New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Secession

That's all fine and good. Of course, there's no way to predict exactly what would happen. I'll say this, I'd give Texas a good look if they seceded. The Federal government of America could use a good kick in the ass.


Sure it is ;)

Time to be honest. Look at the U6 unemployment rate.
The U6 unemployment rate counts not only people without work seeking full-time employment (the more familiar U-3 rate), but also counts "marginally attached workers and those working part-time for economic reasons." Note that some of these part-time workers counted as employed by U-3 could be working as little as an hour a week. And the "marginally attached workers" include those who have gotten discouraged and stopped looking, but still want to work. The age considered for this calculation is 16 years and over

The current true unemployment rate is 12.2%

Obama just chooses not to acknowledge people who are hurt by the poor working economy for better numbers to spout. Nothing more.
You can't mix stats, by reporting the U-6 stat for the US and comparing with the U-3 for Texas. U-6 for Texas is 11.2%. That's a little better than the US as a whole, but not much.

As for the Obama-bashing, he refers primarily to the U-3 number just like every other president. It would just be confusing if he started to refer primarily to the U-6 number, instead. And U-6 isn't "true unemployment," since it counts some employed people (those working part-time who'd be working full-time in a better economy).

Anyway, Texas has a slightly better unemployment rate than the nation as a whole, but it's surprising to me the gap isn't bigger, given how much the Texas economy benefits from oil, and how good the job market is right now in many other areas blessed by significant natural oil reserves. For example, unemployment is 0.5% in Qatar, 1.5% in Kuwait, 2.6% in Brunei, 3.5% in Norway, etc. Texas isn't even doing as well as neighboring Mexico, in terms of unemployment rate.

That isn't the troubling thing about Texas, though. A place can be prosperous even with fairly high unemployment, if conditions aren't terribly rough for the unemployed, and the employed are earning well enough. Rather, what's troubling about Texas is how poorly its people are doing, overall.

Texas has the fifth-highest poverty rate of any state in the nation. They also have fairly high infant mortality rates (6.15, which means your infant is 40% more likely to die in Texas than in my own state of Massachusetts). They also die young -- two years younger, on average, than in Massachusetts. That's probably partly because of their serious obesity problem -- you're around 28% more likely to be obese in Texas than in Massachusetts. They have the fifth-highest incarceration rate, too. You're more than three times as likely to be in jail if you're in Texas than if you're in Massachusetts. Yet, despite that draconian tendency to lock up their residents, they have a high murder rate (you're about two and a half times more more likely to be murdered in Texas than Massachusetts). And their academics are mediocre -- performing about average for the US, generally,on the NAEP, but considering how bad the US average is by the standards of elite nations, that's an embarrassment, and they have a dismally low percentage of residents with degrees (35th in the nation).

By the very low standards of the American South, Texas is doing reasonably well. But they have some serious socio-economic problems, which really stand out if you look at them in the context of more advanced societies, like those of New England or Western Europe.
 
it's foolish to make up a situation where every single red state succedes.

However, if it were just Texas, here is why it would serve Texas' interests to succeed from the Union.

1. The government of Texas has low-debt to GDP ratio. Their GDP-Debt ratio is only 19%. This is sustainable. Currently the US’s gdp-to-debt ratio is 73%. According to projects, the US economy is only going to grow deeper into debt.

2. Texas is a net giver of tax revenue to the national government, while other states are tax takers.

3. Texas as a state does not rack up a trade deficit. It actually has a trade surplus of $100 billion.

4. It is not a landlocked State, which allows it trade with other countries through ports. It also has a neighboring country that is not the US, Mexico.

5. it has the ability to defend itself. It has 13 military bases.

6. It also has a strong economy able to sustain itself. It has a powerful agricultural, aeronautics, computer, energy and healthcare sector.

7. It is the largest exporting state in the nation, exporting $192.2 billion worth of goods and services.

8. It has a low unemployment rate of only 6.1%compared to the national average of 7.9%

9. It’s the second largest economy in the US, with a GDP of over $1.3 trillion and GDP per capita of $45,940

10. It also has a large enough population to defend itself. Texas currently has a population of 26,059,203, which would place it as the 46th out of 242nd largest nations if it seceded.

It would be great if Texas seceded. Then, we could arm Mexico and allow its forces to transit our borders and attack Texas from all sides in return for Baja California. The irony would be supreme.
 
You can't mix stats, by reporting the U-6 stat for the US and comparing with the U-3 for Texas. U-6 for Texas is 11.2%. That's a little better than the US as a whole, but not much.

As for the Obama-bashing, he refers primarily to the U-3 number just like every other president. It would just be confusing if he started to refer primarily to the U-6 number, instead.
The U3 is a phony number no matter who uses it. I'm fine with using the U6 in all instances. It's far more accurate of the true nature of our workplace economy.
And U-6 isn't "true unemployment," since it counts some employed people (those working part-time who'd be working full-time in a better economy).
Come on, are you really that dishonest? No complexity?

Anyway, Texas has a slightly better unemployment rate than the nation as a whole, but it's surprising to me the gap isn't bigger, given how much the Texas economy benefits from oil, and how good the job market is right now in many other areas blessed by significant natural oil reserves. For example, unemployment is 0.5% in Qatar, 1.5% in Kuwait, 2.6% in Brunei, 3.5% in Norway, etc. Texas isn't even doing as well as neighboring Mexico, in terms of unemployment rate.
Because those nations and Texas are entirely comparable...

Texas has the fifth-highest poverty rate of any state in the nation. They also have fairly high infant mortality rates (6.15, which means your infant is 40% more likely to die in Texas than in my own state of Massachusetts). They also die young -- two years younger, on average, than in Massachusetts. That's probably partly because of their serious obesity problem -- you're around 28% more likely to be obese in Texas than in Massachusetts. They have the fifth-highest incarceration rate, too. You're more than three times as likely to be in jail if you're in Texas than if you're in Massachusetts. Yet, despite that draconian tendency to lock up their residents, they have a high murder rate (you're about two and a half times more more likely to be murdered in Texas than Massachusetts). And their academics are mediocre -- performing about average for the US, generally,on the NAEP, but considering how bad the US average is by the standards of elite nations, that's an embarrassment, and they have a dismally low percentage of residents with degrees (35th in the nation).
America does fine with plenty of obese people, murderers, sub-par education strongholds, etc. Plus, Texas would probably have new, more effective ways of dealing with some of these problems. Necessity breeds invention, not Washington DC thinktanks.

Meanwhile, Texas would have something the United States does not... fresh perspective of freedom. So many Americans are so busy whining about what they don't have, they can't see what they do have right in front of them. The unity is lost. There's no uniting enemy force. We are a stale, lazy, self-entitled culture compared to what we were.

Marx had that aspect entirely correct. After a movement occurs, the people are charged to act beyond what is expected, and are unified and appreciating what they have.

I would expect Texans and those who would flock there to be hundreds of times more efficient than any American government worker and bureaucracy.

But let me say, for someone who I assume would lamblast a founding father supporter who would suggest the Native Americans were primitive and savage.. you sure hold some disdain for the South. What's up with that?
 
The Red Scare added part? Yeah...and?

So...indivisible, or divisible?

It's just quite ironic how you were so focused on the exact wording of the pledge, and left out something because you didn't like it.

What if Texas doesn't like "indivisible", and leaves it out? That's what you did... but to a different part.
 
Yes there is:

Texas vs. White made secession "illegal", however:
If the Constitution is no longer in force—the States have separated and resumed their independent status—then the Supreme Court would not have jurisdiction and therefore could not determine the “legality” of the move.

The “Pledge of Allegiance” analogy?

The modern pledge was written by Francis Bellamy, a socialist minister reacting emotionally to the Civil War with a nationalist message, one based on the “great speeches” of Daniel Webster and Abraham Lincoln in relation to the “One Nation which the Civil War was fought to prove.” Sprinkle in some “liberty and justice” from the French Revolution and you have a message that any good leftist nationalist can embrace. The founding generation would not have said such a pledge, if for no other reason that most did not view the United States as a “nation” in the strict sense of the word, a single people.

Even more interesting:

In the Texas v. White decision, Chase implicitly reasoned that the Union was an “indissoluble” contract between the “American people” and the federal government, or in this case the people of Texas and the federal government. All contracts are intended to be perpetual. But if this were the case, how could nine States ratify a new Constitution while four States remained part of another Union in clear violation of the language of the Articles of Confederation. Changes to the Articles required the consent of all thirteen States, not nine, and thus the Constitution can be viewed, in part, as an act of secession.

James Madison argued that the Union was a different type of contract. “We are not to consider the Federal Union as analogous to the social compact of individuals: for if it were so, a majority would have a right to bind the rest, and even to form a new constitution for the whole… .”

The Constitution was framed by the unanimous consent of the States present in convention assembled in Philadelphia, but it had no teeth until the States, in convention, ratified it. Even at that point, Madison suggested, the States could not bind the rest into accepting the document or remaining in the Union. The Constitution does not have a coercive principle, as Ellsworth called it. An “indissoluble” Union would suggest that it does.


The Civil War?

Waging war “against them (the States)” is an act of treason, and as per the Constitution, a State can only be “protected” by the central government on the application of the legislature or the executive in the case of invasion. Lincoln violated both constitutional safeguards against coercion by the central government in 1861, of course only if the states remained in the Union, as he insisted they did. If not, war required a declaration from Congress, something Lincoln did not have, and by declaring war, Congress would have recognized the Confederate States as a legitimate government. Either way, Lincoln violated the Constitution, thus rendering the “bloody nose” argument against secession void.

Neither the Framers nor the ratifiers believed that the Constitution created a “consolidated nation” as Story suggested. It was argued in all state ratifying conventions that the opposite was true. The Union was made “more perfect” but never consolidated. The States still had all powers not delegated to the general government, as the Tenth Amendment to the Constitution clearly illustrates, and every State proposed a “Tenth Amendment” in their suggested bill of rights in the months after ratification.




Actually, we aren't... Any argument saying we are indivisible miserably fails any test of logic.

If the Constitution is no longer in force, then the United States no longer exists and secession becomes moot. Still...there is nothing in the laws of the United States that allows for dissolution or secession of any state.

The 14th weakened the states and the 10th amendment. Equal protection was the new standard.

I know the history of the pledge. I brought it up because, again, many on the right seem to believe it essential and many still recite it. Some make a huge deal about it. Bellamy wrote it to help a magazine sell flags. There was no nation named in the original. Nor was there any mention of God.
 
You can't mix stats, by reporting the U-6 stat for the US and comparing with the U-3 for Texas. U-6 for Texas is 11.2%. That's a little better than the US as a whole, but not much.

As for the Obama-bashing, he refers primarily to the U-3 number just like every other president. It would just be confusing if he started to refer primarily to the U-6 number, instead. And U-6 isn't "true unemployment," since it counts some employed people (those working part-time who'd be working full-time in a better economy).

Anyway, Texas has a slightly better unemployment rate than the nation as a whole, but it's surprising to me the gap isn't bigger, given how much the Texas economy benefits from oil, and how good the job market is right now in many other areas blessed by significant natural oil reserves. For example, unemployment is 0.5% in Qatar, 1.5% in Kuwait, 2.6% in Brunei, 3.5% in Norway, etc. Texas isn't even doing as well as neighboring Mexico, in terms of unemployment rate.

That isn't the troubling thing about Texas, though. A place can be prosperous even with fairly high unemployment, if conditions aren't terribly rough for the unemployed, and the employed are earning well enough. Rather, what's troubling about Texas is how poorly its people are doing, overall.

Texas has the fifth-highest poverty rate of any state in the nation. They also have fairly high infant mortality rates (6.15, which means your infant is 40% more likely to die in Texas than in my own state of Massachusetts). They also die young -- two years younger, on average, than in Massachusetts. That's probably partly because of their serious obesity problem -- you're around 28% more likely to be obese in Texas than in Massachusetts. They have the fifth-highest incarceration rate, too. You're more than three times as likely to be in jail if you're in Texas than if you're in Massachusetts. Yet, despite that draconian tendency to lock up their residents, they have a high murder rate (you're about two and a half times more more likely to be murdered in Texas than Massachusetts). And their academics are mediocre -- performing about average for the US, generally,on the NAEP, but considering how bad the US average is by the standards of elite nations, that's an embarrassment, and they have a dismally low percentage of residents with degrees (35th in the nation).

By the very low standards of the American South, Texas is doing reasonably well. But they have some serious socio-economic problems, which really stand out if you look at them in the context of more advanced societies, like those of New England or Western Europe.

Wow, it almost sounds like Texas has a problem with large numbers of poorly educated, poorly employed people from places where lifestyle, diet and income contribute to poor health. I wonder what could be going on...what might you be missing? Hmmm...
 
It's just quite ironic how you were so focused on the exact wording of the pledge, and left out something because you didn't like it.

What if Texas doesn't like "indivisible", and leaves it out? That's what you did... but to a different part.


Indivisible is part of the original. Under God is not. Nor does Under God have any value to the discussion.
 
If the Constitution is no longer in force, then the United States no longer exists and secession becomes moot. Still...there is nothing in the laws of the United States that allows for dissolution or secession of any state.
Of course, the American federal government has a vested interest here. It's no surprise their Supreme Court would rule as it did in the 1860's, fresh off the Civil War. Let's not act as if this came from logical deducation. Logically, there's no way the Federal government can stop a state that doesn't want to be a member of the union.

The federal government keeps states in line via intimidation, blackmail, and bullying. Plain and simple.

You might find that a necessary evil to keep the union as one, but I don't see that as promoting anything good, and leads to bad government practice..
 
What if Texas thought indivisible has no value?

Some Texans clearly don't.

Why would they value the pledge in any way then? Why recite it, ever? Just more cafeteria philosophy...pick and choose what one likes and whine about the rest. yada yada blah blah blah...
 
Why would they value the pledge in any way then? Why recite it, ever? Just more cafeteria philosophy...pick and choose what one likes and whine about the rest. yada yada blah blah blah...

In other words, exactly what you did on this thread.
 
In other words, exactly what you did on this thread.

I'm fine with the Under God as an extant component of the pledge...as you all feel the need to make that an issue. One nation, under God, indivisible.

Now, back to the meat of the matter...Feel free to explain to me how the phrase involves the idea of secession. Would you say the words under god apply to the concept of secession, or would the word indivisible be the more appropriate word, when discussing the concept of secession?
 
It's just quite ironic how you were so focused on the exact wording of the pledge, and left out something because you didn't like it.

What if Texas doesn't like "indivisible", and leaves it out? That's what you did... but to a different part.

Let me see if I get this right: You think Texas has a right to secede.

Are there any wingers on this sight who aren't extremists?
 
I'm fine with the Under God as an extant component of the pledge...as you all feel the need to make that an issue. One nation, under God, indivisible.

Now, back to the meat of the matter...Feel free to explain to me how the phrase involves the idea of secession. Would you say the words under god apply to the concept of secession, or would the word indivisible be the more appropriate word, when discussing the concept of secession?

I'm not sure why you think the pledge of allegiance has anything at all to do with constitutional law, so your request is denied.
 
I'm not sure why you think the pledge of allegiance has anything at all to do with constitutional law, so your request is denied.

I've explained why I brought up the pledge. It's because of the hypocrites who recite it then seek to leave the union.

As we all know, the words under god have nothing to do with the discussion. That was just a little distraction you and Frisky worked up.
 
I'm fine with the Under God as an extant component of the pledge...as you all feel the need to make that an issue. One nation, under God, indivisible.

Now, back to the meat of the matter...Feel free to explain to me how the phrase involves the idea of secession. Would you say the words under god apply to the concept of secession, or would the word indivisible be the more appropriate word, when discussing the concept of secession?

First, before we get into tearing into the pledge... tell me how the pledge is some binding legal document?
 
Back
Top