That hasn't been what I've observed. What I've seen is that the most economically successful people are generally awful. For example, my richest relative made his fortune first by stealing a customer list from his old employer, then selling those customers reconditioned machines as new, and gaming government contracting rules by putting his company in his wife's name to get access to "woman-owned business" advantages. Ethics would have been a huge hindrance for him.
I see the same within large organizations where I've worked. People who get ahead are those who have no qualms about taking credit for other people's work, and who will happily do the wrong thing, legally or morally, if they perceive it will be liked by whoever controls their next promotion, and they think they can get away with it. And those are just the rank-and-file contestants in the rat race. When you get to the real elite, you find the world-class scumbags, like the crooks who gave us the 2008 meltdown, or Enron, or Tyco, or the Russian oil oligarchs, or African kleptocrats, etc. Even when their houses of cards eventually crumble, they walk away with millions.
That's not even to get into people like Waltons, Kochs, Trump, and the Bushes, who just get rich with money from their wealthy families and political and business connections from their aristocratic upbringings. I think that if it were possible to graph "virtue" against wealth, you'd see a strong inverse correlation as you moved up from the middle ranks of wealth towards the elite.
But, even if they were mostly decent folks, I don't think that would change the fact that the system is currently set up to exploit the poor and middle class for the benefit of the elite. It's a bit like if you were a slave on the plantation of a kindly master, or a serf working the land of a generous Lord. The system itself is exploitative, whether the particular member of the elite is decent or not.
OK. Check the real numbers on that, then. Median weekly earnings for someone with less than a high school diploma are $493, and unemployment rates for that group are 8.0%. By the time you get up to a professional degree, it's $1,730 and 1.5%. Assuming 50 weeks per year and factoring in unemployment, it works out to $85,203 for a professional degree versus $22,678 for not having a high school diploma. Even factoring in the cost of the education, you're going to come out way ahead with the professional degree, on average. And that isn't changed by higher tax rates for higher earners. Progressive taxation isn't anywhere close to progressive enough to counter the impact of the higher earnings.
Go to a really up-scale neighborhood sometime and check out the education levels. For example, close to my own home:
http://www.movoto.com/sudbury-ma/01776/demographics/
90% of the population has at least a Bachelors degree. That's the path to success, and there's no sign people are responding to slightly higher taxes on the top bracket under Obama (or a similar hike under Clinton) by drifting away from that path. They know that there's no serious sense in which they're being punished for their effort. They know that even after the higher taxes, they'll still be getting a big return on investment.
That said, I would point out that our tax policy is a bit weird with regard to education in one way. You "earn out" of interest deductions on your college education loans, even though you don't "earn out" of interest deductions on things like second homes or yachts. So, you end up with a situation where some rich dude with a mortgage on his vacation mansion gets to write off the interest, but someone who invested in his education by borrowing doesn't get to write it off. That makes no sense. So, a modest proposal: eliminate the deductibility of mortgage interest other than for the primary residence and only to the extent that the house's value is median or less. So, for example, if the median house costs $200k and yours is worth $1 million, you can write off 20% of your mortgage interest. Then, make a person's entire educational expense deductible (not just the interest), on the theory that it's an investment that makes the income possible, and so should be taken out when counting what the income's true profit is to the person.
I seek that, too. And based on both common sense and empirical data, I see that they're more likely to stay dependent if you keep them just north of starvation level than if you give them the tools and relative shelter from the hardships of poverty needed to get their lives together and become self sufficient. A little extra investment in people in the short term saves a lot in the long term.
so, do I take it that you and I are the exception? that is, we're not awful, and have qualms...