New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Interesting Case

If you're uncomfortable with the sexual connotations, and you're unconvinced by the political value of the message of awareness, you have available to you a simple solution: don't wear the bracelet. The question is why you should be able to impose your view on others.

Actually, the "imposing" would be done by the bracelet wearers onto the girls, who in my scenario would feel uncomfortable.

Take your avatar as an example. I consider it the very height of bad taste. What kind of a sicko would use that little space to display a human being getting tortured to death? I have trouble imagining anything as crass and disturbing as that. But that doesn't make me want to censor it. Nobody is forcing me to post a similar pic of some other ancient tool for making people suffer and die. We each get to choose for ourselves, and that's fine. Even if you wanted to wear that unimaginably vulgar image on a necklace as a public school student, I'd defend your right to do so. So longer as less tasteless students weren't likewise forced to don your torture porn iconography, it's fine.

You are welcome to choose to see things in a new way. In our culture, the crucifixtion of Jesus is seen as the ultimate sacrifice of compassion by God. A very positive and moving intention and event by Him. If you want to change culture, the future is in your hands!
 
Actually, the "imposing" would be done by the bracelet wearers onto the girls, who in my scenario would feel uncomfortable.



You are welcome to choose to see things in a new way. In our culture, the crucifixtion of Jesus is seen as the ultimate sacrifice of compassion by God. A very positive and moving intention and event by Him. If you want to change culture, the future is in your hands!
I feel uncomfortable seeing some wacko wearing a crucifix around his neck. My solution is not to dwell on it. I don't get to censor other people's first amendment rights to preserve myself from that discomfort, no matter how reasonable it is to be uncomfortable with images of people being tortured to death. In the same way, you don't get to censor other people's first amendment rights to preserve yourself fromt he irrational discomfort of seeing the word "boobies."

Anyway, in YOUR culture, that image may be a symbol of sacrifice and compassion by God. In mine, it's a symbol of the state terrorizing and exterminating those it considers a threat to its power (which is why Jesus was crucified by the Romans). We're each free to see in it the symbol we want, just as you're free to see the boobies bracelets as uncomfortably sexual and someone else is free to see them as a playful attempt to call attention to an important healthcare issue, in a manner that will get the attention of a hard-to-reach youthful demographic. To each his own. The problem comes in when one person tries to use the power of the State to enforce his own view on others, as would be the case if I created a law against your use of the avatar, or a public school administrator created a rule against the Boobies bracelet.
 
Anyway, in YOUR culture, that image may be a symbol of sacrifice and compassion by God. In mine, it's a symbol of the state terrorizing and exterminating those it considers a threat to its power (which is why Jesus was crucified by the Romans). We're each free to see in it the symbol we want

I find this interesting, as our entire modern media and pseudo culture has preached and enforced the opposite of what you speak here.

Look at language today, as regards to "racism". What if I said the term "N*****r" is just a word and used it as it literally was used, just another term for the word "negro"? I'm told there's PLENTY of connotations and historical context to justify that I cannot say that word (nor would I want to in real life).

The point is, I don't get to close my eyes to the context of the world around me, which is what you'd be doing. Use that brain of yours.
 
I find this interesting, as our entire modern media and pseudo culture has preached and enforced the opposite of what you speak here.

Look at language today, as regards to "racism". What if I said the term "N*****r" is just a word and used it as it literally was used, just another term for the word "negro"? I'm told there's PLENTY of connotations and historical context to justify that I cannot say that word (nor would I want to in real life).

The point is, I don't get to close my eyes to the context of the world around me, which is what you'd be doing. Use that brain of yours.
If you use that word, you should fully expect the majority of people to take offense, since it is considered an offensive word by the majority. By comparison, if you wear your little tortured rabbi around your neck, you should only expect a minority of people to take offense, since it is only considered an offensive image by a minority. I'm not arguing one should close one's eyes to the overall cultural reception of an exercise of free speech. Instead, I'm arguing against censorship. Whether you're offending the majority or the minority, that's your first amendment right.
 
I find this interesting, as our entire modern media and pseudo culture has preached and enforced the opposite of what you speak here.

Look at language today, as regards to "racism". What if I said the term "N*****r" is just a word and used it as it literally was used, just another term for the word "negro"? I'm told there's PLENTY of connotations and historical context to justify that I cannot say that word (nor would I want to in real life).

The point is, I don't get to close my eyes to the context of the world around me, which is what you'd be doing. Use that brain of yours.


N*****r is just a word and you are just a racist bigot. Deal with it.
 
I'd argue that our right is not to offend, but to "express ourselves". If it were otherwise, the guvmint couldn't prevent child pornographers from plying their trade on teevee.

Per the likes of J.S. Mill, the idea is that "free expression" represents a net positive to the society, even as it may be offensive to some. And in fact, Mill suggests that that offensiveness may actually be an essential element of that free expression.

However...the idea isn't infinte - consider child pornography. We can all agree to disagree as to whether or not allowing skinheads to march in Skokie, represented a "net positive", although I would argue that it definitely was. But....allowing child pornographers to do their thing? I think ALL of us (but for the pornographer himself) would agree that this one's one of those "exceptions to the rule", that has no societal upside no matter which way we parse it.

As to the middle-school bracelets in question, we know that our Constitution doesn't extend these children the right to vote. Therefore, we know that our Constitution considers them a seperate class from we adults, to which different "rules" apply. And personally, I think it's not just righteous, but responsible of us to apply a somewhat stricter standard to "net good" to children, than we do to adults.

And once again, the child doesn't have a "right" to offend. Otherwise, she would be able to shout the "n-word" at her friends on the playground, with impugnity. This is true no matter how we percieve the "age issue". So, this comes down to those adults responsible for this particular school, weighing the benefits and/or costs of allowing this particular form of "expression".
 
If you use that word, you should fully expect the majority of people to take offense, since it is considered an offensive word by the majority. By comparison, if you wear your little tortured rabbi around your neck, you should only expect a minority of people to take offense, since it is only considered an offensive image by a minority. I'm not arguing one should close one's eyes to the overall cultural reception of an exercise of free speech. Instead, I'm arguing against censorship. Whether you're offending the majority or the minority, that's your first amendment right.

Yet, you wouldn't want a T-shirt that says the word "N*****r" worn in schools, right?

Wouldn't that be a part of your "first amendment right"?
 
Yet, you wouldn't want a T-shirt that says the word "N*****r" worn in schools, right?

Wouldn't that be a part of your "first amendment right"?
No, I wouldn't want it, any more than I wouldn't want someone wearing a crucifix to school. But I wouldn't censor either.

That said, I get that I'm a first-amendment extremist, and that most people accept some manner of free speech infringement in school. However, even from that more moderate context, there's a huge gap between a word that's widely considered the worst obscenity in our culture -- regularly bleeped out of broadcast music and television, and subject to R ratings in the movies -- versus "boobies" which is PG-rated material, at worst.
 
I'd argue that our right is not to offend, but to "express ourselves". If it were otherwise, the guvmint couldn't prevent child pornographers from plying their trade on teevee.

Per the likes of J.S. Mill, the idea is that "free expression" represents a net positive to the society, even as it may be offensive to some. And in fact, Mill suggests that that offensiveness may actually be an essential element of that free expression.

However...the idea isn't infinte - consider child pornography. We can all agree to disagree as to whether or not allowing skinheads to march in Skokie, represented a "net positive", although I would argue that it definitely was. But....allowing child pornographers to do their thing? I think ALL of us (but for the pornographer himself) would agree that this one's one of those "exceptions to the rule", that has no societal upside no matter which way we parse it.

As to the middle-school bracelets in question, we know that our Constitution doesn't extend these children the right to vote. Therefore, we know that our Constitution considers them a seperate class from we adults, to which different "rules" apply. And personally, I think it's not just righteous, but responsible of us to apply a somewhat stricter standard to "net good" to children, than we do to adults.

And once again, the child doesn't have a "right" to offend. Otherwise, she would be able to shout the "n-word" at her friends on the playground, with impugnity. This is true no matter how we percieve the "age issue". So, this comes down to those adults responsible for this particular school, weighing the benefits and/or costs of allowing this particular form of "expression".
Child pornography can rationally be banned on the basis of its relationship with the crime of child abuse. As for pornography that doesn't involve a victim in its creation, it should be legal, but can be banned from broadcast through the airwaves, on the theory that there is limited bandwidth and so the government has to make judgment calls about what's worth distributing that way.
 
No, I wouldn't want it, any more than I wouldn't want someone wearing a crucifix to school. But I wouldn't censor either.

Huge difference between the two, as one is almost certainly done to be hateful while the other is, by definition, meant to be all-inclusive and promote love for man.

However, let me just say "wow" that you wouldn't sensor a T-shirt with that word on it.

That said, I get that I'm a first-amendment extremist, and that most people accept some manner of free speech infringement in school. However, even from that more moderate context, there's a huge gap between a word that's widely considered the worst obscenity in our culture -- regularly bleeped out of broadcast music and television, and subject to R ratings in the movies -- versus "boobies" which is PG-rated material, at worst.

Yet, the same questions are asked.. is it meant to be pure? or is it meant to shock and instigate? If it's the latter, it has no place in school in my opinion.
 
No, I wouldn't want it, any more than I wouldn't want someone wearing a crucifix to school. But I wouldn't censor either.

That said, I get that I'm a first-amendment extremist, and that most people accept some manner of free speech infringement in school. However, even from that more moderate context, there's a huge gap between a word that's widely considered the worst obscenity in our culture -- regularly bleeped out of broadcast music and television, and subject to R ratings in the movies -- versus "boobies" which is PG-rated material, at worst.

Which is it? You wouldn't even censor the "n-word", or you're certain that the "n-word" is way worse than "boobies"? I'm not suggesting that these two statements are in conflict, but it's odd that after stating the first, you'd even bother with the second.
 
Child pornography can rationally be banned on the basis of its relationship with the crime of child abuse. As for pornography that doesn't involve a victim in its creation, it should be legal, but can be banned from broadcast through the airwaves, on the theory that there is limited bandwidth and so the government has to make judgment calls about what's worth distributing that way.

Your justification for the guvmint making "judgment calls" - besides being obvious to all - merely affirms my gist.
 
Me? So? The issue isn't whether it's OK to complain about speech you don't like. The issue is whether it's OK for the state to use its power to censor it.

It is the issue. You're making the case that since the word used in your opinion isn't offensive then it's OK. The flip-side to your argument is that if it were offensive then it wouldn't be OK. You've just confirmed that. You just took your argument out of the realm of civil rights and into whether or not a word is offensive, and you mentioned the word majority to boot. You've just screwed yourself.
 
ompla

Huge difference between the two, as one is almost certainly done to be hateful while the other is, by definition, meant to be all-inclusive and promote love for man.

However, let me just say "wow" that you wouldn't sensor a T-shirt with that word on it.



Yet, the same questions are asked.. is it meant to be pure? or is it meant to shock and instigate? If it's the latter, it has no place in school in my opinion.
The main point of the first amendment was to protect politically-oriented speech that's unpopular. What the Founders had in mind was stuff like burning the king in effigy, or depicting the shootings at the Old State House as a Boston Massacre. Those things were absolutely meant to shock and instigate. Compared to that, a little infantile semi-sexualized breast cancer awareness messaging is about as un-shocking a form of instigation as I can imagine. If we're even going to be censoring that kind of political expression by our young citizens, we shouldn't be surprised when they grow up to be spineless sheep.
 
I'd argue that our right is not to offend, but to "express ourselves". If it were otherwise, the guvmint couldn't prevent child pornographers from plying their trade on teevee.

Per the likes of J.S. Mill, the idea is that "free expression" represents a net positive to the society, even as it may be offensive to some. And in fact, Mill suggests that that offensiveness may actually be an essential element of that free expression.

However...the idea isn't infinte - consider child pornography. We can all agree to disagree as to whether or not allowing skinheads to march in Skokie, represented a "net positive", although I would argue that it definitely was. But....allowing child pornographers to do their thing? I think ALL of us (but for the pornographer himself) would agree that this one's one of those "exceptions to the rule", that has no societal upside no matter which way we parse it.

As to the middle-school bracelets in question, we know that our Constitution doesn't extend these children the right to vote. Therefore, we know that our Constitution considers them a seperate class from we adults, to which different "rules" apply. And personally, I think it's not just righteous, but responsible of us to apply a somewhat stricter standard to "net good" to children, than we do to adults.

And once again, the child doesn't have a "right" to offend. Otherwise, she would be able to shout the "n-word" at her friends on the playground, with impugnity. This is true no matter how we percieve the "age issue". So, this comes down to those adults responsible for this particular school, weighing the benefits and/or costs of allowing this particular form of "expression".


Really?

You're comparing an "I Heart Boobies" bracelet to child pornography?

Really???
 
It is the issue. You're making the case that since the word used in your opinion isn't offensive then it's OK. The flip-side to your argument is that if it were offensive then it wouldn't be OK. You've just confirmed that. You just took your argument out of the realm of civil rights and into whether or not a word is offensive, and you mentioned the word majority to boot. You've just screwed yourself.


Arkady never said that a word that either he, or a majority of the public, finds offensive should be censored.

Yet you are right and he is wrong -- because, by God, you say so.

That's funny! ;)
 
Back
Top