New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Background Checks

So what do you think should happen to the records of sales kept by gun dealers when they go out of business?
 
Jesus....are you doing this just to be annoying?
1. No, I do not support a "ban on assault weapons". I do support the idea that there are some weapons that should not be in the hands of civilians.
2. Even the ban being discussed does not take your guns away. It bans future sales.
3. The card, in your pocket, has the info you've described. How in hell you can call it registration is beyond me. The only information available on a datebase is your card number and the serial number from your gun. So you tell me. How can someone at the BATF go on line and find you? The unique number does not identify you....Your possesion of the card is all you need. The seller looks at the picture, looks at you....verifies the serial number on the card and you get your ammo....Unless you have an example of how the APL, as I've desribed it, can be used to track you down...just give up. You clearly aren't able to explain your paranoia...
 
A tax audit would do the trick.

I think you'll find a tax audit will not "do the trick." The 4473 contains no dollar figures, and would be irrelevant to a tax audit (remember, I've filled out dozens of them, from both sides of the counter).



It would be a good place to start a search for guns if we were doing seizures, don't you think?

And I know some gun collectors who avoid membership for just that reason. I'm not that paranoid -- and like Benjamin Franklin I think if we don't hang together we shall surely hang separately (at least metaphorically).

To allow for enforcing background checks on sales, obviously. That's what we were discussing.

I'm afraid I'm like most collectors. I don't want a bunch of modern marks on my 103 year old Winchester, because someone else somewhere might use a gun wholly unlike it for a crime.



No. That's what YOU'RE saying. I'm saying you are quite welcome to exercise your civil right, but if you want to sell or transfer your firearm, you'll need to have a certificate. If you're too uneducated or remote to handle that, get a buddy to do it for you. Maybe the NRA will help.

Well, my civil rights and my friends civil rights should be free from the "show me your papers" actions of governments less inclined to respect individual rights. And that's what you're putting in place. Licenses, temporary licenses, etcetera -- "show me your papers, you look suspicious." To hell with the 4th Amendment, let alone the 2nd.

The fact that you see no difficulty with this is part of the problem. I shouldn't have to show papers to exercise a civil right.


I don't know when you were a teen, but teen smoking is, in fact, down sharply in recent decades.

I graduated from high school when in 1981. TEEN smoking may be down, but I know more people who smoke in their 20s today than I knew when I was in my 20s. Teen drinking may have decreased, but as I said, that merely means the problems of teen drinking now occur a few years later.


Do you have any ideas for having a no-cost system that would not include "registration" (using your own counter-factual, ultra-broad definition of that term) that would have any enforceability? If not, I'll interpret your statement as "I have no problem with doing this as long as we do it in a way that would be utterly pointless, since then I know we won't bother."

Remember -- I'm opposed to any new regulations. I have to be, because they will merely be the stepping stones to still more regulations. So no, I have no intention of proposing anything other than setting the requirement for an instant check, without regulation, using the rules available today, and making the NICS system available to non-holders of Federal Firearms Licenses. Now, let's say you did this, and person A sell to person B without doing it. Even if Person B is found with the gun, all he has to do is say "I had it before there was an instant check requirement."

Your "ammo purchase card" idea would work -- if there were no sitting Feinstiens, Boxers or Schumers to impose new restrictions six months after it was put in place. Unfortunately, in the real world, they exist and have no respect for my civil rights.

Has Feinstein called for confiscation of all guns? If not, what are you referring to?

Yes. She said "If I could have gotten the votes -- Mr. and Mrs. North America, turn them all in -- that' what I would have done, but I couldn't get the votes." People say this is an "out of context quote" and that she was only talking about assault weapons. I've seen the entire interview, and when she makes that statement she does not separate assault weapons (however you define them) from other weapons. She says "turn them ALL in."
 
middleview;641399 [QUOTE said:
No, your name and picture are on the card. The card also has an embedded machine readable serial number, which, when wanded at the gun store, verifies at the FBI that it is a valid card and that the caliber of ammo you are buying is correct. Why is it that you think that your picture and name on the card means it has to be recorded somewhere?

Because of the entrenched bureaucratic mindset I've found at the BATF, the FAA and the IRS. Your idea sounds fine in an ideal universe, but it will encounter the bureaucracy of the real world, where there must be accountability for everything.

The guy who made your card got your name from your DL when you passed your background check...and your picture was taken at the same time....

Who bears the cost for the equipment? If you require the businessman (sporting goods store, whatever) to bear the cost, you then drive up the cost of the firearms -- so this is no backdoor taxation of gun purchases as well as a means of registering gun owners.

No, and I don't need to. The idea is to make a system that doesn't have loopholes that someone will figure out a way through. As far as your Swiss rifle... You can simply list the appropriate caliber when you go in for your background check. I'm sure that the person handling your APL will understand what you are saying and work with you on it....this isn't hard stuff. You just want to make it seem so.

No, I can't do that, because any knowledgeable person running the background check will know that a .348 Winchester (the required cartridge for modification) was never chambered in a Husqvarna Rolling Block, and will not issue the card for the wrong ammo (and the 11.7mmx44R round for which the Husqvarna is chambered is sufficiently obscure that its ammo is not made anymore and that even a reasonably knowledgeable gun-store clerk may not have heard of it). And your plan makes no provision at all for buying ammo components for making such custom ammo -- I'd have to buy unfired .348 Winchester (and presumably a gun to shoot it), and fire the ammo so as to empty the cartridge, which I would then have to modify -- at which point I'd be violating the law. As far as I'm concerned, you did need to show why such firearms are a significant contributor to crime before you ask me to surrender any of the exercise of my civil rights in the name of these procecures.



[
B]I don't have to know how these systems are created to know how they're abused, hacked and otherwise not suitable for my private information[/B].

You are wrong. You don't know that they were abused, unless you found that credible account of a system that was actually hacked or abused. Your paranoia gets in the way of a rational conversation about solutions....

Please -- in the age of identity theft I'd have have to have lived with my head in a bucket for at least the last 15 years to NOT know how such systems are abused.
 
So you do not have a source for your allegation. Ok. What you know is that some blog, somewhere, says the BATF maintained data for the purpose akin to a registration....got it. So how many guns were confiscated as a result?

No -- it's not a "blog." It is 15 year old information on the Gun Owners of America site, which I know you won't accept. My memory of it dates from the time when I was working as a newspaper reporter, but unfortunately the Clinton era is long enough ago (and the matter was never front-page news), that it largely predates digital archives at most papers.

As far as I know, no guns were confiscated -- that's immaterial to the violation of the law that was going on. If one administration can violate a non-registry in this way, what would an administration with a legal registry do? I can only guess, but my guess doesn't have a happy ending for people like me.
 
middleview;641399 Because of the entrenched bureaucratic mindset I've found at the BATF said:
Oh, now identity theft is your excuse? Admit it, you are not interested in any idea that changes anything. There has been nothing in what I've posted that eliminates any of your "civil rights". There is no link between your identity and the APL as I've described it and you think there is, but cannot be specific about where it is. "Something could go wrong" is the best you can do. Your example of the gun that doesn't have ammunition that fits it and has to have custom made bullets is just so much bullshit and you know it. While you want proof that guns without serial numbers might possibly be used in a crime, I want evidence that you aren't the only guy out there customizing ammo or that somehow the second amendment was meant to protect the "right" to customize ammunition....

Instead of "Hmmm, good idea, could we do X to make it work for a situation where I customize ammo....you just say Oh, here's a problem....your solution won't work". That is why it is so easy to dismiss people like you when it comes to finding a solution.
 
Jesus....are you doing this just to be annoying?
1. No, I do not support a "ban on assault weapons". I do support the idea that there are some weapons that should not be in the hands of civilians
.

That's a distinction without a difference. I only own, at this point, one firearm that is on Fienstein's list. I don't want to give it up -- I want to enjoy it the rest of my days and pass it on to my heirs.

2. Even the ban being discussed does not take your guns away. It bans future sales.

It bans future transfers, such as to my heirs. It would also keep me from completing a collection I've been building for the past decade, of the U.S. Army Infantry rifles spanning the years since the adoption of metallic cartridges in 1866.

3. The card, in your pocket, has the info you've described. How in hell you can call it registration is beyond me. The only information available on a datebase is your card number and the serial number from your gun.

If my card is numbered, it is numbered TO ME, or the system would not work. If it is individually numbered to me, I'm registered. Otherwise, nothing keeps someone from belting me over the head, stealing my card, and using it to buy whatever they desire.

So you tell me. How can someone at the BATF go on line and find you?

By looking up the card number that is individual to me. You're reckoning without the bureaucratic mindset that would require card accountability. I've dealt with that with two different federal bureaucracies (the Army, and the FAA), and I think there is no way they'd allow the issuance of such a card without the ability to account for who received it, and where and when it was issued.
 
None of your post is true. I'm not going to address the product of your imagination or your prediction of things not in fact.
 
No -- it's not a "blog." It is 15 year old information on the Gun Owners of America site, which I know you won't accept. My memory of it dates from the time when I was working as a newspaper reporter, but unfortunately the Clinton era is long enough ago (and the matter was never front-page news), that it largely predates digital archives at most papers.

As far as I know, no guns were confiscated -- that's immaterial to the violation of the law that was going on. If one administration can violate a non-registry in this way, what would an administration with a legal registry do? I can only guess, but my guess doesn't have a happy ending for people like me.

Again, you have no facts. You have vague recollections. You think data from the 90s isn't on the web? Look up Waco and the Branch Davidians....I'm sure you'll get lot's of hits.

I went to the Gun Owners web site. It is ridiculous. It has footnotes to the alleged "misdeads" but no link to any unbiased or outside source for their account. You are right, it isn't a source of information acceptable to me.
 
None of your post is true. I'm not going to address the product of your imagination or your prediction of things not in fact.

The entire "ammo card" system you've been espousing is out of your imagination. I can't counter with my own? That seems an unfair means of debate to me.
 
Again, you have no facts. You have vague recollections. You think data from the 90s isn't on the web? Look up Waco and the Branch Davidians....I'm sure you'll get lot's of hits.

They were front-page news. During the mid-90s, most papers were merely setting up their digital archives. One paper I worked for has none that pre-date 2000. Papers that had such archives frequently focused only on big stories, or on local stories. My memory is indeed not a reliable source for detail, and I'm still seeking detail from a source you'll accept -- I do not expect you to accept an obviously self-interested source such as the Gun Owners of America (I generally pull my firearms statistical data from either the Violence Policy Center or the Brady Campaign for just that reason).
 
I'd be interested in seeing the whole Feinstein interview. If the context makes it clear she meant all guns, not just assault weapons, that's a very extreme view, and one I'd certainly oppose strongly. But we're talking about one member of the legislature. It's hard to imagine half of the legislature from both parties ever supporting that, much less the president. Even in Western Europe, that kind of extremism hasn't won out. There's still plenty of private ownership of hunting rifles and shotguns, for example.
 
Oh, now identity theft is your excuse?

Not an "excuse" -- a reason. In the real world, private data is difficult to achieve and private systems are hacked all the time. I'm simply counting on the real world being the real world. What are you counting on?

Admit it, you are not interested in any idea that changes anything. There has been nothing in what I've posted that eliminates any of your "civil rights". There is no link between your identity and the APL as I've described it and you think there is, but cannot be specific about where it is. "Something could go wrong" is the best you can do. Your example of the gun that doesn't have ammunition that fits it and has to have custom made bullets is just so much bullshit and you know it
.

My example is a real example from my own collection. I gave you the name and caliber of the firearm. Don't take my work for it, look it up. Under current law, I have no problems as reloading components are available, and the firearm itself is considered an antique and is hence immune from most federal and state firearms regulations (as are most weapons made before 1898

While you want proof that guns without serial numbers might possibly be used in a crime, I want evidence that you aren't the only guy out there customizing ammo or that somehow the second amendment was meant to protect the "right" to customize ammunition....

For customizing ammo, I invite you to check out "Handloading" magazine, published by Wolfe Publications, one of at least three magazines devoted exclusively to that subject (it's a billion dollar a year industry). The 2nd Amendment is the right to bear arms. It's damn hard to bear them if they have no ammo.

Instead of "Hmmm, good idea, could we do X to make it work for a situation where I customize ammo....you just say Oh, here's a problem....your solution won't work". That is why it is so easy to dismiss people like you when it comes to finding a solution.


I don't think it IS a good idea. I think it would act as a stepping stone to further regulations. You have reason to trust people on your side of the debate. I have equally sound reasons that I don't trust them -- to believe that ANY new regulation put in place will be extended into areas not originally encompassed by the law (declaring bullet proof vests to be "firearms" was one proposal I saw 10 years ago). Given that I can receive no "line in the sand" saying this and no more, I draw the line at "no more, now." You'd do the same to a threat to one of your civil rights.
 
I'd be interested in seeing the whole Feinstein interview. If the context makes it clear she meant all guns, not just assault weapons, that's a very extreme view, and one I'd certainly oppose strongly. But we're talking about one member of the legislature. It's hard to imagine half of the legislature from both parties ever supporting that, much less the president. Even in Western Europe, that kind of extremism hasn't won out. There's still plenty of private ownership of hunting rifles and shotguns, for example.

Unfortunately, I can't find a clip of the entire interview. (Clips of the quote itself are easy enough to find on YouTube that you can do it yourself). And don't see that we're talking about one member of legislature, either. She's a bad example, but probably no worse than Boxer or Schumer. There are lobbyists in action, too, and the Violence Policy Center, while it doesn't actually call for a ban, calls for so many restrictions that a ban might as well be in place (it would end up being only a hobby for the rich -- I'd be taxed and regulated out of gun ownership under their proposals).

And I don't expect the legislature to support such a ban, either. I expect, "Let's have an ammo ID card." Then, "let's limit the number of rounds of ammo," then "let's limit the number of guns that can be listed on the card," then "let's limit who can receive the card" and then "you have to show why you need a gun before we will issue you the card." An incremental erosion of the right until the right effectively doesn't exist.

That's how New York handles concealed carry today. You're more than welcome to have a concealed carry license in New York City under the law -- but the city refuses to issue the licenses. The sam ething played out in some counties in Missouri when the state legislature legitimized concealed carry -- the county sheriff's in Jackson and St. Louis counties refused to issue the permits (the legislature soon revoked them of this authority). If you predicate "buying a gun" on "having a card" then the access to the card becomes the means of the gun control.
 
You just ignore my posts. I've already told you what the contents of an ATF database would be. What value would there be if someone knew the following....

APL serial number, Gun serial number, caliber, date of issue.....

Because that is all there is on the system.

You invent reasons to object. Your context free "bulletproof vest" as firearm is an example. Just who made that proposal? In what context? Ah, never mind. I don't care. For all I know it was one of your anti-gun legislation wackjobs saying "here is what those guys will do next" and you've turned it into something completely different....because that is what you've done here.

See a shrink. Your paranoia gets in the way of a reasonable debate.
 
MV, "paranoia" is the fear of something that is very unlikely to occur; Trap's concerns are based on the history of anti-gun legislation in America. I don't believe its fair to say he's being "paranoid".
 
You just ignore my posts. I've already told you what the contents of an ATF database would be. What value would there be if someone knew the following....

APL serial number, Gun serial number, caliber, date of issue.....

But you're speculating, and your speculation ignores the way these bureaucracies actually work. If you can speculate that only the good would happen, I'm equally free (without, by the way, ignoring your posts) that something bad would happen.
Because that is all there is on the system.

That's all that's on the system -- in the system you envision. I don't think that it would happen that way in the real world. I know for a fact it isn't a legitimate legislative proposal at this time, and I've heard no legitimate legislative proposal for background checks on secondary sales that doesn't include registration of gun owners.

You invent reasons to object. Your context free "bulletproof vest" as firearm is an example. Just who made that proposal? In what context? Ah, never mind. I don't care. For all I know it was one of your anti-gun legislation wackjobs saying "here is what those guys will do next" and you've turned it into something completely different....because that is what you've done here.

I admit I didn't know this, but body armor is already considered in the same way as a firearm when it comes to purchase by a felon -- under U.S. federal law: http://codes.lp.findlaw.com/uscode/18/I/44/931. The specific law is Search 18 U.S.C. § 931 : US Code - Section 931: Prohibition on purchase, ownership, or possession of body armor by violent felons

See a shrink. Your paranoia gets in the way of a reasonable debate.

The baseball player Dizzy Dean used to say "It ain't braggin if you've got it." It's not paranoia if you have seen it for real. Have I seen gun regulations increased or decreased since I was a child? The answer to that question is that it has been a steady increase. It is more difficult to legally buy a firearm now than at any previous time in U.S. history (including the period when the assault weapons ban was in place). You want to limit a civil right, and then call me paranoid for protesting the limit? I'd say that means you don't wnat to have an honest discussion.

I might add that I provided you with real, factual, information you couldn't or wouldn't addressed about antiques, custom ammo, hunting firearms, etc.
 
Anyone who is so worried that something that 90% of the population is not against will be taken from you is paranoid.
 
Anyone who is so worried that something that 90% of the population is not against will be taken from you is paranoid.

Nor do I worry about that. They don't have the votes for the legislation they desire right now, much less total eradication of the civil right in question. They merely have the ability for one "unimportant" increment after another, until over time they've eroded it away without most people even noticing.
 
MV, "paranoia" is the fear of something that is very unlikely to occur; Trap's concerns are based on the history of anti-gun legislation in America. I don't believe its fair to say he's being "paranoid".

Sorry. He has so inflated any real event in our history that it can only be written off as paranoia. People were much the same when machineguns were sold from the Sears catalog and guns could be mail ordered to your home....when the laws changed there were people running around claiming there would be troops going door to door to take their guns.

I spelled out a plan (that I have also communicated to my congressman and senators). I told Trap what would be in the record on the computer. Somehow he either fails to comprehend or just ignores repeated posts with the details that state he is wrong....but he thinks that the records can magically point to him. That is the textbook definition of paranoid. He clearly stated he is against any change for any reason.....I guess he thinks there isn't a problem. Something like 90% of the population want universal background checks....Trap just wants to argue that nothing will work. His participation in the discussion is what won't work.
 
Back
Top