New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Secession

It certainly can be.

The pledge is a nice ideal for America, but has nothing to do with what we're talking about.

Meanwhile, other things that you and Craig ignored:

1. The Constitution itself was a seccession from the Articles of Confederation.
2. It was the states who finally ratified it, but it was understood that the Federal Gov't could not bind the rest into accepting the document or remaining in the Union.
3. Lincoln acted entirely outside of the Constitution.
4. As far as The Constitution The Union was made “more perfect” but never consolidated. It was never proposed as a binding, unbreakable federation.
 
I asked that question as well. Craig seems to think we view the pledge as some sort of sacrosanct oath of fealty (like the one he took to Obama). Odd...


No...Craig thinks Texans who recite the pledge are hypocrites. Craig thinks anyone who makes noise about the pledge, or about how one places their hand or any such matter and then seeks to leave the nation, is a hypocrite


I mention the Pledge because of the obvious consideration; many still make this pledge, daily. It says...one nation, indivisible. Need I point out the meaning of indivisible?
 
I mention the Pledge because of the obvious consideration; many still make this pledge, daily. It says...one nation, indivisible. Need I point out the meaning of indivisible?

Are you talking about school children? What adults make the pledge of allegiance daily? Do you?
 
You're holding quite a bit of weight in it.

I think you have me confused with a Neocon. or Bible Belt southerner.

I explained why I mentioned the pledge. I made no mention of legal considerations. I was speaking to individuals who recite it, then ignore it. I've explained that to you a number of times, yet you don't seem to grasp the idea.
 
No...Craig thinks Texans who recite the pledge are hypocrites. Craig thinks anyone who makes noise about the pledge, or about how one places their hand or any such matter and then seeks to leave the nation, is a hypocrite


I mention the Pledge because of the obvious consideration; many still make this pledge, daily. It says...one nation, indivisible. Need I point out the meaning of indivisible?

And marriages talk about being together forever.. yet, we have a 60% divorce rate.

Craig, this is entirely a red herring.

Of course, if all sides act in good faith, it would be indivisible. Both sides want the contract to work.

However, when the Federal Government bullies, intimidates, and blackmails the states.. they have the right to stand up for themselves and renegoatiate the terms.

The moment they secede, the constitutionality of it goes out the window, so making it illegal is pointless.
 
Are you talking about school children? What adults make the pledge of allegiance daily? Do you?

I'm talking about anyone that says it by their own volition.

Why are you so focused on pledge? Has the idea of secession been entirely removed from the discussion?
 
And marriages talk about being together forever.. yet, we have a 60% divorce rate.

Craig, this is entirely a red herring.

Of course, if all sides act in good faith, it would be indivisible. Both sides want the contract to work.

However, when the Federal Government bullies, intimidates, and blackmails the states.. they have the right to stand up for themselves and renegoatiate the terms.

The moment they secede, the constitutionality of it goes out the window, so making it illegal is pointless.

It was mere discussion for christsakes...You guys needed to make a federal case about it.
 
I'm talking about anyone that says it by their own volition.

Why are you so focused on pledge? Has the idea of secession been entirely removed from the discussion?

I'm asking you a question about something you posted. Regarding secession, the pledge has nothing to do with it, but you felt the need to bring it into the discussion. I only want to know why.

Secession itself would be a constitutional matter which, I expect, would ultimately be adjudicated by the Supreme Court, unless that entity becomes invalid or disbanded for some reason...
 
I'm asking you a question about something you posted. Regarding secession, the pledge has nothing to do with it, but you felt the need to bring it into the discussion. I only want to know why.

Secession itself would be a constitutional matter which, I expect, would ultimately be adjudicated by the Supreme Court, unless that entity becomes invalid or disbanded for some reason...

Had you read the thread, you would have known my point.

I brought it up...again...because you uber patriots demand politicians recite it. Demand children learn it. Get your panties wadded up if someone doesn't hold their hand over their heart...and in that pledge that you all take seriously as a sign of one's patriotism...it states....indivisible. Secession negates indivisibility. Arguing for secession while pledging indivisibility is not patriotic. It is hypocritical.

Is it really that difficult a concept that you need to have it explained to you?
 
Come on, are you really that dishonest? No complexity?

I'm fine with using U6, provided we don't then compared it to U3 in another area or time. But calling U6 "true unemployment" is misleading, when it includes a huge number of inarguably employed people. Maybe something like "true measure of labor market strength."

Anyway, the improvement in the U6 has been one of the more dramatic things about Obama's time in office. The US got as high as 17.1 during 2009, and now has dropped to 12.2. That nearly five-point drop is pretty amazing. And even if we measure against the end of 2008, there's been a big drop -- a significantly larger point drop than with the U3. By comparison, Obama's predecessor presided over a mind-blowing 6.7-point rise in the U6.

Plus, Texas would probably have new, more effective ways of dealing with some of these problems. Necessity breeds invention.....

I think you're partly right, though I view it differently. I think that Texas and the other conservative states are currently in a position where they can blame their problems on the liberals, while doing nothing about them, and ignoring the fact that the states and countries that are actually run by liberals are outperforming them in most socioeconomic measures. If Texas and the other conservative states were left to their own devices, they could try out every half-baked conservative solution they wanted, and find out why those solutions had long ago been abandoned for liberal alternatives. Deprived of the ability to blame the liberals for keeping them from relapsing into the failures of the past, they'd be forced to start thinking honestly about their troubles. And that would result in them trying out rational solutions, rather than just whining ineffectualy the way they usually do. They'd gradually learn that the liberal states and countries were outperforming them for a reason, and they'd learn to emulate those successes.

But let me say, for someone who I assume would lamblast a founding father supporter who would suggest the Native Americans were primitive and savage.. you sure hold some disdain for the South. What's up with that?

That's an odd form of argument: you simply assume something about me and then ask me about something else. I don't get it.
 
Had you read the thread, you would have known my point.

I brought it up...again...because you uber patriots demand politicians recite it. Demand children learn it. Get your panties wadded up if someone doesn't hold their hand over their heart...and in that pledge that you all take seriously as a sign of one's patriotism...it states....indivisible. Secession negates indivisibility. Arguing for secession while pledging indivisibility is not patriotic. It is hypocritical.

Is it really that difficult a concept that you need to have it explained to you?

When have I demanded any of these things? Can you point me to anyone specifically who recites the pledge regularly and advocates for secession?
 
Wow, it almost sounds like Texas has a problem with large numbers of poorly educated, poorly employed people from places where lifestyle, diet and income contribute to poor health. I wonder what could be going on...what might you be missing? Hmmm...
Please, explain it to me. Innuendo isn't argument.
 
When have I demanded any of these things? Can you point me to anyone specifically who recites the pledge regularly and advocates for secession?

Tell ya what...I'll cite a few names for this important concern as soon as you can locate my oath of fealty...
 
I'm fine with using U6, provided we don't then compared it to U3 in another area or time. But calling U6 "true unemployment" is misleading, when it includes a huge number of inarguably employed people. Maybe something like "true measure of labor market strength."

Anyway, the improvement in the U6 has been one of the more dramatic things about Obama's time in office. The US got as high as 17.1 during 2009, and now has dropped to 12.2. That nearly five-point drop is pretty amazing. And even if we measure against the end of 2008, there's been a big drop -- a significantly larger point drop than with the U3. By comparison, Obama's predecessor presided over a mind-blowing 6.7-point rise in the U6.
I assumed that you had to bring an Obama/Bush comparison in the mix, even though this thread had nothing to do with either. You're a true David Axelrod. I'm happy the U6 has improved, but compared to what we were in, it would be tough to get much worse.

I don't defend Bush, I didn't vote for him, but there WAS a huge market crash and housing bubble that occurred under him. The housing bubble was certainly not 100% his fault, it had been building up for a decade, ask Ron Paul about that. Clinton's ä house for every American" push was quite the catalyst for what happened next. They are both equally to blame.

Or wait, don't tell me Bush has to own all of it because he was President... is it not fair to blame past presidents when they obviously deserve it?

I think you're partly right, though I view it differently. I think that Texas and the other conservative states are currently in a position where they can blame their problems on the liberals, while doing nothing about them, and ignoring the fact that the states and countries that are actually run by liberals are outperforming them in most socioeconomic measures. If Texas and the other conservative states were left to their own devices, they could try out every half-baked conservative solution they wanted, and find out why those solutions had long ago been abandoned for liberal alternatives. Deprived of the ability to blame the liberals for keeping them from relapsing into the failures of the past, they'd be forced to start thinking honestly about their troubles. And that would result in them trying out rational solutions, rather than just whining ineffectualy the way they usually do. They'd gradually learn that the liberal states and countries were outperforming them for a reason, and they'd learn to emulate those successes.
Yet, major liberal strongholds across the nation are in horrible shape. We could probably criss cross on knit picking which areas each are short on. The fact is, a conservative-run state would demand more from individuals, so much of the riff raff would leave overnight.

You make vague claims about how conservative ideals would fail, but don't name any. How are balanced budgets, a non-comfy unemployment chair, "Do It Yourself" attitude, less bureaucracy to cut inefficiency and wastefulness, less reliant on government mindset.. How is that all a bad thing?


That's an odd form of argument: you simply assume something about me and then ask me about something else. I don't get it.

Correct me if I'm wrong then, please.

Were the Native Americans savages? Or would it be shocking/bigoted to hear a European say such a thing when they got there?
 
...fine, it will cut the overhead we now have - so when are you leaving? Don't let the proverbial screen door hit you in the a$$ on the way out.

Actually you have the debt that is now and the debt of the future. Without any support from us. So I ask again how will you continue to pay for those welfare plans? Those on welfare now will be migrating to where you are.
 
...fine, it will cut the overhead we now have - so when are you leaving? Don't let the proverbial screen door hit you in the a$$ on the way out.

Either that, or the Federal Government could actually act honorable.

But we wouldn't want that, would we.. especially when a Democrat is in power...
 
Back
Top