New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Enemy combatant: the exception that eats the Constitution?

I'm all for the "public safety exception" which delays Miranda until the suspect is questioned about possible immediate threats to the public. in this case, the possibility of bombs planted out there or the identity of co-perps.

I understand that what is gathered pre-Miranda is not admissable in Court.

http://www.fbi.gov/stats-services/publications/law-enforcement-bulletin/february2011/legal_digest

oh, yeah, eff both McCain and his sister Lindsey.

Using the old safety exception is fine, if they have reason to think there are more bombs and they're asking him about that. The problem is saying there's some new exception that applies with regard to terrorism in general and that let's them ask him about things unrelated to any imminent threat to public safety.
 
well, there is a narrow exception already carved out by SCOTUS precedent for delaying the reading of the rights already in use for citizens arrested here, and it is based on public safety considerations.

As far as I can tell it's not going to be muddled beyond that, although I agree with your concerns regarding the EC designation sought by the rightwingnuts. Your slipery slope argument has been a concern of mine since the drug war started.
 
Read him his rights then send him to Gitmo and water board the little bastard until he squeals like the pig he is

8th Amendment violation. Just like questioning him without reading him his rights is a 5th Amendment violation. Either the Constitution means something, or it doesn't.

All of these, AND the fear were created by a republican idiot in the oval office and republican controlled senate AND house. "Homeland Security" was the largest expansion of US government in history.

Creating a cabinet-level Department of Homeland Security is an idea introduced by Sen. Joseph Lieberman, who was at the time a Democrat. Bush opposed it at first, and changed his mind because of Congressional pressure. Not that this excuses Bush's signing of it by any means.
 
Bottom line, the enemy combatants definition shouldn't apply to incidents performed by U.S. citizens on U.S. soil. It applies perfectly to someone (regardless of national origin) throwing grenades at U.S. troops while working with the Taliban in Afghanistan.

Read the idiot his rights, try him, and fry him (well, we don't do that anymore -- lethal injection).
 
Republican senators McCain and Graham are urging that the suspect's Miranda rights be ignored under the theory the law of war applies, and he's an enemy combatant. Keep in mind, we're talking about an American citizen who allegedly committed a crime in America. If our Constitution doesn't even apply in that case, when does it? I'm normally skeptical about "slippery slope" arguments, but we've been sliding down one unmistakably for years. First the government could do what it wanted in approved war zones. Then unapproved war zones. Then against non-citizens outside the US in non war zones. Then against US citizens (at least the Muslim ones) outside the US in non war zones. Then against foreigners in the US. Now it looks like it will be against US citizens (at least the Muslim ones) inside the US, so long as terrorism is involved. How long until it's extended to the war on drugs and ultimately the war on crime generally? When do we citizens draw the line and tell our government "no more."

In 50 years, will we be looking back and saying "first they came for the Muslims, and I said nothing, because I was not Muslim"?





McCain and Graham may be "urging" it, but ultimately it is the Obama administration that is actually doing it.


Perhaps we should release him and kill him with a drone without due process. We could call it the "Obama Doctrine" for justice.
 
McCain and Graham may be "urging" it, but ultimately it is the Obama administration that is actually doing it.


Perhaps we should release him and kill him with a drone without due process. We could call it the "Obama Doctrine" for justice.

Yeah. We should have invaded Yemen instead, with maybe 100,000 U.S. Marines, to try to capture Awlaki alive. That would have been a MUCH preferable solution.
 
Yeah. We should have invaded Yemen instead, with maybe 100,000 U.S. Marines, to try to capture Awlaki alive. That would have been a MUCH preferable solution.


I haven't suggested that, so don't pin it on me.

If you want to argue that suspending due process is the preferred course, you are certainly welcome to do so. No one, however, should argue that this administration hasn't done precisely that; it's a matter of record.
 
I haven't suggested that, so don't pin it on me.

If you want to argue that suspending due process is the preferred course, you are certainly welcome to do so. No one, however, should argue that this administration hasn't done precisely that; it's a matter of record.

It has been explained to you, over and over and over again, that if a U.S. citizen joins an organization which is at WAR with the United States, they lose many of the constitutional rights they formerly had. You seem to absurdly and preposterously think that every Confederate soldier should have gotten a trial by jury of his peers before he was killed.

I am very glad that Abraham Lincoln was not susceptible to such crazy and whacked-out ideas.
 
Yeah. We should have invaded Yemen instead, with maybe 100,000 U.S. Marines, to try to capture Awlaki alive. That would have been a MUCH preferable solution.

You know, after the US, Yemen is the country with the highest rate of civilian firearms ownership? Random factoid....
 
It has been explained to you, over and over and over again, that if a U.S. citizen joins an organization which is at WAR with the United States, they lose many of the constitutional rights they formerly had. You seem to absurdly and preposterously think that every Confederate soldier should have gotten a trial by jury of his peers before he was killed.

I am very glad that Abraham Lincoln was not susceptible to such crazy and whacked-out ideas.




Who decides?

Who is consulted?

Is it subject to review?
 
Yes, and Yemen is a CLASSIC example of a failed state.

Coincidence?

I've been to a few dysfunctional countries and while the rate of legal ownership is very low, the rates of actual possession are very high. I was in Honduras in the late 90's and it wasn't but a few weeks before one of the locals tried to sell me an AK for about $75....
 
I'll answer your question when you answer mine.


The ACLU seems to think you might be wrong on this:



The CIA and the military are carrying out an illegal “targeted killing” program in which people far from any battlefield are determined to be enemies of the state and killed without charge or trial.

The executive branch has, in effect, claimed the unchecked authority to put the names of citizens and others on “kill lists” on the basis of a secret determination, based on secret evidence, that a person meets a secret definition of the enemy. The targeted killing program operates with virtually no oversight outside the executive branch, and essential details about the program remain secret, including what criteria are used to put people on CIA and military kill lists or how much evidence is required.

Outside of armed conflict zones, the use of lethal force is strictly limited by international law and, when it comes to U.S. citizens, the Constitution. Specifically, lethal force can be used only as a last resort against an imminent threat to life. Even in the context of an armed conflict against an armed group, the government may use lethal force only against individuals who are directly participating in hostilities against the U. S. Regardless of the context, whenever the government uses lethal force, it must take all possible steps to avoid harming civilian bystanders. These are not the standards that the executive branch is using.

The U.S. continues to carry out illegal targeted killings in Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, and elsewhere. The government must be held to account when it carries out such killings in violation of the Constitution and international law.



http://www.aclu.org/blog/tag/drones



Feel free to explain it to them. Tell them they are wrong, there is no valid view other than yours, and that the matter is settled. I'm sure they'll take it under advisement.
 
ark - you're conflating/confusing 2 separate news stories.

tsarnarev was not 'mirandaized" under an exception clause for "public safety". they wanted to interrogate him immediately and see if other explosive devices had been set to go off.

mccain - in a separate news thread - had been advocating charging tsarnarev as an "enemy combatant". which would be the correct charge if it can be established that these boys had terrorist training at al qaeda. that's ALSO a reason Miranda wouldn't apply - but it's not the reason be advanced by the FBI and the Massachussetts state police (a wholly owned subsidiary of the state of Massachussets, the bluest of the blue states).

please keep your rumor and innuendo straight, lol
 
Republican senators McCain and Graham are urging that the suspect's Miranda rights be ignored under the theory the law of war applies, and he's an enemy combatant. Keep in mind, we're talking about an American citizen who allegedly committed a crime in America. If our Constitution doesn't even apply in that case, when does it? I'm normally skeptical about "slippery slope" arguments, but we've been sliding down one unmistakably for years. First the government could do what it wanted in approved war zones. Then unapproved war zones. Then against non-citizens outside the US in non war zones. Then against US citizens (at least the Muslim ones) outside the US in non war zones. Then against foreigners in the US. Now it looks like it will be against US citizens (at least the Muslim ones) inside the US, so long as terrorism is involved. How long until it's extended to the war on drugs and ultimately the war on crime generally? When do we citizens draw the line and tell our government "no more."

In 50 years, will we be looking back and saying "first they came for the Muslims, and I said nothing, because I was not Muslim"?

Apparently, "justice for all" stops at our doorstep.

I would say that hypocrisy does not add credibility to our stature, nor diffuse or disperse the causes for which people base their attacks upon us. If we want to reduce attacks upon us, we perhaps should not be handing those attacking us, ammunition with which to attack us by, although I do have an understanding of dilemmas and conundrums and how they limit choices to bad or bad.
 
ark - you're conflating/confusing 2 separate news stories.

tsarnarev was not 'mirandaized" under an exception clause for "public safety". they wanted to interrogate him immediately and see if other explosive devices had been set to go off.

mccain - in a separate news thread - had been advocating charging tsarnarev as an "enemy combatant". which would be the correct charge if it can be established that these boys had terrorist training at al qaeda. that's ALSO a reason Miranda wouldn't apply - but it's not the reason be advanced by the FBI and the Massachussetts state police (a wholly owned subsidiary of the state of Massachussets, the bluest of the blue states).

please keep your rumor and innuendo straight, lol

John McCain and/or Lindsay Graham is/are (a) "wholly owned subsidiary(ies)" of whom or what?

We have just over half of the detainees in GITMO on a hunger strike, some have been there over 10 years without a means to present their innocence. We/you would call or consider any other nation in the world that would do such a thing, what?
 
Back
Top