Arkady
President
That is the issue though Arkady -t hey are not removed from the day to day struggles - even in the top 2 percent
I'm not removed in the sense of being able to kick back and live very comfortably on an income stream from a portfolio. But even at my level, work is about luxuries, not necessities. My house is paid off and I have over $600k of investments. If I wanted to quit, those investments would cover an income above the poverty level for my family for the rest of my life. Certainly those in the top tenth of a percent are in a whole different category, but already at my level people are being removed from the daily concerns that have dominated the attention of almost all of mankind for all of history. Even if I decide never to work again, I can keep a roof over my head and food on the table. How many people can say that?
And once we move even a little above my level, the removal from the day-to-day life experiences of regular people grows even more profound. If you inherited a 3 million dollar business, for example, you could sell it and live on the proceeds quite comfortably for life, without ever working. You could buy a $140,000 life annuity and live richer than 87% of households without ever again doing a day's paid work.
I've recently become more aware of just how huge a difference having money, even at my relatively modest level, makes in how life is lived. When I used to travel, when I was young, I was super cautious about money. I never went to a restaurant -- I'd buy a few cheap things in a grocery store and eat them on the street. I never took a cab. I searched exhaustively for youth hostels and other discount places. Etc. Now, I don't even look at the prices of the menus, or think twice about catching a cab. I know it's a bit of a waste for me to sweat the small stuff. As long as I don't develop very fancy hobbies and habits (e.g., buying luxury cars, flying business class, etc.), I'm going to be fine, so there's no point wondering if I could find a cheaper restaurant if I walked a few blocks away from the touristy area. That mindset makes life much different, and much more enjoyable, than it was when I really had to worry about money.
What you are talking about is stirring up classwarfare.
The wealthy have been waging that war for decades. I just urge the working class to man up and fight back for a change. They did so in the early to mid 20th century, but have really lost the knack. Now they're just sheep to the slaughter.
As far as your basis comment, I don't know what you are getting at, there is no reason for the basis on land to have gone up which may or may not make it "inefficient".
You own a citrus grove in Orlando, right where Disney wants to build an expansion. The grove is worth $800,000 to you, if you just keep running it and selling hiked up orange juice to tourists who pass by. Disney is willing to buy it for $1,000,000, which is what it's worth to them. However, you have holdover basis from your grandfather, who bought the plot for $10,000 before Disney's arrival changed everything. If you sell, you pay long term capital gains of 20% on $990,000 of gain. After paying taxes, you have $792,000 from the sale, which is considerably less valuable to you than the grove was. Faced with those facts, you won't sell, even though you would have sold in a situation where you had a basis closer to the purchase offer, and even though having you sell would have been a net gain for the economy (the land is $200,000 more valuable in Disney's hands). That suggests the way that a big spread between basis and market prices can deter economically efficient transactions. If you have inheritance as a realization event, you wash that out occasionally.
they may need to sell that business - to generate the cash to pay the taxes.
You can think of, say, a 10% effective estate tax rate as functionally equivalent to an offer by the government to sell you the property at just 10% of its fair market value. If the property is a business, and you're so singularly inept that you can't figure out how to finance a purchase of a business that you have a once in a lifetime chance to get for just 10% of its value, then I'll be quite happy if that business doesn't spend much time in your hands. A more competent business person will make much better use of it. You'd probably just have pissed away the value, anyway, the next time a cash crunch exceeded your business skills.
No bank is going to come in and loan you money to pay your taxes when the tax liability is based on potential future earnings and intangibles like goodwill and your actual tangible assets are not enough to collateralize the loan.
Banks can and do lend money for more than the value of the assets, if the business can demonstrate a revenue stream. Or convince the lender of secure future revenues. And people can also borrow against their homes, take out personal loans, etc. If the business isn't worth that risk to the heir, that's fine, too. They can instead sell it and enjoy the money, while some more committed or less cash strapped business person has a go at making the business work.
Last edited: