New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Interesting Case

It is the issue. You're making the case that since the word used in your opinion isn't offensive then it's OK. The flip-side to your argument is that if it were offensive then it wouldn't be OK. You've just confirmed that. You just took your argument out of the realm of civil rights and into whether or not a word is offensive, and you mentioned the word majority to boot. You've just screwed yourself.

No. You've misunderstood. I'm not saying that since the word used isn't, in my opinion, offensive, then it's OK. I'm saying that whether or not it's offensive, in my personal opinion, I don't want it censored. I find the crucifix to be a deeply offensive symbol, but I don't want schools outlawing the wearing of it. You're just having trouble following the thread, but I'm happy to help.
 
Yes really. When someone makes an absolutist free speech argument, the comparison isn't just apt, it's necessary. It's a logic thing.
I am very nearly an absolutist on free speech. For example, I would allow child pornography that involved no actual child in its production and so didn't create any victim -- for example, something with adults portraying child characters, or animation. The reason for banning most such material isn't that it's patently offensive to the vast majority of us (though, of course, it is), but because allowing it encourages the victimization of an actual person in its creation.

However, as I said, I accept that most people aren't anywhere near as absolutist as I am on the First Amendment. Yet, even from a point far removed from that absolutism, you could argue that there is a GIGANTIC difference between some PG-rated use of the word "boobies" and child porn. Even for someone who is willing to let the government censor speech that's stomach-churningly offensive to the vast majority of people, that doesn't mean that the government should also be allowed to censor speech that's mildly distasteful to some batch of prudes.
 
No. You've misunderstood. I'm not saying that since the word used isn't, in my opinion, offensive, then it's OK. I'm saying that whether or not it's offensive, in my personal opinion, I don't want it censored. I find the crucifix to be a deeply offensive symbol, but I don't want schools outlawing the wearing of it. You're just having trouble following the thread, but I'm happy to help.

I agree with all you're saying, but I do want to extend my sympathies to you, as it must be difficult to go around being constantly offended. However, I admire your willingness to cowboy up and endure it for the sake of others' constitutionally-guaranteed freedoms...it puts you on a level above your liberal cohorts, who want banned all free expression with which they disagree.
 
I agree with all you're saying, but I do want to extend my sympathies to you, as it must be difficult to go around being constantly offended. However, I admire your willingness to cowboy up and endure it for the sake of others' constitutionally-guaranteed freedoms...it puts you on a level above your liberal cohorts, who want banned all free expression with which they disagree.

Left or right, that's the key test of a person's commitment to the first amendment. It isn't about your willingness to defend speech you agree with, but rather you willingness to defend something that offends you to your core. That's something I've long respected about the ACLU, which is mostly staffed by liberals, but which regularly takes on cases to defend the free speech rights of people saying things that are downright horrifying from a liberal perspective.
 
I am very nearly an absolutist on free speech. For example, I would allow child pornography that involved no actual child in its production and so didn't create any victim -- for example, something with adults portraying child characters, or animation. The reason for banning most such material isn't that it's patently offensive to the vast majority of us (though, of course, it is), but because allowing it encourages the victimization of an actual person in its creation.

However, as I said, I accept that most people aren't anywhere near as absolutist as I am on the First Amendment. Yet, even from a point far removed from that absolutism, you could argue that there is a GIGANTIC difference between some PG-rated use of the word "boobies" and child porn. Even for someone who is willing to let the government censor speech that's stomach-churningly offensive to the vast majority of people, that doesn't mean that the government should also be allowed to censor speech that's mildly distasteful to some batch of prudes.

First, I explained my view as to how middle-school students are a seperate "class" from adults. And frankly, I get sort of a kick out of the circularity of all this. The kids wore the bracelets specifically in order to tweak the noses of the prudes (let's not be naive), then they whine when the prudes' noses are tweaked.
 
ompla


The main point of the first amendment was to protect politically-oriented speech that's unpopular. What the Founders had in mind was stuff like burning the king in effigy, or depicting the shootings at the Old State House as a Boston Massacre. Those things were absolutely meant to shock and instigate. Compared to that, a little infantile semi-sexualized breast cancer awareness messaging is about as un-shocking a form of instigation as I can imagine. If we're even going to be censoring that kind of political expression by our young citizens, we shouldn't be surprised when they grow up to be spineless sheep.

Your point is the First Amendment doesn't apply? I thought you were talking about rights here, at least that's the impression I got from your posts. Or, we can go with the idea that if it's not shocking then it isn't as important? What happened to your self-righteous stand on the civil rights of students?
 
Your point is the First Amendment doesn't apply? I thought you were talking about rights here, at least that's the impression I got from your posts. Or, we can go with the idea that if it's not shocking then it isn't as important? What happened to your self-righteous stand on the civil rights of students?
I'm not able to follow what you're saying at all. No, my point isn't that the First Amendment doesn't apply. What made you think that? No, I don't think that if it's not shocking it's not important. What made you think that? I think you may be suffering from simple reading comprehension issues.
 
First, I explained my view as to how middle-school students are a seperate "class" from adults. And frankly, I get sort of a kick out of the circularity of all this. The kids wore the bracelets specifically in order to tweak the noses of the prudes (let's not be naive), then they whine when the prudes' noses are tweaked.
No, I haven't heard anyone whine about a prude's nose being tweaked. What people are upset about is that the prudes are using the power of the state to censor that free expression. Do you really not see the difference? Prudes are welcome to express their unhappiness with those bracelets. If they want, they can wear bracelets that say "I get uncomfortable with any acknowledgement of human anatomy." What they shouldn't do is censor other people's expression -- even the separate "class" of middle-school students (or high school students, or anyone else who has been nailed by such censors).
 
You can follow, you just don't want to. You allegedly have all of these high ideals about civil rights but when push came to shove what you did was judge one word to be offensive and another word to not be offensive. On top of that, you introduced the idea that the opinion of the majority matters. So, my question to you is: how come your opinion matters but the opinion of the parents, taxpayers, and administrators of the district in question here doesn't matter?
 
No, I haven't heard anyone whine about a prude's nose being tweaked. What people are upset about is that the prudes are using the power of the state to censor that free expression. Do you really not see the difference? Prudes are welcome to express their unhappiness with those bracelets. If they want, they can wear bracelets that say "I get uncomfortable with any acknowledgement of human anatomy." What they shouldn't do is censor other people's expression -- even the separate "class" of middle-school students (or high school students, or anyone else who has been nailed by such censors).

You started this thread about these kids' and their parents filing suit, so it's a little disengenuous of you to say "(you) haven't heard anyone whine"! In any case, it's not just in the school's interest, but that of us all, that the school not support these kids in their prurient designs.
 
You started this thread about these kids' and their parents filing suit, so it's a little disengenuous of you to say "(you) haven't heard anyone whine"! In any case, it's not just in the school's interest, but that of us all, that the school not support these kids in their prurient designs.
No. You're just mixing up your issues again. As a reminder, you claimed that people whine when the prudes' noses are tweaked. They didn't sue to block prudes from complaining about the bracelets. They sued to protect the freedom of expression of their children from state-imposed censorship. That's a key distinction. If you want to call that lawsuit "whining," fine, but then it's not whining about prudes getting their noses tweaked, it's whining about prudes infringing on their children's freedoms.

I suspect, though, you already get that, which is why you were so strategic in your quotation. What I said was : "I haven't heard anyone whine about a prude's nose being tweaked." What you said was:

'...it's a little disengenuous of you to say "(you) haven't heard anyone whine"! '

You left out half of my statement, without any ellipses to indicate the omission. When you pointedly omit critical context that way, altering the nature of what's being said, so that you can then attack me for the altered statement, it looks pretty dishonest.

As for what's in all of our interests, we clearly disagree on that. I think it's in all of our interests for the school actually to ENCOURAGE these nascent stirrings of social and political expression in the leaders of tomorrow. But we can agree to disagree on that, and just let every individual family decide for themselves whether their kids can wear those bracelets, with the school neither requiring them to do so, nor banning it.
 
No. You're just mixing up your issues again. As a reminder, you claimed that people whine when the prudes' noses are tweaked. They didn't sue to block prudes from complaining about the bracelets. They sued to protect the freedom of expression of their children from state-imposed censorship. That's a key distinction. If you want to call that lawsuit "whining," fine, but then it's not whining about prudes getting their noses tweaked, it's whining about prudes infringing on their children's freedoms.

I suspect, though, you already get that, which is why you were so strategic in your quotation. What I said was : "I haven't heard anyone whine about a prude's nose being tweaked." What you said was:

'...it's a little disengenuous of you to say "(you) haven't heard anyone whine"! '

You left out half of my statement, without any ellipses to indicate the omission. When you pointedly omit critical context that way, altering the nature of what's being said, so that you can then attack me for the altered statement, it looks pretty dishonest.

As for what's in all of our interests, we clearly disagree on that. I think it's in all of our interests for the school actually to ENCOURAGE these nascent stirrings of social and political expression in the leaders of tomorrow. But we can agree to disagree on that, and just let every individual family

As I'm not skilled in the art of "verbal gymnastics", I'm going to concede that you're right, as always!
 
As I'm not skilled in the art of "verbal gymnastics", I'm going to concede that you're right, as always!
As I have a pathological need to be right about everything, especially on those rare occasions when I'm wrong, I'll just take that.
 
Arkady never said that a word that either he, or a majority of the public, finds offensive should be censored.

Yet you are right and he is wrong -- because, by God, you say so.

That's funny! ;)


Yep... I called it. I've already been down this road. It's the long way to nowhere.
 
No. You've misunderstood. I'm not saying that since the word used isn't, in my opinion, offensive, then it's OK. I'm saying that whether or not it's offensive, in my personal opinion, I don't want it censored. I find the crucifix to be a deeply offensive symbol, but I don't want schools outlawing the wearing of it. You're just having trouble following the thread, but I'm happy to help.

I'm not having any trouble at all, in fact I'm enjoying it quite a bit now that you've gone off of your holier than thou civil liberties stance. I can sit here and argue in a 3 paragraph post that 2+2=5 and then in my last sentence I could say that 2+2=4 but that doesn't change the fact that I spent 3 paragraphs arguing that 2+2=5, and if I did that I'd be called to task for it, as I should be. You're the one who did that, not me and the "problem" isn't that I don't know what you're saying, it's that I do understand...and I also think you're a little mad at yourself for letting Mr. Friscus bitch slap you like a little rag doll. Either that or you truly don't get it, I suppose that's a possibility too.
 
On second thought I'm just going to go ahead and explain what I've seen you do in this thread and then I'm done, I'll have nothing else to contribute at that point.

You started off strong, I didn't agree with your position that kids have rights but it was just an opinion and I couldn't find any real fault with it.

Then you talked about the 1st Amendment and that's when you started to go off the rails. You made the point that political speech is protected by the 1st, and I agree with that but you neglected to mention that if the 1st is an issue in this case then so are all of the rulings regarding the 1st Amendment. A common one: you can't yell fire in a crowded theater. Why can't you? Because it would lead to a disruption. Now if the word 'boobies' is protected speech then there's no problem here but do you really believe it is? I don't, and I have to ask what you think happens when you inject a bunch of 'boobie' bracelets into an environment full of teenage boys? A disruption perhaps?

Then Mr. Friscus masterfully drew you into a discussion on the word 'N*****r' which you apparently didn't see coming. You made the statement that the majority can find a word to be offensive. It's true you did later in that post reference the right to say whatever you want but that's not really true, reference the word 'fire' in a theater. So at this point if the 1st Amendment doesn't apply, and it doesn't, then we've got your default of majority opinion. Whose opinion would that be? Yours? Mine? A federal court? No, it would be the adults entrusted with operating the school district in question with input from the local taxpayers.

This is why I'm enjoying the thread, you've blown your own argument out of the water without even realizing it.

/bustinchopsmodeoff :)
 
I'm not having any trouble at all, in fact I'm enjoying it quite a bit now that you've gone off of your holier than thou civil liberties stance. I can sit here and argue in a 3 paragraph post that 2+2=5 and then in my last sentence I could say that 2+2=4 but that doesn't change the fact that I spent 3 paragraphs arguing that 2+2=5, and if I did that I'd be called to task for it, as I should be. You're the one who did that, not me and the "problem" isn't that I don't know what you're saying, it's that I do understand...and I also think you're a little mad at yourself for letting Mr. Friscus bitch slap you like a little rag doll. Either that or you truly don't get it, I suppose that's a possibility too.
I think, at this point, you've spotted your mistake. So, I'll just smirk and move on.
 
I don't, and I have to ask what you think happens when you inject a bunch of 'boobie' bracelets into an environment full of teenage boys? A disruption perhaps?

Perhaps. However, I don't expect it to be a disruption in the sense of someone yelling "fire" in a crowded theater (which is a "disruption" that could lead to some corpses). It's the kind of disruption we routinely tolerate in public spaces generally, which is only being treated as unacceptable by this particular set of school administrators because of an unfortunate erosion of rights that has occurred in the school setting over the last few decades, as discussed in my first post. My hope is that we reverse that terrible course.

Then Mr. Friscus masterfully drew you into a discussion on the word 'N*****r' which you apparently didn't see coming.

Since it was a weird non sequitur, I'll admit I didn't see it coming. In the same sense, I bet you didn't expect me to bring up the fact that platypuses are venomous.

You made the statement that the majority can find a word to be offensive. It's true you did later in that post reference the right to say whatever you want but that's not really true, reference the word 'fire' in a theater.

Where, exactly, did I reference a supposed right to say whatever you want? There are lots of exercises of speech that you have no right to: copyright infringement, for example, or death threats, or passing along national secrets to our enemies, or libel, or lying under oath, or providing false witness to a police officer. I don't at all mean to suggest that I'd grant an absolute right to say anything you want. That's why I say I'm "nearly" an absolutist on free speech, not an absolutist. I just am not quick to allow censorship when the justification is that someone might find something rude or crass or politically uncomfortable or titter-worthy (which is basically what we're talking about with the boobies bracelets). I think there should be a very strong presumption in favor of the government not censoring expression, and so that presumption should only be overcome in cases with real victims of something other than being upset about what was said, or distracted by it.

So at this point if the 1st Amendment doesn't apply, and it doesn't

The whole question is whether the first amendment applies. The fact the court agreed to hear the case suggests that they think there's a serious question there. If you want to start with the conclusion and argue from there, that's verbal masturbation.

This is why I'm enjoying the thread, you've blown your own argument out of the water without even realizing it.

No -- but I do appreciate you going into detail so that we could identify the exact nature of your error.
 
Back
Top