New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

it's time to close GITMO

If we're talking about a general in a military of a nation-state with which we're at war, then we're in agreement. For example, any Iraqi generals we captured during that war could be held as prisoners of war until the end of those hostilities. But that's not relevant to a discussion of what we can do to people who merely get labeled "enemy combatants," despite, quite often, having been captured far from any war zone, and despite having never been members of any military with which we are at war. If we allow the precedents of POW treatment to apply to anyone the president, in his unreviewable personal discretion, has labeled an "enemy combatant," that swallows up every Constitutional right you and I have. At that point, our rights can be erased on the whim of one man.

For the most part no one was "just labeled" an enemy combatant. The vast majority were captured either in Iraq or Afghanistan, either in direct combat, or because they were turned in by our allies. It is this latter group that needs more thorough vetting.

Let's say it's not an Iraqi general, but an Afghani caught simply because his AK-47 ran out of ammo at the wrong time while he was shooting at U.S. troops? He's not in uniform and represents no nation, so he's not subject to the POW rules in the Geneva Convention. He belongs to a terrorist organization (probably the Taliban) that we know still exists and is still hostile to the United States. He's not guilty of a crime, or charged with one (it's no crime to be engaged in combat). What do we do with him?
 
The MAJORITY of those at Guantanamo were innocent noncombatants ... http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=102x4336915 <---linked to a Times story behind a paywall. Do you think that because the president is commander-in-chief the military should be able to kidnap anyone they want?

http://www.un.org/documents/ga/docs/56/a56521.pdf <---231 terrorist attacks against Cuba in a 12-year period. These are all legitimate examples of terrorism ... an IED attack on an American invasion force is not terrorism, it is legitimate guerrilla warfare.
 
The MAJORITY of those at Guantanamo were innocent noncombatants ... http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=102x4336915 <---linked to a Times story behind a paywall. Do you think that because the president is commander-in-chief the military should be able to kidnap anyone they want?

http://www.un.org/documents/ga/docs/56/a56521.pdf <---231 terrorist attacks against Cuba in a 12-year period. These are all legitimate examples of terrorism ... an IED attack on an American invasion force is not terrorism, it is legitimate guerrilla warfare.

OK, and as I can document 1000 attacks on U.S. targets over an extended period of time.

For what its worth, I agree that an IED attack is guerilla warfare, but that does nothing about the legal status of the guy who planted the bomb.

So what do we do with that guy, assuming said guerilla warrior is caught?
 
OK, and as I can document 1000 attacks on U.S. targets over an extended period of time.

For what its worth, I agree that an IED attack is guerilla warfare, but that does nothing about the legal status of the guy who planted the bomb.

trap..can you elaborate on that please. is it your position that, the guerilla has no legal status? or that in the instance you describe that due to circumstances, that status is altered?


I've been following your posts with great interest. waiting to see what Arkady has to say in response to your last response to him.

I think those sympathetic to the terrorists believe that the hypothetical Afghani you cite, is 'entitled' to rights. yet they can't cite which rights and they don't know why.

So what do we do with that guy, assuming said guerilla warrior is caught?

....
 
What would Americans who are not in uniform do if a foreign nation's military invaded the U.S.A?

Would they be guerilla "terrorists" with no Geneva Convention rights or would they be considered patriots by their fellow Americans, at least those that didn't think another nation's military troops should be in their nation?
 
Close the prison, shoot the prisoners, keep the base.

yes, 'tea partiers are generally uninformed.' that's obvious from your reply.

you're asking ME to tell YOU about the "Supreme Court rulings during the Bush years on Gitmo detainees".........supports my claim.

if you were informed, you wouldn't need to ask.
 
OK, and as I can document 1000 attacks on U.S. targets over an extended period of time.

For what its worth, I agree that an IED attack is guerilla warfare, but that does nothing about the legal status of the guy who planted the bomb.

So what do we do with that guy, assuming said guerilla warrior is caught?

Ideally, what I'd like to see, is something akin to the Geneva Conventions, negotiated among the leading nations, and ratified by their respective governments, having force of law, that would set standards for the treatment of people in that situation. They're not good fits for either conventional POW rules or conventional international criminal law. Unlike traditional POW cases, it's hard to determine whether someone who is captured really is a "soldier" or not.... since often they have no uniforms, no formal membership in any military, and they may even be operating outside of any war zone. There's not generally any rank, or any authority whose surrender can be taken as the end of hostilities. If people taken in the "war on terror" are prisoners until the "war on terror" is over, they'll be prisoners forever, since terror will never disappear as a tactic.

So, what I'd like to see is a set of standards about who can be seized and where, and what evidence there has to be to support a claim that the person is a POW (e.g., they have to be caught within an internationally-recognized war-zone by military forces who swear to the fact they were caught bearing arms against the country holding them, or otherwise involved directly in the operations of an internationally-recognized combatant organization, or something like that). Then, they'd need to be kept according to various standards (no harsh interrogation methods, decent accommodations, access to international observers), consistent with how the US treated German POWs during WWII. And there'd be the ability for some sort of international body to declare an end to the hostilities in question, triggering release of the POWs within a reasonable time period.

Then, for those who didn't meet that definition of POW, I'd want them to be tried as international criminals, if they are alleged to have committed some crime.

The point, for me, is that there should be a framework of law that limits what any one person is able to do -- checks and balances, to prevent abuse. What troubles me most about the current situation is that the way alleged jihadis fall in the cracks between traditional criminals and traditional POWs had allowed governments (especially the US) to treat them as existing outside both sets of legal standards, so that the president can basically do whatever he wants, for as long as he wants, simply by asserting an unreviewable finding of "enemy combatant" status, without even proper legal guidance about what that means.
 
What would Americans who are not in uniform do if a foreign nation's military invaded the U.S.A?

Would they be guerilla "terrorists" with no Geneva Convention rights or would they be considered patriots by their fellow Americans, at least those that didn't think another nation's military troops should be in their nation?

if we were at war here in America it would be the military waging that war
 
"Gitmo" is a disgrace to America...It needs to be closed....Bull Dozed and given back to the Cuban people...The US military has No business there...

Unsurprisingly, you're confused. Cuba was fully controlled by the United States at the end of the Spanish-American War. In 1903, all Cuban land except for the base at Guantanamo was voluntarily given to Cuba by the US. Cuba was successful for a short time until the leftists gained control in 1959 and turned it into the hellhole it is today (like they do with every other country in which they gain power).
 
Ideally, what I'd like to see, is something akin to the Geneva Conventions, negotiated among the leading nations, and ratified by their respective governments, having force of law, that would set standards for the treatment of people in that situation.

do 'people in that situation' have any responsibility?

Trap has noted a few times that the protections normally available to criminals or warriors are unavailable to terrorists because of HOW THE TERRORISTS conduct THEIR business (FOR emphasis...not screaming).

You seem to want to keep re-jiggering the system to accomodate people who have no interest in signing whatever you ultimately come up with


Then, for those who didn't meet that definition of POW, I'd want them to be tried as international criminals, if they are alleged to have committed some crime.

so you want crimes against America and perpetrators of those crimes to be outsourced? THAT's preferable to Gitmo?

The point, for me, is that there should be a framework of law that limits what any one person is able to do -- checks and balances, to prevent abuse.

except apparently when it comes to terrorists


What troubles me most about the current situation is that the way alleged jihadis fall in the cracks between traditional criminals and traditional POWs had allowed governments (especially the US) to treat them as existing outside both sets of legal standards,

they don't 'FALL in the cracks'. they engineer the cracks and then seek refuge there. and you want to enable that behavior

geez, if only the left would offer the Tea Party the same consideration
 
What would Americans who are not in uniform do if a foreign nation's military invaded the U.S.A?

Would they be guerilla "terrorists" with no Geneva Convention rights or would they be considered patriots by their fellow Americans, at least those that didn't think another nation's military troops should be in their nation?

there's not a con post in this thread that shows sufficient respect for our Constitution, the Geneva Conventions, etc. I suppose that's why they had no problem with Bush lying us into war and ordering torture, and are unable to see why Gitmo needs to be closed and the detainees tried or released.
 
do 'people in that situation' have any responsibility?

Trap has noted a few times that the protections normally available to criminals or warriors are unavailable to terrorists because of HOW THE TERRORISTS conduct THEIR business (FOR emphasis...not screaming).

You seem to want to keep re-jiggering the system to accomodate people who have no interest in signing whatever you ultimately come up with




so you want crimes against America and perpetrators of those crimes to be outsourced? THAT's preferable to Gitmo?



except apparently when it comes to terrorists




they don't 'FALL in the cracks'. they engineer the cracks and then seek refuge there. and you want to enable that behavior

geez, if only the left would offer the Tea Party the same consideration

Keep in mind I'm not trying to protect terrorists. I'm trying to protect those wrongly accused of terrorism. Don't you see the difference? If Obama announces that you're an "enemy combatant," and locks you up, I want to know that's based on something other than Obama's personal discretion. That's the whole idea behind having Constitutionally guarantee due process of law, a guarantee of a jury trial, etc. The unilateral whim of kings was enough to condemn a man, but it shouldn't be enough with a president. And that's very much an issue for ALL OF US in this era of a war on terror, where simply avoiding war zones, not donning the uniform of the enemy, and not taking up arms against America is no guarantee that you won't be labeled an "enemy combatant."

As for your imbecilic last line, of course I give the Tea Party the same consideration.
 
there's not a con post in this thread that shows sufficient respect for our Constitution, the Geneva Conventions, etc. I suppose that's why they had no problem with Bush lying us into war and ordering torture, and are unable to see why Gitmo needs to be closed and the detainees tried or released.

LOL... you're funny
 
Keep in mind I'm not trying to protect terrorists. I'm trying to protect those wrongly accused of terrorism. Don't you see the difference?

no. I could not care less about the disposition of some low life who's been run through (what did Trapdoor articulate - 3? rounds of filters)

you seem to be a more benevolent soul than I. so kudo's to you. I just don't see how this makes your bucket list

at the very least, let the violators of every decent global standard when it comes to warfare and engaging the enemy, first modify their reckless behavior before you start re-writing world legal doctrine.

and if 'innocents' - guy happens to be standing in the street holding an AK47 by accident - are caught in the web that they've woven, that's their problem. not ours.

As for your imbecilic last line, of course I give the Tea Party the same consideration.


it may be imbecilic regarding you specifically. I don't know. but wade into a couple of the, shall we say, less even keeled crowd, and it fits.
 
Unsurprisingly, you're confused. Cuba was fully controlled by the United States at the end of the Spanish-American War. In 1903, all Cuban land except for the base at Guantanamo was voluntarily given to Cuba by the US. Cuba was successful for a short time until the leftists gained control in 1959 and turned it into the hellhole it is today (like they do with every other country in which they gain power).

Wow...1903?...That is relevant...You Fvckin Right Losers need to try and keep up with the times
 
Unsurprisingly, you're confused. Cuba was fully controlled by the United States at the end of the Spanish-American War. In 1903, all Cuban land except for the base at Guantanamo was voluntarily given to Cuba by the US. Cuba was successful for a short time until the leftists gained control in 1959 and turned it into the hellhole it is today (like they do with every other country in which they gain power).

Are you suggesting Batista was a swell guy in your eyes?
 
Back
Top