New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

One down....

Aren't the high spots when she kept her mouth shut? :D
That's exactly right, every time she opens her mouth her numbers drop. She's shrill phony and arrogant, and it shows when she talks.
I'm with you on that. That's the tragedy of our policy of austerity -- it vastly slowed the recovery. If we'd had even a normal level of job creation in the public sector, on Obama's watch, we'd have been fully recovered a while ago. But with public sector jobs instead being eliminated for an unprecedented stretch of time, the whole burden and then some was put on the private sector with predictable (and predicted) results. It was the very course of events the neo-Keynesians warned about -- and the exact opposite of the scenarios right-wing economists promised if we down-sized government. The right-winger finally got what they'd been calling for, and the results were just as bad as those of us who understand economics thought they'd be.
You call throwing 800 billion dollars at various doomed enterprise, and a 20 trillion debt austerity? Eliminate the corporate tax rate and thousands of useless regulations which are just designed to give bureaucrats jobs and you will see high paying private sector jobs by the millions from both American and Foreign companies locating on our shores. Let the damn private sector economy work for once without any government intervention or subsidies.

Raising the minimum wage will result in the elimination of tens of thousands of jobs which will become automated.
 
If your contention held any water, the depression of 1921 would never have recovered

Which contention, exactly, do you think I've put forward that says that the economy can never recover if government spending is slashed? I simply pointed out that cutting the spending slowed the recovery, not that it made recovery impossible. I understand your desire to fight straw men of your own imagination, but I'm not going to let you get away with it.
 
Which contention, exactly, do you think I've put forward that says that the economy can never recover if government spending is slashed? I simply pointed out that cutting the spending slowed the recovery, not that it made recovery impossible. I understand your desire to fight straw men of your own imagination, but I'm not going to let you get away with it.
The government spends 3.2 trillion a year, that's plenty.
 
That's exactly right, every time she opens her mouth her numbers drop. She's shrill phony and arrogant, and it shows when she talks.

You call throwing 800 billion dollars at various doomed enterprise, and a 20 trillion debt austerity? Eliminate the corporate tax rate and thousands of useless regulations which are just designed to give bureaucrats jobs and you will see high paying private sector jobs by the millions from both American and Foreign companies locating on our shores. Let the damn private sector economy work for once without any government intervention or subsidies.

Raising the minimum wage will result in the elimination of tens of thousands of jobs which will become automated.
We've seen your right-wing economic ideas in practice repeatedly, and the results have never been good. By comparison, periods of more liberal economic policy (which the current era emphatically is not) have a track record of outstanding economic growth.
 
We've seen your right-wing economic ideas in practice repeatedly, and the results have never been good. By comparison, periods of more liberal economic policy (which the current era emphatically is not) have a track record of outstanding economic growth.
It's not 'right wing' economics. It's capitalism unchained. We've seen left wing economics and left wing foreign policy and they both are a disaster.
 
What makes you think that's plenty?
divide it by the population and you'll see. If more of that money were left in the private sector we would see a hell of a lot more growth. You can't take money out of the private sector and expect large economic growth. Much of it is flushed down the commode.
 
It's not 'right wing' economics. It's capitalism unchained. We've seen left wing economics and left wing foreign policy and they both are a disaster.
Did you know that the average unemployment rate under every single Republican presidency, going at least back to Hoover, has been higher than the baseline rate that president inherited? Did you know that eras of Democratic presidential leadership fair better, in average economic terms, than Republican ones when it comes to nearly every single major economic indicator?

As I've mentioned, I'm a high-information guy. I draw my political beliefs from a study of what happens in the real world. From that perspective, the world looks very different than it does for someone who starts with a quasi-religious embrace of right-wing economics and cherry picks facts that happen to line up with that dogma.
 
divide it by the population and you'll see.

Ok, I did so. I don't see.

If more of that money were left in the private sector we would see a hell of a lot more growth.

What makes you think that? We've had a shrinking of government spending in the Obama years -- the first such shrinkage over a period this long in a few generations, at least. Are the results what you expected?
 
Yes, perspective is important. Unfortunately, the FRED site doesn't allow for that, since it only goes back to 1984 for that data set. The Census data actually goes all the way back to 1967 on that figure. In 2013 dollars, the median household earned $43,558 in 1967, and $51,939 today.

Even better perspective could be had with family income data, since the Census has tracked that since 1947. In 2013 dollars, a median family earned $27,651 in 1947, and $63,815 today.

Here's the annualized increase or decrease by presidency:

Kennedy/Johnson: +3.43%
Ike: +3.27%
Clinton: +1.80%
Truman: +1.58%

Nixon/Ford: +1.19%
Reagan: +0.92%

Carter: +0.40%
GW Bush: -0.38%
GHW Bush: -0.59%

Obama: -0.84%

It'll be interesting to see if Obama rises up that list when the 2014, 2015, and 2016 numbers come in. If we project forward the 2013 improvement over those three years, he'd end up at +0.40%, putting him at Carter's level -- better than the Bushes, worse than Reagan.

That Obama number doesn't sound correct to me. The 2009 median was $54,059. For your chart to be true, it would need to be $53,604. I don't see us being there, based on this interactive map. It only goes to 2013, but you would need to have seen a very sharp increase for 2014 for that to be true.

https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/MEHOINUSA672N
 
That Obama number doesn't sound correct to me. The 2009 median was $54,059. For your chart to be true, it would need to be $53,604. I don't see us being there, based on this interactive map. It only goes to 2013, but you would need to have seen a very sharp increase for 2014 for that to be true.

https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/MEHOINUSA672N
You're looking at median HOUSEHOLD income. I specified median FAMILY income. For median household income, the figure would be -0.93%. But all the other figures would change, as well. For example, GW Bush would be -0.53% and GHW Bush would be -0.82%.
 
Which contention, exactly, do you think I've put forward that says that the economy can never recover if government spending is slashed? I simply pointed out that cutting the spending slowed the recovery, not that it made recovery impossible. I understand your desire to fight straw men of your own imagination, but I'm not going to let you get away with it.

Which would mean what after seven years and no meaningful recovery? Something else is holding back the economy, which people like you would prefer be obscured by a protracted growth of government.

And that something else is, as I have repeatedly explained to you, Obama's anti-capitalist agenda. It is so nice to finally be able to get somewhere with you. Now, would you please explain for us why you would prefer a growth in government to a removal of Obama's poor choice of economic policies, so that the private sector can grow and pull us out of the economic malaise?
 
You're looking at median HOUSEHOLD income. I specified median FAMILY income. For median household income, the figure would be -0.93%. But all the other figures would change, as well. For example, GW Bush would be -0.53% and GHW Bush would be -0.82%.

So let's see your source, as I have a feeling your numbers aren't quite right.
 
Which would mean what after seven years and no meaningful recovery?

No, of course not. Obviously, there hasn't been a full recovery. But real per capita GDP is up considerably. The issue is one of distribution, not so much of magnitude. The growth is there, but most of it has been used to make the rich much richer and to bring down deficits by half, rather than to do things that benefit the majority. However, we also have considerably lower unemployment and a higher share of people covered by health insurance, so even those lower in the economic distribution have seen meaningful benefits. And, as you know, that's starting to accelerate now that growth is finally "trickling down" in the form of rising real wages and incomes, and falling poverty. It's tragic that this was so long delayed by our blundering into right-wing economics, with government austerity, but better late than never.
 
No, of course not. Obviously, there hasn't been a full recovery. But real per capita GDP is up considerably. The issue is one of distribution, not so much of magnitude. The growth is there, but most of it has been used to make the rich much richer and to bring down deficits by half, rather than to do things that benefit the majority. However, we also have considerably lower unemployment and a higher share of people covered by health insurance, so even those lower in the economic distribution have seen meaningful benefits. And, as you know, that's starting to accelerate now that growth is finally "trickling down" in the form of rising real wages and incomes, and falling poverty. It's tragic that this was so long delayed by our blundering into right-wing economics, with government austerity, but better late than never.

Actually more like not much of a recovery at all. Yes, real per capita GDP is up, thanks to the Obama Administration's efforts to double count IP, among other various and sundry "adjustments," as well as the use of the "official" (read: too low) inflation rate as a "deflator." And "unemployment?" Really? You're still trying to pass that off as a sign of economic progress?

So when you select a few very misleading stats, it looks like the "growth is there" but, in fact, when you look at the employment to population ratio, hours worked and incomes, the picture becomes one of an economy (specifically the middle class) struggling to even get back to the levels it was at near the END of the last recession.

That's clearly not good enough, and your contention that the economy just needs more government is belied by the $18 trillion debt. Anyone who understands economics knows you build a strong economy through the private sector, not the public sector, as every dollar the public sector spends must be pulled from the private sector.

So what we need is a government not focused on over regulating businesses, pushing the labor agenda and raising taxes/increasing entitlements - we need a pro-growth strategy if we want to grow the economy. And that's not what you are proposing.
 
Actually more like not much of a recovery at all. Yes, real per capita GDP is up, thanks to the Obama Administration's efforts to double count IP, among other various and sundry "adjustments,

The attempt to better account for IP was made not just in current data, but retroactively applied to old data, too, so it doesn't explain away the growth of real GDP per capita.

as well as the use of the "official" (read: too low) inflation rate as a "deflator."

As explained previously, a MUCH stronger case can be made that official inflation is too high, not too low, so the growth of real GDP per capita is almost certainly UNDERSTATED.

And "unemployment?" Really? You're still trying to pass that off as a sign of economic progress?

Of course. It has nearly always been regarded as a major economic indicator. It's just that right-wingers decided they don't want to recognize it any more, since the massive improvement in the unemployment rate in recent years is telling them something they don't want to know. Not to worry, though: the next time unemployment dips under a Republican president or rises under a Democrat, they'll again believe it's an incredibly important indicator. They're funny little people.

in fact, when you look at the employment to population ratio, hours worked and incomes, the picture becomes one of an economy (specifically the middle class) struggling to even get back to the levels it was at near the END of the last recession.

Employment-population ratio and hours worked are way to measure how close to economic capacity we currently are. Obviously, we're well below capacity right now. That's the very core of the Keynesian argument, so I appreciate you highlighting it this way. If we were at full employment, there'd be no point in trying to stimulate the economy through government spending. In that situation, added government activity would simply come at the expense of diminished private-sector activity, since they'd be competing for the same resources, and we'd be seeing run-away inflation. But, as you can see, we are not yet near capacity, so there's still headroom for stimulus to work, if we'd just do it.
 
The attempt to better account for IP was made not just in current data, but retroactively applied to old data, too, so it doesn't explain away the growth of real GDP per capita.



As explained previously, a MUCH stronger case can be made that official inflation is too high, not too low, so the growth of real GDP per capita is almost certainly UNDERSTATED.



Of course. It has nearly always been regarded as a major economic indicator. It's just that right-wingers decided they don't want to recognize it any more, since the massive improvement in the unemployment rate in recent years is telling them something they don't want to know. Not to worry, though: the next time unemployment dips under a Republican president or rises under a Democrat, they'll again believe it's an incredibly important indicator. They're funny little people.



Employment-population ratio and hours worked are way to measure how close to economic capacity we currently are. Obviously, we're well below capacity right now. That's the very core of the Keynesian argument, so I appreciate you highlighting it this way. If we were at full employment, there'd be no point in trying to stimulate the economy through government spending. In that situation, added government activity would simply come at the expense of diminished private-sector activity, since they'd be competing for the same resources, and we'd be seeing run-away inflation. But, as you can see, we are not yet near capacity, so there's still headroom for stimulus to work, if we'd just do it.

Sure it does - if you were going to "estimate" a value for IP would you ignore the fact that you can get away with putting a higher value onto more recent years than you would have to put into the earlier years, thereby making the more recent economic performance look better in comparison? Of course you wouldn't - you are a first class propagandist and that little detail wouldn't escape your attention.

The case for "low" inflation is based on imputed values for product improvement, substitution effects and the like. So yes, you could make it any lower rate that you would like, as long as you can keep making the hedonic and substitution effects larger. The case for higher inflation is based on simply observing the increasing costs of most of the things people have to buy each week.

Modern GDP calculation is a (double seasonally adjusted) joke. As is "unemployment" which you keep pointing out is heading down, although the main reason is people (in every age group except the over 65) dropping out of the workforce.

Even though you crow about the "good" trend in unemployment, now you pull the switcheroo and mention that we are (of course) below capacity, and make your standard plea for more "stimulus" despite none of the trillions in "stimulus" spent to date having any discernable effect. This due to the "leakages" in a global economy which made our "stimulus" spending China, Korea and Malaysia's economic gain. So you think this time around it will magically stay within the confines of the continent...why? As anyone with a brain can see, in a global economic situation, "full employment" is to be found on the supply side, not in the mythical pursuit of "increased aggregate demand."
 
Sure it does - if you were going to "estimate" a value for IP would you ignore the fact that you can get away with putting a higher value onto more recent years than you would have to put into the earlier years, thereby making the more recent economic performance look better in comparison?

If by "estimate" you mean "pull a number out of your butt without having to document the methodology," sure. But that's not how it works. They responded to criticisms about the failure to properly account for IP by coming up with an methodology for calculating it better, similar to the way they have methods for estimating other kinds of production, then they applied that method in the past and present to get their revised numbers. If you think their method is poor, feel free to offer a better one.

The case for "low" inflation is based on imputed values for product improvement, substitution effects and the like.

The case for official inflation being overestimated is much stronger, and is based on the official calculation comparing un-like products, by not even attempting to account for product improvements. Thus, even if it would have cost you millions of dollars to buy the equivalent of today's desktop computer just twenty years ago, in terms of equivalent capabilities, the official rate doesn't reflect that massive deflation. Instead, it pretends that today's desktop computer and yesterday's are equivalent products and compares their prices, just as if people were actually buying the same thing.

Modern GDP calculation is a (double seasonally adjusted) joke

I know your right-wing websites have programmed you to regurgitate that "double seasonal adjustment" trope, and you're powerless to resist, but you look like an idiot when you do it in this context, because seasonal adjustments, whatever they might be, wash out in ANNUAL calculations. They merely result in seasonal numbers being higher or lower. If they artificially boost this Spring's numbers, they'll boost next Spring's numbers similarly, resulting in no net increase in annual growth.

As is "unemployment" which you keep pointing out is heading down, although the main reason is people (in every age group except the over 65) dropping out of the workforce.

You haven't even begun to grapple with the concept here. The question isn't whether those in the over-65 age group have higher or lower participation than those in the over-65 age group in some prior era. The question is one of population distribution. The Baby Boom demographic was in traditionally peak working years in the 1990s, and now they're in years where workforce participation traditionally declines fast.

That does not, of course, explain away all the issues with the workforce. We are genuinely under capacity right now, even after accounting for the demographic shift. And we could change that with some stimulus. But even with stimulus, we'd be foolish to expect we'd be getting up to the employment/population ratios we had in 2000, since the demographics have changed. We'd move in that direction, but would not get all the way there.

So you think this time around it will magically stay within the confines of the continent...why?

What makes you think I believe it will all stay within this continent? I"m sure some of the benefit will leak abroad, just as I'm sure some of their stimulus will benefit us. But the question is merely whether we'll be better off with the stimulus. Obviously, we will.

As anyone with a brain can see, in a global economic situation, "full employment" is to be found on the supply side, not in the mythical pursuit of "increased aggregate demand."
Trickle-down economics has failed every time it's been tried, most recently in the Bush years. I know that using your bizarre personal definitions of "supply-side," the demand-side policies of the Clinton years (which included big upper-class tax hikes) are supposed to be called "supply side," while the classic supply-side policies of Bush (which included big upper-class tax cuts) are not supposed to count as supply-side, but that's only because inventing a whole new eccentric lexicon is the only way for you to shelter your religious faith from the facts that supply-side failed miserably, whereas demand-side policies succeeded well.
 
Back
Top