New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

School sentinels

Yep... "Normal" parents would pack a Glock in their kids' lunch boxes.

You know... Just to be on the safe side.

LOL, at my high school I'd estimate probably 5% of students were carrying guns, and at least 50% had knives. Nobody ever tried a mass shooting there....
 
You most likely are aware of the murder that occurred just down the road here in AA County the other day...a NJ cop killed a guy in a road rage incident. And the cop suicide a couple of weeks ago...where he shot himself while traveling on MD100.

Plenty of borderline instability in the police forces.



I don't disagree with that necessarily. However, the reality is we do let these people have guns, patrol the streets, etc. It really is no different to have them patrolling a school. But, we should do more to deal with and catch mentally unstable cops.
 
I don't disagree with that necessarily. However, the reality is we do let these people have guns, patrol the streets, etc. It really is no different to have them patrolling a school. But, we should do more to deal with and catch mentally unstable cops.

We run police applicants through batteries of psychological tests. Some crazy people get through regardless. Some undergo changes while in uniform; perhaps new feelings of power emerge, perhaps powerlessness emerges as society's negatives simply wear them down.

It is difficult to find the balance...and that is the goal. Folks will waver back and forth about the methods in which we try and protect not just our kids, but all of us.

There is, for example, a vid of Hannity on Huff Post...where he is railing against government collection of metadata today...but was in full bore hornblowing support in 2007.
 
Never let a good crisis go to waste. It wasn't us exploiting the victims of Sandyhook to support their globalist/communist agenda.

Of course the libbies didn't say "we want all your guns".

Nah. I don't want all your guns. I'll take all your money, though.

Maybe at gunpoint.
 
So, they shouldn't be allowed to protect themselves because it might cost the state some $? How much does a school shooting cost? Hell, just by publicizing the fact that the school is no longer a "gun free zone" you'll have eliminated most of the potential for a "mass shooting" right there, even if none of the staff take advantage and decide to carry.

Teachers aren't "allowed" to do all manner of things that the school district deems inappropriate.
 
Teachers aren't "allowed" to do all manner of things that the school district deems inappropriate.
Hey, I don't really give a shit, I don't have any kids or grandkids in school currently. But if those that do, want to remove some of the most effective deterrents to these types of incidents, then they shouldn't come back after something does happen and cry about it...
 
More states seeking to arm teachers..

http://schoolsofthought.blogs.cnn.c...tes-move-to-put-guns-in-classrooms/?hpt=hp_t1

Armed guards? maybe. But armed teachers? As the particle indicates..frought with risk

Armed guards are also problematic, just based on cost effectiveness. The thing to remember is that school shootings are incredibly rare. This is now dated, but the stats haven't changed appreciably since it was published:

http://www.prisonpolicy.org/scans/jpi/schoolhouse.pdf

The numbers change, from year to year, but the 40 killings that happened in school, in 1998, were the ballpark we're talking about -- 33 to 63 kids per year between 1992 and 2010. So, what would the cost/life saved be of putting paid armed guards in schools?

Answering that would require nailing down the details of what we're proposing. Are we talking about armed guards in all schools? Just in the high-risk schools? Would we put several guards per school, to get good coverage, or just one? Would they be well-trained, or just low-cost mall-cop types?

Just for a "back of the envelope" estimate, let's say we put an average of one armed guard per public school, at a fully-loaded (benefits included) cost of $50,000 each (about as cheap as you could expect to go if you want people who are more likely to stop shootings than to be involved in accidental shootings themselves), and that this results in cutting the school killing rate in half.... from, let's say, an average of 50 per year to an average of 25.

In that case, the cost-per-life saved would be $50,000*100,000(number of public schools)/25(lives saved). That works out to $200,000,000. Is $200 million a reasonable cost to save a life? No. There are COUNTLESS ways we could save far more lives for far less money.

For example, upgrading guard rails costs about $101,000 per life saved:

http://www.textfiles.com/survival/costja88
http://books.google.com/books?id=Ls...e&q="cost per life saved" guard rails&f=false

Building mobile ICUs in small towns isn't much more expensive than that. There are thousands of things we could spend money on that would be saving lives at a cost of $1 million per life or less. So, why would we blow vast amounts of money on armed school guards, when our kids would be vastly safer if we spent the same money fixing guardrail caps, reducing pollution, or any number of other interventions?

I get why the NRA would love this idea. It flows taxpayer dollars into the pockets of gun manufacturers who, in turn, flow money into the pockets of the NRA leadership. But why would any ordinary citizen think it was a good idea?
 
Armed guards are also problematic, just based on cost effectiveness. The thing to remember is that school shootings are incredibly rare. This is now dated, but the stats haven't changed appreciably since it was published:

http://www.prisonpolicy.org/scans/jpi/schoolhouse.pdf

The numbers change, from year to year, but the 40 killings that happened in school, in 1998, were the ballpark we're talking about -- 33 to 63 kids per year between 1992 and 2010. So, what would the cost/life saved be of putting paid armed guards in schools?

Answering that would require nailing down the details of what we're proposing. Are we talking about armed guards in all schools? Just in the high-risk schools? Would we put several guards per school, to get good coverage, or just one? Would they be well-trained, or just low-cost mall-cop types?

Just for a "back of the envelope" estimate, let's say we put an average of one armed guard per public school, at a fully-loaded (benefits included) cost of $50,000 each (about as cheap as you could expect to go if you want people who are more likely to stop shootings than to be involved in accidental shootings themselves), and that this results in cutting the school killing rate in half.... from, let's say, an average of 50 per year to an average of 25.

In that case, the cost-per-life saved would be $50,000*100,000(number of public schools)/25(lives saved). That works out to $200,000,000. Is $200 million a reasonable cost to save a life? No. There are COUNTLESS ways we could save far more lives for far less money.

For example, upgrading guard rails costs about $101,000 per life saved:

http://www.textfiles.com/survival/costja88
http://books.google.com/books?id=LsXmMHOT8VsC&pg=PA465&lpg=PA465&dq="cost per life saved" guard rails&source=bl&ots=uoTiSc3e33&sig=zpb3wIS7vXWe9ugfnspV_x-183A&hl=en&sa=X&ei=guK5UcevKY_k4APY6YC4Ag&ved=0CDYQ6AEwAQ#v=onepage&q="cost per life saved" guard rails&f=false

Building mobile ICUs in small towns isn't much more expensive than that. There are thousands of things we could spend money on that would be saving lives at a cost of $1 million per life or less. So, why would we blow vast amounts of money on armed school guards, when our kids would be vastly safer if we spent the same money fixing guardrail caps, reducing pollution, or any number of other interventions?

I get why the NRA would love this idea. It flows taxpayer dollars into the pockets of gun manufacturers who, in turn, flow money into the pockets of the NRA leadership. But why would any ordinary citizen think it was a good idea?


I'm not a fan of the "armed guard" idea, (for many of the reasons you pointed out); I think it's easier to just allow school staff who wish to carry, and who take it upon themselves to obtain a permit and the necessary training, to do so. It's cheap, it's easy, (requires nothing on the part of the school), and it's available right now.
 
I'm not a fan of the "armed guard" idea, (for many of the reasons you pointed out); I think it's easier to just allow school staff who wish to carry, and who take it upon themselves to obtain a permit and the necessary training, to do so. It's cheap, it's easy, (requires nothing on the part of the school), and it's available right now.

Put it up for a vote. See what happens. Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean that everyone else isn't. You could be a member of the majority.
 
ooooooh....so you're a telepath?

The proper term is "empath", and my Dad the big lib that voted for Obama is the only one who made that claim openly.

I've spent more than enough time on the West Coast to be exposed to the full spectrum of liberalism to know what you are all about.

And it's not like there isn't Democrats down here, though most of them aren't coo koo like they are in other parts of the country.


But, make no mistake there are a handful of outspoken liberal mouth pieces who are pretty up front with their anti gun zealotry. And more often than not these people have carry permits and multiple armed guards with them when they are in public.


Internet Shill just happens to be one of the most liberal people around.
 
A
I get why the NRA would love this idea. It flows taxpayer dollars into the pockets of gun manufacturers who, in turn, flow money into the pockets of the NRA leadership. But why would any ordinary citizen think it was a good idea?

What a "coincidence", huh? :)
 
The proper term is "empath",....

No.... While a "telepath" would be someone with the ability to determine distinct thoughts like "I want to take everybody's gun away"...an "empath" would be someone psychically gifted with the ability to read emotional states like "I'm angry"...like you are most of the time.

:)
 
No.... While a "telepath" would be someone with the ability to determine distinct thoughts like "I want to take everybody's gun away"...an "empath" would be someone psychically gifted with the ability to read emotional states like "I'm angry"...like you are most of the time.

:)

I don't know that Wookie is so much 'angry' all the time, as suffering from a severe case of future shock.
 
No.... While a "telepath" would be someone with the ability to determine distinct thoughts like "I want to take everybody's gun away"...an "empath" would be someone psychically gifted with the ability to read emotional states like "I'm angry"...like you are most of the time.

You are asking me whether I'm a telepath or an empath trying to be a wise guy like always???? The fact of the matter, I can meet you in person and see how much juice you got, what you are about.

With you, I don't need to.


I've known you for oh 7 or 8 years at least.
 
I don't know that Wookie is so much 'angry' all the time, as suffering from a severe case of future shock.

Shouldn't people be shocked that the Democrat party pays poor people to have babies out of wedlock, buys votes with food stamps and promises of citizenship just to name a few????????
 
Back
Top