New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Ryan solid, but one major mistake.

This is by David Frum about the debate and calling Ryan's lack of connecting with the middleclass a mistake and I think right on...

I had the odd experience of first listening to the debate (or rather the first hour of the debate) on the radio; then watching the debate over again on video.

On radio, Biden was … what's the word? … Oh yeah: terrible. Impatient and dismissive, punctuated by forced, faked little laughs and peevish demands for more airtime. Ryan's voice, by contrast, had a timbre of sincerity, even when he was being evasive, as for example when he sought to escape Martha Raddatz's demand for more specifics on how the Romney tax plan would work.

When he demanded that the "folks" trust him, he sounded a corny old pol.

But on TV, Biden seemed somehow much better: impassioned rather than impatient, aggressive rather than dismissive. Ryan's superior poise and courtesy - the sincere timbre of his voice that resonated so nicely on radio - seemed suddenly defensive and weak: the indicators of a competitor who doesn't want to take and hold the center of the arena.

On this second view, I was struck most by Biden's relentless hammering of the points most likely to resonate with voters: the auto rescue, withdrawal from Afghanistan by 2014, and the economic interests of the middle class.

And I was struck again by the GOP ticket's pronoun trouble. One of Ryan's most powerful set pieces was his explication of how the Obama-Biden team's plans to allow the Bush tax cuts to lapse would touch the middle class. It culminated thus:

And so the next time you hear them say, don't worry about it, we'll get a few wealthy people to pay their fair share, watch out, middle class. The tax bill is coming to you.

That's why we're saying we need fundamental tax reform.

"You" and "we" back-to-back. But who's the "you"? Who's the "we"?

Biden used the phrase "middle class" 24 times; Ryan only eight times. And although Biden may see the middle class fully as much from the outside as Ryan does, he did remember for the duration of the debate to draw a personal connection, not to speak of middle-class voters only as a vote-rich target group:

My friend says that 30 percent of the American people are takers. They — Romney points out, 47 percent of the people won't take responsibility. He's talking about my mother and father. And he's talking about the places I grew up in, my neighbors in Scranton and Claymont.

He's talking about — he's talking about the people that have built this country. All they're looking for, Martha — all they're looking for is an even shot. When they've been given the shot, they've done it. They've done it. Whenever you level the playing field, they've been able to move.

And they want a little bit of peace of mind. And the president and I are not going to rest until that playing field is leveled, they in fact have a clear shot and they have peace of mind, until they can turn to their kid and say with a degree of confidence, honey, it's going to be OK. It's going to be OK. That's what this is all about.​

A lot of phony-baloney there, no doubt. But also - a connection dangerously missing from a Ryan presentation that oftentimes seemed to speak from a position far above the concerns and struggles of the great American middle.

We want everybody to succeed. We want to get people out of poverty, in the middle class, on to lives of self-sufficiency. We believe in opportunity and upward mobility. That's what we're going to push for in a Romney administration.

A fine thought. But it would have been more finely expressed had the "we" in Ryan's mouth more often referred to the country, and less to a party or a political operation.


Link
 
Frum is a smart Republican, thrown under the bus with all the other smart Republicans when Tea Brigade put on their Goober hats and hit the scene came right after the black guy was elected. :)
 
Frum is a smart Republican, thrown under the bus with all the other smart Republicans when Tea Brigade put on their Goober hats and hit the scene came right after the black guy was elected. :)

Yep and now they're finding themselves thrown under the bus. heh heh
 
This is by David Frum about the debate and calling Ryan's lack of connecting with the middleclass a mistake and I think right on...

I had the odd experience of first listening to the debate (or rather the first hour of the debate) on the radio; then watching the debate over again on video.

On radio, Biden was … what's the word? … Oh yeah: terrible. Impatient and dismissive, punctuated by forced, faked little laughs and peevish demands for more airtime. Ryan's voice, by contrast, had a timbre of sincerity, even when he was being evasive, as for example when he sought to escape Martha Raddatz's demand for more specifics on how the Romney tax plan would work.

When he demanded that the "folks" trust him, he sounded a corny old pol.

But on TV, Biden seemed somehow much better: impassioned rather than impatient, aggressive rather than dismissive. Ryan's superior poise and courtesy - the sincere timbre of his voice that resonated so nicely on radio - seemed suddenly defensive and weak: the indicators of a competitor who doesn't want to take and hold the center of the arena.

On this second view, I was struck most by Biden's relentless hammering of the points most likely to resonate with voters: the auto rescue, withdrawal from Afghanistan by 2014, and the economic interests of the middle class.

And I was struck again by the GOP ticket's pronoun trouble. One of Ryan's most powerful set pieces was his explication of how the Obama-Biden team's plans to allow the Bush tax cuts to lapse would touch the middle class. It culminated thus:

And so the next time you hear them say, don't worry about it, we'll get a few wealthy people to pay their fair share, watch out, middle class. The tax bill is coming to you.

That's why we're saying we need fundamental tax reform.

"You" and "we" back-to-back. But who's the "you"? Who's the "we"?

Biden used the phrase "middle class" 24 times; Ryan only eight times. And although Biden may see the middle class fully as much from the outside as Ryan does, he did remember for the duration of the debate to draw a personal connection, not to speak of middle-class voters only as a vote-rich target group:

My friend says that 30 percent of the American people are takers. They — Romney points out, 47 percent of the people won't take responsibility. He's talking about my mother and father. And he's talking about the places I grew up in, my neighbors in Scranton and Claymont.

He's talking about — he's talking about the people that have built this country. All they're looking for, Martha — all they're looking for is an even shot. When they've been given the shot, they've done it. They've done it. Whenever you level the playing field, they've been able to move.

And they want a little bit of peace of mind. And the president and I are not going to rest until that playing field is leveled, they in fact have a clear shot and they have peace of mind, until they can turn to their kid and say with a degree of confidence, honey, it's going to be OK. It's going to be OK. That's what this is all about.​

A lot of phony-baloney there, no doubt. But also - a connection dangerously missing from a Ryan presentation that oftentimes seemed to speak from a position far above the concerns and struggles of the great American middle.

We want everybody to succeed. We want to get people out of poverty, in the middle class, on to lives of self-sufficiency. We believe in opportunity and upward mobility. That's what we're going to push for in a Romney administration.

A fine thought. But it would have been more finely expressed had the "we" in Ryan's mouth more often referred to the country, and less to a party or a political operation.


Link

Interesting......No mention of whether what any one of then said was based in truth, except to suggest Biden's comments were "phoney-baloney".

I do agree that there is a tendency for some people I know to refer to the "we" as their select grouping, not the "we" as in "all men are created equal" "we the people".
 
no doubt Bo. He could try some brain exercises too, because I don't see that his much ballyhooed workouts are that productive, and certainly don't benefit anything other than his undeserved ego.
 
Actually I think Ryan played to conservatives for his own future and threw Mitt under the bus. I do not think he is a numbers guy and do think he is a pretender. He can't relate to the middleclass anymore than Mitt can but his ideas for undermining are set in stone. Mitt is like a noodle and set on nothing. Two extreme opposites with the same damaging results
 
Actually I think Ryan played to conservatives for his own future and threw Mitt under the bus. I do not think he is a numbers guy and do think he is a pretender. He can't relate to the middleclass anymore than Mitt can but his ideas for undermining are set in stone. Mitt is like a noodle and set on nothing. Two extreme opposites with the same damaging results

Well said Min. That whole policy/numbers wonk thingy is vastly overrated. For both R & R, their "numbers" have always come from some Randian thing deep down in their guts but NEVER any specifics other than their abiding faith in rich people, who in their mind ALL create jobs.

As Bushie said.. fool me once --- ehh, (and then he F'd it up) but we'd better not get fooled a third time!!

Mitt is like a noodle and set on nothing? Damn girl, that's why they pay you the big bucks! :D
 
Frum is a big government elitist self appointed know it all. He's like the mirror image of Tom Friedman. There is so little distance between their relative positions that you almost can't fit a piece of paper between their relative ideologies, even though one is a "rightie" and one a "leftie." Really they are neither - they are metro-ideologues. It is no surprise that he doesn't like Ryan.
 
Frum is a big government elitist self appointed know it all. He's like the mirror image of Tom Friedman. There is so little distance between their relative positions that you almost can't fit a piece of paper between their relative ideologies, even though one is a "rightie" and one a "leftie." Really they are neither - they are metro-ideologues. It is no surprise that he doesn't like Ryan.

I rest my case. Oh how the mighty poster hath fallen since November of '08.

Are you one of the ones who threw WF Buckley under the bus as well?

a4.bp.blogspot.com__n7RltmTdk_g_S7XkMqcW3kI_AAAAAAAARko_jfCDyU96e06167f33fcd8c027f14f4a6bf7801.jpg
 
Ryan's voice on the Radio did not sound sincere. It sounded whiney. But maybe my hearing is a bit more sensitive having raised children
 
Yeah...

I thought of you when I read his article. He basically said just the opposite of what you did when listening to the debate on radio.

Ryan's voice on the Radio did not sound sincere. It sounded whiney. But maybe my hearing is a bit more sensitive having raised children
 
Interesting......No mention of whether what any one of then said was based in truth, except to suggest Biden's comments were "phoney-baloney".

I do agree that there is a tendency for some people I know to refer to the "we" as their select grouping, not the "we" as in "all men are created equal" "we the people".

I figured Frum was going to let the factcheckers deal with the truth of the matter. I liked that he picked out that Ryan does not connect with the middleclass which is exactly the same problem the Romneys have. Joe busted their chops on that one.
 
Actually I think Ryan played to conservatives for his own future and threw Mitt under the bus. I do not think he is a numbers guy and do think he is a pretender. He can't relate to the middleclass anymore than Mitt can but his ideas for undermining are set in stone. Mitt is like a noodle and set on nothing. Two extreme opposites with the same damaging results

I think you hit on it. Can you imagine how frustrating it must be to have to answer to all of Romney's flip flops and also being tied to them? I would imagine right about now Ryan's getting pretty tired of it.

Yep, they do not connect with the middleclass and neither do their policy positions and Obama and Biden will bust their chops on it everytime.
 
Well all I know is if we do small changes to SS like they did under Regan, it will be here for all time. If they go the other route and it doesn't work out we will return to a time prior to SS and much of the safety seniors now have could be gone. The big problem is once you change SS, once it doesn't work like it does now, it's over and those who retire are in trouble, those who have kids and die early are in trouble, spouses who don't work are in trouble.

SS is not close to bankruptcy, all it needs is small changes, not do away with it.

I know that I fought for a 401 k for years at my work. Many of us did really good, and retired with a good amount of money, but most didn't. 50% of the people didn't even join and will have only SS to retire on.

Second thing is what does Ryan/Romney want to do with younger workers, will they still get the matching funds that now go to SS from the company they work for? Or would you be on your own? I haven't heard.
 
Well all I know is if we do small changes to SS like they did under Regan, it will be here for all time. If they go the other route and it doesn't work out we will return to a time prior to SS and much of the safety seniors now have could be gone. The big problem is once you change SS, once it doesn't work like it does now, it's over and those who retire are in trouble, those who have kids and die early are in trouble, spouses who don't work are in trouble.

SS is not close to bankruptcy, all it needs is small changes, not do away with it.

I know that I fought for a 401 k for years at my work. Many of us did really good, and retired with a good amount of money, but most didn't. 50% of the people didn't even join and will have only SS to retire on.

Second thing is what does Ryan/Romney want to do with younger workers, will they still get the matching funds that now go to SS from the company they work for? Or would you be on your own? I haven't heard.

Like Biden said 'they've' been after Medicare and SS forever. I'm afraid no one has heard their plans and we probably wont either. They remind me so much of Bush...just elect me and then I'll tell you what I'm going to do. I hope the idiots who voted fore him are happy.
 
Back
Top