New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Settled Science Update

basic physics does not say heat stopped rising in the atmosphere. Your consensus of scientific community is a targeted group of politically motivated scientists.

What political motivation do you think is shared by virtually every scientist, of virtually every political leaning, in virtually every country in the world?
 
I looked at your links. You know perfectly well that I did, because I pointed out some of the embarrassing things about them to you (e.g., your reliance on someone who fit the exact profile I'd discussed of a bored retired petroleum worker masquerading as some sort of climate expert). The links didn't support your statement. So, if you have evidence supporting your statement by all means link to it.



Hehehehahaahaaahaaa!!! You stumbled onto it "years ago," and you think that's a point of pride?! This is elementary-school-level science we're talking about. Literally, it's the kind of thing you cover in third grade when you ask why it's warmer at the equator and colder at the poles. If this was something new for you a few years ago, and you're more than a few years out of elementary school, it explains a lot.



It came mostly from warm ocean currents. Duh.



In the summer, there's plenty of heat in the air to melt plenty of ice. In the winter, the air is cold enough to freeze water, but it is contending with warm currents coming from the south. In past eras, this cycle was in something close to a state of equilibrium, where an average winter's freeze was about equal to an average summer's melt, such that the overall icecap didn't grow or shrink a lot from one year to the next. But guess what happens when the air and the water both warm thanks to global warming? Yeah, that's right: in the summer, there's more melting than there is freezing in the winter. This results in gradual long-term reductions of ice cover. This is, of course, not a unique phenomenon when it comes to sea ice in the Arctic. The general trend for glaciers all over the world is one of retreat. They're not all sitting on top of increasingly active volcanoes. They're just responding to the same global warming trends the Arctic sea ice is.
Besides anyone with an elementary schooler's grasp of physics, you know who else says CO2 does heat the atmosphere?

https://www.politicaljack.com/threads/settled-science-update.101600/page-7#post-1856884

You do!

I'm sure the inconsistency doesn't bother you, though, because it's not about truth for you, it's about saying what's convenient to advance the narrative fed to you by the oil companies.
If you have to twist my words into a pretzel to make your theory work... and that's what you are doing. And it still doesn't work.

Carbon Dioxide is still carbon dioxide, different isotopes of carbon dioxide always existed, oil spews out into the ocean floor, always has, and there are microbes that feed on oil, there is a moth larvae that feeds on plastic, the industrial revolution did not change carbon dioxide into a different element; today's carbon dioxide is not different from carbon dioxide a million years ago; a million years ago, 95% of heat retention in the atmosphere was due to water vapor, today 95% of heat retention in the atmosphere is due to water vapor, a million years ago 99% of our atmosphere was nitrogen and oxygen, today 99% of our atmosphere is nitrogen and oxygen... a million years ago, heat rose from evaporation of ocean surfaces, then cooled from condensation in the upper biosphere, and heat still rises today the same way.

The earth's surface is not going to burn to a crisp. We are on a global warming spike and it will lead to a global cooling spike, like it always has for millions of years. You are listening to propaganda from the global elites, the same global elites who told us we are headed for another ice age, then switched it to, the earth is burning up.

gullible
 
What political motivation do you think is shared by virtually every scientist, of virtually every political leaning, in virtually every country in the world?
I might be able to answer that if you can ever settle on a theory and not change it ten times in every thread we post in. What is it that you say they are saying?
 
Nobody claims that heat stopped dissipating from the (warm) troposphere to the (cold) stratosphere and outer space. It's a question of how rapidly it does so.
heat stopped rising at the same speed heat always has risen at in the atmosphere? No it hasn't. If you have to change the laws of thermodynamics to make a theory work, the theory doesn't work.
 
If you have to twist my words into a pretzel to make your theory work... and that's what you are doing. And it still doesn't work.

Carbon Dioxide is still carbon dioxide, different isotopes of carbon dioxide always existed, oil spews out into the ocean floor, always has, and there are microbes that feed on oil, there is a moth larvae that feeds on plastic, the industrial revolution did not change carbon dioxide into a different element; today's carbon dioxide is not different from carbon dioxide a million years ago; a million years ago, 95% of heat retention in the atmosphere was due to water vapor, today 95% of heat retention in the atmosphere is due to water vapor, a million years ago 99% of our atmosphere was nitrogen and oxygen, today 99% of our atmosphere is nitrogen and oxygen... a million years ago, heat rose from evaporation of ocean surfaces, then cooled from condensation in the upper biosphere, and heat still rises today the same way.

The earth's surface is not going to burn to a crisp. We are on a global warming spike and it will lead to a global cooling spike, like it always has for millions of years. You are listening to propaganda from the global elites, the same global elites who told us we are headed for another ice age, then switched it to, the earth is burning up.

gullible

Get back to me when you make up your mind whether CO2 causes the atmosphere to warm or not.
 
heat stopped rising at the same speed heat always has risen at in the atmosphere? No it hasn't. If you have to change the laws of thermodynamics to make a theory work, the theory doesn't work.

https://books.google.com/books?id=ba6PeTY2slYC&pg=PR11&lpg=PR11&dq="heat+rises"++illiteracy&source=bl&ots=gpZVnOxR7E&sig=z-l8U95xIjb7asW3f56c9WvqOIA&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjQ2t7u9cfTAhWn6YMKHRbwAPMQ6AEIHzAB#v=onepage&q=%22heat%20rises%22%20%20illiteracy&f=false
"Heat rises" is scientifically illiterate as has been pointed out to you repeatedly. What heat does is diffuse in any direction according to the heat equation. The actual laws of thermodynamics say that the rate of heat diffusion is variable.
 
I might be able to answer that if you can ever settle on a theory and not change it ten times in every thread we post in. What is it that you say they are saying?

1. Greenhouse gases trap heat reflected by the Earth in the atmosphere.
2. Hydrocarbon burning has led to increased CO2 concentrations.
3. These have led to warming of the Earth's surface (and more evaporation and methane release which means more potent greenhouse gases).
4. Climate models with a strong track record of success predict increasingly dire consequences as the average global temperature stabilizes at higher and higher points.

I'm not the one who's gone back and forth on this ... that would be you (prevaricating on whether CO2 warms the atmosphere for example).
 
you are saying, that all evidence of an 1100 mountain ridge - that now has a name - is false?

No.

What are you refuting?

I'm asking for evidence that its heat output increase is anywhere close to what would be needed to explain the ice meltage.

yeah, the freezing cold air at the North Pole is what you think melted the ice.

If you're too dumb to understand that I've repeatedly cited warmer ocean currents as a cause, why should I try to explain that to you over and over again? You've fixated on some childish talking points and are intent on deploying them no matter how off-topic they may be.

Anyway, as to the heat requirements, let's do a little math (I know, I know, math isn't really a conservative strength, but I'll walk you through it.) Since around 1980, Arctic sea ice extent has been declining by about 42,700 square kilometers per year. On average, arctic sea ice is around 2.5 meters thick. So, using simple math, that's 106,750,000,000 cubic meters of ice, which would have a mass of about 9.810325e+13 kg. Let's say average temperature of that ice is -19 Celsius (consistent with your figure about average air temperature). So, how much energy would be required to raise that ice up to 0 Celsius and then melt it?

Well, it's 4.184 joules to raise one gram of water one degree. So, 4184 for one kilo one degree. 79,496 joules for one kilo 19 degrees. So,
7.798816e+18 to bring the full amount to the melting point. It's 334 joules to melt a gram of ice at 0 degrees (the state change imposes an energy cost of its own), so 33,400 joules per kilogram or 3.2766486e+18 joules to melt it all. Adding the two together, the total energy needed would be 1.1075465e+19 joules per year, to account for that melting.
If you're looking ultimately to the sun to explain the melting, as mainstream global warming theory does, that's a piece of cake. The earth is hit with around 1.50336e+22 joules of energy per day from the sun. But how about volcanic activity? To give it its best chance, consider Krakatoa, the biggest volcanic eruption in modern times. It went off with 8*10^17 joules of energy. So, you'd need 18,792 Krakatoas per year, or about two per hour to melt that ice. Considering that even one explosion like that is impressive enough that we haven't surpassed it for well over a hundred years, on land, do you think we might notice two per hour going off?

Anyway, all the research scientists who are actually working on studying the Grakkel ridge (as opposed to the retired petroleum geologists sitting in their basement and typing blog entries to right-wing websites about it) say that it hasn't influenced meltage. Here's an example, from Vera Schlindwein, who is an expert in such volcanoes and has been specifically studying this one:

I am currently working on a reconstruction of the Gakkel volcanic episode from 1999-2007 integrating seismicity data and water column observations and I have started to look at sea ice images as well. We know pretty well when the 1999 eruption took place; it will be easy to check for effects on the sea ice. I doubt there will be such effects:

In 2001, the volcano at 85E was still erupting explosively, although in a less vigorous mode (Schlindwein et al., GRL, 2005). The associated event plume in the water column is well surveyed and described in Edmonds et al. (Nature 2003). That plume of relatively “warm” water – temperature anomaly less than 1/10 degree – reaches a minimum water depth of about 1700 m, its center being around 2500 m water depth. These data make it very evident that the sea ice is not influenced by the heat released from the ongoing eruption.
​
Jamie Morison, who also studies it, has similar thoughts:

It occurs to me that we have primary evidence that heat from the bottom is not reaching the ice. Temperature profiles from virtually everywhere in the Arctic Ocean display a maximum temperature at a depth from 200-400 [meters]. This is associated with the Atlantic Water entering the basin from the Norwegian Sea. Fundamental laws of physics require that below the depth of this maximum, the heat flux is downward. Very near the bottom temperatures have been found to increase with depth indicating a small upward heat flux from geothermal sources, which help to heat only the very deepest water.

The heat flux above the Atlantic temperature maximum is upward. The rate of this flux of Atlantic Water heat flux is variable depending on depth of the maximum and overlying stratification (stratification is controlled by salinity in the Arctic Ocean). Treshnikov estimated it from Atlantic Water heat content to be a couple of Watt/m2 in much of the Euarasian Basin. It is smaller farther from Fram Strait and greater near Fram Strait. How this flux changes is potentially very important to the ice cover. Changes in geothermal heat flux are not​

Look, I get it. You got excited when one of your right-wing blogs threw you some wild speculation that you hoped would undermine some science that made you uncomfortable. But there's a reason the speculation came from a bored retiree who has done nothing at all to study the phenomenon, or even to become conversant in the science, rather than from an actual expert in the topic. The actual experts regarding undersea volcanoes, oceanography, and this particular eruption have weighed in, and they're all confidently saying your crackpot is wrong:

https://dotearth.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/07/03/a-last-round-on-fire-under-north-pole-ice/

Dr. Reves-Sohn:

My perspective is thus that on the basin-wide scale there is no chance that these volcanic eruptions/explosions had anything to do with changes in ice cover, for the reasons described by Peter Winsor et al.​

As to your specific assumption that the heat from those volcanoes must rise directly upward and melt the ice, it doesn't work that way, for the same reason that you don't see a smoke-stack's plume rising straight up -- it rises to a certain height and then spreads horizontally:

smokestackplume.jpg

I know it pisses you off that the smokestack there isn't following the ultra-simplified rules of physics as you've been able to understand them, but that's the real world.
1200px-Gaussian_Plume_%28SVG%29.svg.png

And that's what's happening with the sub-surface volcanoes. From Peter Winsor:

Heated water from such events rises vertically and mixes with ambient waters much like a smoke stack in winter until they reach equilibrium density with surrounding water masses at which they spread out horizontally. We have solid measurements that this water spread out horizontally around ~2600 m depth.

As Jamie [Morison] mentioned, water at 300 m depth is much warmer, has a greater heat content and is continuously present but is still on average unable to contribute to any larger heat flux to the underside of the ice, due to the strong stratification of the upper Arctic. Any resemblance of weaker ice cover in 1999 over the Gakkel area is purely coincidental, nothing else.​

Given my own back-of-the-napkin calculations of the kind of energy that would be need to account for that melting sea ice, and the wild mismatch with the kind of energy put out by known volcanoes, what they're saying sounds right.
 
I said the only thing that retains heat in the atmosphere is water... then I defined what I meant by that, 95% of all heat retention in the atmosphere happens via water vapor; only a lawyer would find a contradiction in that statement.

No any sane person would recognize that it's a contradiction. Something cannot be the only cause if there are other causes. This is just common sense.

As for your links, I already saw all of them. Not one show energy output sufficient to account for the melting. The first quotes some idle, numbers-free speculation by bored retiree James Kamis. The second includes no data suggesting the heat reaching the surface is enough to account for any significant portion of the meltage. The third is quality reporting, but never even mentions the idea of it being responsible for ice meltage, nor does it provide any numbers on heat output that would make that plausible. The fourth is by a journalist whose experience is doing research in the transportation industry. Again, no figures about energy output. The lasst one specifically quotes the actual scientists studying this saying they don't think there's any significant connection with melting sea ice:

'"We don't believe the volcanoes had much effect on the overlying ice," Reeves-Sohn told LiveScience...'​
 
https://books.google.com/books?id=ba6PeTY2slYC&pg=PR11&lpg=PR11&dq="heat+rises"++illiteracy&source=bl&ots=gpZVnOxR7E&sig=z-l8U95xIjb7asW3f56c9WvqOIA&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjQ2t7u9cfTAhWn6YMKHRbwAPMQ6AEIHzAB#v=onepage&q=%22heat%20rises%22%20%20illiteracy&f=false
"Heat rises" is scientifically illiterate as has been pointed out to you repeatedly. What heat does is diffuse in any direction according to the heat equation. The actual laws of thermodynamics say that the rate of heat diffusion is variable.
As far as I can tell, he's someone who was a middling science student in junior high and then stopped learning science entirely, until reaching old age and discovering the mud puddles of denialist blogs to wallow in. His view of science ("heat rises") is about where a mid-level seventh grader would be. He grasped the simplified rules of thumb, but had no true grasp on what was happening.
 
No.



I'm asking for evidence that its heat output increase is anywhere close to what would be needed to explain the ice meltage.



If you're too dumb to understand that I've repeatedly cited warmer ocean currents as a cause, why should I try to explain that to you over and over again? You've fixated on some childish talking points and are intent on deploying them no matter how off-topic they may be.

Anyway, as to the heat requirements, let's do a little math (I know, I know, math isn't really a conservative strength, but I'll walk you through it.) Since around 1980, Arctic sea ice extent has been declining by about 42,700 square kilometers per year. On average, arctic sea ice is around 2.5 meters thick. So, using simple math, that's 106,750,000,000 cubic meters of ice, which would have a mass of about 9.810325e+13 kg. Let's say average temperature of that ice is -19 Celsius (consistent with your figure about average air temperature). So, how much energy would be required to raise that ice up to 0 Celsius and then melt it?

Well, it's 4.184 joules to raise one gram of water one degree. So, 4184 for one kilo one degree. 79,496 joules for one kilo 19 degrees. So,
7.798816e+18 to bring the full amount to the melting point. It's 334 joules to melt a gram of ice at 0 degrees (the state change imposes an energy cost of its own), so 33,400 joules per kilogram or 3.2766486e+18 joules to melt it all. Adding the two together, the total energy needed would be 1.1075465e+19 joules per year, to account for that melting.
If you're looking ultimately to the sun to explain the melting, as mainstream global warming theory does, that's a piece of cake. The earth is hit with around 1.50336e+22 joules of energy per day from the sun. But how about volcanic activity? To give it its best chance, consider Krakatoa, the biggest volcanic eruption in modern times. It went off with 8*10^17 joules of energy. So, you'd need 18,792 Krakatoas per year, or about two per hour to melt that ice. Considering that even one explosion like that is impressive enough that we haven't surpassed it for well over a hundred years, on land, do you think we might notice two per hour going off?

Anyway, all the research scientists who are actually working on studying the Grakkel ridge (as opposed to the retired petroleum geologists sitting in their basement and typing blog entries to right-wing websites about it) say that it hasn't influenced meltage. Here's an example, from Vera Schlindwein, who is an expert in such volcanoes and has been specifically studying this one:

I am currently working on a reconstruction of the Gakkel volcanic episode from 1999-2007 integrating seismicity data and water column observations and I have started to look at sea ice images as well. We know pretty well when the 1999 eruption took place; it will be easy to check for effects on the sea ice. I doubt there will be such effects:

In 2001, the volcano at 85E was still erupting explosively, although in a less vigorous mode (Schlindwein et al., GRL, 2005). The associated event plume in the water column is well surveyed and described in Edmonds et al. (Nature 2003). That plume of relatively “warm” water – temperature anomaly less than 1/10 degree – reaches a minimum water depth of about 1700 m, its center being around 2500 m water depth. These data make it very evident that the sea ice is not influenced by the heat released from the ongoing eruption.
​
Jamie Morison, who also studies it, has similar thoughts:

It occurs to me that we have primary evidence that heat from the bottom is not reaching the ice. Temperature profiles from virtually everywhere in the Arctic Ocean display a maximum temperature at a depth from 200-400 [meters]. This is associated with the Atlantic Water entering the basin from the Norwegian Sea. Fundamental laws of physics require that below the depth of this maximum, the heat flux is downward. Very near the bottom temperatures have been found to increase with depth indicating a small upward heat flux from geothermal sources, which help to heat only the very deepest water.

The heat flux above the Atlantic temperature maximum is upward. The rate of this flux of Atlantic Water heat flux is variable depending on depth of the maximum and overlying stratification (stratification is controlled by salinity in the Arctic Ocean). Treshnikov estimated it from Atlantic Water heat content to be a couple of Watt/m2 in much of the Euarasian Basin. It is smaller farther from Fram Strait and greater near Fram Strait. How this flux changes is potentially very important to the ice cover. Changes in geothermal heat flux are not​

Look, I get it. You got excited when one of your right-wing blogs threw you some wild speculation that you hoped would undermine some science that made you uncomfortable. But there's a reason the speculation came from a bored retiree who has done nothing at all to study the phenomenon, or even to become conversant in the science, rather than from an actual expert in the topic. The actual experts regarding undersea volcanoes, oceanography, and this particular eruption have weighed in, and they're all confidently saying your crackpot is wrong:

https://dotearth.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/07/03/a-last-round-on-fire-under-north-pole-ice/

Dr. Reves-Sohn:

My perspective is thus that on the basin-wide scale there is no chance that these volcanic eruptions/explosions had anything to do with changes in ice cover, for the reasons described by Peter Winsor et al.​

As to your specific assumption that the heat from those volcanoes must rise directly upward and melt the ice, it doesn't work that way, for the same reason that you don't see a smoke-stack's plume rising straight up -- it rises to a certain height and then spreads horizontally:

smokestackplume.jpg

I know it pisses you off that the smokestack there isn't following the ultra-simplified rules of physics as you've been able to understand them, but that's the real world.
1200px-Gaussian_Plume_%28SVG%29.svg.png

And that's what's happening with the sub-surface volcanoes. From Peter Winsor:

Heated water from such events rises vertically and mixes with ambient waters much like a smoke stack in winter until they reach equilibrium density with surrounding water masses at which they spread out horizontally. We have solid measurements that this water spread out horizontally around ~2600 m depth.

As Jamie [Morison] mentioned, water at 300 m depth is much warmer, has a greater heat content and is continuously present but is still on average unable to contribute to any larger heat flux to the underside of the ice, due to the strong stratification of the upper Arctic. Any resemblance of weaker ice cover in 1999 over the Gakkel area is purely coincidental, nothing else.​

Given my own back-of-the-napkin calculations of the kind of energy that would be need to account for that melting sea ice, and the wild mismatch with the kind of energy put out by known volcanoes, what they're saying sounds right.
this is so convoluted, it is like chasing a squirrel around a tree. You are not refuting that there was an 1100 mile ridge that pushed up on the ocean floor directly under the ice, or that it is still active? But you still don't think that represents very much heat? You are not refuting that the heat rises to the surface, are you? You are lying somehow, you do that, you tell lies and hide them, and then taunt me that I can't figure out how you are lying ... so that makes me stupid.

Or maybe you really think that a tiny little 1100 mile crack in the earth's crust, spewing up 3000 degree Fahrenheit gas along an entire mountain ridge, would not represent any real volume of heat. Is that what you really think? Because that's what you are typing, but no one is this stupid, so if it comes down to your logic, the exact way you are stating it, then you are beyond help. The actual entry point of Mt St Helens eruption was only one mile at the most, so plug in 1100 Mt St Helens eruptions into your quick math, and these are ongoing vents in the ocean floor, not a three day hiccup.

I can't fathom what you are thinking about warm water currents from surrounding oceans ... are you saying the ice cap was melted by those warm water currents instead of the geo-thermal activity? What temp do you think ocean water is at the Arctic Circle?

You are saying fundamentally ridiculous things, I can't imagine what you are thinking, I can't imagine how in your head you have it calculated that heat in the air at the equator is descending into the water instead of rising up from it, and then that water is travelling to the poles and is melting the polar ice caps. Is that what you think?
 
Get back to me when you make up your mind whether CO2 causes the atmosphere to warm or not.
I already explained this to you in previous threads. You know what I think, I think there is an insignificant increase in air temp from CO2 that doesn't now nor ever has resulted in global warming.
 
No any sane person would recognize that it's a contradiction. Something cannot be the only cause if there are other causes. This is just common sense.

As for your links, I already saw all of them. Not one show energy output sufficient to account for the melting. The first quotes some idle, numbers-free speculation by bored retiree James Kamis. The second includes no data suggesting the heat reaching the surface is enough to account for any significant portion of the meltage. The third is quality reporting, but never even mentions the idea of it being responsible for ice meltage, nor does it provide any numbers on heat output that would make that plausible. The fourth is by a journalist whose experience is doing research in the transportation industry. Again, no figures about energy output. The lasst one specifically quotes the actual scientists studying this saying they don't think there's any significant connection with melting sea ice:

'"We don't believe the volcanoes had much effect on the overlying ice," Reeves-Sohn told LiveScience...'​
You are acting like this is a legal debate in which you can win points by splitting hairs. I don't think you are being honest because I remember saying something like, "to this degree" - what ever - bottom line is water vapor retains 95% of the heat in the atmosphere. Carbon Dioxide is in a group of other elements that combine to retain the remaining 5%.

I originally made that search when you denied that there was geo-thermal activity under the Arctic ice cap. Now you are trying to say the data doesn't show any relevant volume of heat. Alright, it is a recent opening, scientists are just barely aware it exists, what makes you think anyone has measured the heat source? Of course no one has. So that proves it is tiny? Logic like that, the rest of us call that lying; but I know you lawyers think you are just winning, not lying. But for the rest of us, an 1100 mile long vent of 3000 degree (F) gas in the ocean floor, is nothing to be sneezed at.
 
https://books.google.com/books?id=ba6PeTY2slYC&pg=PR11&lpg=PR11&dq="heat+rises"++illiteracy&source=bl&ots=gpZVnOxR7E&sig=z-l8U95xIjb7asW3f56c9WvqOIA&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjQ2t7u9cfTAhWn6YMKHRbwAPMQ6AEIHzAB#v=onepage&q=%22heat%20rises%22%20%20illiteracy&f=false
"Heat rises" is scientifically illiterate as has been pointed out to you repeatedly. What heat does is diffuse in any direction according to the heat equation. The actual laws of thermodynamics say that the rate of heat diffusion is variable.
And that equation hasn't changed, has it? Or has it?
 
Last edited:
1. Greenhouse gases trap heat reflected by the Earth in the atmosphere.
2. Hydrocarbon burning has led to increased CO2 concentrations.
3. These have led to warming of the Earth's surface (and more evaporation and methane release which means more potent greenhouse gases).
4. Climate models with a strong track record of success predict increasingly dire consequences as the average global temperature stabilizes at higher and higher points.

I'm not the one who's gone back and forth on this ... that would be you (prevaricating on whether CO2 warms the atmosphere for example).
1) define "trap heat" (and this is where it keeps changing)

2) Global warming has always led to increased CO2 levels... no big deal.

3) CO2 does not lead to global warming and never has. (so it hasn't led to more evaporation, but wtf? more evaporation = more cooling. More greenhouse gases will not lead to global warming either; greenhouse gases do not result in global warming... if they did, the earth would have burned millions of years ago)

4) Climate models are long term weather forecasts. Long term weather forecasts beyond a month are notoriously wrong.
 
1) define "trap heat" (and this is where it keeps changing)

2) Global warming has always led to increased CO2 levels... no big deal.

3) CO2 does not lead to global warming and never has. (so it hasn't led to more evaporation, but wtf? more evaporation = more cooling. More greenhouse gases will not lead to global warming either; greenhouse gases do not result in global warming... if they did, the earth would have burned millions of years ago)

4) Climate models are long term weather forecasts. Long term weather forecasts beyond a month are notoriously wrong.

Basic greenhouse effect.
http://www.windows2universe.org/earth/climate/greenhouse_effect_gases.html

Climate models.

https://www.skepticalscience.com/climate-models-intermediate.htm

The rest of your post is just the same talking posts you continue to repeat in defiance of all evidence.
 
Nope. What has changed is the variables in that equation.
the variables have always been present and the variables have always been changing, but the way heat expands into open space; the rate at which heat rises, has not changed... unless you break this law of physics.
Basic greenhouse effect.
http://www.windows2universe.org/earth/climate/greenhouse_effect_gases.html

Climate models.

https://www.skepticalscience.com/climate-models-intermediate.htm

The rest of your post is just the same talking posts you continue to repeat in defiance of all evidence.
I don't pass on talking points, I post my own opinions.
 
Back
Top