New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Fair share

Exactly. Just like SNAP benefits. What a person"needs"and what they want - are too separate things.

But, if many of these people were able to adequately distinguish between the two and put of the instant gratification that comes with "treating" oneself, most of them wouldn't be poor.

My friend a recently quit smoker tallied up the money here and her BF have likely spent on cigarettes in the 25 yers, and 30 years they have smoked.. and it was over 50,000. Seriously - they have pissed away over 50K. I laughed and said.. hmmm well, imagine how much you have wasted in alcohol and when he was younger.. pot. They consitently hover at the poverty line.. and she said it made her ill to think of how much better off they could be if they had made better choices.

That's insane. Living within one's means is not really that big of a challenge, unless one is truly destitute. But that level of poverty is practically nonexistent in this country. Most of our so-called "poverty" is due to poor lifestyle choices, misplaced trust in government, and bad decisions.
 
That's insane. Living within one's means is not really that big of a challenge, unless one is truly destitute. But that level of poverty is practically nonexistent in this country. Most of our so-called "poverty" is due to poor lifestyle choices, misplaced trust in government, and bad decisions.

Of course it is, but no one will ever own up to bad decisions making their lives suck.

Of course, I tell my kids all the time, to think about every decision they are going to make.. and think about it again.. because one mistake can ruin their entire lives. One bad choice, and its game over. They could ruin their chances to go to colleges, or worse lose their lives.

My dad is the first of his family to go to college, and my mom's parents ended up pretty well off, but came from being very poor and were lower middle class when she grew up. They worked well into their 80's though so they had a lot of years to earn and squirrel away money and were very frugal.

Anyway,....I have a LOT of not so well off family members and friends. And, there is not a single one who circles the poverty level - that does not have a substance abuse problem, or an alcohol problem, or a criminal record, or who has not had children out of wedlock. Every single one of them has one or more of these issues. Yet if only someone else would do more for them they would be better off.. yeah.. right.... Conversely, I don't know anyone who has done all those things, and are able bodied.. who is impoverished..... coincidence? Yeah.. I think not. There is simply no great mystery. Stay off drugs and alcohol and avoid close associations with people who don't. Stay in school and work your tail off at it. Don't procreate out of wedlock.
 
so why should your rate be higher than someone in the top 1%?

during the Eisenhower years, the top marginal income tax rate was 91%. those were the good old days.....economically.

so why don't you libs that think and feel that way just pay 91% now? Yes, we know why you don't and just post of it............
 
Indeed.



Agreed. But the whole point is that we disagree abut what a "fair share" is. I think the poor currently pay more than their fair share and the rich currently pay a lot less than their fair share.

43% pay NO fed income taxes, making it evident the poor pay nothing:


http://www.businessinsider.com/43-of-americans-dont-pay-federal-income-tax-2013-9

other than for Smart Phones, $200 snickers, sports clothing and lates celeb garb, poor always seem to have $$$ for dope and smokes.......
 
Last edited:
That's insane. Living within one's means is not really that big of a challenge, unless one is truly destitute. But that level of poverty is practically nonexistent in this country. Most of our so-called "poverty" is due to poor lifestyle choices, misplaced trust in government, and bad decisions.

I guess all those Smart Phone all the POOR have are furnished by the government, the POOR have $2000 wheels on their rides and dress in damn expensive clothing..............sports/music/etc and how bout those $200 sneakers!
 
Last edited:
I guess all those Smart Phone all the POOR have are furnished by the government, the POOR have $2000 wheels on their rides and dress in damn expensive clothing..............sports/music/etc and how bout those $200 snickers!
$200 Snickers????.....WTF???.....You claiming Candy Bars are that expensive???
 
Oh I'm not bothered in the slightest. You can make up for yourself that I am, but I am not.

I get it that you want to oppress the poor and keep them dependent.

See how that sucks...making shit up...?

I can read.....and you're whining.....about tax rates and wanting everyone to pay the same rate. that is soooo UN-progressive that it puts you back in the 1800s.
 
So, a question...

What is a 'fair share', as a percentage of income?
If one were truly interested in "fairness", all citizens would pay the same amount. Forget sliding scales, forget percentages. It is inherently UNFAIR that citizen cost for infrastructure is higher for one than another. That is clearly UNEQUAL PROTECTION under the law.

However, we know that the purpose of taxation is not merely funding for government operations. It is intended to be redistributive...and to be demonstrative to certain classes that the hoi polloi are being hammered (a sort of protection racket to keep the mob at bay).

Fairness has nothing to do with taxation. And funding operational cost is but a small part of its purpose.
 
I can read.....and you're whining.....about tax rates and wanting everyone to pay the same rate. that is soooo UN-progressive that it puts you back in the 1800s.

let's guess, @ 70 you don't pay ANY fed income taxes................
 
I can read.....and you're whining.....about tax rates and wanting everyone to pay the same rate. that is soooo UN-progressive that it puts you back in the 1800s.

Nope. I think the rich should pay more. Poof.
Now what...you want to make more stuff up?

Anyway...so why do you support oppressing the poor?
 
If one were truly interested in "fairness", all citizens would pay the same amount. Forget sliding scales, forget percentages. It is inherently UNFAIR that citizen cost for infrastructure is higher for one than another. That is clearly UNEQUAL PROTECTION under the law.

However, we know that the purpose of taxation is not merely funding for government operations. It is intended to be redistributive...and to be demonstrative to certain classes that the hoi polloi are being hammered (a sort of protection racket to keep the mob at bay).

Fairness has nothing to do with taxation. And funding operational cost is but a small part of its purpose.

GOP gospel trickle-down economics is redistributive.
 
GOP gospel trickle-down economics is redistributive.
Whatever you say. Power stations are redistributive.

I was speaking of government tax policy. And, specifically, was trying to make the point that "fairness" is not an objective of taxation as it exists in the USA. We can argue over whether or not it should be - but it's not about "fairness" today.
 
I just want people to think through the consequences of that kind of reckless move -- the way that it would drastically worsen wealth inequality in this country, destabilizing our social structure while driving the middle class into poverty and the lower class to outright violent desperation.... all so some rich folks can afford longer yachts.
 
I would think "fair share," at its most extreme connotation with respect to taxes, would be that they pay a share of the taxes that is roughly equal to their share of the income:

An article from the TaxFoundation contains federal data for 2010, reporting the following:

  • Top 1% earned 18.9% of $$$$, paid 37.4% of taxes.
  • Top 5% earned 33.8% of $$$$, paid 59.1% of taxes.
  • Bottom 50% earned 11.7% of $$$$, paid 2.4% of taxes.
https://constitutionalconservative.wordpress.com/myth-the-rich-dont-pay-their-fair-share/

So, now who exactly is it that isn't paying their "fair share?" Anyone suggesting such nonsense, in light of the facts (above) is simply displaying their Marxist ideology with respect to tax policy. It has nothing to do with "paying their fair share" and everything to do with "wealth redistribution." The fact that Bernie has to lie about this illustrates the subversive nature of the communist agenda.
 
Back
Top