New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Settled Science Update

You lazy son-of-a-gun. I did Link the evidence, I even copy pasted it into posts, I asked you three or four times if you had read any of it, you keep repeating the same mistakes, you haven't acknowledged any of the links or having clicked on a single one, and then you have the unmitigated gall to ask me to ""By all means, link to the evidence supporting that." I explained the event to you also and after all that, you post a representation of total ignorance of any of it. What it does ... it shows me why you refuse to learn anything on this subject ... either you are not reading our posts or you just don't care about the truth, you are stuck in your religion; as far as you are concerned, the earth is flat and all the evidence of all mankind proves it is flat and the rest of us are hopelessly stupid.

I don't seem to understand basic concepts of air and water circulation but I guess I stumbled onto the severe angle of reflection of the sun's rays at the North Pole... interesting, seeing as I stumbled onto that point many years ago and you resisted it all these years until this post.

What you just explained is why warm water currents are heating the water on the edge of the Arctic Circle. More reason the increase in air temps in the Arctic Circle is coming from the water. But you guys are claiming the ice cap melted from the heat in the air. As ignorant as I am of global air circulation, I still know that both poles have polar vortex winds that wall out outside intervention from oceanic currents.

Regardless of whatever influence the Arctic air temps received from ocean currents, the fact remains that the average air temp for the years in question (and for as long as the North pole sat on top of a spinning earth tilted to the sun) is 35-45 degrees (F) below freezing. Explain all you want where the heat came from... you still don't have enough heat in the air to melt any ice. The ice cap melt was a direct result of geo-thermal heat that rose through the water when an entire mountain ridge rose up on the ocean floor. The ridge is still very active, as all my links pointed out, and they point it out in the headlines, God, just read the headlines!
This is why I don't try to teach pigs to learn the alphabet.
 
This is why I don't try to teach pigs to learn the alphabet.
you've got to get the religion...

you don't understand Jack. It all still works for them, you know why? cuz the heat went from the air into the water. You need to see that little secret then you can become a believer, all you have to do is realize that heat radiates from the air into water.... that's not stopping the heat from rising back into the air, heat still rises, except when it gets into the air, now that we have the carbon 12 isotope in this industrial revolution carbon dioxide, it radiates all the heat back downward into the water, that's why the water is warm, it all comes from the air... and that 1100 mile long split in the ocean floor spewing up 3000 degree gas is just incidental, it just isn't important enough to do anything, even after you realize it provided enough heat to do all the melting and then some, well, let's just suppress that information, it all comes from right wing websites so don't listen to it, ignore that 1100 mountain ridge still pushing up on the ocean floor, that doesn't count - nope it is all this heat that can't rise anymore, it is trapped in the atmosphere, that's why it never rains any more on earth, heat doesn't rise through this carbon 12 isotope, it just bounces all the heat back into the water, thunderstorms are a thing of the past, welcome to the brave new world of climate change.

... and they really believe this.

for my money, flat earthers make far more sense.
 
Exactly, Al Gore and his airplane that spews more gunk into the air than Mount St Helens, and lives in a house with a footprint the size of some small towns. And Leonardo de Cappuccino, who has a yacht bigger than the QE-2.

That may reveal those two men as opportunistic and hypocritical, but it doesn't change the reality.
 
And when it's Springtime in Alaska, it's 40 below.

Average April temperature in the Arctic is actually about 10 deg Fahrenheit ... still below freezing but not as cold as you claim ... and the average for the last 5 years is more than 4 deg higher than the overall average ... and then of course there's summer.
 
That may reveal those two men as opportunistic and hypocritical, but it doesn't change the reality.
what reality? Carbon dioxide does not heat the atmosphere, never did, never will, carbon dioxide does not change the balance of heat retained at the earth's surface... if carbon dioxide really did that, we all would never have been born, the earth's surface would have burned to a crisp millions of years ago... you are following a hoax. shake out of it.
 
Average April temperature in the Arctic is actually about 10 deg Fahrenheit ... still below freezing but not as cold as you claim ... and the average for the last 5 years is more than 4 deg higher than the overall average ... and then of course there's summer.
And the average year round air temps for the Arctic Circle is sub zero degrees Fahrenheit ... not just below freezing, but over 30 degrees Fahrenheit below freezing. Dead of winter air temps at the North Pole are 50-60 degrees below zero.
 
what reality? Carbon dioxide does not heat the atmosphere, never did, never will, carbon dioxide does not change the balance of heat retained at the earth's surface... if carbon dioxide really did that, we all would never have been born, the earth's surface would have burned to a crisp millions of years ago... you are following a hoax. shake out of it.

Both basic physics and the consensus of the scientific community say otherwise.
 
And the average year round air temps for the Arctic Circle is sub zero degrees Fahrenheit ... not just below freezing, but over 30 degrees Fahrenheit below freezing. Dead of winter air temps at the North Pole are 50-60 degrees below zero.

And the North Pole is covered with ice, just as one might expect.
 
Average April temperature in the Arctic is actually about 10 deg Fahrenheit ... still below freezing but not as cold as you claim ... and the average for the last 5 years is more than 4 deg higher than the overall average ... and then of course there's summer.
 
So, what makes you think it is something written by an infamous non-scientist upper-class British twit on a disreputable right-wing anti-science blog? OK. I guess that explains it.
You believe your bullshit and I'll believe mine.
 
Did you mean to say Captain Crunch.
http://www.capncrunch.com/
My guess is you do more reps on Captain Crunch than on anything else.
Nope. Give them a try some time:

http://ironmind.com/product-info/grip-strength-training-tools/captains-of-crush-grippers/

I like to leave my #2 Gripper on my desk at work -- in addition to giving me something to fiddle with when I'm bored on conference calls, it provides comic relief when people come to visit. Frequently, guys who lift will come in an try it, and almost none of them can get it closed even once.

Grip strength is supposed to be a decent indicator of overall health.

http://today.uconn.edu/2011/06/grip-strength-is-good-indicator-of-overall-health/
 
Nope. Give them a try some time:

http://ironmind.com/product-info/grip-strength-training-tools/captains-of-crush-grippers/

I like to leave my #2 Gripper on my desk at work -- in addition to giving me something to fiddle with when I'm bored on conference calls, it provides comic relief when people come to visit. Frequently, guys who lift will come in an try it, and almost none of them can get it closed even once.

Grip strength is supposed to be a decent indicator of overall health.

http://today.uconn.edu/2011/06/grip-strength-is-good-indicator-of-overall-health/
Ark: Grip strength is supposed to be a decent indicator of overall health.

JD: Not mental health, obviously.
 
You lazy son-of-a-gun. I did Link the evidence, I even copy pasted it into posts, I asked you three or four times if you had read any of it, you keep repeating the same mistakes, you haven't acknowledged any of the links or having clicked on a single one, and then you have the unmitigated gall to ask me to ""By all means, link to the evidence supporting that."


I looked at your links. You know perfectly well that I did, because I pointed out some of the embarrassing things about them to you (e.g., your reliance on someone who fit the exact profile I'd discussed of a bored retired petroleum worker masquerading as some sort of climate expert). The links didn't support your statement. So, if you have evidence supporting your statement by all means link to it.

I don't seem to understand basic concepts of air and water circulation but I guess I stumbled onto the severe angle of reflection of the sun's rays at the North Pole... interesting, seeing as I stumbled onto that point many years ago and you resisted it all these years until this post.

Hehehehahaahaaahaaa!!! You stumbled onto it "years ago," and you think that's a point of pride?! This is elementary-school-level science we're talking about. Literally, it's the kind of thing you cover in third grade when you ask why it's warmer at the equator and colder at the poles. If this was something new for you a few years ago, and you're more than a few years out of elementary school, it explains a lot.

Explain all you want where the heat came from

It came mostly from warm ocean currents. Duh.

... you still don't have enough heat in the air to melt any ice.

In the summer, there's plenty of heat in the air to melt plenty of ice. In the winter, the air is cold enough to freeze water, but it is contending with warm currents coming from the south. In past eras, this cycle was in something close to a state of equilibrium, where an average winter's freeze was about equal to an average summer's melt, such that the overall icecap didn't grow or shrink a lot from one year to the next. But guess what happens when the air and the water both warm thanks to global warming? Yeah, that's right: in the summer, there's more melting than there is freezing in the winter. This results in gradual long-term reductions of ice cover. This is, of course, not a unique phenomenon when it comes to sea ice in the Arctic. The general trend for glaciers all over the world is one of retreat. They're not all sitting on top of increasingly active volcanoes. They're just responding to the same global warming trends the Arctic sea ice is.
 
what reality? Carbon dioxide does not heat the atmosphere, never did, never will, carbon dioxide does not change the balance of heat retained at the earth's surface... if carbon dioxide really did that, we all would never have been born, the earth's surface would have burned to a crisp millions of years ago... you are following a hoax. shake out of it.

Besides anyone with an elementary schooler's grasp of physics, you know who else says CO2 does heat the atmosphere?

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/settled-science-update.101600/page-7#post-1856884

You do!

I'm sure the inconsistency doesn't bother you, though, because it's not about truth for you, it's about saying what's convenient to advance the narrative fed to you by the oil companies.
 
The water is warmer because the air has warmed around the globe. That's what the scientists believe. You want to imagine the existence of some un-observed vast uptick in geothermal heat under the pole, even though all the evidence we'd expect to see if that were the case just isn't there. We don't see deeper temps rising faster than shallower ones, as we would if the water column was heating from below. We see the opposite. We don't see an uptick in earthquakes in the area, as we would expect if there were more geothermal activity. We don't see the atmospheric and water chemistry changes we'd expect to see, if that were the case, either. What we see is just what we'd expect to see if the AGW theory were correct: we see warming in the vast majority of places around the globe, taking place across the course of decades, including ocean warming that's more intense near the surface (where being insulated by warmer air would make a difference), and less intense near the floor (where the heat change would be greatest if the heat were coming from below). You took your shot in the dark. The data proved it wrong. That's science for you. You can go on throwing all the emotion you want at that theory you desperately wish had been true. But that won't change the data.



You just contradicted yourself. You said the only thing that retains heat in the atmosphere is water, and then said that 5% of what retains heat in the atmosphere isn't water. It's like you can't even keep command of your BS from the beginning of a sentence to the end.
I said the only thing that retains heat in the atmosphere is water... then I defined what I meant by that, 95% of all heat retention in the atmosphere happens via water vapor; only a lawyer would find a contradiction in that statement.

Here's that data again that you say proves there was no relevant geo-thermal activity under the ice cap...

Underwater volcanoes melting Arctic Ice, says geologist
JANUARY 20, 2016 (Link)


Underwater Volcanoes Heating the Arctic Ocean
SEPTEMBER 29, 2015 (Link)


Hotbed of Volcanic Activity Found Beneath Arctic Ocean
John Roach
for National Geographic News
June 25, 2003
(Link)


Are Undersea Volcanoes a Cause of Melting Sea Ice?
By Harry Valentine 2014-09-11 (Link)


Volcanoes Erupt Beneath Arctic Ice
By Jeanna Bryner, Live Science Managing Editor | June 27, 2008 01:05pm ET (Link)
 
Both basic physics and the consensus of the scientific community say otherwise.
basic physics does not say heat stopped rising in the atmosphere. Your consensus of scientific community is a targeted group of politically motivated scientists.
 
basic physics does not say heat stopped rising in the atmosphere. Your consensus of scientific community is a targeted group of politically motivated scientists.

Nobody claims that heat stopped dissipating from the (warm) troposphere to the (cold) stratosphere and outer space. It's a question of how rapidly it does so.
 
Back
Top