New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Flat Tax Math

Then you want to cap welfare spending, rather than cutting it? You figure that will reduce the wealth gap?

The best way to reduce the wealth gap is to reduce the size of government. In case you haven't noticed, the only ones getting rich off of it are the exceedingly wealthy...
 
Hahaha! You don't make the rules around here. The point in that chart is obvious. No matter what the marginal income tax rate was the government collected about the same percent of GDP. So why on earth do you pointy headed progressives keep suggesting that the outcome of changing marginal rates does anything to increase tax take? Obviously (from that chart) the only way to increase tax revenue is to find a tax policy that best supports economic growth.

I do make my rules.

As to your point, I did not even argue the contrary above. You seek to drift off on a tangent.
 
The best way to reduce the wealth gap is to reduce the size of government. In case you haven't noticed, the only ones getting rich off of it are the exceedingly wealthy...

It depends on HOW the size of government is reduced, and HOW the savings are spent, or not spent.

And it's just crazy to claim that shifting tax burden upward would not shrink the gap. That's putting ideology above basic math.
 
It depends on HOW the size of government is reduced, and HOW the savings are spent, or not spent.

And it's just crazy to claim that shifting tax burden upward would not shrink the gap. That's putting ideology above basic math.

The "basic math" is in the chart I linked. Government appears unable to extract more than about 18% of GDP in tax revenue, regardless of marginal rates. The tax burden is already hideously skewed toward progressivity (other than the "insurance" premium wage taxes which are largely recouped, and then some, in benefits by those who pay them).
 
The "basic math" is in the chart I linked. Government appears unable to extract more than about 18% of GDP in tax revenue, regardless of marginal rates. The tax burden is already hideously skewed toward progressivity (other than the "insurance" premium wage taxes which are largely recouped, and then some, in benefits by those who pay them).

Again, you're seeking to obfuscate by mixing issues.

How the tax burden is distributed, as among classes, is basic math.
 
While I agree with you in principle, I would not want to see us make the perfect the enemy of the good here with respect to tax policy. That's why I think you'd have to do the hybrid system like I outlined so you can keep the consumption tax rate low enough to make it less of an issue like Arkady did in his OP regarding how we are "massively shifting the tax policy onto the poor and away from the rich." The rich would pay the income tax and a good deal of the consumption tax, so that's very progressive, but it gets even the poor interested in checking the expansion of government. Which ultimately relieves the pressure for ever higher taxation/borrowing as government expands exponentially.

I think perhaps one way you could do that is to have the National Sales Tax or VAT - be limited on certain items. Many states already do that - so there is no tax on groceries or no tax on clothes. So you could put that in with no taxes on purchase of groceries and maybe some essential clothes items like underwear and socks. Where if the poor are spending their disposable income - they aren't paying tax on the things they spend most of their money on. But, the other consumers who buy electronics buy brand name clothes, etc - are bearing more of the burden.

But, unlike income tax - its a burden they choose or not choose to spend on. So, If i choose not to spend my money on those things - I am not taxed. If I do - then I am taxed and you can tax higher cost goods at a different rate. So, maybe you have a 1% tax on clothes and shoes under $100 a piece, but over $100 per item the tax is 3%. Or Jewlry is all taxed at 5% or electronics are all taxed at 5%. So, you tax at a higher level those things which truly are luxuries. but, those who want them will still buy them.

connie
 
I think perhaps one way you could do that is to have the National Sales Tax or VAT - be limited on certain items. Many states already do that - so there is no tax on groceries or no tax on clothes. So you could put that in with no taxes on purchase of groceries and maybe some essential clothes items like underwear and socks. Where if the poor are spending their disposable income - they aren't paying tax on the things they spend most of their money on. But, the other consumers who buy electronics buy brand name clothes, etc - are bearing more of the burden.

But, unlike income tax - its a burden they choose or not choose to spend on. So, If i choose not to spend my money on those things - I am not taxed. If I do - then I am taxed and you can tax higher cost goods at a different rate. So, maybe you have a 1% tax on clothes and shoes under $100 a piece, but over $100 per item the tax is 3%. Or Jewlry is all taxed at 5% or electronics are all taxed at 5%. So, you tax at a higher level those things which truly are luxuries. but, those who want them will still buy them.

connie

Hooboy! Be careful Connie! I could agree that maybe essential food items (bread milk cheese eggs & veggies) might be exempted but a blanket exemption on food that includes filet mignon and Cheetos is bad policy in my view. And setting dollar limits with different rates applied is going to get the system gamed. I'd rather keep the rate lower and apply it to everything (but maybe essential foods).
 
Hooboy! Be careful Connie! I could agree that maybe essential food items (bread milk cheese eggs & veggies) might be exempted but a blanket exemption on food that includes filet mignon and Cheetos is bad policy in my view. And setting dollar limits with different rates applied is going to get the system gamed. I'd rather keep the rate lower and apply it to everything (but maybe essential foods).

My state Sales tax already does exempt Filet Mignon. Groceries are groceries as long as they are not prepared foods - then I think food should be food at a grocery store EVEN if they are luxuries. But, then raise the rates on other things. And, this is in MD - where trust me those bastards in Annapolis have never met a tax they didn't like or didn't hike ( as Hogan's campaign aptly put it). The reason is - you don't want it to be regressive. If the rich are buying filet ever week and they get a pass - so what. But, if the little family wants filet for a special dinner - and they script and saved for it, I don't care that they didn't pay a few pennies more. I actually think taxing food sales in states that do already is horribly regressive. Additionally - taxing food - if we keep a program like food stamps - just means we pay more. So, I can see limiting the tax on food - just to limit the cost to the taxpayer.

Already in many states though - there are vastly different sales taxes for different types of items. So retailers already have those kind of systems in place, and in reality it doesn't result in much gaming of the system. Because in the end very few people are going to buy or not buy based on the timing and if they want it or not. So, its not uncommon that this would be done like that. Which is why I suggested it.
 
I think perhaps one way you could do that is to have the National Sales Tax or VAT - be limited on certain items. Many states already do that - so there is no tax on groceries or no tax on clothes. So you could put that in with no taxes on purchase of groceries and maybe some essential clothes items like underwear and socks. Where if the poor are spending their disposable income - they aren't paying tax on the things they spend most of their money on. But, the other consumers who buy electronics buy brand name clothes, etc - are bearing more of the burden.

But, unlike income tax - its a burden they choose or not choose to spend on. So, If i choose not to spend my money on those things - I am not taxed. If I do - then I am taxed and you can tax higher cost goods at a different rate. So, maybe you have a 1% tax on clothes and shoes under $100 a piece, but over $100 per item the tax is 3%. Or Jewlry is all taxed at 5% or electronics are all taxed at 5%. So, you tax at a higher level those things which truly are luxuries. but, those who want them will still buy them.

connie

Models proposing to replace the income tax with such consumption taxes (whether called sales taxes or VATs, or whatever) typically call for a consumption tax in the range of 20%, not 1% or 5%.

And I think it's exceptionally bad policy to tax consumption of goods and/or services (not to mention extremely regressive). We want to encourage consumption for economic reasons, not discourage it.
 
Models proposing to replace the income tax with such consumption taxes (whether called sales taxes or VATs, or whatever) typically call for a consumption tax in the range of 20%, not 1% or 5%.

And I think it's exceptionally bad policy to tax consumption of goods and/or services (not to mention extremely regressive). We want to encourage consumption for economic reasons, not discourage it.

Yes, I know.... prop up our shitty economy that you need to be able to manipulate your debt service with - by encouraging people to spend all the money they can - as opposed to save it and build wealth for themselves. That trend needs to change. Americans don't save near enough.

Part of the point of making it small though at least to start is so that it does not disrupt the economy over much to begin with as over the course of time people's buying habits will change.

And, yes, you see it at 20% AND the people there barely buy anything. There is a problem with taking it too high, and I was speaking in regards to Lukey's suggestion to couple a flat tax with a VAT. In which case the VAT does not need to be 20% I do not advocate a VAT unless and until - we eliminate the vast majority of other taxes.

connie
 
Yes, I know.... prop up our shitty economy that you need to be able to manipulate your debt service with - by encouraging people to spend all the money they can - as opposed to save it and build wealth for themselves. That trend needs to change. Americans don't save near enough.

Part of the point of making it small though at least to start is so that it does not disrupt the economy over much to begin with as over the course of time people's buying habits will change.

And, yes, you see it at 20% AND the people there barely buy anything. There is a problem with taking it too high, and I was speaking in regards to Lukey's suggestion to couple a flat tax with a VAT. In which case the VAT does not need to be 20% I do not advocate a VAT unless and until - we eliminate the vast majority of other taxes.

connie

If we have a VAT and all other taxes eliminated the VAT would have to be in the neighborhood of 20% (likely higher) - that was my point.

And discouraging consumption of goods and services is horrible economic policy. That's what makes our economy tick. And poorer people can't save, VAT or no VAT - they will still spend all their money, not save it. Same with most middle class people.
 
How are your "unearned" investments doing?
Quite nicely, thanks.

I've got one particularly nice deal going thanks to an employee stock purchase plan, which is essentially a way that companies are allowed to disguise compensation in order to take advantage of the lower taxes on unearned income. Basically, I get a 15% discount on company stock, which (given how much of it I buy) is functionally equivalent to the company handing me a few thousand extra dollars. Only, I don't have to pay taxes on that extra money, the way I would if it were in my salary. No income taxes, much less payroll taxes. So long as I hold it for two years without selling, the discount just shows up as an increase in capital gain.

So, for example, say I earn $350,000 this year. At that level, the federal income tax on my top dollar is 33%, plus 2.9% for Medicare (I'm over the SS cap, so nothing there). That's 35.9%, not even counting state taxes. But if I instead get to count that extra money as a long-term capital gain, I get taxed just 15%. It's a pretty amazing (albeit wholly indefensible) benefit, slashing my tax bill by over half (and letting me defer it as long as I like, by just holding off on the sale).

It's truly bizarre that our tax system is set up to punish people the more they deserve their money. If you are handed $1 million for actual productive work, it is taxed more than if you are handed the exact same $1 million for doing nothing other than making some investment choices, and even that is taxed more than if the exact same $1 million were transferred by way of an inheritance, where you did nothing to earn it other than having the right relative. It's a tax system set up for the benefit of the aristocracy.
 
If we have a VAT and all other taxes eliminated the VAT would have to be in the neighborhood of 20% (likely higher) - that was my point.

And discouraging consumption of goods and services is horrible economic policy. That's what makes our economy tick. And poorer people can't save, VAT or no VAT - they will still spend all their money, not save it. Same with most middle class people.

You can save no matter HOW little you earn. It is a mindset. Not a dollars and cents thing. If you think you can't save you wont.

And, yes - we know that you would rather have individuals broke with none of their own safetynet. That way they are easier for Big Gov't to control with promises of payouts. Yes the economy would have to re-adjust. Yet, the WWII generation were some of the best savers we ever had, and grew their net worth in un predicented levels.. and yet the economy expanded as well while they were saving and building net worth. So, it can be done.

And, the VAT does not have to be 20% if you DRASTICALLY cut Gov't, both the size, scope and Gov't services. That has to be part of any flat tax discussion and the reason for instituting one. So everyone feels the pain and wants big cuts.
 
If we have a VAT and all other taxes eliminated the VAT would have to be in the neighborhood of 20% (likely higher) - that was my point.

And discouraging consumption of goods and services is horrible economic policy. That's what makes our economy tick. And poorer people can't save, VAT or no VAT - they will still spend all their money, not save it. Same with most middle class people.

Which is why I didn't advocate for that, as Connie pointed out. You have to keep the consumption tax low and the only way to do that is keep an income tax (preferably a simple flat one with no deductions) on upper income people.
 
Quite nicely, thanks.

I've got one particularly nice deal going thanks to an employee stock purchase plan, which is essentially a way that companies are allowed to disguise compensation in order to take advantage of the lower taxes on unearned income. Basically, I get a 15% discount on company stock, which (given how much of it I buy) is functionally equivalent to the company handing me a few thousand extra dollars. Only, I don't have to pay taxes on that extra money, the way I would if it were in my salary. No income taxes, much less payroll taxes. So long as I hold it for two years without selling, the discount just shows up as an increase in capital gain.

So, for example, say I earn $350,000 this year. At that level, the federal income tax on my top dollar is 33%, plus 2.9% for Medicare (I'm over the SS cap, so nothing there). That's 35.9%, not even counting state taxes. But if I instead get to count that extra money as a long-term capital gain, I get taxed just 15%. It's a pretty amazing (albeit wholly indefensible) benefit, slashing my tax bill by over half (and letting me defer it as long as I like, by just holding off on the sale).

It's truly bizarre that our tax system is set up to punish people the more they deserve their money. If you are handed $1 million for actual productive work, it is taxed more than if you are handed the exact same $1 million for doing nothing other than making some investment choices, and even that is taxed more than if the exact same $1 million were transferred by way of an inheritance, where you did nothing to earn it other than having the right relative. It's a tax system set up for the benefit of the aristocracy.

Yes, but you pay that 15% on only "a few thousand dollars" of your income. How much tax does the company pay before you earn any dividends or capital gains?
 
Yes, but you pay that 15% on only "a few thousand dollars" of your income. How much tax does the company pay before you earn any dividends or capital gains?
From my perspective, who cares? The question for me is how much I pay in taxes, and I pay a lot more for the money I work for than I do for the money I get as investment income (or the money that's disguised as investment income).
 
You can save no matter HOW little you earn. It is a mindset. Not a dollars and cents thing. If you think you can't save you wont.

And, yes - we know that you would rather have individuals broke with none of their own safetynet. That way they are easier for Big Gov't to control with promises of payouts. Yes the economy would have to re-adjust. Yet, the WWII generation were some of the best savers we ever had, and grew their net worth in un predicented levels.. and yet the economy expanded as well while they were saving and building net worth. So, it can be done.

And, the VAT does not have to be 20% if you DRASTICALLY cut Gov't, both the size, scope and Gov't services. That has to be part of any flat tax discussion and the reason for instituting one. So everyone feels the pain and wants big cuts.

I'll ignore your concoctions of what I supposedly believe. I say what I believe.

And one thing I believe is that it's fantasy to think that everyone can save money. Many people spend every cent they earn and they still live in squalor and go hungry. If consumers did manage to save money, less purchase of goods and services would take place, the economy would take a hit, and more people would lose their jobs. A horrible cycle. The solution is putting more money in the hands of consumers by doing things like shifting tax burden upward, hiking the minimum wage, curtailing outsourcing, and strengthening unions - all bitterly opposed by the GOP.
 
From my perspective, who cares? The question for me is how much I pay in taxes, and I pay a lot more for the money I work for than I do for the money I get as investment income (or the money that's disguised as investment income).

That's because it is the result of your ownership stake in a business which presumably is also paying taxes on its earnings on your behalf.
 
Which is why I didn't advocate for that, as Connie pointed out. You have to keep the consumption tax low and the only way to do that is keep an income tax (preferably a simple flat one with no deductions) on upper income people.

That's two regressive proposals. The wealth gap would soar.
 
Back
Top