New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives

Here's my belated response, imreallyperplexed:

Yes, if you've been reading Krugman, you're probably familiar with the general thrust of what I think Obama should have done differently. I think stimulus should have been larger and I also think it would have been more efficient if structured around federal jobs-creation programs, rather than tax cuts and handouts to the states, to corporations, and to the poor and unemployed.

I would have liked to see New Deal-style federal government hiring of the long-term jobless to do work that benefits the nation as a whole (akin to Clinton's Americorps, but on a far grander scale). That would include WPA-style new infrastructure projects, as well as inspection and maintenance work on our existing infrastructure. Those things would have raised our economic capacity for the future while lowering our future costs. I also would have looked for creative ways to soak up excess labor capacity, in the short term, with jobs programs that created quality-of-life improvements. For example, picture hiring a lot of young people to lead free exercise and nutrition classes for the elderly, and to ferry around old people who can't drive. Picture hiring them to do after-school educational camps for kids. Etc.

I'm a deficit hawk during good economic times, but this isn't a good economic time. So, I wouldn't focus on the deficit right now.

As for what was politically possible to do, it's impossible to say. However, I don't see the kind of behavior I'd expect if Obama were really doing everything he could. I mean, look at what FDR did -- trying to pack the courts, doing all sorts of crap that got smacked down hard by the courts, in an effort to get things done. He wasn't politically cautious. The fact he overreached often is a sign that he was trying hard. Truman, in his "Given em Hell" period, was similar. So was LBJ. Even Clinton, who was fairly conservative, appeared to be fighting a lot harder than Obama (evidenced by his more emphatic use of the bully pulpit, his vastly greater use of vetoes, and his triggering of multiple government shutdowns).

I'm just guessing here, but I think that if Obama had been more aggressive, we could have gotten the public option (they didn't need a single Republican vote, after all). He could have started by having the more liberal members of Congress push hard to extend Medicare to all, and then he could have come out in favor of a public option as a centrist alternative to that... playing good cop to their bad cop, and ignoring the Republicans (the more you pay attention to them, the more it creates a false center, due to their radical right-wing positioning). I think he could have gotten his own party behind the public option, if he'd been clever enough to position that as the centrist alternative.

I also think Obama could have managed to get tax cuts for the lower and middle class extended, while letting them lapse for the upper class. Just call the GOP's bluff and refuse to sign the extension unless the upper-class portion is taken out. Then, if they don't swerve, use the bully pulpit (as Clinton once did during the government shutdowns) to get the media to blame the Republicans. Let the GOP explain to middle-class Americans why low-taxes for the top 2% are so important to them that they'd happily see the other 98% pay higher taxes than compromise with the Democrats. This election would look a lot different, today, if taxes were higher and Obama kept pushing for tax cuts for 98% of Americans, and Republicans kept rejecting them.

As for the next few years, it's tough, because presumably Obama will continue to lack a strong majority in Congress to work with. But I'd like to see him stand up to the Republicans. When they try to play chicken, don't swerve. They've gotten themselves so far to the right that they're badly positioned for making their case to the public. There will be standoffs (on the automatic spending cuts), and I'm worried Obama will have so little confidence in his own communications skills that he'll give the Republicans what they want, rather than daring to go to the American people with his story (about, for example, why the defense cuts are happening). And he's got to stop trying to win bipartisan support. If the Republicans want to be a part of government, they can move back towards the center. If they refuse to do so, and the result is gridlock and crisis -- well, better to let that crisis come and have the American people punish Congress in two years than to avoid the crisis and further train the Republicans to think that hostage taking works.

As for the deficit, we have a good model for turning a record deficit into a record surplus in a few short years. We should repeat what we did that time (in the Clinton era). Clinton may have thrown a rhetorical bone to the Republicans by saying the era of big government is over, but the truth is we didn't balance the budget by shrinking government. It was significantly bigger at the end of the Clinton era than at the beginning. Rather, we raised taxes on the rich and merely slowed growth of government. The major portion of that was in the form of military spending cuts, which is what we need to do again. We spend more than five times as much as the second-highest-spending nation on earth, on the military, and that's ridiculous. Sure, we can identify and reduce waste outside the Pentagon's budget, too, but overall government shrinkage needn't be (and shouldn't be) the goal.
 
Nah its more 60:40... that's what the demographics say. And that's why conservatives for 30 years have tried to reduce the number of voters turning out. Don't believe me? look at the demographics at http://www.ropercenter.uconn.edu/elections/how_groups_voted/voted_84.html http://www.ropercenter.uconn.edu/elections/how_groups_voted/voted_08.html



But then how are you going to deal with the Below Average Per Capita GDP production, and the lack fo subsidies from blue States? I'm asking tha seriously:


And what do you do with someplace like Texas where currently the minority has Gerrymandered the districts so the majority cannot win enough seats to control the government. But that will change in 4-5 years simply because of demographics.

Does texas then leave the failing Conservative States of the Union and joing the United States? See the real issue is that liberals DO understand conservatives. We really do. I could predict what you are likley to say in any given post well enough that were I a good enough writer to change writing styles, I could write your posts for you.

I don't think you could do the same with me. See BD, I UNDERSTAND how you actually think. But I don't think the revers is true.


BTW one other problem with your view is that if you do a county by county breakdown of red vs. blue weighted by population... there is no such clean Red/Blue divide. rather its an artificact of "first past the post" voting rules Check out this population by county weighted cartogram That's what the USA looks like in terms of Red/Blue when done at a more granular level. http://www-personal.umich.edu/~mejn/election/2008/ (the second image shows how it looked at the state level) So you can't really do what you want to do without disenfranchising a lot of blue voters. And remember they tend to be the productive types so if you evict them to the coasts... the red inerior just dies.

View attachment 3028View attachment 3029

Actually, my wish for separate countries is highly impractical and near impossible. I would pose that what you believe regardless of your chosen stats does not show what the true outcome would be of a liberal vs. conservative state. I would take my chances in a place where there is more individual freedom.

I haven't looked at what each State brings to the table but I do know some States seem to have more natural disasters than others on a yearly basis and the Federal Government pours billions in those areas.

Your ego is once again getting the best of you if you think you know me, you have already in previous posts labeled me and got it wrong nearly 100% of the time. I wouldn't make bets on it.
 
Actually, my wish for separate countries is highly impractical and near impossible. I would pose that what you believe regardless of your chosen stats does not show what the true outcome would be of a liberal vs. conservative state. I would take my chances in a place where there is more individual freedom.
Well that depends on how you define individual freedom. The Constitution of the USSR guaranteed a much more robust protection of Free Speech LEGALLY. but it was essentially unexercisable by all but the TsarPartyChairman.

you are confusing the THEORETICAL ie "negative Liberty" view of freedom with the actual ability to exercise your liberties ("positive Liberty") http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/liberty-positive-negative/


I haven't looked at what each State brings to the table but I do know some States seem to have more natural disasters than others on a yearly basis and the Federal Government pours billions in those areas.
Nah that's not the differnce. The difference is that places like GA, SCa, NCa etc. basically have sh!t for economies because smart talented people as a whole DO NOT want to live there. Its not like CA doesn't get natural Disasters: Fires, floods, earthquakes... And its not like CA doesn't have military bases. And yet CA consistently sends $50 Billion+ PER YEAR in CA $$ to support the budgets of about HALF A DOZEN red states just by CA alone. NY is the same way, MA similar (and they get hit with Hurricanes and 911) CT too, OR, WA... its consistent. BLUE STATES support Red states and have for over 30 years.

IN fact iif you drill down into any one Red state - and I did this for South Carolina because I had exactly the same discussion back in 2010 with a conservative South Carolinian - you will find that

  • Rural 911 telephonye
  • Rural Cell phone coverage
  • Rural Road paving
  • Rural Hospital services
  • Rural FD Services
  • Rural Ambulance Services
are ALL funded via NHTSA funds "in support of" the interstate highways and the traffic they carry. And since 9/11 you can add First Rsponder support from Homeland Security

Which BTW gave $250,000 to the Fire Dept in Tenn that let that house burn down while watching it

And rural schools are funded by Dept. of Ed grants.

Basically South Carolina underfunds its own INTRA STATE responsiblities by about 1/3. Some Red states are as high as 75% of their state spending is actually federal spending redirected to them. So if Red States were to adequately fund their own services.. ON AVERAGE they would have to raise local taxes by about 50%... and that's not even paying back 30+ years documented by the CONSERVATIVE TAX Foundation data I linked you to.

Much less the Rural Electrification projects and Rural Telephony projects of the 50s and 60s.

To "pay back" all the infrastructure they have had paid for by more productive Blue States - would mean basically a doubling of local taxes... which of course would drive out the low cost, low margin businesses like Chicken Rendering and non-union plants that they have raced to the bottom to attract.


There are exceptions: Nevada with Gaming is self sustaining, Wyoming and North Dakota are self-sustaining becasue of the Gas boom, and so is Texas. But that's fundamentally a 3rd world Resource Extraction economy. Highly susceptible to commodity boom/bust pricing. but otherwise Red States basically not only don't pull their own weight, but most of their citizens are trapped, unable to exercise most of their liberties unless they get funding from wealther Blue States.

as a resident of such a blue state, who has paid into that for years, you logically should be resentful of this. Why the fvck did you have to pay for lazy assed Utahans who weren't willing to work but instead basically wanted to have half a dozen wives, 5 of which collect welfare?



And no I've not gotten you wrong 100% of the time. I got your wrong once. and have not gotten you wrong since then.
 
Interesting thoughts. Still not sure that it was all politically realistic. But .....

I do hope that Obama is a little more feisty in a second term (assuming that he is reelected).

Here's my belated response, imreallyperplexed:

Yes, if you've been reading Krugman, you're probably familiar with the general thrust of what I think Obama should have done differently. I think stimulus should have been larger and I also think it would have been more efficient if structured around federal jobs-creation programs, rather than tax cuts and handouts to the states, to corporations, and to the poor and unemployed.

I would have liked to see New Deal-style federal government hiring of the long-term jobless to do work that benefits the nation as a whole (akin to Clinton's Americorps, but on a far grander scale). That would include WPA-style new infrastructure projects, as well as inspection and maintenance work on our existing infrastructure. Those things would have raised our economic capacity for the future while lowering our future costs. I also would have looked for creative ways to soak up excess labor capacity, in the short term, with jobs programs that created quality-of-life improvements. For example, picture hiring a lot of young people to lead free exercise and nutrition classes for the elderly, and to ferry around old people who can't drive. Picture hiring them to do after-school educational camps for kids. Etc.

I'm a deficit hawk during good economic times, but this isn't a good economic time. So, I wouldn't focus on the deficit right now.

As for what was politically possible to do, it's impossible to say. However, I don't see the kind of behavior I'd expect if Obama were really doing everything he could. I mean, look at what FDR did -- trying to pack the courts, doing all sorts of crap that got smacked down hard by the courts, in an effort to get things done. He wasn't politically cautious. The fact he overreached often is a sign that he was trying hard. Truman, in his "Given em Hell" period, was similar. So was LBJ. Even Clinton, who was fairly conservative, appeared to be fighting a lot harder than Obama (evidenced by his more emphatic use of the bully pulpit, his vastly greater use of vetoes, and his triggering of multiple government shutdowns).

I'm just guessing here, but I think that if Obama had been more aggressive, we could have gotten the public option (they didn't need a single Republican vote, after all). He could have started by having the more liberal members of Congress push hard to extend Medicare to all, and then he could have come out in favor of a public option as a centrist alternative to that... playing good cop to their bad cop, and ignoring the Republicans (the more you pay attention to them, the more it creates a false center, due to their radical right-wing positioning). I think he could have gotten his own party behind the public option, if he'd been clever enough to position that as the centrist alternative.

I also think Obama could have managed to get tax cuts for the lower and middle class extended, while letting them lapse for the upper class. Just call the GOP's bluff and refuse to sign the extension unless the upper-class portion is taken out. Then, if they don't swerve, use the bully pulpit (as Clinton once did during the government shutdowns) to get the media to blame the Republicans. Let the GOP explain to middle-class Americans why low-taxes for the top 2% are so important to them that they'd happily see the other 98% pay higher taxes than compromise with the Democrats. This election would look a lot different, today, if taxes were higher and Obama kept pushing for tax cuts for 98% of Americans, and Republicans kept rejecting them.

As for the next few years, it's tough, because presumably Obama will continue to lack a strong majority in Congress to work with. But I'd like to see him stand up to the Republicans. When they try to play chicken, don't swerve. They've gotten themselves so far to the right that they're badly positioned for making their case to the public. There will be standoffs (on the automatic spending cuts), and I'm worried Obama will have so little confidence in his own communications skills that he'll give the Republicans what they want, rather than daring to go to the American people with his story (about, for example, why the defense cuts are happening). And he's got to stop trying to win bipartisan support. If the Republicans want to be a part of government, they can move back towards the center. If they refuse to do so, and the result is gridlock and crisis -- well, better to let that crisis come and have the American people punish Congress in two years than to avoid the crisis and further train the Republicans to think that hostage taking works.

As for the deficit, we have a good model for turning a record deficit into a record surplus in a few short years. We should repeat what we did that time (in the Clinton era). Clinton may have thrown a rhetorical bone to the Republicans by saying the era of big government is over, but the truth is we didn't balance the budget by shrinking government. It was significantly bigger at the end of the Clinton era than at the beginning. Rather, we raised taxes on the rich and merely slowed growth of government. The major portion of that was in the form of military spending cuts, which is what we need to do again. We spend more than five times as much as the second-highest-spending nation on earth, on the military, and that's ridiculous. Sure, we can identify and reduce waste outside the Pentagon's budget, too, but overall government shrinkage needn't be (and shouldn't be) the goal.
 
They are sitting on some of this money precisely because of this crap coming down from Obama. How can you go and spend a whole bunch of money not know when the next shoe from this idiot administration is going to drop and have you scrambling for cash at a moment's notice.

I appreciate the work you're doing in mentally masturbating this BS into a positive, but there is no aspect of this that is beneficial in helping the economy or the middle class, who is dependent on the jobs that 5 million could have provided just from Dominos alone, much less from the thousands of other restaurants affected.
 
They are sitting on some of this money precisely because of this crap coming down from Obama. How can you go and spend a whole bunch of money not know when the next shoe from this idiot administration is going to drop and have you scrambling for cash at a moment's notice.

I appreciate the work you're doing in mentally masturbating this BS into a positive, but there is no aspect of this that is beneficial in helping the economy or the middle class, who is dependent on the jobs that 5 million could have provided just from Domino's alone, much less from the thousands of other restaurants affected.

Man I have to ask you something ? Why are you so hung up on shit ass minimum wage jobs at Domino's ? Those jobs you are so anxious to preserve, contribute nothing to the tax base, little benefit for the job holder, no heath care benefits. Hell they are what people regard them to be, crap jobs ! But yet you would fight tooth and nail for that and allow corporations the benefit of taking $15+ per hour jobs and ship them overseas. Get a grip on reality. Labor in this country fought for over 100 years to grab a level playing field for itself. Good jobs that paid a fair wage, that made management recognize and adopt safe working conditions, paid appropriate compensation for debilitating injuries, and provide death benefits for widows and orphans. Maybe you forgot your history. Maybe you don't remember when your grandparents were paid $0.25 a day. There are a lot of people in this country who haven't. And you can't sell them anymore on the fact that they should return to those days.

For the last 30 years since the the administration of Ronald Reagan, labor has taken it on the chin for every stupid mistake of management, including his own when he fired the Air Traffic Controllers. Congress and the American People let him get away with. Congress because they were more interested in taking care of themselves, and the American people because they were scared to death their segment of the labor force would be next.

And what did they get out of it ? A decimated middle class, an economy dedicated to the further aggrandizement and isolation of wealth to a "blessed" few. Yeah, the economy is upside down, and things aren't working and shouldn't we all be lighting eternal flames at the graves of those who set it up. Be glad if you have a few bucks, you won't have them long, because the entire thrust of the so called Republican Party is dedicated to the proposition that only the rich are created equal, and they have the right to control the destiny of the unwashed less wealthy. Pick yourself a plantation where you are comfortable the day is coming.

Tai Pan
 
They are sitting on some of this money precisely because of this crap coming down from Obama. How can you go and spend a whole bunch of money not know when the next shoe from this idiot administration is going to drop and have you scrambling for cash at a moment's notice.

I appreciate the work you're doing in mentally masturbating this BS into a positive, but there is no aspect of this that is beneficial in helping the economy or the middle class, who is dependent on the jobs that 5 million could have provided just from Dominos alone, much less from the thousands of other restaurants affected.

As we saw under Clinton, Kennedy/Johnson, and FDR/Truman, GDP is not held down by a fear of what the "other shoe to drop" (from a conservative's perspective) might be. During each of those eras, we had more liberal leadership than under Obama (FAR more liberal in two of those cases), and yet we also had very strong GDP growth. We had excellent investment in new business. That's because investment in new business is about anticipated consumer demand, not tax rates or any of the other crap Republicans obsess over.

In the FDR/Truman era, there was MASSIVE increases in regulation, like nothing seen before or since, and taxes ballooned enormously (at one point, the top bracket paid 92%), and yet do you know what the average annualized GDP growth rate was? 5.8%. And do you know what that figure was for the low-tax, deregulation-minded Bush era? 2.0%. In the Bush era, business leaders were not, presumably, waiting for the other shoe to drop. They had some of the lowest taxes in their history, and a Republican president who would veto any attempt to change that, and they had a regulatory climate that was as loose as at any point in decades, and an administration that didn't even care to enforce the regulations on the book (e.g., letting Microsoft off the hook for its antitrust violations). But they also didn't anticipate strong growth in consumer demand, so they weren't terribly eager to hire or invest in new capacity.
 
Good Post Arkady ! Too much truth though. This isn't a world where the truth means anything to the conservative right. Hell they worship Rush Limburger, and he has more trouble with the truth than Al Sharpton.

Ta
 
Well that depends on how you define individual freedom. The Constitution of the USSR guaranteed a much more robust protection of Free Speech LEGALLY. but it was essentially unexercisable by all but the TsarPartyChairman.

you are confusing the THEORETICAL ie "negative Liberty" view of freedom with the actual ability to exercise your liberties ("positive Liberty") http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/liberty-positive-negative/



Nah that's not the differnce. The difference is that places like GA, SCa, NCa etc. basically have sh!t for economies because smart talented people as a whole DO NOT want to live there. Its not like CA doesn't get natural Disasters: Fires, floods, earthquakes... And its not like CA doesn't have military bases. And yet CA consistently sends $50 Billion+ PER YEAR in CA $$ to support the budgets of about HALF A DOZEN red states just by CA alone. NY is the same way, MA similar (and they get hit with Hurricanes and 911) CT too, OR, WA... its consistent. BLUE STATES support Red states and have for over 30 years.

IN fact iif you drill down into any one Red state - and I did this for South Carolina because I had exactly the same discussion back in 2010 with a conservative South Carolinian - you will find that

  • Rural 911 telephonye
  • Rural Cell phone coverage
  • Rural Road paving
  • Rural Hospital services
  • Rural FD Services
  • Rural Ambulance Services
are ALL funded via NHTSA funds "in support of" the interstate highways and the traffic they carry. And since 9/11 you can add First Rsponder support from Homeland Security

Which BTW gave $250,000 to the Fire Dept in Tenn that let that house burn down while watching it

And rural schools are funded by Dept. of Ed grants.

Basically South Carolina underfunds its own INTRA STATE responsiblities by about 1/3. Some Red states are as high as 75% of their state spending is actually federal spending redirected to them. So if Red States were to adequately fund their own services.. ON AVERAGE they would have to raise local taxes by about 50%... and that's not even paying back 30+ years documented by the CONSERVATIVE TAX Foundation data I linked you to.

Much less the Rural Electrification projects and Rural Telephony projects of the 50s and 60s.

To "pay back" all the infrastructure they have had paid for by more productive Blue States - would mean basically a doubling of local taxes... which of course would drive out the low cost, low margin businesses like Chicken Rendering and non-union plants that they have raced to the bottom to attract.


There are exceptions: Nevada with Gaming is self sustaining, Wyoming and North Dakota are self-sustaining becasue of the Gas boom, and so is Texas. But that's fundamentally a 3rd world Resource Extraction economy. Highly susceptible to commodity boom/bust pricing. but otherwise Red States basically not only don't pull their own weight, but most of their citizens are trapped, unable to exercise most of their liberties unless they get funding from wealther Blue States.

as a resident of such a blue state, who has paid into that for years, you logically should be resentful of this. Why the fvck did you have to pay for lazy assed Utahans who weren't willing to work but instead basically wanted to have half a dozen wives, 5 of which collect welfare?



And no I've not gotten you wrong 100% of the time. I got your wrong once. and have not gotten you wrong since then.

Well, when I have time to research the truth, as I've found some of your facts to not match the subject, I'll let you know what I come up with. Per your argument, all the more reason to keep the feds out of the States business.

You were wrong once about me and since, you have never been right.
 
Would also add that as a business person myself, I can't hire until I have more clients and it is doubtful I am going to have more clients if some major businesses are using labor to cut their cost of doing business and improve their profit margins. Employees are equally and perhaps more important ALSO consumers, that is why they seek employment, to have something to spend on food, housing and other basics as well as move up slightly if not more and have some disposible income to actually invest in actual job creation, NOT just personal net worth improvement or personal net worth improvement at the COST of jobs.

I agree it is not the government (Mr. Obama's) job to create jobs, but he is charged by the preamble of the Constitution of the United States to "promte the general welfare" as Congress and the SCOTUS are too. How does one "promote the general welfare"??? One might begin by not letting down and out citizens sink en masse to the point the nation goes down the tubes. This is kind of like how soup kitchens attempt to not let down and out people simply litter the streets with their corpses because no one wants to spend a dime of their own money to help them survive.

Are independent soup kitchens, charities and churches that work to help the homeless, sick and otherwise in trouble considered welfare dependency enablers?

If the private sector is shedding jobs because of expense, faster than they are rehiring, hiring at all or they are rehiring at lower wages and salaries they cannot at the same time be wondering why so many Americans are unemployed and not paying taxes. They also shouldn't be wondering why in the future, their sales are going to drop. Employees earn a paycheck they then spend as consumers. If they don't have a job or they have a job that pays less, the buy less as consumers and the economy continues to shrink.

If the private sector is not doing anything significant to add more jobs than they are shedding, then some think it is Constitutional for the President, the Congress and the SCOTUS to do something to "promote the general welfare" of the nation by engaging in what would be necessary to do so, once again, until there is no longer a need for such action because the private sector is once again supporting the economy by to a sufficient standard without any additional boost or infill.
 
These are stepping stone positions. Unlike the beliefs of the left, more myth than reality, no one is expected to make a living from these jobs. These are starter positions than the unskilled work while they prepare to go into the real workforce.

Again, this isn't just Dominos, and it isn't just this one regulation. Your position is myopic.
 
A lot of nice unsubstantiated declarations. Can you please tell me how this raising of taxes and vast increases in regulation grows our economy? I'm all kinds of curious.
 
Hey Buddy, I live in SC and you are right. One of the funnies for me last year, but it isn't so funny, is that Medicaid funding for child healthcare was cut, and co-pays were raised for other users, while the SC Legislature and senior state officials were given a new health care benefit. Liposuction.

Tai Pan.


Well that depends on how you define individual freedom. The Constitution of the USSR guaranteed a much more robust protection of Free Speech LEGALLY. but it was essentially unexercisable by all but the TsarPartyChairman.

you are confusing the THEORETICAL ie "negative Liberty" view of freedom with the actual ability to exercise your liberties ("positive Liberty") http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/liberty-positive-negative/



Nah that's not the differnce. The difference is that places like GA, SCa, NCa etc. basically have sh!t for economies because smart talented people as a whole DO NOT want to live there. Its not like CA doesn't get natural Disasters: Fires, floods, earthquakes... And its not like CA doesn't have military bases. And yet CA consistently sends $50 Billion+ PER YEAR in CA $$ to support the budgets of about HALF A DOZEN red states just by CA alone. NY is the same way, MA similar (and they get hit with Hurricanes and 911) CT too, OR, WA... its consistent. BLUE STATES support Red states and have for over 30 years.

IN fact iif you drill down into any one Red state - and I did this for South Carolina because I had exactly the same discussion back in 2010 with a conservative South Carolinian - you will find that

  • Rural 911 telephonye
  • Rural Cell phone coverage
  • Rural Road paving
  • Rural Hospital services
  • Rural FD Services
  • Rural Ambulance Services
are ALL funded via NHTSA funds "in support of" the interstate highways and the traffic they carry. And since 9/11 you can add First Rsponder support from Homeland Security

Which BTW gave $250,000 to the Fire Dept in Tenn that let that house burn down while watching it

And rural schools are funded by Dept. of Ed grants.

Basically South Carolina underfunds its own INTRA STATE responsiblities by about 1/3. Some Red states are as high as 75% of their state spending is actually federal spending redirected to them. So if Red States were to adequately fund their own services.. ON AVERAGE they would have to raise local taxes by about 50%... and that's not even paying back 30+ years documented by the CONSERVATIVE TAX Foundation data I linked you to.

Much less the Rural Electrification projects and Rural Telephony projects of the 50s and 60s.

To "pay back" all the infrastructure they have had paid for by more productive Blue States - would mean basically a doubling of local taxes... which of course would drive out the low cost, low margin businesses like Chicken Rendering and non-union plants that they have raced to the bottom to attract.


There are exceptions: Nevada with Gaming is self sustaining, Wyoming and North Dakota are self-sustaining becasue of the Gas boom, and so is Texas. But that's fundamentally a 3rd world Resource Extraction economy. Highly susceptible to commodity boom/bust pricing. but otherwise Red States basically not only don't pull their own weight, but most of their citizens are trapped, unable to exercise most of their liberties unless they get funding from wealther Blue States.

as a resident of such a blue state, who has paid into that for years, you logically should be resentful of this. Why the fvck did you have to pay for lazy assed Utahans who weren't willing to work but instead basically wanted to have half a dozen wives, 5 of which collect welfare?



And no I've not gotten you wrong 100% of the time. I got your wrong once. and have not gotten you wrong since then.
 
I'm all kinds of curious.

Color,

I doubt that you are really curious. I suspect that you are really skeptical (which is not curious). I am not sure that there is anything that anyone could tell you that would move you to question our own creed. (And, I suspect that you feel the same way in reverse. So it goes. Personally, I am skeptical of a lot of what you claim because it does not comport with my own experience as a business person.)
 
These are stepping stone positions. Unlike the beliefs of the left, more myth than reality, no one is expected to make a living from these jobs. These are starter positions than the unskilled work while they prepare to go into the real workforce.

Again, this isn't just Dominos, and it isn't just this one regulation. Your position is myopic.


STEPPING STONE JOBS ! In almost 20 years of posting on boards like these and reading and countless thousands of posts on politics, economics, history, education, foreign policy, war and peace, international trade, and government I have NEVER seen such ignorant twaddle posted. How about the next time you are in Wal-Mart and the little grey haired lady or the older gentleman greet you, you ask them how they like their step off job.

It is the ignorance shown in this post that clearly and unequivocally demonstrates what is wrong with this country today.

If I insulted you I apologize, but what you have written remains written. quod scripsit scripsit that it is an insult to people who have no other choice left than a minimum wage, benefitless job, when what they had before was a good American Middle Class wage with benefits demonstrates clearly how out of touch the conservative right is with the people who put food in their mouths.

a very angry
taipan

(when you get to know me better you will recognize the shift in the spelling of the nic)
 
A lot of nice unsubstantiated declarations. Can you please tell me how this raising of taxes and vast increases in regulation grows our economy? I'm all kinds of curious.
it is VERY VERY SIMPLE.

Federal Spending on Non-Military expenditures has a Fiscal Multiplier of between 1.5 and 2.5 (depending on the spending and the state of the economy).

Tax Cuts in marginal Tax rates for the upper quintile for rates BELOW 75% Marginal Rates.. have a Fiscal Multiplier of 0.7 OR LESS

So if you raise taxes on the LESS PRODUCTIVE High Earners
and Spend it on Non-Military spending... For Every $1 in taxes you collect YOU GROW GDP by $2.00 OR MORE

Up to a marginal rate of about 0.75%.


Another way to think about it is this. If you earn $1 mil/yr - you have way less incentive to be careful about how efficiently you spend AND INVEST than a middle class family earning $54k/yr. After all, if your investments perform at 1/2 market averages, you still are making a sh!tload of money/

BUT if your marginal tax rate iis 75%.. you suddenly have an incentive to BE MORE EFFICIENT IN YOUR INVESTMENTS.
 
Well, when I have time to research the truth, as I've found some of your facts to not match the subject, I'll let you know what I come up with. Per your argument, all the more reason to keep the feds out of the States business.

Go for it. Research you do yourself will be more convincing than anything I can offer.

As for Feds out of States' businesse.. sorry, having 1/2 the states be stuck in the 19th century is hardly good for the nation as a whole.
 
Hey Buddy, I live in SC and you are right. One of the funnies for me last year, but it isn't so funny, is that Medicaid funding for child healthcare was cut, and co-pays were raised for other users, while the SC Legislature and senior state officials were given a new health care benefit. Liposuction.

Tai Pan.
Sadly not suprising... Nikki Haley is looking forward to her 2016 run for POTUS and is making sure she has the medical coverage she needs :)
 
Okay, fine. The whole world is wrong except you. I get it. Little magic logic tricks and persistence beyond the patience of others has prevailed again.

Screw reality, Degs has lawyered his way through another discussion. Kudos.
No the point is that REALITY is actually there. And letting a biased source weaselword its way around it is what you were looking to do. Little magic tricks is what YOU DEPLOYED.

and no the whole world is not wrong... just people - like you - who are too credulous of ideas that appeal to their beliefs...
 
The retained earnings analysis is exactly right. In the current climate, with companies very reluctant to invest until demand picks up (and with capital being dirt cheap at the moment) it's unlikely that the cost of having to comply with that regulation is displacing spending that otherwise would have gone to expanding the business (if there's demand enough to justify expansion, they almost surely have cash on hand for it, and can borrow very cheaply if they don't). So, the regulation just means a little extra job creation now, in place of retained earnings/dividends.

This is the part that proves these conservatives have never actually managed meaningful budgets. REmember that it was HIGH TAXES that CREATED the Commercial Passenger Jet industry. Because Bill Boeing did not want to pay that level of taxes if he got all the dividends from WWII that Boeing was carrying forward. So instead he reinvested it in the design of the 707 and took out cash loans against his shares as needed... and that created the commercial Passenger Jet age...
 
Back
Top