Arkady
President
Here's my belated response, imreallyperplexed:
Yes, if you've been reading Krugman, you're probably familiar with the general thrust of what I think Obama should have done differently. I think stimulus should have been larger and I also think it would have been more efficient if structured around federal jobs-creation programs, rather than tax cuts and handouts to the states, to corporations, and to the poor and unemployed.
I would have liked to see New Deal-style federal government hiring of the long-term jobless to do work that benefits the nation as a whole (akin to Clinton's Americorps, but on a far grander scale). That would include WPA-style new infrastructure projects, as well as inspection and maintenance work on our existing infrastructure. Those things would have raised our economic capacity for the future while lowering our future costs. I also would have looked for creative ways to soak up excess labor capacity, in the short term, with jobs programs that created quality-of-life improvements. For example, picture hiring a lot of young people to lead free exercise and nutrition classes for the elderly, and to ferry around old people who can't drive. Picture hiring them to do after-school educational camps for kids. Etc.
I'm a deficit hawk during good economic times, but this isn't a good economic time. So, I wouldn't focus on the deficit right now.
As for what was politically possible to do, it's impossible to say. However, I don't see the kind of behavior I'd expect if Obama were really doing everything he could. I mean, look at what FDR did -- trying to pack the courts, doing all sorts of crap that got smacked down hard by the courts, in an effort to get things done. He wasn't politically cautious. The fact he overreached often is a sign that he was trying hard. Truman, in his "Given em Hell" period, was similar. So was LBJ. Even Clinton, who was fairly conservative, appeared to be fighting a lot harder than Obama (evidenced by his more emphatic use of the bully pulpit, his vastly greater use of vetoes, and his triggering of multiple government shutdowns).
I'm just guessing here, but I think that if Obama had been more aggressive, we could have gotten the public option (they didn't need a single Republican vote, after all). He could have started by having the more liberal members of Congress push hard to extend Medicare to all, and then he could have come out in favor of a public option as a centrist alternative to that... playing good cop to their bad cop, and ignoring the Republicans (the more you pay attention to them, the more it creates a false center, due to their radical right-wing positioning). I think he could have gotten his own party behind the public option, if he'd been clever enough to position that as the centrist alternative.
I also think Obama could have managed to get tax cuts for the lower and middle class extended, while letting them lapse for the upper class. Just call the GOP's bluff and refuse to sign the extension unless the upper-class portion is taken out. Then, if they don't swerve, use the bully pulpit (as Clinton once did during the government shutdowns) to get the media to blame the Republicans. Let the GOP explain to middle-class Americans why low-taxes for the top 2% are so important to them that they'd happily see the other 98% pay higher taxes than compromise with the Democrats. This election would look a lot different, today, if taxes were higher and Obama kept pushing for tax cuts for 98% of Americans, and Republicans kept rejecting them.
As for the next few years, it's tough, because presumably Obama will continue to lack a strong majority in Congress to work with. But I'd like to see him stand up to the Republicans. When they try to play chicken, don't swerve. They've gotten themselves so far to the right that they're badly positioned for making their case to the public. There will be standoffs (on the automatic spending cuts), and I'm worried Obama will have so little confidence in his own communications skills that he'll give the Republicans what they want, rather than daring to go to the American people with his story (about, for example, why the defense cuts are happening). And he's got to stop trying to win bipartisan support. If the Republicans want to be a part of government, they can move back towards the center. If they refuse to do so, and the result is gridlock and crisis -- well, better to let that crisis come and have the American people punish Congress in two years than to avoid the crisis and further train the Republicans to think that hostage taking works.
As for the deficit, we have a good model for turning a record deficit into a record surplus in a few short years. We should repeat what we did that time (in the Clinton era). Clinton may have thrown a rhetorical bone to the Republicans by saying the era of big government is over, but the truth is we didn't balance the budget by shrinking government. It was significantly bigger at the end of the Clinton era than at the beginning. Rather, we raised taxes on the rich and merely slowed growth of government. The major portion of that was in the form of military spending cuts, which is what we need to do again. We spend more than five times as much as the second-highest-spending nation on earth, on the military, and that's ridiculous. Sure, we can identify and reduce waste outside the Pentagon's budget, too, but overall government shrinkage needn't be (and shouldn't be) the goal.
Yes, if you've been reading Krugman, you're probably familiar with the general thrust of what I think Obama should have done differently. I think stimulus should have been larger and I also think it would have been more efficient if structured around federal jobs-creation programs, rather than tax cuts and handouts to the states, to corporations, and to the poor and unemployed.
I would have liked to see New Deal-style federal government hiring of the long-term jobless to do work that benefits the nation as a whole (akin to Clinton's Americorps, but on a far grander scale). That would include WPA-style new infrastructure projects, as well as inspection and maintenance work on our existing infrastructure. Those things would have raised our economic capacity for the future while lowering our future costs. I also would have looked for creative ways to soak up excess labor capacity, in the short term, with jobs programs that created quality-of-life improvements. For example, picture hiring a lot of young people to lead free exercise and nutrition classes for the elderly, and to ferry around old people who can't drive. Picture hiring them to do after-school educational camps for kids. Etc.
I'm a deficit hawk during good economic times, but this isn't a good economic time. So, I wouldn't focus on the deficit right now.
As for what was politically possible to do, it's impossible to say. However, I don't see the kind of behavior I'd expect if Obama were really doing everything he could. I mean, look at what FDR did -- trying to pack the courts, doing all sorts of crap that got smacked down hard by the courts, in an effort to get things done. He wasn't politically cautious. The fact he overreached often is a sign that he was trying hard. Truman, in his "Given em Hell" period, was similar. So was LBJ. Even Clinton, who was fairly conservative, appeared to be fighting a lot harder than Obama (evidenced by his more emphatic use of the bully pulpit, his vastly greater use of vetoes, and his triggering of multiple government shutdowns).
I'm just guessing here, but I think that if Obama had been more aggressive, we could have gotten the public option (they didn't need a single Republican vote, after all). He could have started by having the more liberal members of Congress push hard to extend Medicare to all, and then he could have come out in favor of a public option as a centrist alternative to that... playing good cop to their bad cop, and ignoring the Republicans (the more you pay attention to them, the more it creates a false center, due to their radical right-wing positioning). I think he could have gotten his own party behind the public option, if he'd been clever enough to position that as the centrist alternative.
I also think Obama could have managed to get tax cuts for the lower and middle class extended, while letting them lapse for the upper class. Just call the GOP's bluff and refuse to sign the extension unless the upper-class portion is taken out. Then, if they don't swerve, use the bully pulpit (as Clinton once did during the government shutdowns) to get the media to blame the Republicans. Let the GOP explain to middle-class Americans why low-taxes for the top 2% are so important to them that they'd happily see the other 98% pay higher taxes than compromise with the Democrats. This election would look a lot different, today, if taxes were higher and Obama kept pushing for tax cuts for 98% of Americans, and Republicans kept rejecting them.
As for the next few years, it's tough, because presumably Obama will continue to lack a strong majority in Congress to work with. But I'd like to see him stand up to the Republicans. When they try to play chicken, don't swerve. They've gotten themselves so far to the right that they're badly positioned for making their case to the public. There will be standoffs (on the automatic spending cuts), and I'm worried Obama will have so little confidence in his own communications skills that he'll give the Republicans what they want, rather than daring to go to the American people with his story (about, for example, why the defense cuts are happening). And he's got to stop trying to win bipartisan support. If the Republicans want to be a part of government, they can move back towards the center. If they refuse to do so, and the result is gridlock and crisis -- well, better to let that crisis come and have the American people punish Congress in two years than to avoid the crisis and further train the Republicans to think that hostage taking works.
As for the deficit, we have a good model for turning a record deficit into a record surplus in a few short years. We should repeat what we did that time (in the Clinton era). Clinton may have thrown a rhetorical bone to the Republicans by saying the era of big government is over, but the truth is we didn't balance the budget by shrinking government. It was significantly bigger at the end of the Clinton era than at the beginning. Rather, we raised taxes on the rich and merely slowed growth of government. The major portion of that was in the form of military spending cuts, which is what we need to do again. We spend more than five times as much as the second-highest-spending nation on earth, on the military, and that's ridiculous. Sure, we can identify and reduce waste outside the Pentagon's budget, too, but overall government shrinkage needn't be (and shouldn't be) the goal.