New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Inheritance Crisis

That is the issue though Arkady -t hey are not removed from the day to day struggles - even in the top 2 percent

I'm not removed in the sense of being able to kick back and live very comfortably on an income stream from a portfolio. But even at my level, work is about luxuries, not necessities. My house is paid off and I have over $600k of investments. If I wanted to quit, those investments would cover an income above the poverty level for my family for the rest of my life. Certainly those in the top tenth of a percent are in a whole different category, but already at my level people are being removed from the daily concerns that have dominated the attention of almost all of mankind for all of history. Even if I decide never to work again, I can keep a roof over my head and food on the table. How many people can say that?

And once we move even a little above my level, the removal from the day-to-day life experiences of regular people grows even more profound. If you inherited a 3 million dollar business, for example, you could sell it and live on the proceeds quite comfortably for life, without ever working. You could buy a $140,000 life annuity and live richer than 87% of households without ever again doing a day's paid work.

I've recently become more aware of just how huge a difference having money, even at my relatively modest level, makes in how life is lived. When I used to travel, when I was young, I was super cautious about money. I never went to a restaurant -- I'd buy a few cheap things in a grocery store and eat them on the street. I never took a cab. I searched exhaustively for youth hostels and other discount places. Etc. Now, I don't even look at the prices of the menus, or think twice about catching a cab. I know it's a bit of a waste for me to sweat the small stuff. As long as I don't develop very fancy hobbies and habits (e.g., buying luxury cars, flying business class, etc.), I'm going to be fine, so there's no point wondering if I could find a cheaper restaurant if I walked a few blocks away from the touristy area. That mindset makes life much different, and much more enjoyable, than it was when I really had to worry about money.

What you are talking about is stirring up classwarfare.

The wealthy have been waging that war for decades. I just urge the working class to man up and fight back for a change. They did so in the early to mid 20th century, but have really lost the knack. Now they're just sheep to the slaughter.

As far as your basis comment, I don't know what you are getting at, there is no reason for the basis on land to have gone up which may or may not make it "inefficient".

You own a citrus grove in Orlando, right where Disney wants to build an expansion. The grove is worth $800,000 to you, if you just keep running it and selling hiked up orange juice to tourists who pass by. Disney is willing to buy it for $1,000,000, which is what it's worth to them. However, you have holdover basis from your grandfather, who bought the plot for $10,000 before Disney's arrival changed everything. If you sell, you pay long term capital gains of 20% on $990,000 of gain. After paying taxes, you have $792,000 from the sale, which is considerably less valuable to you than the grove was. Faced with those facts, you won't sell, even though you would have sold in a situation where you had a basis closer to the purchase offer, and even though having you sell would have been a net gain for the economy (the land is $200,000 more valuable in Disney's hands). That suggests the way that a big spread between basis and market prices can deter economically efficient transactions. If you have inheritance as a realization event, you wash that out occasionally.


they may need to sell that business - to generate the cash to pay the taxes.

You can think of, say, a 10% effective estate tax rate as functionally equivalent to an offer by the government to sell you the property at just 10% of its fair market value. If the property is a business, and you're so singularly inept that you can't figure out how to finance a purchase of a business that you have a once in a lifetime chance to get for just 10% of its value, then I'll be quite happy if that business doesn't spend much time in your hands. A more competent business person will make much better use of it. You'd probably just have pissed away the value, anyway, the next time a cash crunch exceeded your business skills.

No bank is going to come in and loan you money to pay your taxes when the tax liability is based on potential future earnings and intangibles like goodwill and your actual tangible assets are not enough to collateralize the loan.

Banks can and do lend money for more than the value of the assets, if the business can demonstrate a revenue stream. Or convince the lender of secure future revenues. And people can also borrow against their homes, take out personal loans, etc. If the business isn't worth that risk to the heir, that's fine, too. They can instead sell it and enjoy the money, while some more committed or less cash strapped business person has a go at making the business work.
 
Last edited:
This article makes the argument that there will be a major shift in inheritance patterns in a few years, as Baby Boomers die off an leave their fortunes:

http://www.salon.com/2014/04/02/gen...mericas_coming_inheritance_explosion_partner/

I suppose it makes sense that would be the case. The Baby Boomer generation was unusually large and, at least during the period when "Generation X" was born, produced relatively few heirs. That's a recipe for a much greater share of individual wealth being attributable to inheritance than in prior generations, when big fortunes would have been divided up among more heirs.

To head off the problems associated with excessive wealth inequality (and particularly with having much of the society's wealth in the hands of people who've shown no particular talent), we'd do well to reform inheritance laws now, while there's still time before the Boomers start kicking the bucket in large numbers.

My preferred reform is to exempt a relatively small portion of an estate (e.g., set at 120% of the value of a median home, so that a typical person could leave the family home and personal effects tax free), with everything beyond that taxed as regular income for the heirs. So, for example, if someone died with an estate valued at $1 million, leaving it to three children, something around $275,000 would be exempted, with each heir then having around $242,000 in extra "income" to account for. To avoid having it be too harsh a hit, I'd allow the income to be pro-rated over the next decade, so that, in the described scenario, it would only increase taxable income by $24,200 per heir per year.

However, even short of that kind of comprehensive reform, just rolling the rules back to something more like we had in earlier eras would help. For example, starting in 1942, and throughout our economic golden age (the 50s and 60s), we had a fairly low estate tax exemption and graduated rates that rose as high as 77%. The exemption in that time was $60,000. If we adjusted that for inflation, from the late 60s to today, that would be like a $400,000 exemption today (instead of the sky-high exemption of $5 million we currently have). A $400,000 exemption would allow a fairly nice home and personal effects, or even a genuinely small business, to be handed down without worrying about tax.

Over the years, a number of changes to the estate tax were implemented to benefit the very rich, aside from just a vastly higher exemption and lower rates. In 1980, for example they retroactively repealed the "carry-over basis" rules. In effect, the rule directly before the repeal was that if you inherited property, your "basis" was what the prior owner had paid for it. For example, if someone bought stocks for $100 and then left them to you when they were worth $1000, and then you sold them for $1600, your capital gain would be on $1500 -- the actual capital gain those stocks had experienced. After 1980, you got "stepped up basis," so that you got to pretend you'd acquired the property for whatever it was worth when you inherited it, even though you had not, in fact, paid a dime, so that, in the prior example, you'd only pay capital gains taxes on the $600 of the capital gain that happened to occur after you were handed the stocks, thereby sheltering the majority of the gain from ever being taxed. By simply repealing this rule and going back to carried-over basis, we could reduce the accumulation of wealth by the very rich, while also enhancing revenues in order to cut the deficit. We would also reduce a distortion in the market, since currently the wealthy have an incentive to hold onto assets until they die, even if it would be more economically efficient to sell them, simply because if those assets have unrealized capital gains, those need never be taxed if they're inherited before being liquidated.

So, for example, say you own some land out west that you no longer have any use for, and which others have great use for, and you could really use the cash from selling it to help grow a business you have back east. But say the estern property has millions of dollars of unrealized capital gains, so you'll take a tax hit on it if you sell. The current code encourages you to sit on it until you die, and then your heir can immediately liquidate it tax-free. Meanwhile, the land is being under-utilized and your business is unnecessarily cash-starved. Without stepped-up basis, this isn't an issue, since the taxes will have to be paid sooner or later, by you or your heir, so you may as well make the move whenever it makes sense from a purely business perspective, rather than gaming the tax system.

Another change was letting spouses inherit tax free. It used to be that 50% of jointly owned property was subject to taxation upon the death of a spouse -- the idea being you were being taxed on the half of the property you'd received from your spouse, just as you'd be taxed for property you inherited from anyone else. That was changed so that spouses could inherit unlimited amounts tax free. This allows for multi-generational passage of wealth without tax. For example, a wealth old man can marry a young woman and leaves her all his money tax-free. Decades later, when she's a rich society matron, she can marry a boy-toy and leave him that money tax-free, and so on.

All these changes together resulted in estate taxes bringing in a much smaller share of total federal revenue. Estate and gift taxes brought in 2.3% of total revenues in the mid-1960s, and as of 2009 (in 2010, there was no estate tax), that was down to 1.1%, a decrease of over half. And because of that, the rule changes have played some role in sky-rocketing wealth inequality in this country. Simply by rolling back some or all of these rules to something closer to what we had in the 1960s, we could minimize the social damage tax-free and low-tax inheritance of large estates has been causing.
A true liberal would question himself when his every redress of societal problem is the state. State structure, state strategy, state policy...always, ALWAYS the state.
Where is true liberalism?
Liberals, have you been intimidated and bullied out of participation? Have you surrendered your post to illiberal leftists the way conservatives have abrogated their core principles?
 
A true liberal would question himself when his every redress of societal problem is the state. State structure, state strategy, state policy...always, ALWAYS the state.
Where is true liberalism?
Liberals, have you been intimidated and bullied out of participation? Have you surrendered your post to illiberal leftists the way conservatives have abrogated their core principles?
If you meet a poster for whom every redress of a societal problem is the state, your post will be a very valuable addition to the conversation. For now, though, you're hacking away at straw men.
 
I'm not removed in the sense of being able to kick back and live very comfortably on an income stream from a portfolio. But even at my level, work is about luxuries, not necessities. My house is paid off and I have over $600k of investments. If I wanted to quit, those investments would cover an income above the poverty level for my family for the rest of my life. Certainly those in the top tenth of a percent are in a whole different category, but already at my level people are being removed from the daily concerns that have dominated the attention of almost all of mankind for all of history. Even if I decide never to work again, I can keep a roof over my head and food on the table. How many people can say that?

And once we move even a little above my level, the removal from the day-to-day life experiences of regular people grows even more profound. If you inherited a 3 million dollar business, for example, you could sell it and live on the proceeds quite comfortably for life, without ever working. You could buy a $140,000 life annuity and live richer than 87% of households without ever again doing a day's paid work.

I've recently become more aware of just how huge a difference having money, even at my relatively modest level, makes in how life is lived. When I used to travel, when I was young, I was super cautious about money. I never went to a restaurant -- I'd buy a few cheap things in a grocery store and eat them on the street. I never took a cab. I searched exhaustively for youth hostels and other discount places. Etc. Now, I don't even look at the prices of the menus, or think twice about catching a cab. I know it's a bit of a waste for me to sweat the small stuff. As long as I don't develop very fancy hobbies and habits (e.g., buying luxury cars, flying business class, etc.), I'm going to be fine, so there's no point wondering if I could find a cheaper restaurant if I walked a few blocks away from the touristy area. That mindset makes life much different, and much more enjoyable, than it was when I really had to worry about money.



The wealthy have been waging that war for decades. I just urge the working class to man up and fight back for a change. They did so in the early to mid 20th century, but have really lost the knack. Now they're just sheep to the slaughter.



You own a citrus grove in Orlando, right where Disney wants to build an expansion. The grove is worth $800,000 to you, if you just keep running it and selling hiked up orange juice to tourists who pass by. Disney is willing to buy it for $1,000,000, which is what it's worth to them. However, you have holdover basis from your grandfather, who bought the plot for $10,000 before Disney's arrival changed everything. If you sell, you pay long term capital gains of 20% on $990,000 of gain. After paying taxes, you have $792,000 from the sale, which is considerably less valuable to you than the grove was. Faced with those facts, you won't sell, even though you would have sold in a situation where you had a basis closer to the purchase offer, and even though having you sell would have been a net gain for the economy (the land is $200,000 more valuable in Disney's hands). That suggests the way that a big spread between basis and market prices can deter economically efficient transactions. If you have inheritance as a realization event, you wash that out occasionally.




You can think of, say, a 10% effective estate tax rate as functionally equivalent to an offer by the government to sell you the property at just 10% of its fair market value. If the property is a business, and you're so singularly inept that you can't figure out how to finance a purchase of a business that you have a once in a lifetime chance to get for just 10% of its value, then I'll be quite happy if that business doesn't spend much time in your hands. A more competent business person will make much better use of it. You'd probably just have pissed away the value, anyway, the next time a cash crunch exceeded your business skills.



Banks can and do lend money for more than the value of the assets, if the business can demonstrate a revenue stream. Or convince the lender of secure future revenues. And people can also borrow against their homes, take out personal loans, etc. If the business isn't worth that risk to the heir, that's fine, too. They can instead sell it and enjoy the money, while some more committed or less cash strapped business person has a go at making the business work.


Arkady,

Quite simply we disagree on a basic level of the role of the individual and society as a whole. We will never find common ground on this as I simply believe that the rule of law and government only exists to provide the framework for stability and allow people to work out their differences. That is it. So, there is no greater good of haviing land be put to a "better use" there is no greater good about not allowing people to maximize their family wealth. Those things aren't even relative.

I disagree on many levels with your examples for which I do not have time to go into but you are making many assumptions which simply do not pan out in the real business world. The buying and selling and financing of small businesses - are completely different than how you believe it operates. I know, I see it and live it every single day.

If you are living the high life, good for you. That is not the reality I know fo rmany people in the 5 or less percent range. They are working their tails off every day, giving job opportunities to friends and family, helping others start business, have mortgages and money worries etc. and if in the end of the day they have several millions to pass on, good for them and their families and quite simply they owe noboody anything else at all.

connie
 
Arkady,

Quite simply we disagree on a basic level of the role of the individual and society as a whole. We will never find common ground on this as I simply believe that the rule of law and government only exists to provide the framework for stability and allow people to work out their differences. That is it. So, there is no greater good of haviing land be put to a "better use" there is no greater good about not allowing people to maximize their family wealth. Those things aren't even relative.

I disagree on many levels with your examples for which I do not have time to go into but you are making many assumptions which simply do not pan out in the real business world. The buying and selling and financing of small businesses - are completely different than how you believe it operates. I know, I see it and live it every single day.

If you are living the high life, good for you. That is not the reality I know fo rmany people in the 5 or less percent range. They are working their tails off every day, giving job opportunities to friends and family, helping others start business, have mortgages and money worries etc. and if in the end of the day they have several millions to pass on, good for them and their families and quite simply they owe noboody anything else at all.

connie
I'm starting to develop a serious crush on you....;)
 
Arkady,

Quite simply we disagree on a basic level of the role of the individual and society as a whole. We will never find common ground on this as I simply believe that the rule of law and government only exists to provide the framework for stability and allow people to work out their differences. That is it. So, there is no greater good of haviing land be put to a "better use" there is no greater good about not allowing people to maximize their family wealth. Those things aren't even relative.

I disagree on many levels with your examples for which I do not have time to go into but you are making many assumptions which simply do not pan out in the real business world. The buying and selling and financing of small businesses - are completely different than how you believe it operates. I know, I see it and live it every single day.

If you are living the high life, good for you. That is not the reality I know fo rmany people in the 5 or less percent range. They are working their tails off every day, giving job opportunities to friends and family, helping others start business, have mortgages and money worries etc. and if in the end of the day they have several millions to pass on, good for them and their families and quite simply they owe noboody anything else at all.

connie


money worries....but will leave several millions...


I shake my head...
 
money worries....but will leave several millions...


I shake my head...

Yes, Craig... if you have a 3 million house that is fully financed - you still worry about how to pay your mortgage. Of perahps you have lived much more simply and your money is invested in things that aren't liquid - so if something should happen to you - you don't have ready cash - guess what - those people worry about how they will pay their bills, too. Its all relative - just on a different scale. Business owners may make $1mil in one year and loose one million the next. Guess what - they worry about how they will keep the business going - they worry about the people that work for them and making sure they still have jobs. For most people - its all the same worries, just on a different scale.

connie
 
Yes, Craig... if you have a 3 million house that is fully financed - you still worry about how to pay your mortgage. Of perahps you have lived much more simply and your money is invested in things that aren't liquid - so if something should happen to you - you don't have ready cash - guess what - those people worry about how they will pay their bills, too. Its all relative - just on a different scale. Business owners may make $1mil in one year and loose one million the next. Guess what - they worry about how they will keep the business going - they worry about the people that work for them and making sure they still have jobs. For most people - its all the same worries, just on a different scale.

connie

It is a different world...and I shake my head at it.

If one has fully financed a house worth millions of dollars and worries over their mortgage payment, they over extended themselves by magnitudes. They should worry about such an absurd purchase.

Still, it goes to how one can use debt to help build wealth.
 
It is a different world...and I shake my head at it.

If one has fully financed a house worth millions of dollars and worries over their mortgage payment, they over extended themselves by magnitudes. They should worry about such an absurd purchase.

Still, it goes to how one can use debt to help build wealth.

So, its ok to judge those people by what they do, how they spend their money on, etc... but it is completely in appropriate for those people to comment that the poor may not be good stewards of their funds or make them work for them in the best possible way. I love the hypocrisy.

Here is the bottom line, with the exception of the Paris Hilton's or the Karsashians or the Romney's of the world, people are just people. They don't have servants or housekeepers, or a staff of people ready and willing to do their bidding. They go to work, they have jobs, they have friends and kids they love to worry about... but i know this goes against the meme of these "evil" rich people who somehow owe someone they never met, whose existence is not affected by each other at all in anyway shape or form "something" because that other person just happens to exist.
 
So, its ok to judge those people by what they do, how they spend their money on, etc... but it is completely in appropriate for those people to comment that the poor may not be good stewards of their funds or make them work for them in the best possible way. I love the hypocrisy.

Here is the bottom line, with the exception of the Paris Hilton's or the Karsashians or the Romney's of the world, people are just people. They don't have servants or housekeepers, or a staff of people ready and willing to do their bidding. They go to work, they have jobs, they have friends and kids they love to worry about... but i know this goes against the meme of these "evil" rich people who somehow owe someone they never met, whose existence is not affected by each other at all in anyway shape or form "something" because that other person just happens to exist.

Where do you get the idea that I don't think folks get to comment on anything they desire to?

Gee...you may have noticed a post from me where I state fast foods outlet aren't a good target for food stamps...but if you had, then you couldn't so easily call me a hypocrite.

You are an apologist for "rich people". You serve oligarchs in hopes to be one yourself.

So...instead of you telling me what I think...I'll tell you what I think. I think rich people get rich a number of ways. Some work hard, some do not. Some are good, some are not. Some work for the greater good, some work for themselves. Some are happy to pay taxes, some avoid paying taxes at every opportunity. Some have limos with drivers, some take public transit. In short, "rich people" are much the same as everyone else in that they cannot be pigeonholed, but they do have more money.

Donald Trump is vastly different in every way from Bill Gates. Both rich, they serve different masters and concern themselves with different issues.
 
If you meet a poster for whom every redress of a societal problem is the state, your post will be a very valuable addition to the conversation. For now, though, you're hacking away at straw men.
Not straw men, but Bay State government cultists certainly. ;)
 
Where do you get the idea that I don't think folks get to comment on anything they desire to?

Gee...you may have noticed a post from me where I state fast foods outlet aren't a good target for food stamps...but if you had, then you couldn't so easily call me a hypocrite.

You are an apologist for "rich people". You serve oligarchs in hopes to be one yourself.

So...instead of you telling me what I think...I'll tell you what I think. I think rich people get rich a number of ways. Some work hard, some do not. Some are good, some are not. Some work for the greater good, some work for themselves. Some are happy to pay taxes, some avoid paying taxes at every opportunity. Some have limos with drivers, some take public transit. In short, "rich people" are much the same as everyone else in that they cannot be pigeonholed, but they do have more money.

Donald Trump is vastly different in every way from Bill Gates. Both rich, they serve different masters and concern themselves with different issues.


I am not an apologist. I am apathetic about rich people. Their wealth doesn't stop me from obtaining wealth. Not in the least. So, why do I care what they have? I do believe morally its wrong to covet what others have... so I do not understand this resentment and anger towards those that have more. But, because of that, I don't think the rich owe anyone anything.
 
I am not an apologist. I am apathetic about rich people. Their wealth doesn't stop me from obtaining wealth. Not in the least. So, why do I care what they have? I do believe morally its wrong to covet what others have... so I do not understand this resentment and anger towards those that have more. But, because of that, I don't think the rich owe anyone anything.

Stop you? No...you use them to get your wealth. You care what they have because they are your clients and you do everything in your power to maximize their wealth.

I think the rich are rich...in part...due to the system set up by our governments. I believe tax structure and infrastructure are governmental activities that promote business, so one who succeeds owes for the structure.

Benjamin Franklin felt the same way. Adam Smith felt the same way. I do not resent the rich, I resent the greedy.
 
Stop you? No...you use them to get your wealth. You care what they have because they are your clients and you do everything in your power to maximize their wealth.

I think the rich are rich...in part...due to the system set up by our governments. I believe tax structure and infrastructure are governmental activities that promote business, so one who succeeds owes for the structure.

Benjamin Franklin felt the same way. Adam Smith felt the same way. I do not resent the rich, I resent the greedy.

Yes, I believe in maximizing an individual's wealth - and that goes for any individual. if you want to maximize yours - go ahead - you want some help?

But, if that isn't your deal or you don't care - it doesn't make others greedy. It only makes them greedy if they twart you from getting your own wealth, from developing your own products, for coming up iwht your own business or unique service. If you ( subjective you - not you personally) don't have it in you to do that - then its no ones fault but your own that you too are not wealthy.

Those people have and do pay for the structure. They use the roads - they pay for them. They use the police - they pay for them, they use the courts - they pay for them. They got nothing different than what is available to everyone else - but they were able to use what they got to better advantage. That doesn't mean they have to pay more for the same service that everyone benefits from.

I went to HS with someone who ended up working for Google early on and is now a multi-multi millionaire. What did he have that I didn't have? Same classes at public school, same teachers, same level of secondary education. He got lucky - he took the same benefits I had available to me - and was able because of his particular skill set - to turn that into something awesome for himself. Explain to me then why he owes me anything? Or why he should pay more than me for the same services?

connie
 
I simply believe that the rule of law and government only exists to provide the framework for stability and allow people to work out their differences.

Like the founders, I disagree with you there. They were coming from a system that was remarkably stable. The English monarchy and common law system had been in place, with only a brief break, for many centuries. But they saw the possibility of a better country -- one that could promote the general welfare. I share that vision.

The buying and selling and financing of small businesses - are completely different than how you believe it operates.

I've been involved in buying about three dozen "small" businesses. One of my early jobs, out of law school, was doing due diligence on behalf of a company that was going around the country buying up a lot of mom and pop businesses to form a larger, more efficient enterprise. The deals ranged between $100,000 and $15 million. I was also involved in the sale of a mid-sized business (around $20 million). Most of my experience, over the last decade, has been on behalf of multi-billion-dollar enterprises, but I cut my teeth on the small stuff.

That is not the reality I know fo rmany people in the 5 or less percent range.

That's a problem of mindset, not finances. The median household in this country manages to afford a middle-class lifestyle for $51,371 per year. A household in the top 5% earns $220,000 or more. If someone is earning as much as four or five middle-class households combined, and still feels he's struggling, it's because he has allowed himself to be addled by luxuries -- to convince himself that a 4000-square foot home and a new BMW are necessities, and thus chaining himself to debt, when he could easily be free of money worries if his expectations hadn't risen as fast as his earnings. I've carefully guarded against that. I could sell my house and buy a house in the $1.5-$2 million range, with a 30-year mortgage, according to those online affordability calculators. But, instead, I'm going to live in my modest middle-class fully-paid house, until I have enough cash to buy a significantly better place without debt. If I chose to live an upper-class lifestyle, I'd then share the money worries of everyday Americans. But I've resisted that urge.
 
Yes, I believe in maximizing an individual's wealth - and that goes for any individual. if you want to maximize yours - go ahead - you want some help?

But, if that isn't your deal or you don't care - it doesn't make others greedy. It only makes them greedy if they twart you from getting your own wealth, from developing your own products, for coming up iwht your own business or unique service. If you ( subjective you - not you personally) don't have it in you to do that - then its no ones fault but your own that you too are not wealthy.

Those people have and do pay for the structure. They use the roads - they pay for them. They use the police - they pay for them, they use the courts - they pay for them. They got nothing different than what is available to everyone else - but they were able to use what they got to better advantage. That doesn't mean they have to pay more for the same service that everyone benefits from.

I went to HS with someone who ended up working for Google early on and is now a multi-multi millionaire. What did he have that I didn't have? Same classes at public school, same teachers, same level of secondary education. He got lucky - he took the same benefits I had available to me - and was able because of his particular skill set - to turn that into something awesome for himself. Explain to me then why he owes me anything? Or why he should pay more than me for the same services?

connie


Adam Smith and Ben Franklin can explain. Indeed, they have...and I take my philosophy from those two. The basic reason one pays more is that one has more.


The necessaries [necessities] of life occasion the great expense of the poor. They find it difficult to get food, and the greater part of their little revenue is spent in getting it. The luxuries and vanities of life occasion the principal expense of the rich, and a magnificent house embellishes and sets off to the best advantage all the other luxuries and vanities which they possess. A tax upon house-rents, therefore, would in general fall heaviest upon the rich; and in this sort of inequality there would not, perhaps, be anything very unreasonable. It is not very unreasonable that the rich should contribute to the public expense, not only in proportion to their revenue, but something more than in that proportion.

The subjects of every state ought to contribute towards the support of the government, as nearly as possible, in proportion to their respective abilities; that is, in proportion to the revenue which they respectively enjoy under the protection of the state. The expense of government to the individuals of a great nation is like the expense of management to the joint tenants of a great estate, who are all obliged to contribute in proportion to their respective interests in the estate. In the observation or neglect of this maxim consists what is called the equality or inequality of taxation.

http://coursesite.uhcl.edu/HSH/Whitec/texts/UtopTexts/smithadamwealth.htm


Benjamin Franklin to Robert Morris

25 Dec. 1783
1ptrans.gif
Writings 9:138

The Remissness of our People in Paying Taxes is highly blameable; the Unwillingness to pay them is still more so. I see, in some Resolutions of Town Meetings, a Remonstrance against giving Congress a Power to take, as they call it, the People's Money out of their Pockets, tho' only to pay the Interest and Principal of Debts duly contracted. They seem to mistake the Point. Money, justly due from the People, is their Creditors' Money, and no longer the Money of the People, who, if they withold it, should be compell'd to pay by some Law.

All Property, indeed, except the Savage's temporary Cabin, his Bow, his Matchcoat, and other little Acquisitions, absolutely necessary for his Subsistence, seems to me to be the Creature of public Convention. Hence the Public has the Right of Regulating Descents, and all other Conveyances of Property, and even of limiting the Quantity and the Uses of it. All the Property that is necessary to a Man, for the Conservation of the Individual and the Propagation of the Species, is his natural Right, which none can justly deprive him of: But all Property superfluous to such purposes is the Property of the Publick, who, by their Laws, have created it, and who may therefore by other Laws dispose of it, whenever the Welfare of the Publick shall demand such Disposition. He that does not like civil Society on these Terms, let him retire and live among Savages. He can have no right to the benefits of Society, who will not pay his Club towards the Support of it.
 
Like the founders, I disagree with you there. They were coming from a system that was remarkably stable. The English monarchy and common law system had been in place, with only a brief break, for many centuries. But they saw the possibility of a better country -- one that could promote the general welfare. I share that vision.



I've been involved in buying about three dozen "small" businesses. One of my early jobs, out of law school, was doing due diligence on behalf of a company that was going around the country buying up a lot of mom and pop businesses to form a larger, more efficient enterprise. The deals ranged between $100,000 and $15 million. I was also involved in the sale of a mid-sized business (around $20 million). Most of my experience, over the last decade, has been on behalf of multi-billion-dollar enterprises, but I cut my teeth on the small stuff.



That's a problem of mindset, not finances. The median household in this country manages to afford a middle-class lifestyle for $51,371 per year. A household in the top 5% earns $220,000 or more. If someone is earning as much as four or five middle-class households combined, and still feels he's struggling, it's because he has allowed himself to be addled by luxuries -- to convince himself that a 4000-square foot home and a new BMW are necessities, and thus chaining himself to debt, when he could easily be free of money worries if his expectations hadn't risen as fast as his earnings. I've carefully guarded against that. I could sell my house and buy a house in the $1.5-$2 million range, with a 30-year mortgage, according to those online affordability calculators. But, instead, I'm going to live in my modest middle-class fully-paid house, until I have enough cash to buy a significantly better place without debt. If I chose to live an upper-class lifestyle, I'd then share the money worries of everyday Americans. But I've resisted that urge.


Arkady,

The founders opinions have alrgely been corrupted by progressives, but at the heart of what they thought was important was "liberty" and thus - the government should function so that people within set framwork - can do what they want to do. What they essentially left behind was a formal caste system and I agree with that. A lowly farmer should be able to become a wealthy land owner... but they offerend nothing intiially in teh founding documents to assist that farmer - so to me that says that their opinion was some woudl make it, some wouldn't and that was a fine system. I agree with them.

As far as your small business experience, all I can say, is that you need a brush up if that is how you think it operates in the current economic climate.

As far as the difference in incomes - you are making the determination of luxuries and what is and is not a necessity and how someone should live. Why is it ok to do that when you evaluate how much the rich should be able to have - but yet - its not ok for the taxpayers to make the same determination about the takers and the users? The reality is - that people do have those mortgages they think of themselves like everyone else and the scale of their problems is the only thing that is different. But that doesn't work in the evil rich meme.

connie
 
I went to HS with someone who ended up working for Google early on and is now a multi-multi millionaire. What did he have that I didn't have? Same classes at public school, same teachers, same level of secondary education. He got lucky - he took the same benefits I had available to me - and was able because of his particular skill set - to turn that into something awesome for himself. Explain to me then why he owes me anything? Or why he should pay more than me for the same services?

Modify that a bit. Picture you had two classmates, each of whom took a risk on an uncertain startup. One was Google. One was Pets.com. Both worked hard. Both were equally skilled. The lucky one is a multi-multi millionaire. The unlucky one found himself out of a job and struggling for years. Pure dumb luck.

There's nothing wrong with having luck play some role in the system. But there's also nothing wrong with having a social compact whereby we all agree that if we end up being among the lucky ones, we'll pay back a portion of that bounty to help out those who took the same gambles and lost.

That isn't just humane. It can also be efficient. In a society where everyone feels he's one unlucky break from starvation, beneficial risk-taking is discouraged. I went to a circus once where there was a tightrope act with a safety net, and then they cut away the net. I found the latter part of the act boring. Unless you really get off on the risk of the performer having his brains dashed, the act with the benefit of the net was far more entertaining. Knowing the net was there, the performers could be more acrobatic (juggling, doing hand-stands, etc.) -- when it was cut away, they were just walking the rope, focused on survival. Economics can be like that, too. If you know the cost of taking chances is potentially utter poverty, you'll be less likely to take chances than if you know there's a decent social safety net in place even if you fall. That also makes it more possible for someone who does slip and fall to rise again, and potentially perform much better the next time, than if falling in the economy often locks you into a cycle of poverty and debt. I don't think it's a coincidence that the economy, after the start of the New Deal, had better GDP growth, longer growth periods, and shorter, shallower recessions than before the New Deal. Knowing that safety net is there causes people to perform better than if most are just hoping not to make a mistake that ends with their brains strewn across the center ring.
 
What they essentially left behind was a formal caste system and I agree with that. A lowly farmer should be able to become a wealthy land owner... but they offerend nothing intiially in teh founding documents to assist that farmer

At least from the time of president Jefferson, they were handing farmers public land for pennies on the dollar. That's what makes it so ironic that the modern holders of that same land tend to get bent out of shape when asked to pay taxes on the wealth predicated on that gift.
its not ok for the taxpayers to make the same determination about the takers and the users?

It's OK for the citizens to decide how to set tax policy. I'm arguing, as a citizen, for what I think the rules should be. What's wrong with that?

The reality is - that people do have those mortgages they think of themselves like everyone else and the scale of their problems is the only thing that is different.

Yes, and I suppose even King George III felt himself financially troubled by the debts of the crown. But the fact is that the rich have problems of their own making, when it comes to financial trouble. If a person borrows heavily to buy a house that would comfortably fit four families, with pointless luxuries like granite countertops and real hardwood floors, and he then feels financially burdened by that debt, that's simply a self-imposed burden. He could sell that house, downsize to a middle-class home, and not worry a bit about money.
 
Back
Top