New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives

So you're saying they're not supposed to represent their constituents.
Depends on what you mean by "represent". Politics is the art of accomplishing that which you want accomplished. And there rarely are non-conflicting needs and desires. So representing the BEST INTERESTS of the constituency may well involve ignoring their popular democratic demands of the moment. That of course requires that come next election cycle you have to convince your constituents that you represented their best interests.

And this notion is very much precisely why the Senate was designed to be appointed by state leges, and why even Jefferson believed the voting franchise should be restricted to well-to-do landowners

As for elected representatives ignoring constituencies--- what do you think the Senators from Texas do every day? Texas is about 40% democratic. Yet they have NEVER EVER payed attention to that "constituency".
 
See Jack even YOU are starting to move towards Julian Castro's way of expressing ideas!!

Now if you are referring to a "robbing of rights"... Well there is a difference between THEORETICAL RIGHTS - the USSR's Constitution had STRONGER free speech protections than the USA's Constitution.... but the were not meaningfully exerciseable.

That's essentially what the election of Romney promises... lots of theoretical rights that you Jack, nor the average person will have much access to.

OTOH Obama HAS ALREADY increased the access to exercising of rights to thousands if not millions of people that did not have that access before. Hardly a "robbing" of any rights.


If you don't mind a newbie giving you a bit of advice on Jack's posts, his goal is not to logically take or defend a position. Most of the time he really doesn't really have a position unless he's had his daily dose of Billow and Limbaugh. But what he does is craft his post in such a way that you are forced to question know fact of well thought out and logical conclusions. If he can get you there, you are off balance and forced to feed his need for attention.

If you stand your ground, and you know you are on the side of the angels whatever the issue, you have to return by minimizing the miniscule. Kind of like TR, you have to speak softly but keep the big stick handy, just be prepared to use it well and thoroughly when necessary. Humor works best for me, because its something he really lacks, as well a a credible knowledge of what he is talking about most of the time.

Tai Pan
 
Well I see JD slightly differently. He's a white guy in TX, older... near or in retirement. VERY fundy religious, and simply cannot see beyond his prejudices. He's scared of Texas not only going Democratic but its brownification. And his fear is sublimated in hate.

For a long time I actually thought he was a MoveOn.Org "falseflag" operation - he was such a predcitable caricature of a conservative.

Calling him on his hatred and reminding him of his fears works for me. I guess I'm a meaner person than you are.
 
Deggs, a little research once again shows that you are hopelessly dishonest.

According to 24/7 Wall Street, they show a breakdown of every State that provides and receives revenues from the Feds. According to you Red States have poor economies and need to be bolstered up, and that Blue States do better, wrong.
No its not wrong. On a per capita basis.. GDP in Red States is mostly BELOW AVERAGE: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_GDP

Net dollar amount shows that States like California and New York receive the most money, so you must be talking about per capita.
No I'm simply talking about Balance of Payments. I gave you the links. The Tax Foundation is a CONSERVAtIVE SOURCE..For example in 2005, Alabama paid into the Federal Government $24.7 Billion in taxes and RECEIVED from the Feds $42.1 Billion. That's a NET INFLOW of $17.4 Billion. In the same year Alabama's BUDGET was $22.5 Bill. http://www.usgovernmentspending.com/year_spending_2005ALbn_13bs1n

Meanwhile CA sent to the feds $289.6 Billion but got back only $242 Billion. That's a net $45.6 Billion TRANSFER of funds from Californians to other states. $17.4 of which WENT TO ALABAMA. That is a straight Welfare subsidy from EVERY CALIFORNIAN to the Red State of Alabama.

Research shows on a per capita basis that individual income in Red States is higher than those in Blue States,
What "research"??? Seriously... just saying "research says" when you offer no evidence and the evidence out there IS TO THE CONTRARY: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_GDP Only SIX "red states" even have Above Average Per Capita GDP. Alaska, Wyoming, Idaho, both Dakotas and Nebraska.

And Alaska and Idaho are both NET INFLUXES of Federal dollars so even those are suspect numbers.

The reason that States like Alaska, N Dakota, Virginia receive more money per capita is mainly based on two reasons, military and medicare, as high as 80 to 90%,
I already pointed out that Military is every bit as big IF NOT BIGGER in CA than in the Dakotas or Alaska. so that don't score. As for Medicare - perhaps... except that places like Alabam - which I cited spent roughly $13 bil on education in 2005,,, $7.7 Bil of which was FEDERAL SPENDING... IOW paid for by California.

You can call me "dishonest" all you want. but I cite my sources.. So far you have simply name called and cited NOTHING.
 
You didn't know the taipan vs the Tai Pan. I used both nics interchangeably on Slate and they sent a message to those who knew the difference. I can still go anger, but maybe I've learned a few things in the last couple of years, one is it drives my blood pressure up and enlarges an already damaged heart, and two is it peaks my blood sugar and scares my dog. So where possible, I substitute humor and wit, if if there's a bite to both.

Best to you.

I like your posts generally. Here's a quote you might enjoy tracking down. " Tax the rich and tax them heavily. " It dates from around the beginning of the First World War, and was said by neither a socialist or a liberal, but rather (at that time) one of the wealthiest peers in England and one of the wealthiest men in the world. If I recall correctly, his wife is credited with asking her head gardener around the same time (having lost 1/2 of their gardening staff to the English military draft), how he had managed to spread such a large assortment of beautiful leaves amidst the walking paths of their estate !

The people quoted may surprise you.

Tai Pan
 
What does any of that have to do with the fiscal multiplier you were claiming in the thread I questioned. You have yet to explain how the worth of a dollar in the public sector is twice what it is in the private sector.
Depends completely on what part of the public sector and what part of the private sector. Public sector FMs go from 0.28 (new weapons dev) to as high as 4.0 (child care subsidies for the working poor).

Private sector FMs are similar. BUT here's the key. Marginal Income FMs for Private Sector FALL OFF the higher the income rate. So while the FM for a tax cut to the middle class is about the same as extending unemployment bennefits (1.5-2.5 inversly proportional to the state of the economy) the FM for a tax cut to the UPPER QUINTILES is about the same as DoD spending.

FM for marginal income of the upper quintile is LESS THAN 0.7 (when Reagan cut top marginal rates from 70% to 50% - 30% of each dollar cut - disappeared from our GDP)
FM for infrastructure construction by Public sector is between 1.4 and 1.7. 1.5 is the average.


1.5 is about twice 0.7. That means PUBLIC SPENDING on infrastructure is TWICE AS EFFICIENT as the spending and investing by the wealthy. THAT'S JUST THE MEASUREMENTS.. so that's not a question of "faith".

As for explaining it? Its been explained 7 ways till sunday.

Its called the Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility. a staple of Econ 101. http://www.investopedia.com/terms/l/lawofdiminishingutility.asp As the example points out - its how All You can Eat restaurants work... the 3rd chocolate brownie does not generate the same level of pleasure as the first one. Similarly earning an extra $100 when you earn $20,000/yr is a big deal. You might even work an extra day of OT to do this. Earning $100 extra when you earn $200,000 is not a big deal. You might blow that much on a mediocre dinner and you would definately not give up your saturday to earn this.

That also applies to how carefully you will invest. If you earn $20k you are going to invest in a way that absolutely maximizes returns. If you earn $200k you just want a decent return since a few percent diff in ROI isn't going to change your retirement quality of life.

So that means that upper quintile folks will be LESS CAREFUL STEWARDS of their income than middle and lower quintiles. And hence fiscal multipliers on things that primarily benefit lower q 3/5ths of the popl (like unemployment, childcare, ) are going to have higher Fiscal Multipliers than things that benefit upper quintile earners like lower taxes on Capital Gains and Income.

Its quite simple.
 
i don't begrudge dave his success either. But he did it largely using information collected for him by The Government. hardly self-made.

As for MBAs etc.. there are always outliers as you know.. but I stand by my Teacher vs. MBA. Most MBA's I've worked with are blindered by their classwork. Works great for existing businesses, but not so good for startups.
 
My brother is an MBA high school teacher, you act as if we hadn't gone to school and don't know the inner workings. I don't disdain teachers, I disdain the rhetoric that you guys throw out there as if no one else has a difficult job.

You did disdain teachers. You said they required no more skill than secretaries. And thats very much disdaining them.

As for teachers starting companies - as you well know, starting a company basically requires you to make do with what you have and make lemonade out of lemons. That's basically what teachers do on a daily basis. Zero Safetynet? at the end of every school year that's what teachers face as well. As for gambling on your life savings? That's not a skill requirement, nor does that make a job "harder"... that's just a tolerance for risk.

Note also how you are generalizing about obesity from an invalidly small sample... and how you equate obesity with incompetence... bigotted much?


You're right, I don't like to work for others but I could and be damned good at it.
you may or may not be. But you likely would fail as a teacher.
 
I did compare bank tellers to teachers. Some tellers would be better some would not, some teacher shouldn't be teaching and they can't get fired. I heard that there is quite a number of New York City teachers who are not allowed in the class room due to various reasons but report for duty, do nothing and get a full salary. This morning in the Los Angeles area, LAUSD has provided a plan to test a teachers ability in order to make sure they are up to par.
You "heard" you "heard" you "heard".. how about bothering to investigate? hmm?

In NY they have enough subsitute teachers in the system that when ANY teacher gets accused of any sort of misconduct, they are IMMEDIATELY pulled from the class until the investigation completes. Like benching a police officer who has used a firearm in the line of duty. And the system is large enough - 75,000 teachers - that even if you had a 1% baddie rate, you wouold have 750 teachers per year, in such situations.

As for "a plan to test teachers ability"... well there are lots of "plans"... the question is whether it is a FAIR plan and an ACCURATE plan. Turns out Standardized testing SUCKS as such a plan.

Now as to teachers "can't get fired" WTF??? Of course they can get fired and often are. But the problem is that there simply are not enough teachers TO FILL THE JOBS, Why? Cuz the job sucks. It does not pay enough http://www.mckinseyonsociety.com/downloads/reports/Education/Closing_the_talent_gap.pdf all the while ignoramouses like you think it can be done by "secretaries" and "bank tellers".

Government is a catch 22, they do not have to be profitable but require money to operate. Rather than budget they raise taxes, this is the cause of inefficiency.
Hmm so then why are the fiscal multipliers for government in things like education BETTER THAN private sector?
 
cut tax collections, create tax policy that helps to out source jobs, lay off people, allow more deductions to the wealthy, give tax cuts that mainly go to the wealthy, and then cut programs that mainly go to those in need as a way to balance a budget because of a outcome of less income to the govt and too much cost.

You guys really understand on the right how to create and solve don't you?
 
Rothschild right?

Baron Lionel de Rothschild, of the English branch of the family, it was his wife who was wondering about the leaves. His brother Baron Walter had an estate, Tring, where he had the world's largest private zoo, sent a letter asking the War Office to determine if some exotic walnut or hickory trees were appropriate for use a pit props in the trenches. He lost his trees. Even then, the supra- rich lived totally different kinds of lives, having their own peculiar point of view. Anyway, I thought you would enjoy the taxation quotation. You might need it sometime.

Tai Pan
 
Baron Lionel de Rothschild, of the English branch of the family, it was his wife who was wondering about the leaves. His brother Baron Walter had an estate, Tring, where he had the world's largest private zoo, sent a letter asking the War Office to determine if some exotic walnut or hickory trees were appropriate for use a pit props in the trenches. He lost his trees. Even then, the supra- rich lived totally different kinds of lives, having their own peculiar point of view. Anyway, I thought you would enjoy the taxation quotation. You might need it sometime.

Tai Pan

Well the hard part of course is that conservatives dismiss anything european as "inapplicable because they are different" if it contradicts their views- of course all the while taking data out of context that serves them.

One of my current irritations with Trapdoor is his claim that France is "cutting back on its welfare state dramaticallY" and that in doing so it is facing riots. My partner is French. So we often watch the French news, discuss it as well as visiting. Furthermore her job has her tightly "hooked up" with the French and EU governments. And while it is true that France - like any nation - is continually tweaking and adjusting it policies in response to circumstances... it IS NOT massively cutting back on services. What France did do, was to extend the retirement age by 2-3 years. And initially it did so across the board.

And THAT was seen as unfair to Heavy industry and blue collar workers because it meant that not only did they have the roughest jobs and died sooner, but they also ended up working MORE YEARS than the others. So Sarkozy was forced into an ADJUSTMENT that raised the MEAN age by leveling YEARS WORKED as your retirment criteria.
 
Last night I said I wasn't going to reply to any more post in this thread, but buddy, you just opened you mouth and swallowed your ass. Since 1964 the Federal Government has had a Program called AMERICORPS-VISTA (Volunteers in Service to America. Part of that program allows mature adults to take a sabbatical from their usual career and devote a year to teaching in schools all across the country. Here's the web site: http://www.americorps.gov/about/programs/vista.asp So take off those $1000.00 Bruno Magli shoes, pack your suit case and get in a classroom.

Btw many thousands of teachers have their own small businesses, in real estate, insurance, auto repair and host of others, including restaurants, from fast food franchises to fine dining. Many contonue to teach will running these businesses. More succeed than you would even begin to believe.

So, man with a plan who can accomplish everything, put up or shut up. The ball is in your court. Do it and prove it, or stop talking nonsense.

taipan

I'll take you up on that. In two years I'm going to let others take over my role here. Now to be fair, this is not a one way street, either you or if you can find a teacher, get out and start a company. We will see what we will see.

These many thousands of teachers with small companies are who? How do you know these people? are they friends.
 
LeRoy: I would like to see a 'secretary' come to my school and teach the classes on Calculus II, Calculus III, Differential Equations, Number Theory, Advanced Microeconomics, and Current Events, that I am currently teaching.

I would find it deeply amusing to just take a day off and watch that.
 
Hmm Solyndra is expected.. it will happen in a recovery
Muslim Brotherhood is not being funded by the USA - it simply didn't happen
Bailing out Unions was a good thing
Foreign Car Cos? Well Fiat buying Chrysler saved us a LOT of money
healthcare reform scams? Such as?

And the racist comment about Obama's wife isn't worth responding to.
 
In a layoff, the company clearly is temporarily reducing capacity
No the same is true in a firing. Capacity goes down. but in a firing the temporary nature is usually shorter.

And no layoffs are not inherently temporary. When you disband a division, as in, get out of the business completely... its still a layoff.

And mostly what we've seen as a result of the stimulus was people returning to unfilled positions -- not a creation of new jobs
Sure it is. Without the stimulus those jobs don't exist. With it they do. IE with the stimulus a non-existant job is CREATED.

A company that has had two years of losses and then has six months of improved sales has not experienced growth.
over two years? no. Over six mos yes.

You are engaged in newspeak.

When you get called back from a layoff, your employer isn't growing.
Is the staffing larger than before you got called back?

Tell us do... what mathematical sign would you put into the place of the Question mark in the below equation
CompanyAStaffing[SUB]After Layoff, before hiring[/SUB] ? CompanyAStaffing[SUB]After_Layoff_After hiring

[/SUB]​
Lets see if you remember Middle School Math.
But the person who has spent $50 has not spent LESS Degs
That's the wrong question. The question is whether the person got THE SAME PRODUCT VALUE for Less or more or equal to Market Retail Price?

You are making a comparison across two different scopes of reference. like comparing Kilograms to meters. you cannot make the comparison validly. This is a fundamental problem many non-science types make with math. You don't understand how to properly define the scope of problems.
 
Well the hard part of course is that conservatives dismiss anything european as "inapplicable because they are different" if it contradicts their views- of course all the while taking data out of context that serves them.

One of my current irritations with Trapdoor is his claim that France is "cutting back on its welfare state dramaticallY" and that in doing so it is facing riots
.

If I had made either claim, then you'd have a valid irritation. I didn't claim France was cutting back its welfare state dramatically -- I said it was cutting back its nationalized health care system dramatically. The only French riots I'm aware of (outside the occasional dispute over places serving the Royale du Fromage beneath the golden arches, is the race riots after the two Afro-French kids electrocuted themselves a couple of years ago.

My partner is French. So we often watch the French news, discuss it as well as visiting. Furthermore her job has her tightly "hooked up" with the French and EU governments. And while it is true that France - like any nation - is continually tweaking and adjusting it policies in response to circumstances... it IS NOT massively cutting back on services. What France did do, was to extend the retirement age by 2-3 years. And initially it did so across the board.

You know, I'd actually forgotten the young people rioting in the streets over that. I guess it didn't happen.
 
Back
Top