New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Is Romney ethical?

Where would he draw the line when it came between choosing money and power and doing the right thing?

"At present, the ethics curriculum at business schools can best be described as an unsuccessful work-in-progress. It’s not that business schools are turning Mother Teresas into Jeffrey Skillings (Harvard Business School, class of ‘79), despite some claims to that effect. It’s easy to come up with examples of rogue MBA graduates who have lied, cheated and stolen their ways to fortunes (recently convicted Raj Rajaratnam is a graduate of the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School of Business; his partner in crime, Rajat Gupta, is a Harvard Business School alum). But a huge number of companies are run by business school grads, and for every Gupta and Rajaratnam there are scores of others who run their companies in perfectly legal anonymity. And of course, there are the many ethical missteps by non-MBA business leaders — Bernie Madoff was educated as a lawyer; Enron’s Ken Lay had a Ph.D. in economics."

"In actuality, the picture suggested by the data is that business schools have no impact whatsoever on the likelihood that someone will cook the books or otherwise commit fraud. MBA programs are thus damned by faint praise: “We do not turn our students into criminals” would hardly make for an effective recruiting slogan."


http://www.dailyherald.com/article/20120909/business/709099980/print/



The above article presents an interesting discussion since Mr. Romney insists on suggesting his "business experience" will be better for the nation than Mr. Obama's lack of

When did Mr. Romney actually leave Bain Capitial based on a clear legal and explained definition of "leaving" or being "out of" a corporation?

Why does Mr. Romney NOT at least equal his father's lead with regard to release of the same number of years of returns?

Why does Mr. Romney repeatedly claim credit for things that were not his to claim or were not all his to claim, even after they were shown over and over NOT to be as he framed them to be?

Why was the hair cutting incident just an "innocent prank" of the type younsters get involved in? How many here got involved in similar "pranks"??
 
He's white and/or Republican....ALL that matters to the Right, even the "We're more moral than you liberals" self-righteous Right.
 
We were talking about that today. Some felt that so much of the world favors Obama and yet 50% of our own country does not and that might stem from the fact that people will go with a guy that we know we can't even trust with the hope that they will have money in their pockets.

So I would say 'yes' it is the only thing that explains their decision. Sure Democrats are materialistic but on an issue that decides how all will live in the next four years, I we they are wiser.
 
I think we have a problem defining the word, "ethical". The top-cited piece appears to define "UNethical", as "lying, cheating, and stealing". That's all well and good. But then, the implication is that the definition of "ethical", is the absence of lying, cheating, and stealing.

But..is that what we really believe? Many of us are put off by Mitt's Bain bidness model of siponing the value out of existing American companies, outsourcing the work, then sending the resultant profits off to foreign banks. Yet, we have no specific evidence - at least from a legal standpoint - that any of that involved lying, cheating, or stealing. Is it therefore, ethical?

Personally, I think not. We have regimes in place - however imperfect - for confronting overt acts of unethicality, like lying, cheating, and stealing. But it seems, all too many Americans seem to remain convinced that the way to confront the Mittian form of unethicality, is simply to implore people to "play nice", even as that runs directly counter to our free market model.

Long babble short, I don't know if Mitt's unethical from a legal standpoint, or not. But I DO know that's he's unethical per my standards. And I also know that the only way of confronting all that, is to reform our legal regimes - and especially our tax regimes - so's to "disincentivize" Mitt, such that it doesn't matter whether he's personally unethical or not.
 
I think we have a problem defining the word, "ethical". The top-cited piece appears to define "UNethical", as "lying, cheating, and stealing". That's all well and good. But then, the implication is that the definition of "ethical", is the absence of lying, cheating, and stealing.

But..is that what we really believe? Many of us are put off by Mitt's Bain bidness model of siponing the value out of existing American companies, outsourcing the work, then sending the resultant profits off to foreign banks. Yet, we have no specific evidence - at least from a legal standpoint - that any of that involved lying, cheating, or stealing. Is it therefore, ethical?

Personally, I think not. We have regimes in place - however imperfect - for confronting overt acts of unethicality, like lying, cheating, and stealing. But it seems, all too many Americans seem to remain convinced that the way to confront the Mittian form of unethicality, is simply to implore people to "play nice", even as that runs directly counter to our free market model.

Long babble short, I don't know if Mitt's unethical from a legal standpoint, or not. But I DO know that's he's unethical per my standards. And I also know that the only way of confronting all that, is to reform our legal regimes - and especially our tax regimes - so's to "disincentivize" Mitt, such that it doesn't matter whether he's personally unethical or not.

Some good thoughts all, thanks.

I will go back to what is observed and concluded here by Benjamin Rush, a signer of the Declaration of Independence when discussing a means to prevent monied influence and power in a singular legislative body, but it also applies to a society as well, especially one that just may have developed a sense that money is more important than morality and ethics itself.

No one is arguing dilemmas do not arise where no matter what a decision is it a bad one and may be more than unethical, but immoral (either choice one makes), but that when such a dilemma arises, recognition of it and discussion about it at least demonstrates ethical and moral thought was not ignored or put aside.

When people simply act as if something that would reflect on them negatively never occurred or try to hide it, they only exacerbate the negative they are concerned about. (I go back to the George Washington cut down cherry tree attribution and the moral value of the story whether GW was actually the person involved or not)
 
Some good thoughts all, thanks.

I will go back to what is observed and concluded here by Benjamin Rush, a signer of the Declaration of Independence when discussing a means to prevent monied influence and power in a singular legislative body, but it also applies to a society as well, especially one that just may have developed a sense that money is more important than morality and ethics itself.

No one is arguing dilemmas do not arise where no matter what a decision is it a bad one and may be more than unethical, but immoral (either choice one makes), but that when such a dilemma arises, recognition of it and discussion about it at least demonstrates ethical and moral thought was not ignored or put aside.

When people simply act as if something that would reflect on them negatively never occurred or try to hide it, they only exacerbate the negative they are concerned about. (I go back to the George Washington cut down cherry tree attribution and the moral value of the story whether GW was actually the person involved or not)

IMHO, our capitalist free market model is "good". It's good that people strive to enrich themselves and in so doing, produce wonderous life-enhancing products, create lots of well-paying jobs, pay their fair share of taxes, and in general, make our nation better place to live. But in order for our system to work, competition is essential. Otherwise, we'll founder on Soviet rocks in short order.

But then, that demands that every competitive player, push every limit. As nice as it may be to think that as every widget manufacturer but Ace, is cutting employee pay from $25hr to $15hr, Ace will be "ethical" or "nice" and keeping paying $25, it's simply untenable. As nice and ethical as Ace my be, they WILL be outcompeted and they WILL go out of bidness.

This is real. It can't be wished, nor prayed, nor speechified away. But, neither should we feel or be victimized by it. For WE make the rules. WE can order the rules of the "competition", such that in bidnesses pushing every limit, WE realize the benefit. We used to get that. But since Reagan, we've tended to forget.
 
IMHO, our capitalist free market model is "good". It's good that people strive to enrich themselves and in so doing, produce wonderous life-enhancing products, create lots of well-paying jobs, pay their fair share of taxes, and in general, make our nation better place to live. But in order for our system to work, competition is essential. Otherwise, we'll founder on Soviet rocks in short order.

But then, that demands that every competitive player, push every limit. As nice as it may be to think that as every widget manufacturer but Ace, is cutting employee pay from $25hr to $15hr, Ace will be "ethical" or "nice" and keeping paying $25, it's simply untenable. As nice and ethical as Ace my be, they WILL be outcompeted and they WILL go out of bidness.

This is real. It can't be wished, nor prayed, nor speechified away. But, neither should we feel or be victimized by it. For WE make the rules. WE can order the rules of the "competition", such that in bidnesses pushing every limit, WE realize the benefit. We used to get that. But since Reagan, we've tended to forget.

I understand what you are saying FS, but you will note if you read the documents of our founders, in their notes, letters, minutes and publications and read Montesquieu, that the success of a republic is in part dependent upon the virtue of the the people that make up the population who are also the people that create the rules that govern that population. If the population is made up mostly of crooks and liars, so will the government reflect that. If the population is made of of mostly virtuous people, a government composed of the same mix will reflect that. In other words, we get what we elect and we elect the type of people we want. When there is an even mix of crooks and liars and virtuous people there will be a battle between the two for the majority representation.

It is important to try to figure out the causes of the 2008 economic crash so that we don't go back to installing the same persons, policies and factors that return us to another similar crash. Crooks and liars love markets that are "free" to the extend virtuosity or moral values need not apply, just profit.

I believe our founders as well as those that have found more stable sustainable economies have taken a realistic view when it comes to the ill effects of extremes in light of human nature where some, left to their own devises would simply steal and hoard from others rather than see the benefit of shared health and shared wealth. This does not mean all have to have exactly the same all around, it means a balance between the upper and lower where there are far more (in numbers) at the lower (as there have always been) but what those mutitudes possess in great masses of small quantity is not overpowered by what a few posssess in great quantity.

It means if 100 million people possess a dollar, 10 people should not possess 200 million dollars.

What we have now are 10 people who purchase 5 items at a given price and 90 people who buy one of the same item at the same price. Which multiple equals more?

If you cut the buying power of the 90 in half so they can no longer afford the item, what is the total items sold as opposed to the first equation?

If you cut the buying power of the 10 in half and increased the buying power of the 90 by 1/8, what would the total items sold amount to?
 
Where would he draw the line when it came between choosing money and power and doing the right thing?

"At present, the ethics curriculum at business schools can best be described as an unsuccessful work-in-progress. It’s not that business schools are turning Mother Teresas into Jeffrey Skillings (Harvard Business School, class of ‘79), despite some claims to that effect. It’s easy to come up with examples of rogue MBA graduates who have lied, cheated and stolen their ways to fortunes (recently convicted Raj Rajaratnam is a graduate of the University of Pennsylvania’s Wharton School of Business; his partner in crime, Rajat Gupta, is a Harvard Business School alum). But a huge number of companies are run by business school grads, and for every Gupta and Rajaratnam there are scores of others who run their companies in perfectly legal anonymity. And of course, there are the many ethical missteps by non-MBA business leaders — Bernie Madoff was educated as a lawyer; Enron’s Ken Lay had a Ph.D. in economics."

"In actuality, the picture suggested by the data is that business schools have no impact whatsoever on the likelihood that someone will cook the books or otherwise commit fraud. MBA programs are thus damned by faint praise: “We do not turn our students into criminals” would hardly make for an effective recruiting slogan."


http://www.dailyherald.com/article/20120909/business/709099980/print/



The above article presents an interesting discussion since Mr. Romney insists on suggesting his "business experience" will be better for the nation than Mr. Obama's lack of

When did Mr. Romney actually leave Bain Capitial based on a clear legal and explained definition of "leaving" or being "out of" a corporation?

Why does Mr. Romney NOT at least equal his father's lead with regard to release of the same number of years of returns?

Why does Mr. Romney repeatedly claim credit for things that were not his to claim or were not all his to claim, even after they were shown over and over NOT to be as he framed them to be?

Why was the hair cutting incident just an "innocent prank" of the type younsters get involved in? How many here got involved in similar "pranks"??

No, Romney is NOT ethical. He's an empty vessel that will say and do anything to get to the WH.

And these "so-called principled cons" are right there with him. They don't care that he tried to turn himself into the "sweaty, white version of Obama" the other night. Cons are afflicted with both ODS, and "Romnesia". Stage 4.

He, and his entire clan (minus the little children that LOVE Barack...lol), are a disturbing, ugly family that the country, as a whole, will not want to look at for the next 4 years.
 
Knot, even as I may express it all a little differently, I think we're both very much on exactly the same page.
 
We were talking about that today. Some felt that so much of the world favors Obama and yet 50% of our own country does not and that might stem from the fact that people will go with a guy that we know we can't even trust with the hope that they will have money in their pockets.

So I would say 'yes' it is the only thing that explains their decision. Sure Democrats are materialistic but on an issue that decides how all will live in the next four years, I we they are wiser.

Lilly, you are 100% right, I did exactly that in the 2000 election. I was a union liberal that voted my pocket book I thought and voted for GWB. I was turned off by his lying us into a war of choice and would not vote for him again in 2004. I made a mistake, one I will not do again.

The question asked in the title, is NO.

Romney needs to release his tax returns, America knows why he does not do it, he has a lot to hide and Republicans who may at some time want to look at a Democrats tax returns will not have that opportunity ever again.
WHAT ARE YOU HIDING ROMNEY, WHY ARE YOU REPUBLICANS HELPING HIM HIDE HIS PAST?
 
Mr. Rush lays it all out pretty well. It was no different then, but at least the founders recognized it and worked to find solutions to prevent the result Benjamin Rush points to.

"I cannot help commending the zeal that appears in my countrymen against the power of a King or a House of Lords. I concur with them in all their prejudices against hereditary titles, honour and power. History is little else than a recital of the follies and vices of kings and noblemen, and it is because I dread so much from them, that I wish to exclude them for ever from Pennsylvania, for notwithstanding our government has been called a simple democracy, I maintain, that a foundation is laid in it for the most complete aristocracy that ever existed in the world."

"In order to prove this assertion, I shall premise two propositions, which have never been controverted: First, where there is wealth, there will be power; and, secondly, the rich have always been an over-match for the poor in all contests for power."

"These truths being admitted, I desire to know what can prevent our single representation being filled, in the course of a few years, with a majority of rich men? Say not, the people will not choose such men to represent them. The influence of wealth at elections is irresistible. It has been seen and felt in Pennsylvania, and I am obliged in justice to my subject to say, that there are poor men among us as prepared to be influenced, as the rich are prepared to influence them. The fault must be laid in both cases upon human nature. The consequence of a majority of rich men getting into the legislature is plain. Their wealth will administer fuel to the love of arbitrary power that is common to all men. The present Assembly have furnished them with precedents for breaking the Constitution. Farewell now to annual elections! Public emergencies will sanctify the most daring measures. The clamours of their constituents will be silenced with offices, bribes or punishments. An aristocracy will be established, and Pennsylvania will be inhabited like most of the countries in Europe, with only two sorts of animals, tyrants and slaves."

-Benjamin Rush - 1777 - Bicameralism
 
Back
Top