New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Interesting Case

I'd settle for our next generation of citizens understanding that the world doesn't revolve around them and that actions have consequences.
So, what are the consequences for the school administrators thinking they're the center of the world and can censor harmless political statements by those Americans in their custody?
 
I'm remembering just how quickly the "Occupy" thing devolved into little more than a prostest in favor of their right to protest. And to a considerable extent, the same thing happened to the Tea Partiers. I mean seriously...at this point, can anyone tell me what those movements actually stood FOR?

There's some trite old saw that goes something like....."With rights, come responsibilities". I think the point is that if we want to have rights, we need to help preserve them by knowing when to draw appropriate lines for ourselves. We would be incredibly naive to assume that the bracelets in question weren't mostly prurient. After all, what to middle-school students have to contribute to the breast cancer issue? Therefore, these girls' parents should've said just no, rather than making this about their "right" to wear the bracelets.
 
The Supreme Court will be considering whether a bracelet saying "I Love Boobies" is protect speech under the First Amendment, for school children:

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...could_decide_the_fate_of_free_speech_for.html

It sounds almost trivial, but I think it's actually extremely important. Over the last few decades, with the Supreme Court having been stuffed with Republicans (for a significant stretch, up until the Obama administration, seven Republicans to only two Democrats), the overall trend has been a roll-back of civil liberties in school. For example, these days there are practically no limitations on unreasonable searches and seizures of children on public school grounds. They can even be forced to pee in a cup on the perverse whim of school officials, with not so much as an inkling of suspicion of drug use, if they want to participate in any extracurricular activities.

This, predictably, has consequences for our nation. When you take children at an impressionable age and train them to see themselves as having no civil rights -- train them to submit to the demands of authorities no matter how unreasonable -- these children don't magically graduate from school to become citizens who zealously defend their Constitutional rights against government overreach. When you train children in the manner authorized by the courts during the last few decades, you raise generations of Americans who fully expect to have the government pry into their personal business with no reasonable basis, no warrants, no checks and balances.

If you look around the country today and find yourself confused as to how we degenerated into a nation of bleating sheep, eager to submit to the nearest shepherd figure, look no further than the degeneration of civil rights in our school systems. Look to Hazelwood v. Kuhlmeier, New Jersey v. T.L. O. , Bethel School District v. Fraser, Veronia School District v. Acton, Board of Education of Pottawatomie County v. Earls, and other Supreme Court cases, all pushed through by a Republican majority, that came down against the idea that students have various basic cvil rights.

It was not always this way. As recently as the 1960s and 70s, the trend was in the other direction, before the court got packed with conservative ringers. Tinker v. Des Moines, decided in 1969, stood for the simple, and elegantly worded notion that students do not leave their rights at the school house door. Goss v. Lopez, in 1975, gave students due process protections for things like suspension reviews. But it's been all downhill fast since the 1980s. There's some hope, with the adorable Boobies case, that the court may finally move in the other direction. The court still leans Republican, but only by a 5-to-4 split. I've got my questions about Kagan, who was a poor choice by Obama, but assuming she stands up for students rights in this case, that'll probably mean drawing off just one of the five Republicans would be enough to stop the slide into schoolhouse totalitarianism and set the first real precedent for expanded student civil rights since the mid 1970s. That, in turn, could signal a wider improvement for the nation as a whole, as a new generation of kids grew up believing they actually have some rights against authority figures. That's how you educate a nation of citizens.


Ah, but here is the rub:

Two middle school students in Easton, Penn., wore the bracelets (with their parents’ permission) despite a school ban that called them “distracting and demeaning.” The girls were suspended and banned from participating in extracurriculars


They knew of the ban and wore them anyway.

That's not a matter of free speech. It's a matter of knowing the rules and willfully breaking them.
 
That's not a matter of free speech. It's a matter of knowing the rules and willfully breaking them.

I disagree. It's still a matter of whether the rule violated the students' Constitutionally guaranteed rights. Civil disobedience is an acceptable form of protest against civil rights violations.
 
I disagree. It's still a matter of whether the rule violated the students' Constitutionally guaranteed rights. Civil disobedience is an acceptable form of protest against civil rights violations.

Yes but....we seem to've forgotten the second and essential fundament of "civil disobedience". The doer must be preparted to take the legal consequences. In this case, I'm not sure what their "cause" might've been. At BEST, it seems like they were protesting in favor of their "right" to protest. And at more likely....they were protesting in favor of their need to draw attention to themselves.
 
Yes but....we seem to've forgotten the second and essential fundament of "civil disobedience". The doer must be preparted to take the legal consequences. In this case, I'm not sure what their "cause" might've been. At BEST, it seems like they were protesting in favor of their "right" to protest. And at more likely....they were protesting in favor of their need to draw attention to themselves.

Isn't the case in court? Is your speculation as to their motives really relevant to anything aside from your own self esteem?
 
Ah, but here is the rub:




They knew of the ban and wore them anyway.

That's not a matter of free speech. It's a matter of knowing the rules and willfully breaking them.

I missed that part too. Makes all the difference in the world in my opinion. The rule came first the action was to defy the rule. Shame on the parents.
 
I disagree. It's still a matter of whether the rule violated the students' Constitutionally guaranteed rights. Civil disobedience is an acceptable form of protest against civil rights violations.

Sure, but it isn't (nor should it be) the primary form of protest. How about attending a school board meeting or circulating a petition? There are much better ways of addressing issues than 'in your face' disobedience.
 
Sure, but it isn't (nor should it be) the primary form of protest. How about attending a school board meeting or circulating a petition? There are much better ways of addressing issues than 'in your face' disobedience.

I don't really know whether any of that happened. Do you?
 
So, what are the consequences for the school administrators thinking they're the center of the world and can censor harmless political statements by those Americans in their custody?



If a student wore an "Obama is an Idiot!" tee-shirt to school, is that okay? Should the school board stay out of it? Who decides what constitutes "harmless political statements" and what is offensive and disruptive?
 
The Supreme Court will be considering whether a bracelet saying "I Love Boobies" is protect speech under the First Amendment, for school children:

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_...could_decide_the_fate_of_free_speech_for.html

It sounds almost trivial, but I think it's actually extremely important. Over the last few decades, with the Supreme Court having been stuffed with Republicans (for a significant stretch, up until the Obama administration, seven Republicans to only two Democrats), the overall trend has been a roll-back of civil liberties in school. For example, these days there are practically no limitations on unreasonable searches and seizures of children on public school grounds. They can even be forced to pee in a cup on the perverse whim of school officials, with not so much as an inkling of suspicion of drug use, if they want to participate in any extracurricular activities.

This, predictably, has consequences for our nation. When you take children at an impressionable age and train them to see themselves as having no civil rights -- train them to submit to the demands of authorities no matter how unreasonable -- these children don't magically graduate from school to become citizens who zealously defend their Constitutional rights against government overreach. When you train children in the manner authorized by the courts during the last few decades, you raise generations of Americans who fully expect to have the government pry into their personal business with no reasonable basis, no warrants, no checks and balances.

If you look around the country today and find yourself confused as to how we degenerated into a nation of bleating sheep, eager to submit to the nearest shepherd figure, look no further than the degeneration of civil rights in our school systems. Look to Hazelwood v. Kuhlmeier, New Jersey v. T.L. O. , Bethel School District v. Fraser, Veronia School District v. Acton, Board of Education of Pottawatomie County v. Earls, and other Supreme Court cases, all pushed through by a Republican majority, that came down against the idea that students have various basic cvil rights.

It was not always this way. As recently as the 1960s and 70s, the trend was in the other direction, before the court got packed with conservative ringers. Tinker v. Des Moines, decided in 1969, stood for the simple, and elegantly worded notion that students do not leave their rights at the school house door. Goss v. Lopez, in 1975, gave students due process protections for things like suspension reviews. But it's been all downhill fast since the 1980s. There's some hope, with the adorable Boobies case, that the court may finally move in the other direction. The court still leans Republican, but only by a 5-to-4 split. I've got my questions about Kagan, who was a poor choice by Obama, but assuming she stands up for students rights in this case, that'll probably mean drawing off just one of the five Republicans would be enough to stop the slide into schoolhouse totalitarianism and set the first real precedent for expanded student civil rights since the mid 1970s. That, in turn, could signal a wider improvement for the nation as a whole, as a new generation of kids grew up believing they actually have some rights against authority figures. That's how you educate a nation of citizens.


I am somewhere in the middle here. I agree with you Arkady in that the continual erosion of rights, definitely affects how kids will ultimately grow up and whether they will understand and want to protect their rights.

At the same time however, I do think that society has the right to place some sort of standards on public behavior. Additionally, as a property owner, a school as the right to control the types of things brought onto their property and search and seize those items to some degree.

So, I agree - pee test way over bounds in school as well as punishing a kid for off-school time. I agree that boobies is pretty innocuous. But, I also think that the school should be allowed to create and enforce some sort of code with respect to allowed language, i.e. what curse words are not allowed, what other phrases or figures of speech are not allowed because they are offensive or deemed disruptive during the school day. But again, regulating what a student does off school property - for instance - punishing them for what they write on Facebook, I would not support.

When it comes to things like search and seizure, I do think that probably cause should be required and that the actual search and seizure should be done by law enforcement in accordance with normal law enforcement protocols. I don't think the random principal should just be able to go digging in a child's backpack, etc. I do think however that lockers - are a different animal... and any search of a locker should be permitted because lockers are not the personal property of the student, they are provided as property of the school for the student's convenience. So, if you want to sell drugs - keep them in your bookbag or on your person. Don't hide them in your locker.

I remember some kids getting busted at a weekend party for drinking then being kicked off the sports team for that season. I personally have a problem with this because what they did and got in trouble for they did on their own time. Its not really the school's business. They have a right to make rules and regulations to govern their facility and promote an environment for learning in the actual school building. But they are not a second set of parents or law enforcement outside of the school day.

connie
 
If a student wore an "Obama is an Idiot!" tee-shirt to school, is that okay? Should the school board stay out of it? Who decides what constitutes "harmless political statements" and what is offensive and disruptive?

If such tee shirts are banned by a dress code, then all such tee shirts should be banned.

Same with the bracelets. Ban the "Boobies" only if you also ban the "Live Strongs".
 
If such tee shirts are banned by a dress code, then all such tee shirts should be banned.

Same with the bracelets. Ban the "Boobies" only if you also ban the "Live Strongs".


I think each school has a right to establish a dress code, and it should be consistent. If a student has a problem with it, they should either acquiesce or go to school elsewhere.
 
Back
Top