New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Occupy Tea Party

Minotaur

Governor
This get together idea is all well and good except the Tea Party brings NOTHING to the table beyond experience since polls show they are held in low regard for whatever their ideas are - in fact lower than Congress. Why compare? Perhaps it can gel the message OWS needs to make and maybe this is a sign OWS is organizing better but if we had to be honest this may just be a desperate move by a Tea Party already ignored. The younger, professional, and educated group of young people (known by republicans as the dirty people) will either make it this spring or fall on the sword of nothingness the Tea Party finds itself now being. The OWS movement is going to have to make sure they are not being used. If they can get something from this, fine. I suspect it may actually be the dying breath of the Tea Party with the most to gain by latching onto the kids to suck their blood. The OWS may well have to remember this is THEIR movement.

http://nbcpolitics.msnbc.msn.com/_n...etween-members-of-the-two-movements#c61460865

'Tea and Occupy' -- a discussion/debate between members of the two movements
The Tea Party and Occupy movements have each generated considerable attention and helped shape the conversation heading into the 2012 presidential election. But seldom have the two sides engaged in a dialogue.

NBCPolitics.com aims to change that on Wednesday with a Web-only discussion between six members of the two movements – three Occupy protesters and three members of Tea Party affiliated groups. And we'd like you to participate.

"Among other things, we’ll ask them about the issues most important to them, similarities and differences between the two movements and the impact they feel they are having on the political process."
 
You suspect wrong. The Tea Party Patriots actually DO represent the majority of Americans and the mainstream/backbone OF America....whereas the OWSers do not, despite their bullshit claims to the contrary. But hey...never let facts, truth AND reality get in the way of that ssdd leftie agenda....lol.

I suspect it may actually be the dying breath of the Tea Party with the most to gain by latching onto the kids to suck their blood.
 
There is nothing ever wrong for loving your country, and, if these groups found some common ground between them, look out! A collective groan from both the D's and R's could be heard if these two entities found some common ground.
 
You suspect wrong. The Tea Party Patriots actually DO represent the majority of Americans and the mainstream/backbone OF America....whereas the OWSers do not, despite their bullshit claims to the contrary. But hey...never let facts, truth AND reality get in the way of that ssdd leftie agenda....lol.

They represent a majority of Americans Lappy? Interesting! :D

Thirty percent of Americans, on average, identify as Tea Party supporters -- a percentage remarkably consistent across the three surveys.

http://www.gallup.com/poll/141098/tea-party-supporters-overlap-republican-base.aspx
 
A poll over a year-and-a-half old (July of 2010)??

Now that's relevant in January of 2012...:rofl:
 
Tea Party MUST be winning....just look at who the GOP is about to nominate.

Not some "Commie who created a Gub'mint-run health care system!" :)
 
I don't know. OWS can peel off the many tea partiers who

are against repub-style capitalism......i.e. crony, vulture, predatory......

that the eventual repub nominee epitomizes perfectly.
 
Now that's relevant in January of 2012...:rofl:

Good point 58.. support of the teabaggers is way down in past 18 months!

In the latest Pew Research Center survey, conducted Nov. 9-14, more Americans say they disagree (27%) than agree (20%) with the Tea Party movement. A year ago, in the wake of the sweeping GOP gains in the midterm elections, the balance of opinion was just the opposite: 27% agreed and 22% disagreed with the Tea Party. At both points, more than half offered no opinion.

http://www.occasionalplanet.org/2011/12/08/support-for-tea-party-plummets/
 
This get together idea is all well and good except the Tea Party brings NOTHING to the table beyond experience since polls show they are held in low regard for whatever their ideas are - in fact lower than Congress. Why compare? Perhaps it can gel the message OWS needs to make and maybe this is a sign OWS is organizing better but if we had to be honest this may just be a desperate move by a Tea Party already ignored. The younger, professional, and educated group of young people (known by republicans as the dirty people) will either make it this spring or fall on the sword of nothingness the Tea Party finds itself now being. The OWS movement is going to have to make sure they are not being used. If they can get something from this, fine. I suspect it may actually be the dying breath of the Tea Party with the most to gain by latching onto the kids to suck their blood. The OWS may well have to remember this is THEIR movement.

http://nbcpolitics.msnbc.msn.com/_n...etween-members-of-the-two-movements#c61460865

'Tea and Occupy' -- a discussion/debate between members of the two movements
The Tea Party and Occupy movements have each generated considerable attention and helped shape the conversation heading into the 2012 presidential election. But seldom have the two sides engaged in a dialogue.

NBCPolitics.com aims to change that on Wednesday with a Web-only discussion between six members of the two movements – three Occupy protesters and three members of Tea Party affiliated groups. And we'd like you to participate.

"Among other things, we’ll ask them about the issues most important to them, similarities and differences between the two movements and the impact they feel they are having on the political process."

The FACT of the matter, is that the two groups have more in common than most would think.

The ONLY major philisophical difference (from what I can tell, as the Occupiers have yet to make a coherent, consistent message...) is that the Tea Party places more of the blame on POLITICAL Elites, while the Occupiers place more of the blame on the Ultra-Wealthy Elites.

Neither side realising that the Elites are ALL IN BED TOGETHER!
 
There is nothing ever wrong for loving your country, and, if these groups found some common ground between them, look out! A collective groan from both the D's and R's could be heard if these two entities found some common ground.

It is the OWS that has to keep their identity. It would be a negative if another older group took it over. I do think there are some things they may be able to agree on but they are the opposite on the more important things. I would hate to see a Tea Party group come in as anything but just another protestor.
 
I don't know. OWS can peel off the many tea partiers who

are against repub-style capitalism......i.e. crony, vulture, predatory......

that the eventual repub nominee epitomizes perfectly.

If OWS can keep the Tea Party arms distance and retain their own mission statement then the Tea Party folks would just be another protestor. Personally I think that of those Tea Party members who are not happy with what they started, it could be a win win but not sure about the numbers it may impact or "peel away".
 
This get together idea is all well and good except the Tea Party brings NOTHING to the table beyond experience since polls show they are held in low regard for whatever their ideas are - in fact lower than Congress. Why compare? Perhaps it can gel the message OWS needs to make and maybe this is a sign OWS is organizing better but if we had to be honest this may just be a desperate move by a Tea Party already ignored. The younger, professional, and educated group of young people (known by republicans as the dirty people) will either make it this spring or fall on the sword of nothingness the Tea Party finds itself now being. The OWS movement is going to have to make sure they are not being used. If they can get something from this, fine. I suspect it may actually be the dying breath of the Tea Party with the most to gain by latching onto the kids to suck their blood. The OWS may well have to remember this is THEIR movement.

http://nbcpolitics.msnbc.msn.com/_n...etween-members-of-the-two-movements#c61460865

'Tea and Occupy' -- a discussion/debate between members of the two movements
The Tea Party and Occupy movements have each generated considerable attention and helped shape the conversation heading into the 2012 presidential election. But seldom have the two sides engaged in a dialogue.

NBCPolitics.com aims to change that on Wednesday with a Web-only discussion between six members of the two movements – three Occupy protesters and three members of Tea Party affiliated groups. And we'd like you to participate.

"Among other things, we’ll ask them about the issues most important to them, similarities and differences between the two movements and the impact they feel they are having on the political process."

Ms. Minotaur,

The difference is, the Teaparty cause a rush of new legislators to be rushed into office, whereas the Occupy movement has caused a slew on new gonarrhia cases to be rushed into the free clinic.
 
Ms. Minotaur,

The difference is, the Teaparty cause a rush of new legislators to be rushed into office, whereas the Occupy movement has caused a slew on new gonarrhia cases to be rushed into the free clinic.

Don't forget about the uptick in Coin Car Wash sales in New York. Particularly for Police Cruisers!
 
The FACT of the matter, is that the two groups have more in common than most would think.

The ONLY major philisophical difference (from what I can tell, as the Occupiers have yet to make a coherent, consistent message...) is that the Tea Party places more of the blame on POLITICAL Elites, while the Occupiers place more of the blame on the Ultra-Wealthy Elites.

Neither side realising that the Elites are ALL IN BED TOGETHER!

That is where I feel the Tea Party has proven themselves different as they have almost been punitive to middle class in Washington while going after "politics". It seems like a natural marriage but there are some large holes between them. Not all is bad though if the OWS can run the show. You made good points but I have one nit: The OWS message has been get Wall Street out of Government. So they are connecting the dots...loosely. That I guess brings us back to your correct point of "coherent, consistent message".
 
Ms. Minotaur,

The difference is, the Teaparty cause a rush of new legislators to be rushed into office, whereas the Occupy movement has caused a slew on new gonarrhia cases to be rushed into the free clinic.

One summer does not give any of us an answer where American protests are the subject. The Tea Party did not organize and get politicians seated in Washington the first 3 month's of their existence either. Patience.
 
The tea party is right, Americans hate waste. But America hates greed also. Abuse and needless waste is certainly something that we should all be against. But to think that forcing people who are hurting to suck it up so those at the top can continue to gain is really NOT AMERICAN for most of us.
 
That is where I feel the Tea Party has proven themselves different as they have almost been punitive to middle class in Washington while going after "politics". It seems like a natural marriage but there are some large holes between them. Not all is bad though if the OWS can run the show. You made good points but I have one nit: The OWS message has been get Wall Street out of Government. So they are connecting the dots...loosely. That I guess brings us back to your correct point of "coherent, consistent message".

I disagree with your contention that the "Tea Party has HURT the Middle Class." This is, of course, a base philisophical difference between Liberals and Conservatives: Conservatives tend to have a DIStrust of Government, while Liberals tend to "want more OUT of Government." (I would have to point out, that in this aspect, HISTORY, and, basic observation of how "goverhment spends money" is on the side of Conservatives: Government is WASTEFUL...)

I agree, however that the "1%" should be forced OUT of politics. Unfortunately, that would leave Congress with only about .05% of it's current membership.

One of the Occupiers major problems in "formulating a message," as well as "controlling their image," is that at the very BASE of their philosophy is a "we ain't ORGANIZED" position. Now that is fine, in small, local protests, where a few can exert some control, but, as we saw, this can get out of hand in some places.

What they REALLY need to do, is to look at what worked, and what did not:

--LA Protests, worked WITH the local police, who came in and "helped" control those on the protest site, who caused problems.
--In Nashville, they have set their own set of rules, which are also enforced on any and all of the Homeless who show up (Nashville does not have any real problem with Homeless folks, but, in such a setting, some can overstep their bounds....) They have also worked hard to keep from disrupting tourism, and any of the downtown businesses.
--In many of the Protests, the Occupiers had set "groups," some of which would be in the "front lines," EXPECTING to get arrested. This actually 'worked' on several levels. One, the police KNEW who was going to "push" the situation. Two, those folks understood, that they would likely be arrested, and CHOSE that. Three, it helps BOTH the Occupy organizers, AND, the Police, to weed out the REAL troublemakers (Who may not even be associated with the movement, only there to cause trouble...HUMAN NATURE!).

In some other places, I think, they either failed, or, perhaps, even HURT their message. New York is a prime example: Those "1%" folks were drinking wine as they looked down at the Protestors, with a sort of arrogant, bemused humor. THEY were not kept up all night, by the pounding of drums, as their gated communities are miles away. (But, many of the MIDDLE Class Folks, in the area were kept up.) The 1% did not have people taking dumps and uriniating on the front porches of their Gated Communities. (But, businesses and individuals who lived in the area DID have to suffer some of that). As far as I know, not a SINGLE 1%'er lost his or her job. Yet, many of the small businesses, some of which CATER to the 1%...had to close their doors.

And, in Oakland, I honestly think that the OCCUPIERS allowed themselves and their protest to be overtaken by Anarchists and Thugs.

Remember, AFTER all the problems they had, some of the REAL Occupy Protestors, were back, the next day, cleaning graffitti off the walls and sidewalks. (Basically, cleaning up the mess left behind by others who would and WILL USE the movement for their own agenda....)

I know it may be counter to the basic ideal of the Occupy Wall Street movement, but...they NEED some stronger organization, and control over their own movement.

If they can not do that, then, it will be more likely the TEA PARTY using THEM, not, the other way around.....
 
I disagree with your contention that the "Tea Party has HURT the Middle Class." This is, of course, a base philisophical difference between Liberals and Conservatives: Conservatives tend to have a DIStrust of Government, while Liberals tend to "want more OUT of Government." (I would have to point out, that in this aspect, HISTORY, and, basic observation of how "goverhment spends money" is on the side of Conservatives: Government is WASTEFUL...)

Don't disagree with the part I did not include in this as most of what you listed is accurate and I'll add may be predictable for a protest located in Inner Cities only 3 month's young. We'll see how they evolve. It should be interesting.

But the part I did copy is because I find it to be an old argument that I do not disagree exists but there is another place to see it from. I am a confirmed, and militant FCSL (fiscal conservative/social liberal) and my view is the basic problem is not money spent as they both spend near like-amounts, but rather it is what each considers "well spent money". America has already spoken in law and programs and declared her heart to be "social" so it is my opinion if conservatives wish to change that reality, they are the ones who must make the case. They haven't made a good case to date because they want to spend as much but on other things they want money spent on. So it is not that liberals want social, it is that America already is social and it is woven throughout all aspects of government and the people. So I guess what I am saying is if both sides spend like-amounts, conservatives have not sold the US on changing our heart toward a more rigid interpretation of what well spent money means.
 
Back
Top