New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

it's time to close GITMO

actually, it's past time. when Pres Obama first issued the order to close Gitmo, repubs and dems alike got all wobbly and stopped him from proceeding with the plan.

When did Obama issue what order? He didn't. He can't. He's deluded enough to believe that he's a supreme dictator, but what you refer to as 'repubs and dems alike got all wobbly and stopped him', happens to be referred to in our founding documents as 'checks and balances'

It's how our government is structured.

I'd have figured that Obama would have considered that prior to running his yap and declaring "make no mistake we will close Guantanemo prison"

there's no reason to be afraid to close GITMO and bring the detainees stateside.

No reason? None? no reasonable person acting prudently could suggest the slightest potential for a clusterflack were we to bring a prison full of terrorists who no other nation on the face of the earth will accept?

ok, thanks for that analysis.....

"The original premise for opening GTMO – that detainees would not be able to challenge their detention – was found unconstitutional five years ago. In the meantime, GTMO has become a symbol around the world for an America that flouts the rule of law. Our allies won’t cooperate with us if they think a terrorist will end up at GTMO. During a time of budget cuts, we spend $150 million each year to imprison 166 people –almost $1 million per prisoner. And the Department of Defense estimates that we must spend another $200 million to keep GTMO open at a time when we are cutting investments in education and research here at home." --- Pres Obama

the original premise for opening Gitmo was brilliant. stack scum in a location that's inaccessible by the enemy and off American soil.

What they didn't anticipate was whiny terrorist sympathizers who believe that the constitution ought to be a death sentence rather than a means for responsible government. That human debris who follow no code, no convention, who would murder each of our pregnant mothers, are 'entitled' to anything, because by some warped sense of justice, is insane.

I'd lay odds that these same folks, would light the match if you could stack enough kindling and Tea Party patriots.
 
there's no reason to be afraid to close GITMO and bring the detainees stateside.

No reason? None? no reasonable person acting prudently could suggest the slightest potential for a clusterflack were we to bring a prison full of terrorists who no other nation on the face of the earth will accept?

you would be afraid of terrorists confined to a maximum security prison here in the states?

LOL.

that's the thinking of a coward. go hide under your bed.
 
you would be afraid of terrorists confined to a maximum security prison here in the states?

LOL.

that's the thinking of a coward. go hide under your bed.

good point. no one was recently injured in the Boston Bombings and no one died on 9/11. or in the 5 instances since when terrorists got to there destination, just proved incompetent to detonate their devices

I'll just be over here being paranoid.

so why do you want them moved? what's got your knickers in a twist about human debris being given better living conditions than they've ever had on your nickel?

Are you more or less offended by the Tea Party than the inmates at Club Gitmo? What's your motivation here?
 
you're an irrational, stupid and cowardly person to be afraid of detainees who would be confined in maximum security prisons.
 
"Gitmo" is a disgrace to America...It needs to be closed....Bull Dozed and given back to the Cuban people...The US military has No business there...
 
trying to change the subject is an admission you've lost the argument. scram.

do you actually have a gavel in your hand when you write this drivel?

you skipped a step in your 'logic' train...

aside from the jihadist influence on fellow prisoners once stateside, your dream shot allows these maggots their day in court. (will you be hosting a party?)

as you may know, trials allow the defendant the opportunity to defend themselves. A judge/jury (of his peers? have to import some sand trash for that... maybe some of your neighbors/sympathizers?) will then rule.

it's conceivable, i.e. possible, i.e. the basis for suspicion (fear as you like to call it), regarding this 'strategy'

I say we leave things alone and make their hunger strike a pay per view event with proceeds to the families of our fallen troops since 9/11


or does your fear-less solution involve treating these guys constitutional protections like American 2nd Amendment supporters?

so how about it. c'mon be brave. tell me that you find these attacks on the 2nd amendment to be worthless propaganda based on the emotional appeal at the expense of aggrieved families to further a Utopian agenda based on fear and repression.
 
"Gitmo" is a disgrace to America...It needs to be closed....Bull Dozed and given back to the Cuban people...The US military has No business there...

I'm an American. I'm not disgraced. from what misguided sense of justice does your sympathy for people who want you dead, and who abide no code of justice themselves nor any conventions regarding war, arise?

hold on .... you're not one of them, are you?
 
I'm an American. I'm not disgraced. from what misguided sense of justice does your sympathy for people who want you dead, and who abide no code of justice themselves nor any conventions regarding war, arise?

hold on .... you're not one of them, are you?

Got any proof of their Guilt?....Nah didn't think so...Just babbling paranoid bullshit...Fvck Gitmo
 
I'm an American. I'm not disgraced. from what misguided sense of justice does your sympathy for people who want you dead, and who abide no code of justice themselves nor any conventions regarding war, arise?

hold on .... you're not one of them, are you?

You are one sick troll.
 
actually, it's past time. when Pres Obama first issued the order to close Gitmo, repubs and dems alike got all wobbly and stopped him from proceeding with the plan.

there's no reason to be afraid to close GITMO and bring the detainees stateside.

"The original premise for opening GTMO – that detainees would not be able to challenge their detention – was found unconstitutional five years ago. In the meantime, GTMO has become a symbol around the world for an America that flouts the rule of law. Our allies won’t cooperate with us if they think a terrorist will end up at GTMO. During a time of budget cuts, we spend $150 million each year to imprison 166 people –almost $1 million per prisoner. And the Department of Defense estimates that we must spend another $200 million to keep GTMO open at a time when we are cutting investments in education and research here at home." --- Pres Obama

I'm all for closing Gitmo, but it's largely a cosmetic thing, unless the fundamental legal issue is addressed. Gitmo is a problem not because we have a jail sitting at a military base in the Caribbean. Who cares about that? It's a problem because we lock people up without trial, in a kind of legal black-hole. It's a problem because people aren't granted the Constitutionally guaranteed speedy due process of law, trial by jury, representation by counsel, the right to confront their accusers and hear the evidence against them, the right to be free from cruel and unusual punishment, etc. If we recreate that legal black-hole elsewhere, then closing Gitmo does nothing other than distract shallow people by way of destruction of a meaningless symbol. By comparison, if we fixed those underlying legal problems, I'd have no problem with expanding Gitmo.
 
I'm all for closing Gitmo, but it's largely a cosmetic thing, unless the fundamental legal issue is addressed. Gitmo is a problem not because we have a jail sitting at a military base in the Caribbean. Who cares about that? It's a problem because we lock people up without trial, in a kind of legal black-hole. It's a problem because people aren't granted the Constitutionally guaranteed speedy due process of law, trial by jury, representation by counsel, the right to confront their accusers and hear the evidence against them, the right to be free from cruel and unusual punishment, etc. If we recreate that legal black-hole elsewhere, then closing Gitmo does nothing other than distract shallow people by way of destruction of a meaningless symbol. By comparison, if we fixed those underlying legal problems, I'd have no problem with expanding Gitmo.

I'm one of the shallow ones who wants our SYMBOL of torture/war crimes torn down......as a first step.
 
Back
Top