub along fine.

So, I think affirmative action has corrected maybe some of the issue of racisim in this country. But, now we are down to do we still need to give people and advantage over others. And, I honestly think, no.

I think we provide public education. And, it is sad and dispaointing that kids in inner city schools don't take advantage of that and are not poised to take advantage of it. But, does that mean then as an ill prepared student they should get preferential treatment at school? Did we not do what we were supposed to do in leveling the playing field by providing the opportunity for education? And, is it not now the parent's responsibility to make sure the child takes full advantage. And, as you noted, and is my experience too, the people who are most currently using affirmative action are those from upper middle class minority families. They themselves have not been disadvantaged and are not economically disadvantaged. But, are using it to further their careers or get promotions that many may not deserve. And, honestly I think that is unfair to minorities who have worked their tails off and have proven that they deserve promotions and advancements because I think they have to try to prove doubly that they are not a "token".

So, if we want to keep affirmative action - I think we need to take it out of the employment/business arena. End set assides for construction work which is a process I am most familiar with that is horribly abused. End, quotas. Get it out of education as well. If the issue is to bring up economically disadvantaged people -then lets offer whatever extra scholarship and and token spots we are going to offer up to people whose parents fit into the disadvantaged socio-economic ladder - across the board.

Bravo....set asides for minority owned contracts does nothing but fleece the taxpayers.. Set aside projects allow for unqualified contractors to charge 20% higher rate only to have the job require revamp work to correct work completed and paid for that is not up to standards
 
Bravo....set asides for minority owned contracts does nothing but fleece the taxpayers.. Set aside projects allow for unqualified contractors to charge 20% higher rate only to have the job require revamp work to correct work completed and paid for that is not up to standards


Completely agree. And, in many cases the minority contractor is only a front or a "teaming" partner for a larger company that is essentially letting the minority contractor handle the paperwork. They have tried to crack down on this in the last few years since so much construction money was from the Government everyone started up this kind of arrangement.. But, there are some pretty specific legal requirements they have to meet and plenty of them do, on paper. But, that is as far as it goes.

And I have seen the fall out. You get a minority owned construction company - getting all sorts of good work at unbelieveable margins while being run not by the minority figure head - but of a crew of other backers... the company outgrows whatever special set aside program they are in. The margins dry up because no one needs their "participation" any more. Then the partners leave... and the business goes bankrupt and the owner is standing there trying to figure out how it all went wrong.

connie
 
Way to promote your racist views...not since lefty attacked the bus that the freedom riders were on near Birmingham Ala have we seen anything so dispicable...isnt the first time I hve called you out and wont be the last.

Now that's rich... in irony.
 
Because you point out that somehow a "hispanic with no markers" somehow isn't confronting any challenges. Which means that if someone "whitifies" themselves, they have no need for Affirmative Action. which essentially is the same as saying that "if you whitify" then you eliminate the need for Affirmative Action.

I guess we may be talking past each other here, because it seems I have absolutely no idea what "whitify" means. As far as I know, he's made no attempt to emulate any ethnic norms of any sort. He looks like what he looks like because of genetics, and talks the way he talks because that's how people in his peer group talked (at his elite boarding schools). I very much doubt he had to work on his accent any more than I did (I used to have a Texas twang when I was little, which faded effortlessly when I moved away from Texas). Your comments suggest he must have worked to "whitify." I see absolutely no reason to think that's true, if by "whitify" you mean to work to fit in with social cues expected of non-Hispanic whites.

You assume he faced a lot of discrimination. I assume he didn't. Neither of us know for sure. I do know that he was the youngest person in my department to reach a certain rank, and that he did so despite being CONSPICUOUSLY lazy (working shorter hours than any other person in a large department), and despite giving no appearance of being particularly bright. I also know that his mother was personal friends with the CEO, thanks to them serving together on a charity board. And I know that he went to the same private school as another senior executive, who served as his mentor. He basically followed a path similar to George Bush or Mitt Romney, with the whole path greased by family money and connections (admittedly on a smaller scale than those two). The only difference is that his father came from a dynasty in Latin America, rather than one in North America.

"And Affirmative Action for her would not put her in competition with Trap but in competition with me."

It puts her in competition with all of us. I have coworkers who came from money. And I've got ones who came from nothing. I came from the middle class. That gave me a few advantages that some of those working-class people I'm competing with didn't have (e.g., I only worked over the summers during high school, even though I had to work during college; and I lack any verbal signifiers of lower-class upbringing). But it gave me disadvantages relative to those who came from the upper class, like my Hispanic colleague. My mom doesn't go to social events with the CEO. My high school didn't give me an "in" with a senior VP (it was a public school in a small town in Maine). I didn't have an upbringing that lets me chat with the industry movers and shakers about skiing in Vail or our summer home in Hilton Head. I can't name-drop VIPs. And so a lot of doors were swung open for people like him that people like me have to fight like mad to open for ourselves. I'm very much in competition with people like that, and their economic and social advantages make the playing field of that competition decidedly uneven. Giving the advantage of affirmative action to some of them just makes that playing field even less fair.

"He's not competing with you since he's coming in with a higher starting off point."

I don't have a clue what you mean. I compete with him directly. Our reviews are done on a curve. I'm competing with him for raises, bonuses, and promotions. When there are layoffs, I'm competing with him for an opportunity to keep my job. In that competition, he'd have an advantage already, thanks to his connections and background. Affirmative action gives him another advantage on top of that. And it's not just the intended affirmative action, but also the subconscious affirmative action of those who know he's in a position to sue and I'm not. If they have to fire one of us, he's a member of a protected class, so he can at least get past the opening hurdle with a lawsuit, forcing expensive production of documents to establish that he wasn't fired for being Hispanic. If I try to sue when I'm fired, it's going to be very cheap and quick, because as a non-Hispanic white male who has not yet reached his elder years, I simply don't have standing for a wrongful termination claim. They won't have to show they had any cause to terminate me, because there's no reason that would have been off limits. So, which are they going to fire? Unless they can make a very clear-cut case that I was a lot better than him, I'm the much safer termination. And that also spares them the embarrassment of the CEO having to explain to mommy why her little boy suffered that loss.

Now, I'll fully admit again that he's an unusual case, and you can support affirmative action on the basis of the idea that ON AVERAGE it will do more good than harm, and thus that he's an unintended beneficiary and the poor whites he out-competes on that basis are the unintended victims. I have no problem with supporting policies that have some negative side effects when the alternative would be worse. I just won't agree to pretend those side effects don't happen or that they're inconsequential. Affirmative action does, without a doubt in my mind, worsen inequities in some cases, by enhancing the privilege of some already-privileged people. Some princes of the aristocracy get yet another unearned advantage against their competitors because of a meaningless accident of birth.
 
Honestly.... I couldn't check the boxes for race. To me that would be like milking the system... and I can't do that. i don't believe in taking from the system. YEARS ago my exhusband lost his job because the company went out of businesss and we had a huge fight and ultimately he gave into me - because I didn't want him to claim unemployment. It was a hand out. And, I wanted no parts of it. Instead he took a job for $8 at a deli counter. Better to go to work for that than take one cent of government cheese.

connie
 
Brown said he could tell Warren was not Native American by looking at her.She said she never used that to get a job or into a school. She said her parents told her the family was unhappy that her Mother was Native American.

Brown was an ass for bringing it up first thing and Gregory asked him again in the second debate. Gregory is an ass too!

Liawatha however is of course, above reproach. she wasn't native American. then she was. then she wasn't. then she couldn't hear the question in a loud ....blah blah blah....
she's a lib. she get's a pass.

let's not make this complicated
 
Except that this analysis is nonsense, for the simple and obvious reason that if Vanessa Williams and I were applying for the same school, and there were only the two of us applying, she would receive the advantage of affirmative action and I would not. THE LAW DOES NOT BALANCE FOR CLASS. If it did, it would still be racist because it divides people by race and race alone without addressing their individual situations -- the law pre-judges people based on race (gee, I wish the English language contained a word for that).

I don't consider race-based affirmative action inherently racist. I just see it as a very blunt instrument attempting to address some negative trends in the society. If it were the only available way to address the economic legacy of racism in the country, and the lingering impact racism still has, I could support it. I just think there are better ways to accomplish the same things.

Just to provide one last anecdote about the problems with the "blunt instrument", consider the example of a cousin of mine. He's half Okinawan and half generic white. He got the Okinawan hair and skin tone, but white facial features. This gives him an indeterminately ethnic look -- he could be Arabic, Hispanic, Filipino, or maybe even Greek. However, he grew up in New Mexico, and ran with a tough crowd in school, and as a result he has a speaking pattern and accent that you'd recognize as Mexican American (even throwing Spanish words and slang into his English sentences), along with a tendency to dress the way Mexican American youths do. As a result, he's commonly mistaken for an Hispanic. It doesn't help that his first name is also one that is common among Latinos. There's no question that if he happens to apply for a job where the interviewer is a racist or xenophobe who is prejudiced against Hispanics, he's going to trigger that prejudice. And yet he gets no affirmative action at all. In fact, as someone of Japanese ancestry, he's often considered "over-represented" in things like school admissions.

There are, similarly, people of Asian descent who can be mistaken for African Americans or Native Americans, and yet get treated as over-represented and undeserving of affirmative action, even though they might have faced a lot more racial discrimination than those with African American or Native American ancestry who look white.
 
This is sort of a side point, Connieb, but I object to the use of the phrase "the old fashioned way" in the manner you used it. It implies that the old fashioned way to get ahead was through personal hard work. I'd argue that the old fashioned way to get ahead was to be born into the right family. The primary predictor of a person's wealth is the wealth of his parents, and although there have been brief periods when that was less true than today, there have been much longer periods when it was a whole lot more true than it is today. Feudal times are an obvious and extreme example -- get born into a landed aristocratic family, and you were set for life, but get born into the peasantry and even if you somehow managed to survive to adulthood, even working yourself to the bone was unlikely to get you more than a subsistence-level existence. There's nothing at all old-fashioned about the idea that people can get ahead through their own initiative and hard work. That's very much a new-fashioned ideal.... and a big part of why I'm a progressive and not a conservative. I reject nostalgia for the "old fashioned" virtues that are a trick of our collective memory.
 
I do not disagree that some minorities in this country are economically and socially disadvantaged and we should have programs in place to help them. But, there are many whose parents took advantage of programs or did it the old fashioned way and are now no longer socially or economically disadvantaged.

This is simply not true. At EVERY STRATA of socioeconomics in the USA, minorities and women face prejudices and obstacles that white males do not.

Since pretty much everything else derives from this inaccurate assessment by you, Its really dubious in its conclusions.

I think we provide public education. And, it is sad and dispaointing that kids in inner city schools don't take advantage of that and are not poised to take advantage of it.
Frankly this is racist.

Because it is a mythologized view of what is happening in public ed and you are applying that myth based on race when it has nothing to do with race.

It has to do with the crap funding we provide for that public education. My ex taught in a couple such schools. A "master teacher" she was a sucker for "rescuing" kids. But the problem was that
  • She rarely had adequate textbooks to go around
  • When she did, they were usually out of date and badly mauled - essentially telling the kids they weren't worth quality materials
  • Her classroom invariably had some sort of physical infrastructure problem. In one case the roof leak was so bad that if it had been an actual parent keeping children in such an environment would be considered "abusinve"
  • She spent about 10% of her salary providing classroom materials for her students
  • She typically had about 35 kids in her class

that sort of environment is hardly "providing a public education" In fact the difference between what your children experienced and their experience is so Night and Day that if we drop the 12% of the POOREST school districts from the National Ed statistics - the USA ranks #2 in the world


We are NOT providing equal levels of opportunity nor education... and the pretense that we are borders on the racist in and of itself
 
This is simply not true. At EVERY STRATA of socioeconomics in the USA, minorities and women face prejudices and obstacles that white males do not.


what kind of nonsense is this?

I can give you first hand accounts where the exact opposite is true. and I don't even have to mention the affirmative action hire in the white house
 
what kind of nonsense is this?

I can give you first hand accounts where the exact opposite is true.
No you cannot. because you have not sat and monitored their every experience in life. So you have no first hand account. You at best have 2nd Hand accounts - and those are "self identified" - which is not the most accurate source of data.


and I don't even have to mention the affirmative action hire in the white house
To suggest that a Harvard Magna Cum Laude, eloquent and experienced politician is an "Affirmative Action" hire makes one wonder what someone like Ulysses Grant, Andrew Jackson, Abraham Lincoln, Teddy Roosevelt, Zachary Taylor, Millard Fillmore, Chester Arthur, Taft, Hoover, Eisenhower... an GWB (Texas is a "weak governor" state. Ie the Governor is not the Chief Executive) would count as. with the Exception of Roosevelt, each has inferior education, Constitutional Law credentials and Political leadership experience.

So calling Obama an "Affirmative Action" hire is inherently a case of bigotry and bigotry based in Race.

IE racism
 
No you cannot. because you have not sat and monitored their every experience in life. So you have no first hand account. You at best have 2nd Hand accounts - and those are "self identified" - which is not the most accurate source of data.

Nor have you -- nor has anyone else. You have a couple of studies in which they were done, and those studies in no way disambiguate for region, class composition, etc.

To suggest that a Harvard Magna Cum Laude, eloquent and experienced politician is an "Affirmative Action" hire makes one wonder what someone like Ulysses Grant, Andrew Jackson, Abraham Lincoln, Teddy Roosevelt, Zachary Taylor, Millard Fillmore, Chester Arthur, Taft, Hoover, Eisenhower... an GWB (Texas is a "weak governor" state. Ie the Governor is not the Chief Executive) would count as. with the Exception of Roosevelt, each has inferior education, Constitutional Law credentials and Political leadership experience.

I would disagree that some of these had weak educations -- Grant and Eisenhower, for example, were both West Point graduates and West Point has never been considered a poor school. Taft graduated from Yale. Roosevelt graduated from Harvard.

We don't know how much affirmative action benefited Obama. We do know it benefited him some, particularly in his selection as editor of the Harvard law review.
 
Back
Top