New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Simple question on 14th Amendment...

Haha! Every other fricking idea you come down on the side of the Euro-socialists - EXCEPT this one. Which is why I consider your every argument intellectually bankrupt.
No, there are several issues on which I come down on the side of the unusual American rule instead of the more common systems abroad. In addition to immigration rules, I like the US First Amendment, which is uncommon in at least two ways: (1) in most countries there are limits on speech that wouldn't fly here (e.g., it's illegal to deny the holocaust, or ridicule a religion, or slander the monarchy), and (2) in most countries there are problematic entanglements between church and state (e.g., taxes collected by the state to fund churches.) There are things that the US does right that other advanced nations can learn from and things that we do wrong where we could learn from other advanced nations. Obviously, I also favor a system where taxpayers don't support a monarchy, and where no role in government can be inherited by birthright, which puts us well up on the Brits, for example.
 
Yes. I understand that's your assertion, but I'm asking what makes you think so. I mean, obviously the country has remained stable for very many generations with this rule and, as I pointed out, we're not currently experiencing any kind of apparent ramp-up in the problems associated with illegal immigration. Quite the contrary, illegal immigration is down, and many of the problems traditionally associated with illegal immigration have been declining, too. So, what cause do we have to think that this phenomenon is now unstable?

Wages have stagnated for 30 years (and salaries).

Technology to replace certain manual labor is 20 years behind where it should be.

Our schools are over burdened with children whose parents will never pay for their education in terms of their income taxed.

When those parents retire they will draw more out of SS and Medicare than they ever put in because of their low income.

Crime derived from illegal immigrants (and their progeny) greatly harms the nation and is out sized to their proportion.

Black citizens in terms of jobs and education are not given second chances because illegals take those opportunities.
 
No, there are several issues on which I come down on the side of the unusual American rule instead of the more common systems abroad. In addition to immigration rules, I like the US First Amendment, which is uncommon in at least two ways: (1) in most countries there are limits on speech that wouldn't fly here (e.g., it's illegal to deny the holocaust, or ridicule a religion, or slander the monarchy), and (2) in most countries there are problematic entanglements between church and state (e.g., taxes collected by the state to fund churches.) There are things that the US does right that other advanced nations can learn from and things that we do wrong where we could learn from other advanced nations. Obviously, I also favor a system where taxpayers don't support a monarchy, and where no role in government can be inherited by birthright, which puts us well up on the Brits, for example.

NOW IS WHEN EUROPE IS ASS BACKWARDS AND WE SHOULDN"T EMULATE THEM??!?!? NOW!!!

Ha ha

Maybe free speech created all the gun crime, bad educational results, bad economics and bad healthcare results that compare so poorly with Europe and that you LOVE Europe for.
 
Last edited:
Wages have stagnated for 30 years (and salaries).

No, there have been periods of stagnation, but also periods of advance. The Clinton era, for example, had strong wage growth despite it being an era with high illegal immigration (since the strong economy here and weak economy in Mexico was driving a lot of people across the border).

Technology to replace certain manual labor is 20 years behind where it should be.

In what sense do you mean it when you say "where it should be." I mean, if there are two ways to accomplish a piece of work, and one of them provides employment and an income to a person who needs it, and the other one is based on automation which enriches a few senior execs and shareholders somewhere, is the latter definitely the better option? For example, if I can have my lawn mowed by an immigrant who is happy for the work and will use it to support a family, or, for about the same cost, I can have my lawn mowed by a lawn-mowing robot, while the family is left in abject poverty, is that a better solution?

Our schools are over burdened with children whose parents will never pay for their education in terms of their income taxed.

What makes you think they're over-burdened? It was my understanding that school enrollment has been growing at less than the rate of population growth. And the schools seem, from the stats, to be doing a better job than in the past, with declining drop-out rates, coupled with steady test scores in the upper grades and rising test scores in the lower grades, as well as rising levels of students going on to higher education. What's the evidence for over-burdening?

Crime derived from illegal immigrants (and their progeny) greatly harms the nation and is out sized to their proportion.

What makes you think that? I suppose that since immigrant populations tend to be disproportionately young and male, and young and male populations tend to commit more crime, I'd expect a somewhat higher crime rate for those here illegally, but is there data to back that up?
 
No, there have been periods of stagnation, but also periods of advance. The Clinton era, for example, had strong wage growth despite it being an era with high illegal immigration (since the strong economy here and weak economy in Mexico was driving a lot of people across the border).



In what sense do you mean it when you say "where it should be." I mean, if there are two ways to accomplish a piece of work, and one of them provides employment and an income to a person who needs it, and the other one is based on automation which enriches a few senior execs and shareholders somewhere, is the latter definitely the better option? For example, if I can have my lawn mowed by an immigrant who is happy for the work and will use it to support a family, or, for about the same cost, I can have my lawn mowed by a lawn-mowing robot, while the family is left in abject poverty, is that a better solution?



What makes you think they're over-burdened? It was my understanding that school enrollment has been growing at less than the rate of population growth. And the schools seem, from the stats, to be doing a better job than in the past, with declining drop-out rates, coupled with steady test scores in the upper grades and rising test scores in the lower grades, as well as rising levels of students going on to higher education. What's the evidence for over-burdening?



What makes you think that? I suppose that since immigrant populations tend to be disproportionately young and male, and young and male populations tend to commit more crime, I'd expect a somewhat higher crime rate for those here illegally, but is there data to back that up?

Blah blah blah.

You have your free speech rights and I have mine but facts are facts. The financial burden of illegal immigration needs to end and reversed.
 
NOW IS WHEN EUROPE IS ASS BACKWARDS AND WE SHOULDN"T EMULATE THEM??!?!? NOW!!!

Ha ha

Maybe free speech created all the gun crime, bad educational results, bad economics and bad healthcare results that compare so poorly with Europe and that you LOVE Europe for.
Do you have any reason to think so? I mean, there's a pretty logical and obvious connection between the availability of guns and the frequency with which guns are used in crime. What evidence do you see that gun crime is instead being driven by free speech? I know it's fun to just throw this stuff out there, but it's not much use if you can't draw any rational mechanisms between the supposed cause and effect.
 
Blah blah blah.

You have your free speech rights and I have mine but facts are facts. The financial burden of illegal immigration needs to end and reversed.
I'll take your "blah blah blah" to mean "yeah, I know I"m out of my depth, so I'm not going to bother thinking about it." Fair enough.
 
I'll take your "blah blah blah" to mean "yeah, I know I"m out of my depth, so I'm not going to bother thinking about it." Fair enough.
No, you simply blah'ed the points. Facts are facts and illegal immigration is a very large financial burden now and even more so in the future.
 
Do you have any reason to think so? I mean, there's a pretty logical and obvious connection between the availability of guns and the frequency with which guns are used in crime. What evidence do you see that gun crime is instead being driven by free speech? I know it's fun to just throw this stuff out there, but it's not much use if you can't draw any rational mechanisms between the supposed cause and effect.
Obviously, from your point of view, if free speech was stifled you could get rid of the guns and change the healthcare system without those pesky opinions of others holding you back, duh. Just look at Europe. ha ha
 
No, you simply blah'ed the points. Facts are facts and illegal immigration is a very large financial burden now and even more so in the future.
I asked questions. You demonstrated that you don't think you're mentally capable of answering them. I'm simply acknowledging your humility in the face of your weak mind.
 
Obviously, from your point of view, if free speech was stifled you could get rid of the guns and change the healthcare system without those pesky opinions of others holding you back, duh. Just look at Europe. ha ha
I'm not aware of any European country where free speech limits apply to discussions of gun control and healthcare. Are you?
 
I asked questions. You demonstrated that you don't think you're mentally capable of answering them. I'm simply acknowledging your humility in the face of your weak mind.
You did't even get the point about stifling free speech getting you what you wanted which is a Europeanized United Stated. That is what I call simple.
 
I'm too lazy to look it up, but there is a clause in the constitution that says congress shall have the sole power to determine immigration policies. By that statement, even SCOTUS would be hard pressed to rule.
 
You did't even get the point about stifling free speech getting you what you wanted which is a Europeanized United Stated. That is what I call simple.
You missed the point again. Try harder. Thinking is a skill and can be mastered with practice.
 
The fourteenth amendment postdates that, and so it supersedes in the event of conflict.

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof

They are not subject to jurisdiction thereof because their parents are foreign nationals.
 
All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof

They are not subject to jurisdiction thereof because their parents are foreign nationals.
Incorrect. Here's a simple test for your theory. You're driving down the street when someone runs a red light and runs into your car, totaling it. You find out the other driver is a foreign national. Does this mean you have no ability to collect damages against him, even though the accident was clearly his fault? Could he simply make a 12(b)(2) civil procedure motion, claiming that any US court lacks personal jurisdiction against him?

https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp/rule_12

Of course not. It's well-established that when foreigners come into our borders, they submit to the jurisdiction of US law (federal law and the law of the state they're in). There are partial exceptions for diplomats and a few others:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diplomatic_immunity

However, assuming he wasn't a diplomat, he's subject to the jurisdiction of the US, notwithstanding being a foreign national. A court can enforce both civil and criminal judgments against him.
 
Back
Top