New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Non-partisan question

an interesting one too, not only from a legal point of view but a public perception view.

Let's forget for just a moment who the President is. Let's just say either/or, a conservative or a liberal, a Democrat or a Republican. It doesn't matter.

Actually it's three questions...

1) Short of a nuclear war breaking out, or an approaching meteor, whatever ...under what conditions would you be comfortable with postponing a General Election?

2) Would extreme weather be one reason?
Possibly

3) Who would you accept as having the authority to do so (.... a court, the Congress, etc.)?
Congres can. Nothing in The Constitution sets the date and time of the elections http://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/articleii#section1
 
Slavery may well have been the primary political motivator for the occurrence of the war, but what does that have to do with the motivation of the soldiers? The people who start the wars almost never fight in the wars. Do you believe that we fought in Vietnam to secure the freedom of the South Vietnamese peasants?

None of which alters the fact that the Confederate soldiers were fighting for a dishonorable cause. I think the Vietnam War was a terrible mistake, but would not go so far as to say that our soldiers in Vietnam were fighting for a dishonorable cause.
 
Of course not. They were on your team.

I hope you're not one of the people that drive around with a Confederate flag in the back of your pickup truck, NS. Our soldiers in Vietnam BELIEVED they were fighting to save those South Vietnamese peasants from falling under a terrible Communist tyranny. Which, of course, is exactly what happened after we declared victory and got the hell out. But it was still all wrong, because those soldiers were misinformed by our leadership of that era. Ho Chi Minh was never a committed Marxist. He was a nationalist, who simply wanted nothing more than for Vietnam to be united. In that sense, he was sort of like Lincoln! We drove him into the arms of the Communists.

I hope you don't try to give me any lectures on Vietnam. I did not speak with my father, and he did not speak with me, for the last six months of his life, because we strenuously disagreed on the Vietnam War. I had told him that I would be a conscientious objector, or would even flee to Canada. He was the old-fashioned sort who thought our government could do no wrong. Except for Spiro Agnew, whom my father loathed. To this day, I regret that my father and I parted on such very poor terms, that we could not even speak to each other.
 
Congress should have taken steps to modernize our election laws after the debacle in 2000. This storm scenario is one of many issues that should have been addressed. Instead, we got nothing from Congress and a plethora of state level laws designed to restrict voter turnout.

Unfortunately, in the immediate wake of the 2000 debacle, we had an infantile dolt in the Oval Office, whose idea of pressing concerns were lowering the already-low tax rates on the rich, and conquering Iraq for no discernible reason. By the time his reign of error was over, the public consciousness that could have supported serious election reforms after 2000 had faded.
 
I hope you're not one of the people that drive around with a Confederate flag in the back of your pickup truck, NS.


Nope. Neither am I one to glom onto war propaganda simply because my side happened to win the war. There was plenty of immorality to go around in the 1860s.
 
Why would you celebrate the crash of the economy?

Tell me, why should the Dems in the Senate do anything to cooperate with Romney? After all, the GOP will have just shown that it is the POTUS that pays the price for a crashed economy, not the Senate.

Seriously - what motivation?
 
Why would you celebrate the crash of the economy?

I wouldn't. That's why I am voting Romney. Besides, if, after 4 years, the economy is still so precariously balanced as to be that easy to crash, then Obama didn't do his job anyway.

It's always been that way, Degs. And I don't expect the democrats to cooperate with anything. Government is in a stalemate unless one party gets overwhelming control.
 
If I remember this right from the "complicated" election of 2000, the Constitution has surprisingly little to say about the elections themselves. What it IS decisive about the Constitution though, is the length of the president's term. It's 4-years long...and not an hour longer.

I think it would be fair to say that there's nothing to prevent a sitting/contesting president from postponing an election however he sees fit. Although presumably...if the electorate wasn't down with his call, they'd not reelect him once the election actually WAS held.

But...what if he postponed the election past inauguration day? It's my understanding that if that happened, his term would end on inauguration day and we'd have NO president. Even if he wanted to...say under cover of "martial law", he doesn't have the authority to declare himself president beyond his fixed 4-year term. I imagine the Constitution could be amended to allow something like that, but I think it would take one helluvan "emergency", to make that happen in the short period between election day and inauguration day.
 
It's always been that way, Degs. And I don't expect the democrats to cooperate with anything. Government is in a stalemate unless one party gets overwhelming control.

That's simply not true. In 2000 the Dems cooperated. they did not engage in an unprecendented rate of filibusters the way the GOP did in 2009.http://www.senate.gov/pagelayout/reference/cloture_motions/clotureCounts.htm

There was a change. And no government does not stalemate. The Dems have historically worked with the GOP. The GOP less so. the GOP's response in 2009 was borderline treaonsous. And if Romney wins, they will have basically taught the Dems that there is no penalty for doing this.

Well done.

So again, why are you going to celebrate the crash of the economy and the triumph of a campaign built on lies?
 
That's hilarious, Degs. Dems were so out of control in 2000 that they were even filibustering judicial appointments. Republicans were getting to the point of using the nuclear option and restrict filibusters because it was being so abused. Democrats set the now familiar tone in Washington and I warned you guys back then that anything you did was going to come back to bite you. And now all you're doing is whining about it.
 
Now there's what I was hunting for, some insight into the legalities, as well as some other things to think about. For example on a state-by-state basis...why should the rest of the country be delayed if the Gulf Coast states get slammed, or overwhelming blizzard conditions pop up in the Northeast. But that brings into play Knot's valid concern about reporting results.

I'm still in a quandry though about who decides? I'm not comfortable with the idea of a single judge making the call....it just seems to me it should be a more broadly based decision, if for no other reason than having a judge in the hot seat.

Thanks for joining in.
 
As I read your link, Congress sets the date and time for the Electoral College to meet (which I didn't know, thank you) but I was talking about the General Election, which I think somewhere it says the first Tuesday in November.
 
Actually it would be up to the States AND Congress.

Congressional Law sets by when the EC must vote

State law sets when the state's votes must be counted and how their EC delegate get chosen.


And SCOTUS and State Courts get to oversee both
 
That's hilarious, Degs. Dems were so out of control in 2000 that they were even filibustering judicial appointments.
SOME judicial appointments. and yes the GOP was getting ready to restrict filibusters. But the RATE of filibusters was one half that of what it was in 2009/2010 That's simply the factual record. The PREVIOUS HIGH had been against Clinton.

Again, this shows that the "out of controlness" is all driven by the GOP.

That tone was SET BY THE GOP under Reagan with Lee Atwater's "poltiics of personal destruction" and then in the early 1990s with Gingrich's GOPAC memo.

You don't get to duck that legacy and pretend it was some other party. the record is clear. Go look at the link I provided.

FACTS Color
 
but the General Election is an election of the EC. That's what drove the 2000 debacle. SCOTUS pretending that Congress could not move that and that the Florida Courts could not order a FULL recount in time to meet the EC meeting deadline.

AGain its not really clear what happens if a state fails to send delegates to the EC.

so this is very much a Congressional as well as State lege issue as well as State and Federal courts.
 
Well, by defination, "The War of Northern Aggression" is probably as accurate as "The Civil War".

Not arguing if either of these, or any number of other titles given to this war, is somehow "THE" one correct or proper one mind you.

Some believe the north was the aggressor, others believe the north was forced to act because of the southern initiation of war acts so an arguement could be made either way.

Some in the south believed that when they voted to form or join the union they had a right to leave the union should they ever think the union was not serving in their best interest while others in the north believed that when you voted to form or join the union you gave up any right to ever leave, so there were arguements made both ways.

However, "Civil Wars" on the other hand traditionally involve attempts to overthrow a sitting government.

Which simply wasn't the case here in the US, so that lablel really doesn't fit very well and yet it is by far the one we all hear, read or speak of the most.

Perhaps "The War of Southern Seccession" would fit better..................

But did you ever stop to think that it COULD be that those down in the South, who call it 'The War of Northern Aggression' are just doing like others who call it "The Civil War", and labeling it as they see fit.

If that is acceptable for some it surely must be acceptable for all.

try again pal

Nevertheless the International Committee of the Red Cross has sought to provide some clarification through its commentaries on the Geneva Conventions, noting that the Conventions are "so general, so vague, that many of the delegations feared that it might be taken to cover any act committed by force of arms". Accordingly the commentaries provide for different 'conditions' on which the application of the Geneva Convention would depend, the commentary however points out that these should not be interpreted as rigid conditions. The conditions listed by the ICRC in its commentary are as follows:[6][7]
(1) That the Party in revolt against the de jure Government possesses an organized military force, an authority responsible for its acts, acting within a determinate territory and having the means of respecting and ensuring respect for the Convention.
(2) That the legal Government is obliged to have recourse to the regular military forces against insurgents organized as military and in possession of a part of the national territory.
(3) (a) That the de jure Government has recognized the insurgents as belligerents; or (b) That it has claimed for itself the rights of a belligerent; or (c) That it has accorded the insurgents recognition as belligerents for the purposes only of the present Convention; or (d) That the dispute has been admitted to the agenda of the Security Council or the General Assembly of the United Nations as being a threat to international peace, a breach of the peace, or an act of aggression.
(4) (a) That the insurgents have an organization purporting to have the characteristics of a State. (b) That the insurgent civil authority exercises de facto authority over the population within a determinate portion of the national territory. (c) That the armed forces act under the direction of an organized authority and are prepared to observe the ordinary laws of war. (d) That the insurgent civil authority agrees to be bound by the provisions of the Convention.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_war
 
BS Degs, the tone we are experiencing now is all democrat created and fostered. It doesn't matter if the democrats only obstructed Bush half as much as republicans are restricting Obama. The point is, they did it and republicans are doing exactly what democrats defended doing for 8 years.

You get what you pay for, Degs, and democrats specifically took out this line of credit, "power of the minority" and all.
 
I just don't see how a president could assume that power unilaterally ( which is why I offered as a caveat nuclear war or an asteroid, and maybe even little green men popping in).

It's pretty obvious to everyone I threw this out because of Sandy, and from what I've heard today, there's a possibilty power could be out for weeks in the largest metropolitan region of the country. And other effects in dozens of states that will no doubt affect voter turnout to some extent which may very well determine the election. Is that reason enough and who decides. It may surprise you but I happen to think it is reason enough? But who decides? And after that who sets the rules?

Virginia is about to get slammed. Can the Governor just say hey we'll vote next month?

It's not an idle question...we may have to answer it in a few days.

Not "we" here of course....
 
Back
Top