New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Secession

...fine, it will cut the overhead we now have - so when are you leaving? Don't let the proverbial screen door hit you in the a$$ on the way out.
You'll still have the debt with the lose of revenue, and next you'll have an influx of people wanting their welfare. Same thing would have happen to the federal government during the last civil war.the northern states would not have been able to sustain the fed alone.
 
The pledge is a nice ideal for America, but has nothing to do with what we're talking about

You claimed a pledge cannot be legally binding, and I proved you wrong.

Meanwhile, other things that you and Craig ignored:

1. The Constitution itself was a seccession from the Articles of Confederation.

And the Articles of Confederation were a secession from England. Apparently, a secession can be legal or illegal much as a pledge can be legally binding or not. In short, secession can be legally agreed upon, and if it is not legally agreed upon, the knives come out.

Is that what you want, another civil war? I am asking that because I doubt the country will agree to letting Texas secede, and its only other avenue would be war.

2. It was the states who finally ratified it, but it was understood that the Federal Gov't could not bind the rest into accepting the document or remaining in the Union.

The minute our Constitution was ratified, it was legal, and it bound all our states and all our people to our Constitution.

3. Lincoln acted entirely outside of the Constitution.

The hell.

4. As far as The Constitution The Union was made “more perfect” but never consolidated. It was never proposed as a binding, unbreakable federation.

Our Constitution can be amended, and that's what it would take for a state to legally secede. Of course, Texas and the rest of the South can declare war on the US, but I'm confident you'd lose again.
 
You claimed a pledge cannot be legally binding, and I proved you wrong.
I said "The pledge of allegiance" isn't legally binding. It isn't.
And the Articles of Confederation were a secession from England. Apparently, a secession can be legal or illegal much as a pledge can be legally binding or not. In short, secession can be legally agreed upon, and if it is not legally agreed upon, the knives come out.
If America can secede from England, why can't Texas secede from America? Seems kinda funky logic.

Is that what you want, another civil war? I am asking that because I doubt the country will agree to letting Texas secede, and its only other avenue would be war.
I don't want another civil war.

I will always say that the threat of secession is absolutely healthy for the federal government to check themselves. States and the Fed are heavily intertwined thanks to the dominant fed and it's ravaging of state power.. but one with enough muster would be Texas. Without that threat and consideration, the abuse will continue until state lines won't even be needed, and we'll not be "United States" whatsoever. We'll just be "America", and that's not what the founders thought was healthy. Taking human nature into account, it would quickly become monarchal in nature..

The minute our Constitution was ratified, it was legal, and it bound all our states and all our people to our Constitution.
Well then the minute Texas ratifies their Constitution, IT will become legal.

The hell.
Lincoln declared war without approval from Congress. Just stating a fact.

Our Constitution can be amended, and that's what it would take for a state to legally secede. Of course, Texas and the rest of the South can declare war on the US, but I'm confident you'd lose again.

No, it would be America who would be declaring war on Texas.
 
I said "The pledge of allegiance" isn't legally binding. It isn't.

Fair enough.

If America can secede from England, why can't Texas secede from America? Seems kinda funky logic.

I am saying Texas can secede, but to do so legally would require an amendment to our Constitution. To secede without legal justification would mean bloodshed.

I hope that clears your funky logic up some.

I don't want another civil war.

I will always say that the threat of secession is absolutely healthy for the federal government to check themselves. States and the Fed are heavily intertwined thanks to the dominant fed and it's ravaging of state power.. but one with enough muster would be Texas. Without that threat and consideration, the abuse will continue until state lines won't even be needed, and we'll not be "United States" whatsoever. We'll just be "America", and that's not what the founders thought was healthy. Taking human nature into account, it would quickly become monarchal in nature..

Actually, it is unhealthy to espouse secession, and the earlier attempt led to a great loss of life. Of course, if you and your compatriots manage to change our Constitution and allow Texas to secede, I'd wish you luck and possibly treat with the Mexicans. I'm sure Mexico wouldn't mind getting Texas back.

Well then the minute Texas ratifies their Constitution, IT will become legal.

Not a chance.

Lincoln declared war without approval from Congress. Just stating a fact.

Lincoln waited until the South declared war. Just stating a fact.

No, it would be America who would be declaring war on Texas.

Hopefully, we wouldn't wait this time, so I agree with you in principle.

This time, after the war is over, I expect the rebels, traitors or whatever you want to call them, will be treated like the treasonous bastards they are unlike last time.

If I were in charge back then, I'd go Carthage on the South. I would have been smart enough to hunt each last one of the secessionists down just to string them up no matter the cost whilst sowing salt in the land, and our Constitution would have agreed.

A well deserved hear, hear to Sherman! May he ride again and mean it this time.
 
Last edited:
I assumed that you had to bring an Obama/Bush comparison in the mix
You bashed Obama. I put him in historical context. Things could be better, but they're a whole lot better than they were.


I don't defend Bush, I didn't vote for him, but there WAS a huge market crash and housing bubble that occurred under him.

That's part of what was so amazing. It was an epic bubble -- much larger than the Clinton dot com bubble -- big enough to plunge the global economy into depression when it popped. Yet it didn't bring about prosperity like the Clinton bubble when it was inflating. We got the severe withdrawal without ever having gotten the stimulus. Even at the high point, the Bush economy was fairly weak. Very strange.
The housing bubble was certainly not 100% his fault, it had been building up for a decade, ask Ron Paul about that.

Why would I ask Ron Paul about anything? The guy is a deluded, Ayn Rand-fetishizing halfwit. If I ever want advice on how to raise a jackass for a son, Ron's my guy, but otherwise he has nothing to teach.

Clinton's ä house for every American" push was quite the catalyst for what happened next. They are both equally to blame.

That push was inconsequential. The bubble inflated everywhere, not just in the poorer markets where Democratic efforts had pushed for additional lending. In fact, the worst inflation was in areas with vacation homes and investment homes, in the Sun Belt, and involved lenders besides Fannie and Freddie, and the Dems sure weren't pushing for that. And the problem took off globally, far beyond the reach of American politicians. It was because of the rise of the shadow banking system. The politicians were too reluctant to regulate the exotic new investment vehicles that were backing poorly secured mortgages. The anti-regulatory fever that hit most developed nations finally caught up to us all. Clinton deserves some blame, in that her partook in the deregulatory fad, but the popping of the bubble never took real estate values back to 2000 levels, so there wasn't really a bubble in the Clinton years. If you bought a house in the Clinton years, and didn't refinance, you never went underwater when the bubble burst. In fact, you had so much equity, even after the pop, that you could have refinanced if you ran into trouble. The bubble inflated on Bush's watch, and he's the person who is most responsible for missing the opportunity to regulate the market before it was too late. He was listening to too many dim-bulb libertarians, though, who thought the market could do no wrong. And we all paid the price for their profound misunderstanding of economics.

Yet, major liberal strongholds across the nation are in horrible shape

There's localized trouble in liberal as well as conservative areas. But, overall, liberal regions are doing much better. It's similar to the way there is cancer both among health nuts and chain-smoking junk-food addicts, but, overall, the health nuts are living longer, healthier lives.

a conservative-run state would demand more from individuals

It would demand less of them, in terms of contributing to the common good. That's the whole appeal of conservatism: it asks so very little of people.


How is that all a bad thing?

It produces worse results, on average.

Were the Native Americans savages?

That depends which ones you're asking about and how you define the word. Same with the Europeans.
 
- LMAO - we're supporting all these deadbeat red states now -

Not for long A-hole.....in case you haven't noticed all of the insudtry from the North is making a mass migration to the South. Pretty soon you will be eating chicken gravy and biscuits from Auntie Jeanie's Kitchen becuase you'll be moving there to work.

See....Keynes notwithstanding it's the guy who works that has a full pantry. Unless of course you're like BP and you simply profit off of the misery of others.

JO
 
Not for long A-hole.....in case you haven't noticed all of the insudtry from the North is making a mass migration to the South. Pretty soon you will be eating chicken gravy and biscuits from Auntie Jeanie's Kitchen becuase you'll be moving there to work.

See....Keynes notwithstanding it's the guy who works that has a full pantry. Unless of course you're like BP and you simply profit off of the misery of others.

JO

Do you need a gratuitous back-hand?
 
Last edited:
...LMAO - yea, sure as long as States like OK continue suppress wages, sure, why wouldn't we move the low-intellect jobs to poor under-educated southern States? - Does that make us like BP? No, it just makes us smarter, richer and less polluted - it's called capitalism.

...what you seem to fail to grasp is that the economy has changed - the US needs to be the leader in ideas and design, not the manufacturing leader - you want that, fine.

...resorting to name calling - LMAO...

Not for long A-hole.....in case you haven't noticed all of the insudtry from the North is making a mass migration to the South. Pretty soon you will be eating chicken gravy and biscuits from Auntie Jeanie's Kitchen becuase you'll be moving there to work.

See....Keynes notwithstanding it's the guy who works that has a full pantry. Unless of course you're like BP and you simply profit off of the misery of others.

JO
 
Except, of course, the well-publicized secession movement in California.

You need to get out more...

Oh yes, a couple of rural counties with a population of a few hundred batted that concept around. Until of course they realized that they would have to build an entirely new infrastructure for utilities at a cost of billions they didn't have.

Nice idea while it lasted. ;)
 
I keep telling you guys this would only happen after a complete collapse of the USA. And states or groups of states agree to go it on their own. I could see the West Coast being very prosperous but they will have to remove their oil drilling restrictions as there are probably billions of barrels in reserves offshore there

But if it did Medical Tourism would be big business for Texas also
 
Last edited:
...LMAO - yea, sure as long as States like OK continue suppress wages, sure, why wouldn't we move the low-intellect jobs to poor under-educated southern States? - Does that make us like BP? No, it just makes us smarter, richer and less polluted - it's called capitalism.

...what you seem to fail to grasp is that the economy has changed - the US needs to be the leader in ideas and design, not the manufacturing leader - you want that, fine.

...resorting to name calling - LMAO...
States suppress wages?
Here's how it's done since it seems you don't have a job. If a person who is looking for work finds a company looking to hire. If you meet what the company is looking for, you are called in for an interview. Now here's the tricky part a question will be ask, "HOW MUCH YOU LOOKING FOR TO COME AND WORK FOR ME?" You tell them and your wages are set. If they don't like what you're asking for you negotiate. If both party's agree you start to work at a set date, if not you go back home.
 
...LMAO - yea, sure as long as States like OK continue suppress wages, sure, why wouldn't we move the low-intellect jobs to poor under-educated southern States? - Does that make us like BP? No, it just makes us smarter, richer and less polluted - it's called capitalism.

...what you seem to fail to grasp is that the economy has changed - the US needs to be the leader in ideas and design, not the manufacturing leader - you want that, fine.

...resorting to name calling - LMAO...

Your ignorance of American History is astounding.

Suppressed wages eh? This entire nation was built on cheap labor including the Blue states....no....especially the blue states slavery notwithstanding. The most egregious capitalism is practiced by the double standard Dems who cozy up to corporate America behind closed door while at the same time pretending to hate it in public. Why do you think Nancy Pelosi tried to exempt American Samoa from the minimu wage laws?

It's not just capitalism it is the inevitable osmosis of wealth from areas that have it to areas that do not have it. It will always happen that way as it always has.

1.) You are not smarter but you sure do have that Opinion of yourself, that much is certain.
2.) You are not less polluted. You simply sub it out to other places that kill their own folks to make products for you. It's still your pollution and your dear prius has a larger carbon footprint pound for pound than a standard hydrocarbon combustion vehicle. Your wind turbines have created the Sea of Death in China. I could go on by it normally doesn't pay to speak to those who are willfully ignorant of the facts including History.
3.) Low intellect? Maybe the hourly workers are ..... but there is no such thing as low intellect/low technology manufacturing anymore...every single operation on the face of the planet that has any kind of footprint is controlled by high tech...even if it's a widget factory.

Man....not only are you not right....you are not even wrong!

JO
 
Last edited:
Ark.... Let's talk about this. Remember the little posting board that we both belonged to that was strictly a financial info board? Remember the conversations we had over there about this very thing...even before it crashed?

It's not strange....the entire ugly mess was highly visible, highly predictable and did not happen without many, many well read and well informed people screaming at the top of their lungs to both Republican and Democratic Politicians that it would end up in a world shattering financial implosion.

Both Parties has something to do with the ultimate results but I have to hand the Lion's share of the blame to the blindness of the Democratic legislatures that literally made lenders sit down and write loans that could never be recovered conventionally. Ergo we had the birth of the derivatives monster....a market that is still trading behind the scenes right now btw.



That's part of what was so amazing. It was an epic bubble -- much larger than the Clinton dot com bubble -- big enough to plunge the global economy into depression when it popped. Yet it didn't bring about prosperity like the Clinton bubble when it was inflating. We got the severe withdrawal without ever having gotten the stimulus. Even at the high point, the Bush economy was fairly weak. Very strange.
 
You bashed Obama. I put him in historical context. Things could be better, but they're a whole lot better than they were.
Where did I bash Obama?

Is it that i dared suggest a more realistic number as far as unemployment?

That's part of what was so amazing. It was an epic bubble -- much larger than the Clinton dot com bubble -- big enough to plunge the global economy into depression when it popped. Yet it didn't bring about prosperity like the Clinton bubble when it was inflating. We got the severe withdrawal without ever having gotten the stimulus. Even at the high point, the Bush economy was fairly weak. Very strange.
It's interesting that you so pigeon hole presidents and "their" economies, but yet Obama has never taken account for his...

It's always been Bush's fault.

What if Bush's was effected by Clinton? What if Clinton's was effected by Bush Sr.?

I only seek consistancy as far as considerations.

Why would I ask Ron Paul about anything? The guy is a deluded, Ayn Rand-fetishizing halfwit. If I ever want advice on how to raise a jackass for a son, Ron's my guy, but otherwise he has nothing to teach.
He predicted the housing bubble, and he makes eons more sense than the guy you support. I'd argue that all day, every day. Ron Paul just doesn't play ball with the major party corruptions as Obama does.

Start the thread, Obama vs. Ron Paul, If you dare...
 
Back
Top