New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Settled Science Update

A little parable for you. Picture a ship at sea, with the water in the bilge rising fast. The ship's engineers tell the captain that he needs to have a hole in the hull patched, or find a way to pump the water out faster, or the ship will founder soon. The captain, being an utter imbecile, responds:

Water is an integral part of the circle of life. Without it, there would be no life on earth. It is part of the cycle between plants and animals. We are water based creatures; water is not a "pollutant", neither is sea water a pollutant; water has always resulted in more life, not less.​



Incorrect. Carbon dioxide has been producing global warming for many decades now.



There is a greenhouse effect in our atmosphere, and in the atmosphere of other planets we've studied. If it didn't exist, we'd all freeze solid every night, as the heat escaped directly into space. The physics of this are easy to understand and easy to demonstrate in experiments. CO2 (and some other gases) have a structure that causes resonating at infrared wavelengths. That means some of the infrared light that would have radiated directly into space instead gets transformed into kinetic molecular motion in the molecules of the atmosphere. The more greenhouse gases, the fewer photons of infrared radiation make it to space and the more of that energy goes to warm the atmosphere. The same thing keeps that heat, in the form of kinetic molecular motion, from exiting our atmosphere that keeps the air itself from doing so: gravity. Gravity holds those excited molecules around the Earth. Eventually that energy gets transformed back into infrared light and radiates out into space, but it's like a situation where you have a faucet emptying into a tub and a drain draining away from it. Restrict the flow of water out of the tub through the drain, and the water level will rise, even though eventually every bit of water that goes into it will leave it. Similarly, restrict the flow of infrared radiation way from the Earth, while the radiation coming in stays fairly constant, and the heat rises, even though eventually all that energy will leave into space. This isn't hard to understand. It's bizarre some people can't think their way through it.



You missed the point badly. Why is the water warmer? It's not volcanic activity on the Arctic ocean floor. No such activity has been observed, the pattern within the water column is inconsistent with the idea that the heat is radiating from the depths (there's less warming deep down than above), and we aren't measuring the changes in atmospheric chemistry or water chemistry that would show up with a big uptick in volcanic activity (e.g., CO2 isotopes associated with volcanoes as opposed to fossil fuels, plus other elements that are associated with volcanic outgassing). This is how science works. You're welcome to guess at alternative explanations for what we're seeing. But those hypotheses can be tested, by measuring various things. There's a particular pattern of data we'd expect to see if the polar ice was melting from global warming, and another pattern we'd expect to see if it was being melted geothermally. Turns out, the pattern of data is consistent with the AGW theory, not the geothermal one. It was worth looking into, but like all the other desperate attempts by the denialists, it was killed by the data. But, of course, mere real-world facts won't cause the know-nothing brigades to abandon their silly petty theory, even as the more serious climate change skeptics left it by the wayside long ago.

A correction: CO2 has been warming the Earth for eons. It's just that increased CO2 concentrations in recent decades have meant an accelerated warming trend.
 
I told you what I believed. Am I wrong? What was your position? How did it change?


Wow. This is getting to be an obsession with you.

Yes - You were wrong. That's not an uncommon occurrence. Be at peace with that, unless you just can't.
 
Last edited:
Have your views on it changed over time?

For example, 2016 was the hottest year on record, beating 2015, the previous record holder. The most recent decade is the hottest one on record, beating the prior decade, the previous record holder, which beat the one before that, the prior record holder. The pace at which the warming is occurring has accelerated. During that time, the breadth of the scientific consensus on the topic has grown, as has the confidence with which the majority of scientists are expressing their views (e.g., the IPCC officially going from "likely" to "highly likely" in stating key positions, to reflect the expanding depth of the supporting research and analysis and the impact it has had on the majority of expert's opinions.)

Those developments altered my views over time, because I have an open mind. Like the majority within the scientific community, I went from a very tentative assumption that AGW was real, a few decades ago, to a high degree of confidence in it. What I'm asking is whether your views changed, too, in light of those decades of increasingly dramatic warming, increasing amounts of exhaustive research, and increasingly convinced experts? It's one thing to assert that your mind is open. But if such incredibly dramatic external changes do not actually impact your opinions on a topic, how open can your mind be?
No it hasn't. You either made that up or got it from some other nutcase who made it up.
 
A correction: CO2 has been warming the Earth for eons. It's just that increased CO2 concentrations in recent decades have meant an accelerated warming trend.
the recent variations in solar cycles suggest that CO2 concentrations aren't the major influence on temperature variations.

in any case, earth has been emerging from the most recent ice age for the past 10,000 years. and we're not done yet. planet earth almost never has polar ice caps. we still do, in 2017. dinosaurs used to graze in Alaska.

nothing can prevent the continued waning of the last ice age. the correct scientific and political approach is to make hard choices about which coastal regions to defend against rising sea levels, and how to do it.
 
debating with the uniformed an unread is like shooting fish in barrel.

It can be a frustrating process, to be sure. But I hold out hope that eventually you'll learn something. For example, you might learn that the idea is that the Atlantic conveyor could become crippled, changing the distribution of warm water through the oceans. As your own link showed, when this happened before it didn't mean a "cooling of the ocean" (the misinterpretation you'd asserted in your post). It meant erratic regional climates, including an oscillation where there'd be periods when the North was unusually cool and the South unusually warm, and vice versa. You're mistaking a periodic regional phenomenon with a long-term global one.

There's a real possibility that a melting cryosphere could change the salinity levels that drive the conveyor, resulting in a similar erratic pattern showing up. But there's still a lot of uncertainty about that -- scientists can confidently predict long-term warming from GHGs, and they can confidently predict that this will mean weather disruptions, but more detailed modeling is still in its infancy so nobody can say with any level of confidence what's going to happen in terms of specific weather changes in specific areas on specific timelines.
 
Last edited:
Bingo! Look up James Kamis's bio. Sound familiar? Here, a reminder from my prior post:

If you follow up on the "experts" those crackpot bloggers quote, you'll find that they nearly always fit a particular profile. They're pretty much never leading scientists in their field, much less ones actively researching the questions being addressed. Instead, they're generally retirees or semi-retirees, spending their days seeking attention with armchair quarterbacking of the professionals engaged in the work. The most frequent profile is a retired petroleum geologist -- some graying dude with an undergrad or masters degree in geology from a non-competitive university, obtained back in the 60s or 70s. These aren't experts in the topic at hand, by any stretch of the imagination. They're just bored old people speculating about something they read in the paper, who provide convenient quotations for the bloggers to use, since at least they're nominally scientists. The "scientists" may be "published," but only in the sense that they hand their garbage papers to some joke outlet like junkscience.com which exists to put a shoddy academic veneer on political propaganda.​

So, who is James Kamis? He's a retired oil company worker, with a 1976 geology degree from Idaho State (a school that isn't even ranked, overall). What you're posting isn't the work of a research scientist in this field. It's the rambling of a bored retiree.

http://www.plateclimatology.com/about/

What does it tell you that you rely not on leading experts who are actively researching in the field and publishing in respectable peer-reviewed journals, and instead you rely on amateur geezers sitting in their basements writing dispatches for shoddy right-wing blogs like Climate Change Dispatch?

You could hardly have come up with a better example to illustrate my point about the sewers denialists like you wade through to find the stories that tell you what you want to believe. Climate Change Dispatch isn't a science journal. It's the nighttime project of Thomas Richard, a freelance reporter whose education consists of an undergrad degree in communications from a state school. And Kamis isn't a climate researcher, he's a retiree speculating aimlessly in his ample free time. It's very telling that this is the kind of source material the dummies in the denialist community have to come back to, again and again -- they're so starved for credible evidence supporting their prejudices that they can't resist this garbage even directly after having been warned about such sourcing. Pathetic.
 
Last edited:
And stop with the "your right wing websites" bullsh*t.


dm_com_29.png
Ah yes, thanks for the reminder. They aren't all just right wing websites. The denialist dummies also like to pull from an infamous British tabloid that, when it's not publishing juicy stories about celebrity affairs, likes to host climate change denialist garbage.
 
Last edited:
And since the United States is the same as a globe, a short-term cooling trend in the United States clearly implies long-term global cooling.
The people who make this mistake must have drastically skewed geography in their head. The US makes up less than 2% of the Earth. The US is to the Earth, in terms of footprint, what Georgia is to the contiguous US. If Georgia had a hot decade, the denialists wouldn't fall for someone using that to argue that the US must have warmed. Yet they'll fall for something saying that if the US had a cool period, the Earth as a whole must have cooled.
 
Last edited:
It is not "a certain political party" warning about the dangers of global warming, but rather virtually every scientific body in every country in the world.
Yep. Just about all the national academies of science have come down on that side, as have the royal societies of science, plus the IPCC, NASA, NOAA, the Japan Meteorological Agency, the UK's met office, and pretty much every large body of scientists assembled for any purpose other than climate change denialism (e.g., everything from the professional bodies of physicists and meteorologists, to the American Medical Association).

The irony I see, from my perch within the for-profit corporate world in the US, is that in the board rooms and senior executive meetings, it's simply taken as a fact that AGW is happening and will just keep getting more serious. They may be cagey about saying that outright in public, but when dollars are on the line, they set aside the political rhetoric needed to stay in good standing with the GOP, and simply accept the consensus position of the scientists. It's one thing to play at being a "skeptic" for public consumption. But if you're, say, deciding where to site a new billion-dollar facility near the coast, you damned well want to get serious about whether or not the sea levels are likely to rise. When real money is on the line, the phony politicized "skepticism" is left at the board room door.
 
You don't believe in physics?
I can drop this 50 pound dumbbell and not worry about it slamming into my foot that's directly below it. Gravity is a liberal conspiracy. The actual cause of things appearing to fall to Earth are undersea volcanoes, and since there are none of them around me, I'm good.
 
Yes - You were wrong.
I can see a few options here:

(1) You used to be more sure that AGW isn't real, but the huge amount of new data and analysis has undermined that belief for you, and so now you're neutral on the question.
(2) You used to be more sure AGW is real, but somehow the huge amount of new supporting data actually decreased your confidence, making you neutral on it.
(3) You used to be neutral on the topic, and are neutral on it again, but in between you had a period of being non-neutral on it, with your moves away from and back to neutrality having something to do with new information along the way.

Is it one of those three? If so, which one? Or if it's something else entirely, what is it? Or is the truth that you were neutral all along, with the massive number of new facts and analysis making no impact on your mind, because it was closed to them?
 
Last edited:
No it hasn't.
Sure it has. Pull up any historical record of global temperatures and take a look. For example, NASA and NOAA publish an instrument record going back to 1880, showing average global temperatures. The Japan Meteorological agency and the UK's Met office have similar records going back to the late 1800s, with slightly different methods. Take whichever you want, and do some simple math. What was the average rise in temperature in the first fifth, second fifth, etc., of the record? You'll see a clear trend of acceleration.

Or, if you want to go back further, take one of the paleoclimate reconstructions, going back thousands of years. What was the pace of warming (or cooling) in various periods. How does that compare to the pace of warming in, say, the last half century?

Make an honest effort to answer those questions for yourself and you'll see what I mean.
 
the recent variations in solar cycles suggest that CO2 concentrations aren't the major influence on temperature variations.

Be specific, please. What recent variations in the cycle are you talking about, and how does it suggest that CO2 concentrations aren't the major influence?

in any case, earth has been emerging from the most recent ice age for the past 10,000 years.

We were, in fact, emerging from the ice age for much of that time. It's possible that without anthropogenic GHGs, we would still have been emerging and that temperatures still would have risen over the last century. Or it's possible we would have plateaued or headed back into another ice age. We don't have a great understanding of ice ages, so nobody can really be sure. But what we can say with great confidence is that the current warming cycle is nothing like the warming cycles we've documented in the pre-industrial past, based on various reconstruction methods (ice cores, sediments, tree rings, microfossils, etc.) We know, from looking at the record of several prior cycles of warming, that they tend to happen much, much more slowly than what we're seeing today. There does not appear to be any warming cycle, dating back at least 100,000 years, that's even within an order of magnitude of the pace of the current warming cycle. And the current cycle has been getting faster and faster in its warming. There's no plausible mechanism to explain that other than AGHGs.

nothing can prevent the continued waning of the last ice age

Here, a simple question for you: what was the average pace of planetary warming between 10,000 years ago and, say, 100 years ago, in terms of degrees per decade? Once you have that answer, what have we averaged for the last 100 years? The last 50 years? The last 20? Do you see the issue now, with being complacent about the recent warming just based on the idea there probably would have been some warming regardless of what we did?

Since you're very concerned with recreational drug use, here's a rough analogy. Imagine you have a friend who starts smoking pot very heavily. Her memory begins to go to crap, her focus declines, and her work suffers, jeopardizing her job. You urge her to cut way back on the pot, and you point her to a broad scientific consensus saying heavy marijuana use can permanently damage short term memory and cause other types of brain dysfunction. But she loves getting stoned and insists her recent memory problems and other mental lapses have nothing to do with weed. To support that "motivated reasoning," she points to other studies that say that short-term memory and other indicators of brain function tend to decline as a person ages. So,she'd have been having trouble regardless.

Your friend would be right that her brain would almost certainly be sliding in the direction of worsened function even if she never touched drugs. It's a natural part of the aging process. But PACE is a huge difference. In just a few years, she could cause changes that would have taken many decades at the natural pace of decline. She could wind up a 40-year-old with the focus and retention you'd expect from an 80-year-0ld. Pace matters. And pace matters for climate change, too. Maybe we were doomed to have 3 degrees of warming over the next 5000 years, just based on emerging from the last ice age. But if we instead have 3 degrees of warming over the next 100 years, based on carbon pollution, that's going to be VASTLY more expensive and difficult to adapt to.
 
Last edited:
Bingo! Look up James Kamis's bio. Sound familiar? Here, a reminder from my prior post:

f you follow up on the "experts" those crackpot bloggers quote, you'll find that they nearly always fit a particular profile. They're pretty much never leading scientists in their field, much less ones actively researching the questions being addressed. Instead, they're generally retirees or semi-retirees, spending their days seeking attention with armchair quarterbacking of the professionals engaged in the work. The most frequent profile is a retired petroleum geologist -- some graying dude with an undergrad or masters degree in geology from a non-competitive university, obtained back in the 60s or 70s. These aren't experts in the topic at hand, by any stretch of the imagination. They're just bored old people speculating about something they read in the paper, who provide convenient quotations for the bloggers to use, since at least they're nominally scientists. The "scientists" may be "published," but only in the sense that they hand their garbage papers to some joke outlet like junkscience.com which exists to put a shoddy academic veneer on political propaganda.​

So, who is James Kamis? He's a retired oil company worker, with a 1976 geology degree from Idaho State (a school that isn't even ranked, overall). What you're posting isn't the work of a research scientist in this field. It's the ramblings of bored retiree.

http://www.plateclimatology.com/about/

What does it tell you that you rely not on leading experts who are actively researching in the field and publishing in respectable peer-reviewed journals, and instead relying on amateur geezers sitting in their basements writing dispatches for shoddy right-wing blogs like Climate Change Dispatch? You could hardly have come up with a better example to illustrate my point about the sewers denialists like you wade through to find the stories that tell you what you want to believe. Climate Change Dispatch isn't a science journal. It's the nighttime project of Thomas Richard, a freelance reporter whose education consists of an undergrad degree in communications from a state school. And Kamis isn't a climate researcher, he's a retiree speculating aimlessly in his ample free time. It's very telling that this is the kind of source material the dummies in the denialist community have to come back to, again and again -- they're so starved for credible evidence supporting their prejudices that they can't resist this garbage even directly after having been warned about such sourcing. Pathetic.
holy sh*t, you are seriously deluded. Didn't you perceive that it was a Google search?

EVERYONE reports geothermal (volcanic) activity along that 1100 mile long ridge; do a little study and you will discover that the entire mountain range rose up in the same half century the Arctic ice was melting. Did you read the article I painstakingly copied pasted for you into 3 posts?

Let's compare the temperature (in Fahrenheit) of geothermal gas versus the average air temps in the Arctic circle. Which one do you think was melting the ice cap? (hint: the one that was hotter)

avg air temps at North pole: .................. -10 degrees
geothermal gas from ocean floor: .......... 3000 degrees

Here's a little dilemma that I pointed out years ago to you. Air temps below freezing (32 degrees) don't actually melt ice. In fact, they freeze water into more ice. You never managed to wrap your head around that either.

I don't mean to insult you, but how else can I characterize this "science" than utter nonsense? You refuse to acknowledge the geothermal activity associated with an entire mountain range rising on the ocean floor and steadfastly maintain that air temps that averaged 4o degrees below freezing are what melted the ice cap. That's looney tunes.
 
the recent variations in solar cycles suggest that CO2 concentrations aren't the major influence on temperature variations.

in any case, earth has been emerging from the most recent ice age for the past 10,000 years. and we're not done yet. planet earth almost never has polar ice caps. we still do, in 2017. dinosaurs used to graze in Alaska.

nothing can prevent the continued waning of the last ice age. the correct scientific and political approach is to make hard choices about which coastal regions to defend against rising sea levels, and how to do it.

How do they suggest that? It seems odd to me that a decrease in solar energy output would coincide with an unprecedented increase in average global temperature.

As noted above, many things drive climate trends. But the overwhelming signal in recent years, as determined by attribution studies that actually look at the expected effects of different inputs and compare them to the real world, is increased GHG concentrations.

The thousands - year-long "emergence" from the last glacial period is one thing. Extremely rapid climate change with no plausible cause other than GHGs is something else entirely.
 
Here, a simple question for you: what was the average pace of planetary warming between 10,000 years ago and, say, 100 years ago, in terms of degrees per decade? QUOTE]

warming accelerates as the massive glaciers/ice caps of 10,000 years ago recede.

same principle as "your drink warms faster as the ice cubes melt"

glad I could help you out with some science 101, ark.

7565467-Cola-pouring-from-a-can-into-a-glass-filled-with-Ice-Over-white-background-with-water-droplets-on-th-Stock-Photo.jpg
 
It can be a frustrating process, to be sure. But I hold out hope that eventually you'll learn something. For example, you might learn that the idea is that the Atlantic conveyor could become crippled, changing the distribution of warm water through the oceans. As your own link showed, when this happened before it didn't mean a "cooling of the ocean" (the misinterpretation you'd asserted in your post). It meant erratic regional climates, including an oscillation where there'd be periods when the North was unusually cool and the South unusually warm, and vice versa. You're mistaking a periodic regional phenomenon with a long-term global one.

There's a real possibility that a melting cryosphere could change the salinity levels that drive the conveyor, resulting in a similar erratic pattern showing up. But there's still a lot of uncertainty about that -- scientists can confidently predict long-term warming from GHGs, and they can confidently predict that this will mean weather disruptions, but more detailed modeling is still in its infancy so nobody can say with any level of confidence what's going to happen in terms of specific weather changes in specific areas on specific timelines.

I don't know whether this is a consensus view, but Michael Mann, whose particular area of expertise is natural climate oscillations, says it's likely that a global warming trend would drive short-term cooling in the N. Atlantic (Greenland and W. Europe mostly)--although nothing like on the scale of that movie--before the regional oscillation is overwhelmed by the general warming trend.
 
How do they suggest that? It seems odd to me that a decrease in solar energy output would coincide with an unprecedented increase in average global temperature.

As noted above, many things drive climate trends. But the overwhelming signal in recent years, as determined by attribution studies that actually look at the expected effects of different inputs and compare them to the real world, is increased GHG concentrations.

The thousands - year-long "emergence" from the last glacial period is one thing. Extremely rapid climate change with no plausible cause other than GHGs is something else entirely.
Carbon14_with_activity_labels.svg
 
Back
Top