Arkady
President
Sometimes it's run fairly well. And other times we have Republican administrations.And that is one of the problems. Government workers are not efficient and is not run like a company
Sometimes it's run fairly well. And other times we have Republican administrations.And that is one of the problems. Government workers are not efficient and is not run like a company
Do the math. It's unworkable. A flat tax would lower the taxes on the rich and raise them on everyone else. In a time when income inequality is growing, that will just make things worse. You wind up with the working class going to bed hungry so Mitt Romney can get yet another mansion.Right now there is a lot of equality and fairness talk and subjects going around in the usa.
Flat tax fits into that conversation. Each person paying equally for the roads, government services, and national defense.
Makes a lot of sense.
Sometimes it's run fairly well. And other times we have Republican administrations.
Do the math. It's unworkable. A flat tax would lower the taxes on the rich and raise them on everyone else. In a time when income inequality is growing, that will just make things worse. You wind up with the working class going to bed hungry so Mitt Romney can get yet another mansion.
Again a strange way to look at it. You could have said Al Gore gets another mansion. Or you could just say you are jealous of those with mansions.
If we are going to force political correctness in gay marriage, racial equality etc, then why not have everyone pay the same amount of tax?
Leadership matters. When the government's senior leadership is highly competent, the technocrats below them are generally able to do a pretty good job. When the senior leadership is a diseased swamp of right-wing idiots pushing ideological fantasies, even strong technocrats have trouble operating efficiently.That is a very strange way of looking at it considering the government workers are the same under both administrations
They're not my mansions, so I couldn't be jealous of them:
http://www.vocabulary.com/articles/chooseyourwords/envy-jealousy/
Currently, total government spending is $6.5 trillion (federal, state, and local). If we paid for that will everyone paying the same amount, that would be an annual tax bill of $20,376 for every man, woman, and child in the country, or $81,504 for a family of four. Considering the median family doesn't earn that much total in a year, having everyone pay the same amount of tax simply isn't going to work.
And that is one of the problems. Government workers are not efficient and is not run like a company
I very much encourage people here to try the math themselves. Come up with a proposed tax scheme, plug it into an Excel spreadsheet using the Census's data on income distribution by household, and you can figure out easily enough what level of revenue it'll produce. If you make an honest effort to play around with that, you'll soon realize that a flatter tax system must necessarily mean a crushing increase of taxes on the majority, a gigantic deficit, or the necessity for huge spending cuts.... or some combination of the three.
Flatter taxes can be made to work, even in modern nations, but everywhere they've succeeded on a large scale they're coupled with much more generous social spending and much less military spending. Essentially, you wind up with much higher taxes on the poor and middle class, but then that burden is offset by the government financing much more of their lifestyles (e.g., free healthcare, free university, highly subsidized public transit and childcare, etc.), so that their expendable income remains similar. Much of Western Europe has a tax structure like that, with most revenues coming through a fairly flat AMT. But, as I suggested, they have a generous welfare state. I'm not clear on how you'd make a flatter tax work in a modern nation without that expansion of social spending, and shrinkage of the military budget, since the hardship you'd create for the majority seems certain to create dangerous social instability. How do you hit the middle and lower classes with a huge hike to their tax bill without doing anything more to help them make ends meet, and not expect that to trigger serious problems in the society?
I very much encourage people here to try the math themselves. Come up with a proposed tax scheme, plug it into an Excel spreadsheet using the Census's data on income distribution by household, and you can figure out easily enough what level of revenue it'll produce. If you make an honest effort to play around with that, you'll soon realize that a flatter tax system must necessarily mean a crushing increase of taxes on the majority, a gigantic deficit, or the necessity for huge spending cuts.... or some combination of the three.
Flatter taxes can be made to work, even in modern nations, but everywhere they've succeeded on a large scale they're coupled with much more generous social spending and much less military spending. Essentially, you wind up with much higher taxes on the poor and middle class, but then that burden is offset by the government financing much more of their lifestyles (e.g., free healthcare, free university, highly subsidized public transit and childcare, etc.), so that their expendable income remains similar. Much of Western Europe has a tax structure like that, with most revenues coming through a fairly flat AMT. But, as I suggested, they have a generous welfare state. I'm not clear on how you'd make a flatter tax work in a modern nation without that expansion of social spending, and shrinkage of the military budget, since the hardship you'd create for the majority seems certain to create dangerous social instability. How do you hit the middle and lower classes with a huge hike to their tax bill without doing anything more to help them make ends meet, and not expect that to trigger serious problems in the society?
This, and the idea of replacing the income tax with a national sales tax, is no more than a ruse; and poorer people will suffer the brunt of either one.
They're not my mansions, so I couldn't be jealous of them:
http://www.vocabulary.com/articles/chooseyourwords/envy-jealousy/
Currently, total government spending is $6.5 trillion (federal, state, and local). If we paid for that will everyone paying the same amount, that would be an annual tax bill of $20,376 for every man, woman, and child in the country, or $81,504 for a family of four. Considering the median family doesn't earn that much total in a year, having everyone pay the same amount of tax simply isn't going to work.
Leadership matters. When the government's senior leadership is highly competent, the technocrats below them are generally able to do a pretty good job. When the senior leadership is a diseased swamp of right-wing idiots pushing ideological fantasies, even strong technocrats have trouble operating efficiently.
I mean, picture yourself as a disaster-management specialist with years of experience at FEMA. Only, instead of answering up through the usual highly-skilled emergency management professional, like a James Witt, now you're reporting up through Michael Brown, a man with no relevant experience whose prior job was as a horse judge, and who was put in charge of FEMA simply because he was a good fund raiser for the party. It might be a lot harder to do a "heckuva job," in that scenario, if, say, New Orleans gets hit by a major hurricane, don't you think?
Well, that's what you get with Republicans. It is, even in the words of a Republican insider, the rule of the "Mayberry Machievellis" where everything ends up being run by the political arm of the administration, and actual competence matters for nothing.
Monica Goodling was another good example.... she was a freshly minted lawyer from a joke of a law school run by evangelical dimwit Pat Robertson, yet the Bush administration gave her major power in the justice department. She was involved in the unprecedented dismissible of seven US States Attorneys in order to impede investigations into Republican political wrongdoing. It doesn't matter if those US Attorneys were all brilliant, hard-working lawyers, some with years of experience and elite educations. If you put them under the thumb of one of the Mayberry Machiavellis, like Goodling, you destroy their value to the nation.
That's why, if you check the numbers, the nation routinely does markedly better with Democratic presidents than Republican ones. Taken as a group, Democratic administrations, going back a century, have stronger job creation, better stock market performance, a better fiscal balance, better movement of the poverty rate, stronger GDP growth rates, etc. Leadership matters, and Republicans are horrible, horrible leaders.
The simple fact of the matter is that America has been in serious fiscal decline since the progressives succeeded in exempting almost half the population from paying any income tax and shifted more and more of the burden for the cost of government upward, so a vast majority of voters has no economic reason to support cutting government back to a size that is more conducive to economic growth. So yes, that means in order to move the electorate back to a point where they have a reason to vote for government frugality, you have to increase taxes on the un-wealthy. There is no easy (painless) way to do that but it must be done. While I am very wary of rate creep I would do so with a flat income tax that carries a high standard deductable (say 120% of poverty level income) and then couple that with a low rate VAT or national sales tax. This insures a) tax policy remains progressive and b) that everyone has an interest in making sure we have an effective, rather than expansive government. The only way to do this is to set rates so the middle class is kept about the same, with a modest increase on the wealthy and a small hit to the working class. That way you could probably forge a majority that would support this change.
As for investment income, I would stop taxing it at the business level and tax dividends and capital gains as ordinary income as above. Our goal should be first to get the economy growing and the way to do that is get new businesses established and existing ones expanding and then to produce sufficient tax revenue to fund the basics of government, including some standard level of social welfare and reasonable levels of military readiness.
What these guys are ignoring totally is that financial dismcomfort has been authored by the fed's policy of a weak dollar and not specifically by tax policy per se. The Government then has to use that very same dollar to buy inflated goods and services...pretty stupid. To avoid discomfort for itself the Government hacks oder up more paper....even if it is electronic and find ways to suck more of the currency unit out of the pockets of productive citizens because... well they can't get very much from the unproductive crowd that they have cultivated over the past 5 decades of ggiving away free shit. While doing this they expand the benefits base by offering more and more of the borrowed, printed and confiscated crapola currency in exchange for votes.
This is why I say that only a consumption based tax can possibly work the needed reform because it is the only tax that is self regulating...all others depend on good will and honesty of which we have exactly NONE in the the government process.
By adding this tax to the price of purchase you immediately make everyone a voter. Even the guy who walks across the Mexican border to buy a gallon of milk becomes a legal voter and at that point who cares? He is going to vote for fiscal sanity because he wants to pay less in pesos or in dollars for that gallon of milk.
As for tax collection we have an army of tens of millions of cashiers who do this already as part of their job..... Now the Policiticians would have to appeal to the wallets of each citizen for their votes...a massive change indeed from the current position of offering other people's wallets in exchange for votes and unfortunately for mindless egalitarians like Bugs and Ark....there will still be rich people. Sigh....oh the pain!!
I'm telling you it's the only way.
JO
While I agree with you in principle, I would not want to see us make the perfect the enemy of the good here with respect to tax policy. That's why I think you'd have to do the hybrid system like I outlined so you can keep the consumption tax rate low enough to make it less of an issue like Arkady did in his OP regarding how we are "massively shifting the tax policy onto the poor and away from the rich." The rich would pay the income tax and a good deal of the consumption tax, so that's very progressive, but it gets even the poor interested in checking the expansion of government. Which ultimately relieves the pressure for ever higher taxation/borrowing as government expands exponentially.
The simple fact of the matter is that America has been in serious fiscal decline since the progressives succeeded in exempting almost half the population from paying any income tax and shifted more and more of the burden for the cost of government upward, so a vast majority of voters has no economic reason to support cutting government back to a size that is more conducive to economic growth. So yes, that means in order to move the electorate back to a point where they have a reason to vote for government frugality, you have to increase taxes on the un-wealthy. There is no easy (painless) way to do that but it must be done. While I am very wary of rate creep I would do so with a flat income tax that carries a high standard deductable (say 120% of poverty level income) and then couple that with a low rate VAT or national sales tax. This insures a) tax policy remains progressive and b) that everyone has an interest in making sure we have an effective, rather than expansive government. The only way to do this is to set rates so the middle class is kept about the same, with a modest increase on the wealthy and a small hit to the working class. That way you could probably forge a majority that would support this change.
As for investment income, I would stop taxing it at the business level and tax dividends and capital gains as ordinary income as above. Our goal should be first to get the economy growing and the way to do that is get new businesses established and existing ones expanding and then to produce sufficient tax revenue to fund the basics of government, including some standard level of social welfare and reasonable levels of military readiness.
You alternate posts carping about the growth in the wealth gap with posts carping about how the wealthy have been asked to bear too great a portion of the income tax burden. The usual inconsistency and incoherence.
And I'm sure you know that, all forms of taxation included, the poor and middle class pay a very large percentage of their income in taxes. The mega wealthy, like Steve Forbes, snicker when they see the GOP rabble supporting their flat tax hooey - they would love another huge tax cut!
;-)
Which is why my plan actually increases taxes on the rich while seeking to curb the growth of government which assures them that pressure for even more hikes are not developing (like Bill Clinton so successfully did). So I'm sure you didn't know (but should have) that my plan is not anything like Steve Forbes'...