New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

it's time to close GITMO

what does this have to do with anything?

who does any common criminal represent?

We're talking about improvised explosive devices and "guerilla" status based on not representing a nation, but possibly some "militarized" grouping, no? Would you like to deny that before 9/11, McVeigh's improvised explosive device was the WORST terrorist act on U.S. soil? Did we round up McVeigh and his Militia Movement pals and send them to GITMO and deny them any sort of justice or suggest they should be denied protection under the Geneva Convention because they set off an IED as "guerillas" in their own nation in an act of terrorism?

Would you suggest that Americans should be hauled off to someplace like GITMO if they plant IED's that target foreign military troops who have invaded their nation?

Was it okay for Mujahideen (supported by the U.S. CIA) to fight Soviet troops who had invaded their nation (Afghanistan) in the 80's? What changed from then other than we became the invading military force? Did we really expect all the people of other nations would welcome our military incursions into their nations without shooing at us? Would you be cheering on the incursion of a foreign nation's military into our nation or would you be shooting at them? Do you know what the Vichy French refers to? Were they patriots or traitors to the French people? Have you ever thought about why it is important to seriously consider military incursions into other nations to go after "common criminals", most of which haven't killed as many Americans as Timothy McVeigh killed or amount to the same sort of threat to Americans as America's own homicide rate?

Read what John Qunicy Adams said in a 4th of July speech in 1821:
http://millercenter.org/president/speeches/detail/3484

In addition, think about what terrorists use to recruit people against the U.S. and whether our actions do more to give them ammunition and feed the fires or deprive them of ammunition and extinguish the fires?
 
OK, and as I can document 1000 attacks on U.S. targets over an extended period of time.

For what its worth, I agree that an IED attack is guerilla warfare, but that does nothing about the legal status of the guy who planted the bomb.

So what do we do with that guy, assuming said guerilla warrior is caught?

The point is, it's not an act of terrorism. The U.S. invasion of, say, Iraq is illegal. It is the crime of aggression, the supreme crime under international law. The people of Iraq have a right, under the UN Charter, to resist this aggression against their country. So asking what "we" should do is like asking what the Nazis should've done when they captured a member of the Polish resistance.

Unsurprisingly, you're confused. Cuba was fully controlled by the United States at the end of the Spanish-American War. In 1903, all Cuban land except for the base at Guantanamo was voluntarily given to Cuba by the US. Cuba was successful for a short time until the leftists gained control in 1959 and turned it into the hellhole it is today (like they do with every other country in which they gain power).

Cuba had been fighting the Spanish for years--and winning--before the U.S. jumped into the war and snatched the fruits of victory from the Cuban patriots. The U.S. didn't attempt to hold Cuba by military force because the main prize for them was the Philippines, where they faced a strong insurgency, and they would've been hard-pressed to defeat both the Filipinos and the Cubans. So Cuba won its independence, but not because of the U.S.'s generosity. Cuba today is a success by many measures. It has the lowest infant mortality rate, the 2nd-highest life expectancy, the lowest HIV infection rate, and the 4th-highest literacy rate in the Western Hemisphere. It was one of the first countries to wipe out malaria and polio. Cuba performed the first successful gall bladder transplant, and is one of a handful of countries researching an AIDS vaccine. Cuba went through a serious economic crisis in the 1990s (because of the Soviet Union's collapse), yet didn't close a single school or hospital. It is the only country in the world without homelessness.
 
Republicans Critcize Obama's shift on Drone Use

May 26, 2013

WASHINGTON, DC — Republicans criticized President Barack Obama on Sunday for what they described as a retreat in the war against terrorism when they said the world’s crises demand a more aggressive, vigilant United States.

In a speech Thursday at the National Defense University in Washington, Obama said he would narrow the use of drone attacks against suspected terrorists and seek to close the prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.

Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-SC, who serves on the Senate Armed Services Committee, said on “Fox News Sunday” that he had “never been more worried about national security” and called the president “tone deaf” on the issue.

Well that takes care of the only two problems I have ever had with my President. :D
 
What would Americans who are not in uniform do if a foreign nation's military invaded the U.S.A?

Would they be guerilla "terrorists" with no Geneva Convention rights or would they be considered patriots by their fellow Americans, at least those that didn't think another nation's military troops should be in their nation?

I would hope that they would form a resistance that distinguished itself from the surrounding population in accordance with the Geneva' Convention's recognition of spontaneous militias. This would mean they were not criminals. As the roadside bombers discussed above do not separate themselves from the surrounding population, they do not fit the Geneva Convention conditions for being recognized and detained with the full privileges of POWs. Neither are they criminals. So, what do we do with those we capture?
 
Ideally, what I'd like to see, is something akin to the Geneva Conventions, negotiated among the leading nations, and ratified by their respective governments, having force of law, that would set standards for the treatment of people in that situation.

When that was proposed, in an addendum to the Geneva Convention in 1979, our Congress rejected it. But if they'd accepted it, its conditions wouldn't apply to an actual Taliban member caught in the act, as the Taliban has not operated under the conditions set forth in that codicil (which was accepted by numerous other GC signatories).

They're not good fits for either conventional POW rules or conventional international criminal law. Unlike traditional POW cases, it's hard to determine whether someone who is captured really is a "soldier" or not.... since often they have no uniforms, no formal membership in any military, and they may even be operating outside of any war zone. There's not generally any rank, or any authority whose surrender can be taken as the end of hostilities. If people taken in the "war on terror" are prisoners until the "war on terror" is over, they'll be prisoners forever, since terror will never disappear as a tactic.

So, what I'd like to see is a set of standards about who can be seized and where, and what evidence there has to be to support a claim that the person is a POW (e.g., they have to be caught within an internationally-recognized war-zone by military forces who swear to the fact they were caught bearing arms against the country holding them, or otherwise involved directly in the operations of an internationally-recognized combatant organization, or something like that). Then, they'd need to be kept according to various standards (no harsh interrogation methods, decent accommodations, access to international observers), consistent with how the US treated German POWs during WWII. And there'd be the ability for some sort of international body to declare an end to the hostilities in question, triggering release of the POWs within a reasonable time period.

Here you touch on a very touchy matter. OK, some "international body" declares an end of hostilities. Will the Taliban/Al Qaeda recognize that body and cease hostilities? I think we can look at the numerous negotiated peace settlements between Israel and the PLO for an example of what might happen -- everyone declares peace except those doing the shooting.
 
You probably think Benghazi was a long time ago, right? Fascists like you are always so ignorant of history, and thus eternally doomed to repeat it...

What has Benghazi (a place you Right Wing Morons couldn't find on a map) have to do with Gitmo?...Try to keep up you babbling moron
 
What has Benghazi (a place you Right Wing Morons couldn't find on a map) have to do with Gitmo?...Try to keep up you babbling moron

other than a general elevation in the level of discourse when you chime in, the detail provided hits it's mark about as often as a Barack Obama set shot (he doesn't even shoot a jumper).

Benghazi appeared on every thinking American's map on the morning of 9/12/12 when this administration left 4 brave souls there to die.

Unlike those soldiers, the story won't die because the same incompetents went all Nixon on the nation and concocted a story that's not credible beyond the inner circle of only the most strident believers.
 
other than a general elevation in the level of discourse when you chime in, the detail provided hits it's mark about as often as a Barack Obama set shot (he doesn't even shoot a jumper).

Benghazi appeared on every thinking American's map on the morning of 9/12/12 when this administration left 4 brave souls there to die.

Unlike those soldiers, the story won't die because the same incompetents went all Nixon on the nation and concocted a story that's not credible beyond the inner circle of only the most strident believers.

Wow another babbling Jack ass bringing up "Benghazi"...LOl
 
Back
Top