New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

One down....

You'd think that during the prep sessions for the debate it would have become clear the pain killers were too much for him, and one of his team members would have had the nerve to say "Governor, you need to take a powder on this debate, or you're going to kill your campaign."

Not showing up because of health concerns would have killed his campaign even quicker than showing up.
 
That's not what your chart says. Your chart says that the most nonfarm business sector hours of all persons in all of American history was 110.634, in April 2015 (the last month on record). Back before Bush screwed up the labor market, we got as high as 109.267, in 2000, but never quite to where we are today.

In 2007, when Bush was "screwing up the labor market" the number actually reached 110.394. But regardless, we're talking rounding errors here and hours worked are essentially flat since the turn of the century. Which kind of messes with your thesis that we're setting new (employment) records as the economy (and population) expands.
 
Which kind of messes with your thesis that we're setting new (employment) records as the economy (and population) expands.

No. You THOUGHT it messed it up, when you misread the chart. But the chart is an example of exactly what I'm talking about -- that, over time, thanks to growing population, we ought to expect to set new highs every several years. Even in the pathetic Bush years we did so. So, the meaningful measure will not be a raw number, like the number of people in the labor force or the number out of it, but rather a proportion. As you know the labor force participation rate is down since its Clinton-era high (but still higher than through most of American history). Similarly, the employment-population ratio is much more meaningful than the raw employment count.
 
I'm surprised it didn't happen sooner

2 weeks ago news reports aid Perry had "stopped" paying campaign workers in some locations.

Hillary has the largest number of campaign workers. and thus the highest "weekly payroll" to meet.

how soon until we read that she's stopped paying some workers? or that some have changed their status to "unpaid volunteers"?
 
No. You THOUGHT it messed it up, when you misread the chart. But the chart is an example of exactly what I'm talking about -- that, over time, thanks to growing population, we ought to expect to set new highs every several years. Even in the pathetic Bush years we did so. So, the meaningful measure will not be a raw number, like the number of people in the labor force or the number out of it, but rather a proportion. As you know the labor force participation rate is down since its Clinton-era high (but still higher than through most of American history). Similarly, the employment-population ratio is much more meaningful than the raw employment count.

You mean the time when women weren't welcome in the workforce, right? Because that's the part of our "history" where the LFPR was lower than today. And the employment population ratio is meaningful, as you keep saying, although you never post the chart:
Screen Shot 2015-09-14 at 9.47.59 AM.png

Because it's not very supportive of your "economic recovery" narrative. But frankly, none of that is as indicative of the strength of employment as the total hours number, which, as I pointed out, is essentially flat since the turn of the century.

Edit: Or real median incomes, which are down since the turn of the century:

Screen Shot 2015-09-14 at 10.12.28 AM.png

Which essentially renders your premise that the employment situation is much improved thanks to all the Keynesian interventionism we have endured, well, false.
 
Last edited:
You mean the time when women weren't welcome in the workforce, right? Because that's the part of our "history" where the LFPR was lower than today. And the employment population ratio is meaningful, as you keep saying, although you never post the chart:
View attachment 28103

As always, I appreciate your posting the chart, since it really shows in a more easily grasped way what I've been saying, about the way the employment-population ratio has been rising lately -- that it's not just a matter of unemployment falling because people are dropping out of the workforce: these days, the share of the population that has jobs has been growing, too.

Which essentially renders your premise that the employment situation is much improved thanks to all the Keynesian interventionism we have endured, well, false.

As you know, real per capita government spending has fallen on Obama's watch, for the first extended period in generations. That's the exact opposite of what the Keynesians wanted to see, but just what the right-wing economists told us would help the economy. So, how's that working out for you?
 
So you're going to blame the near absolute certainty of such a populated field dwindling to lower numbers on Trump?

I think many to most politicians on either side, Democrat or Republican, at least make the effort to fart in the wind to see if anyone smells it.

And if nobody much notices their attempted splash, and poll numbers are down, they bow out.

Isn't that how it usually works?

What's with Trump?


eh, wot? no, but I'll have a funny ha ha en route to the dwindled field.
 
You mean the time when women weren't welcome in the workforce, right? Because that's the part of our "history" where the LFPR was lower than today. And the employment population ratio is meaningful, as you keep saying, although you never post the chart:
View attachment 28103

Because it's not very supportive of your "economic recovery" narrative. But frankly, none of that is as indicative of the strength of employment as the total hours number, which, as I pointed out, is essentially flat since the turn of the century.

Edit: Or real median incomes, which are down since the turn of the century:

View attachment 28102

Which essentially renders your premise that the employment situation is much improved thanks to all the Keynesian interventionism we have endured, well, false.
Also, just on a side note, I hope people realize you used a dated chart of real median household income, to imply it was falling instead of rising, as it currently is.


fredgraph.png
 
I wouldn't hold your breath. She's averaging nearly a 22-point spread over the second-place candidate, and with over 44% of poll respondents behind her, she has a rare --maybe even unprecedented for a non-incumbent-- level of support at this stage. She's also, by an enormous margin, the most likely next president, according to the political-futures sites where people actually put their money where their mouths are. It's not often that someone who has a dominating lead like that drops out. It would be like a football team conceding at a point where they're up by 22 points at the end of the first quarter.
Could you tell me what your smoking, I gotta get me some of that. You really are a low information voter. She's even losing to some Republicans. The only ones that still support her are head up their rectum Democrats who wouldn't blame her if she committed murder, which she did indirectly. Please nominate her. I'd love to see her in a debate against just about any of the Republican candidates;

Didn't you say that the Republicans weren't going to take control of the Senate in the last election? She won't last until the end of the year.

Hillary Clinton's Favorable Rating One of Her Worst----Gallup

WASHINGTON, D.C. -- Dogged by continued scrutiny of her email practices as secretary of state, Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton's favorability with the American public has sunk to one of its lowest levels in Gallup's 23-year trend. Currently, 41% ( and falling) of U.S. adults say they have a favorable opinion of the Democratic front-runner, while 51% hold an unfavorable view.
spzchdnjfeqe5rnewjnqng.png
 
Really? What, specifically was wrong in what I said? Deficits have fallen by half, as I said. The stock market surged ahead, as I said. Unemployment is way down, as I said. The incarceration rate has started to decline for the first time in decades, as I said. The share of Americans covered by health insurance has risen sharply, as I said.

The only arguably wrong item is the claim that we're out of Iraq, since we still have some presence there. But there's a gigantic difference between our current minor presence there (three GIs killed in all of 2015), and what was going on in the Bush years (as many as 904 GIs killed in a single year).

You are absolutely correct about Iraq. I was being lazy. My bad and my apology for that. I gotta run, but will get to the other stuff.
 
As always, I appreciate your posting the chart, since it really shows in a more easily grasped way what I've been saying, about the way the employment-population ratio has been rising lately -- that it's not just a matter of unemployment falling because people are dropping out of the workforce: these days, the share of the population that has jobs has been growing, too.



As you know, real per capita government spending has fallen on Obama's watch, for the first extended period in generations. That's the exact opposite of what the Keynesians wanted to see, but just what the right-wing economists told us would help the economy. So, how's that working out for you?

Yes, and as that chart shows, soon (we hope) we will reach the actual employment-population ratio that existed when we exited the Great Recession. You may think a (relatively) small recent increase is reason to celebrate but anyone with an understanding of economics (as opposed to, say, law) is going to immediately understand that eight years into "recovery" we should certainly expect to exceed the levels seen during the recession.

And, as you know, the rate of growth of per capita government spending has no correlation to median income levels (at least not a positive one), as show in that chart, nor does the absolute level of real per capita government spending, or we'd notice some beneficial effect showing up after seven years of the highest levels of real per capita government spending since WWII. So how's THAT working out for you?
 
Also, just on a side note, I hope people realize you used a dated chart of real median household income, to imply it was falling instead of rising, as it currently is.


fredgraph.png

Lets put that "increase" in context, shall we?


Screen Shot 2015-09-14 at 10.51.00 AM.png
Like I said, we're arguing over rounding errors. If there was, indeed, a real recovery going on, that would not be the case as the stats would clearly show the magnitude of the improvement (and not require your selective framing).
 
Also, just on a side note, I hope people realize you used a dated chart of real median household income, to imply it was falling instead of rising, as it currently is.


fredgraph.png

Impressive looking. But I prefer a little more perspective:

1024px-US_Real_Household_Median_Income_thru_2012.png
 
Could you tell me what your smoking, I gotta get me some of that.

I'm simply reacting to the actual numbers -- the polls showing her huge lead over the next-closest Democrat, and her support at levels far above what anyone in the Republican field has. Right now, Trump stands at 30.4% of the Republican field, and Clinton at 44.2% of the Democratic field. If you check the political futures sites, you'll see that she has a dominating lead as the most probable next president, according to those who actually have to put their money where their mouths are.

I realize that these facts are inconvenient to you. They are to me, too, since I'm a Sanders supporter. But the big difference is that I'm a high-information voter. The facts matter to me. You, on the other hand, run off pure emotion, and the facts only matter to the extent they harmonize with what you wish to believe.

Didn't you say that the Republicans weren't going to take control of the Senate in the last election? She won't last until the end of the year.

No. What would make you think I said that?
 
Yes, and as that chart shows, soon (we hope) we will reach the actual employment-population ratio that existed when we exited the Great Recession. You may think a (relatively) small recent increase is reason to celebrate but anyone with an understanding of economics (as opposed to, say, law) is going to immediately understand that eight years into "recovery" we should certainly expect to exceed the levels seen during the recession.

I'm with you on that. That's the tragedy of our policy of austerity -- it vastly slowed the recovery. If we'd had even a normal level of job creation in the public sector, on Obama's watch, we'd have been fully recovered a while ago. But with public sector jobs instead being eliminated for an unprecedented stretch of time, the whole burden and then some was put on the private sector with predictable (and predicted) results. It was the very course of events the neo-Keynesians warned about -- and the exact opposite of the scenarios right-wing economists promised if we down-sized government. The right-winger finally got what they'd been calling for, and the results were just as bad as those of us who understand economics thought they'd be.
 
Could you tell me what your smoking, I gotta get me some of that. You really are a low information voter. She's even losing to some Republicans. The only ones that still support her are head up their rectum Democrats who wouldn't blame her if she committed murder, which she did indirectly. Please nominate her. I'd love to see her in a debate against just about any of the Republican candidates;

Didn't you say that the Republicans weren't going to take control of the Senate in the last election? She won't last until the end of the year.

Hillary Clinton's Favorable Rating One of Her Worst----Gallup

WASHINGTON, D.C. -- Dogged by continued scrutiny of her email practices as secretary of state, Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton's favorability with the American public has sunk to one of its lowest levels in Gallup's 23-year trend. Currently, 41% ( and falling) of U.S. adults say they have a favorable opinion of the Democratic front-runner, while 51% hold an unfavorable view.
spzchdnjfeqe5rnewjnqng.png

Aren't the high spots when she kept her mouth shut? :D
 
Impressive looking. But I prefer a little more perspective:

1024px-US_Real_Household_Median_Income_thru_2012.png
That is a dated chart. It lacks the uptick. And note that even the chart I posted is dated, since it lacks 2014 and 2015, since those haven't been officially reported. But it's almost certain incomes will be up in both years, given the rise of the employment-population ratio and the fact hours and wages are finally trending up. The 2014 numbers should be out in the next few days.... the 2013 numbers came out on September 16 of 2014, so we should have the update on Wednesday of this week.
 
That is a dated chart. It lacks the uptick. And note that even the chart I posted is dated, since it lacks 2014 and 2015, since those haven't been officially reported. But it's almost certain incomes will be up in both years, given the rise of the employment-population ratio and the fact hours and wages are finally trending up. The 2014 numbers should be out in the next few days.... the 2013 numbers came out on September 16 of 2014, so we should have the update on Wednesday of this week.

Very true. Now I really gotta run. I see Lukey provided the view needed. I am all for the most information possible as I'm sure you are.
 
I'm with you on that. That's the tragedy of our policy of austerity -- it vastly slowed the recovery. If we'd had even a normal level of job creation in the public sector, on Obama's watch, we'd have been fully recovered a while ago. But with public sector jobs instead being eliminated for an unprecedented stretch of time, the whole burden and then some was put on the private sector with predictable (and predicted) results. It was the very course of events the neo-Keynesians warned about -- and the exact opposite of the scenarios right-wing economists promised if we down-sized government. The right-winger finally got what they'd been calling for, and the results were just as bad as those of us who understand economics thought they'd be.

Thanks again for demonstrating a complete lack of understanding with respect to how the economy works. If your contention held any water, the depression of 1921 would never have recovered, as government spending (and employment) was slashed. And again, anyone with a rudimentary understanding of economics would know that basing an economic recovery on government is unsustainable, as every dollar governments spend must be paid out of private sector income, which, if it isn't growing, is going to struggle mightily to pay that tab (see Detroit for reference).
 
Very true. Now I really gotta run. I see Lukey provided the view needed. I am all for the most information possible as I'm sure you are.
Yes, perspective is important. Unfortunately, the FRED site doesn't allow for that, since it only goes back to 1984 for that data set. The Census data actually goes all the way back to 1967 on that figure. In 2013 dollars, the median household earned $43,558 in 1967, and $51,939 today.

Even better perspective could be had with family income data, since the Census has tracked that since 1947. In 2013 dollars, a median family earned $27,651 in 1947, and $63,815 today.

Here's the annualized increase or decrease by presidency:

Kennedy/Johnson: +3.43%
Ike: +3.27%
Clinton: +1.80%
Truman: +1.58%

Nixon/Ford: +1.19%
Reagan: +0.92%

Carter: +0.40%
GW Bush: -0.38%
GHW Bush: -0.59%

Obama: -0.84%

It'll be interesting to see if Obama rises up that list when the 2014, 2015, and 2016 numbers come in. If we project forward the 2013 improvement over those three years, he'd end up at +0.40%, putting him at Carter's level -- better than the Bushes, worse than Reagan.
 
Back
Top