New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Secession

what about the california initiative to break the state up into smaller ones, so that people with jobs and farms won't have to pay outrageous taxes to subsidize welfare and illegal aliens clustered in urban areas?

As I mentioned above, that is a well-documented and widely publicized debate that's been going on for a while. My county would be one of the ones seceding from the southern part of the state. The main goal as you say is for more rural counties to have equal representation in the state government affairs. Currently, rural counties needs are generally not considered, except when they need our water or other natural resources.
 
Most people certainly do not think the matter through when there is mention nade of leaving the Federal Union. It can and does do more things on a larger scale and in a more definitive way than a fractured Union could possibly do.

However your characterization of the Blue states as good living is a bit skewed.
There's plenty of subsidized poverty in Mass, New York, Connecticut and so on.
Just because that's where most of the nation's CEO's make their corporate office is no reason to ignore the real living situation in those places and it is indeed dismal for the average blue collar family and getting worse. The North East specifically is saddled with the unsustainable growth of pension liablity. It is bankrupting one commuinty after another.

Additionally I think you vastly underestimate the self sufficieny of Southern communities. You may not be able to examine a carpenter's skills on the Wall Street index...but free from Federal Persecution, taxation and regulation I submit to you that the South would flourish much more quickly per capita that would the north.

JO
I certainly don't mean to suggest there's no poverty in the Northeast. There is. But there is much less poverty than in the country as a whole. In the US as a whole, the poverty rate by household income is 12.6%. New York is the only state in the Northeast that has it worse (14.5%), and much of the Northeast is among the lowest-poverty states. NH has the lowest, NJ has the second-lowest, VT has the third lowest, CT the 10th, MA the 14th, PA the 21st, etc. The highest-poverty states (in order) are MS, LA, NM, AL, TX, AK, OK, WV, AZ, TN, SC, and KY, and the only one of those that might not go with a hypothetical conservative-state secession would be NM.

And it's not just the official poverty rates that indicate better quality of life in the Northeast. Secondary indicators that tend to be affected by poverty also tend to be better in the Northeast, like academic performance (e.g., NAEP test scores), crime, teen pregnancy, infant mortality, and life expectancy. And gross state product per capita, and median household income tend to be higher there, too. I suspect that if they were freed of the burden of subsidizing places like the Deep South, and freed from the political obstructions those other areas represent against higher social spending regionally, they'd be doing even better.

As for the self-sufficiency of the South, it sure doesn't show up in the stats, given the many tens of billions of dollars of federal subsidization -- places like the Northeast pay higher federal taxes than they get back in federal spending, so that places like the South can benefit from higher federal spending than they pay in federal taxes. Some of that is because Southerners pay unusually low effective federal tax rates (mostly because they're poorer, on average, and thus pay at lower rates, but also because of tax favoritism for rural areas, in the area of preferential tax treatment for farms). And some is because of disproportionate federal spending in the South (extra welfare because they're poorer, farm subsidies, a disproportionate share of military bases and defense contractors, disproportionate federal assistance for natural disasters, etc.)

It's conceivable a couple places in the South could be better off after secession. Texas, for example, although it's a poverty-plagued sewer of social problems, does pay more in federal taxes than it gets in benefits, and it has a high GDP per capita. But, if it broke away together with the rest of the South, it would have to decide whether to continue the kinds of subsidies of those poorer states that the federal government used to handle, or to pocket that money. Given the states-rights mentality in Texas, I'd assume they'd be no more excited about sending money to Atlanta (or wherever the capital of this neo-confederacy was) than they were about sending money to Washington. That would be a hell of a blow for most of the Deep South, suddenly to have "self sufficiency" go from a point of false pride to something actually expected of them.
 
As was the case in the 19th century, talk of secession normally comes from southern, rural, conservative whites:

http://www.salon.com/2014/07/01/chr...confederate_talk_grows_louder_at_the_fringes/

I've always found that odd, since if there was a secession, along red-state/blue-state lines, it seems almost certain it would turn out better for the blue states.

As most people know, red-states are much more likely to be net federal tax dollar leeches than blue states. The federal budget represents a net subsidy of "Red America" by "Blue America," and if that flow of funds were halted, it would mean a windfall for Blue America and sudden hardship for Red America. Using 2012 presidential election outcomes to designate "red state" and "blue state,' "Red America" collectively received $165.792 billion more in federal expenditures than it pays in federal taxes, using the most recent budget data available (2005). "Blue America" received $74.191 billion LESS in federal expenditures than it pays in taxes:

http://taxfoundation.org/article/federal-taxes-paid-vs-federal-spending-received-state-1981-2005

Yet, even without considering the impact of ending that leeching by the red states from the blue states, Blue America would be markedly better off than Red America following a secession. First, Blue America would be much larger (about 200 million citizens vs. 115.5 million), with an economy over twice as large. And it would be much richer. Median household income of Blue America would be 16% higher than for Red America. If you then account for the ending of net flows of federal funds from blue to red states, Blue America would be roughly one-quarter ahead of red (I'd need a precise household count by state to do that calculation).

It's not just that Blue America would be richer, either. It would also be better off sociologically, in terms of less crime, lower teen pregnancy, lower obesity, higher life expectancies, lower infant mortality, better academic test scores, and so on. For example, the weighted average murder rate for Blue America is 4.4, versus 5.3 for Red America, meaning someone in Red America would be about 20% more likely to be murdered than someone in Blue America. Blue America would also have the headquarters of the vast majority of Fortune 500 companies, most of the elite universities in the country, most of the elite cultural offerings (the best museums, ballets, symphonies, etc.), and even a disproportionate share of the best sports franchises, as well as being the location of most movie and TV studios.

If secession were to happen along red-state/blue-state lines, the resulting Blue America would remain an economic and cultural powerhouse, while climbing up the international rankings when it came to socioeconomic well-being of its citizens. Red America, by comparison, would fall to an international prominence somewhere between Japan and Mexico, while sliding still farther in most international rankings. It's odd that secession talk isn't more popular on the left, and less so on the right.

RACIST POST

enjoy eating grass.................
 
I don't see such an amendment as a possibility because of the reasons you mentioned.

Random thought: Texas has 1,254 miles of the 1,954 miles of border with Mexico. That would massively alter the task of the US Border Control.

In re: secession, I do see a regular confusion between states dividing into new states and states leaving the union. Nearly all of the states have regional divisions that keep talk of dividing alive. North Jersey, South Jersey. California. Washington. Oregon. Maryland's Eastern Shore and western counties both speak of it regularly, but in these instances, they wish to stay in the USA.
The border control problem would get better for a time, for the US, since so much would be the job of Texas. But if the Texan petrostate failed badly enough that Texan residents started crossing north, illegally, in search of a brighter future for their families, there could be an even tougher border-control problem.

California should definitely be broken up. Thanks to the idiocy of our Constitutional voting framework, their sheer size deprives them of a massive portion of their rightful voting power in the presidential and Senate elections. Reducing the state to something closer to the median state's population would diminish that injustice. They should probably be divided into six or seven states.
 
what about the california initiative to break the state up into smaller ones, so that people with jobs and farms won't have to pay outrageous taxes to subsidize welfare and illegal aliens clustered in urban areas?
I'd like to see California broken down into more manageable states. Currently, the small states have vastly disproportionate voting power relative to the large ones -- which is part of the reason the red states (which include more smaller-population states) get so much pork barrel spending. On a per-resident basis, they simply wield way too much political power. Breaking California down so they has twelve or fourteen senators, instead of two, and a lot more electoral college votes would help to change that.
 
...we'd survive just fine and that's a fact, Jack.

GOT WATER
appears ya'll having trouble surviving today........."water fetching record prices, in the last five years alone, the price has grown tenfold to as much as $2,200 an acre-foot"..........
As I said I lived in Monterey in the 70's during a drought..........are they playing the ads on the radio "if it's yellow let it mellow if it's brown flush it down"..........now?

40 years later still in a drought, worse than back then evidently.......guess keeping up illegals and dead-beats taking the $$$$$$ to solve this problem..........turning pacfic ocean water into drinkable water!
 
You would survive on what? Where would you get your fuel from? Where would your revenue come from to support your welfare system?Most of the blue states are in cold regions So how would you feed yourself?

especially with the DROUGHT...........water cost is tenfold in past 5 yrs..........
 
The Military Bases belong to The United States, not to Texas.

Regardless, there is no mechanism for secession from the US.

You guys all love the Pledge right? Indivisible...is what you pledge to.

wasn't WE Pledge lovers that posted this BS...............
 
Most people certainly do not think the matter through when there is mention nade of leaving the Federal Union. It can and does do more things on a larger scale and in a more definitive way than a fractured Union could possibly do.

However your characterization of the Blue states as good living is a bit skewed.
There's plenty of subsidized poverty in Mass, New York, Connecticut and so on.
Just because that's where most of the nation's CEO's make their corporate office is no reason to ignore the real living situation in those places and it is indeed dismal for the average blue collar family and getting worse. The North East specifically is saddled with the unsustainable growth of pension liablity. It is bankrupting one commuinty after another.

Additionally I think you vastly underestimate the self sufficieny of Southern communities. You may not be able to examine a carpenter's skills on the Wall Street index...but free from Federal Persecution, taxation and regulation I submit to you that the South would flourish much more quickly per capita that would the north.

JO

I can always double/triple the size of my garden.............breed more live-stock....hunt more...........2 springs produce water 24/7/365........

A Country Boy Can Survive
 
...dawg, since you have lived here they have invested in infrastructure and storage. One cannot force nature to make it rain. Desalination is very expensive and not the entire answer.

GOT WATER
appears ya'll having trouble surviving today........."water fetching record prices, in the last five years alone, the price has grown tenfold to as much as $2,200 an acre-foot"..........
As I said I lived in Monterey in the 70's during a drought..........are they playing the ads on the radio "if it's yellow let it mellow if it's brown flush it down"..........now?

40 years later still in a drought, worse than back then evidently.......guess keeping up illegals and dead-beats taking the $$$$$$ to solve this problem..........turning pacfic ocean water into drinkable water!
 
...dawg, since you have lived here they have invested in infrastructure and storage. One cannot force nature to make it rain. Desalination is very expensive and not the entire answer.

evidently not enough storage..............I'm aware we can't make it rain.........not having water appears to very expensive and deadly as well...........
wish I could have the tropical storm we've having this week....rain is surely something we don't need more of rite now.........
I'll try head it ya'lls way................

http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory/dry-california-water-fetching-record-prices-24384513

didn't know if you had seen that..................
 
The Military Bases belong to The United States, not to Texas.

Regardless, there is no mechanism for secession from the US.

You guys all love the Pledge right? Indivisible...is what you pledge to.

The pledge is a nice symbol of unity, but then again, secession IS a possibility when the federal government becomes too powerful, as it clearly is today.

There's a huge difference in viewing the USA as a bunch of states who decided to join a union vs. just one country. I prefer the former, and the federal government must earn a state's unity. Nowadays, there's an incredibly sinister blackmail set up against all states. Texas is probably the only state that has the resources and infastructure to pull it off.
 
Texas would do OK for a while, while oil supplies are OK and oil prices are high. But it sure wouldn't be a place I'd want to live after secession. Economies built around oil tend to favor tyrannical governments and huge gaps in wealth.
That's all fine and good. Of course, there's no way to predict exactly what would happen. I'll say this, I'd give Texas a good look if they seceded. The Federal government of America could use a good kick in the ass.
Also, the national unemployment rate isn't 7.9%. It's 6.3%.

Sure it is ;)

Time to be honest. Look at the U6 unemployment rate.

The U6 unemployment rate counts not only people without work seeking full-time employment (the more familiar U-3 rate), but also counts "marginally attached workers and those working part-time for economic reasons." Note that some of these part-time workers counted as employed by U-3 could be working as little as an hour a week. And the "marginally attached workers" include those who have gotten discouraged and stopped looking, but still want to work. The age considered for this calculation is 16 years and over


The current true unemployment rate is 12.2%

Obama just chooses not to acknowledge people who are hurt by the poor working economy for better numbers to spout. Nothing more.
 
The pledge is a nice symbol of unity, but then again, secession IS a possibility when the federal government becomes too powerful, as it clearly is today.

There's a huge difference in viewing the USA as a bunch of states who decided to join a union vs. just one country. I prefer the former, and the federal government must earn a state's unity. Nowadays, there's an incredibly sinister blackmail set up against all states. Texas is probably the only state that has the resources and infastructure to pull it off.


There is no mechanism for secession from the Union.

I mention the Pledge because of the obvious consideration; many still make this pledge, daily. It says...one nation, indivisible. Need I point out the meaning of indivisible?

I don't care how you prefer to see the nation. It is The UNITED States...and the states pledged their unity upon joining the union. We are just one country, no matter how you prefer to look at it.
 
- LMAO - we're supporting all these deadbeat red states now -
Actually you have the debt that is now and the debt of the future. Without any support from us. So I ask again how will you continue to pay for those welfare plans? Those on welfare now will be migrating to where you are.
 
There is no mechanism for secession from the Union.
Yes there is:

Texas vs. White made secession "illegal", however:

If the Constitution is no longer in force—the States have separated and resumed their independent status—then the Supreme Court would not have jurisdiction and therefore could not determine the “legality” of the move.


The “Pledge of Allegiance” analogy?

The modern pledge was written by Francis Bellamy, a socialist minister reacting emotionally to the Civil War with a nationalist message, one based on the “great speeches” of Daniel Webster and Abraham Lincoln in relation to the “One Nation which the Civil War was fought to prove.” Sprinkle in some “liberty and justice” from the French Revolution and you have a message that any good leftist nationalist can embrace. The founding generation would not have said such a pledge, if for no other reason that most did not view the United States as a “nation” in the strict sense of the word, a single people.

Even more interesting:

In the Texas v. White decision, Chase implicitly reasoned that the Union was an “indissoluble” contract between the “American people” and the federal government, or in this case the people of Texas and the federal government. All contracts are intended to be perpetual. But if this were the case, how could nine States ratify a new Constitution while four States remained part of another Union in clear violation of the language of the Articles of Confederation. Changes to the Articles required the consent of all thirteen States, not nine, and thus the Constitution can be viewed, in part, as an act of secession.

James Madison argued that the Union was a different type of contract. “We are not to consider the Federal Union as analogous to the social compact of individuals: for if it were so, a majority would have a right to bind the rest, and even to form a new constitution for the whole… .”

The Constitution was framed by the unanimous consent of the States present in convention assembled in Philadelphia, but it had no teeth until the States, in convention, ratified it. Even at that point, Madison suggested, the States could not bind the rest into accepting the document or remaining in the Union. The Constitution does not have a coercive principle, as Ellsworth called it. An “indissoluble” Union would suggest that it does.


The Civil War?

Waging war “against them (the States)” is an act of treason, and as per the Constitution, a State can only be “protected” by the central government on the application of the legislature or the executive in the case of invasion. Lincoln violated both constitutional safeguards against coercion by the central government in 1861, of course only if the states remained in the Union, as he insisted they did. If not, war required a declaration from Congress, something Lincoln did not have, and by declaring war, Congress would have recognized the Confederate States as a legitimate government. Either way, Lincoln violated the Constitution, thus rendering the “bloody nose” argument against secession void.

Neither the Framers nor the ratifiers believed that the Constitution created a “consolidated nation” as Story suggested. It was argued in all state ratifying conventions that the opposite was true. The Union was made “more perfect” but never consolidated. The States still had all powers not delegated to the general government, as the Tenth Amendment to the Constitution clearly illustrates, and every State proposed a “Tenth Amendment” in their suggested bill of rights in the months after ratification.


We are just one country, no matter how you prefer to look at it.

Actually, we aren't... Any argument saying we are indivisible miserably fails any test of logic.
 
Back
Top