New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Support for redistribution?

Apologies...I was referring to subjective rather than objective.

Either way, you skirted the point I was making that in class the objectiveness of grading sets folk on MORE of an even ground than America's upward mobility paths and a good portion of the resistance in that upward mobility is humans willingness to subject others to their "isms"...that is especially true amongst conservatives who support organizations that implement racist policies for the sake of garnering votes.

Thx
 
How can they not be compatible? Why would one need a 4.0 GPA when others only have a 2.0? The majority of employers that pay attention to GPAs only require a 3.2 or 3.3...the highest I've seen required is a 3.5...so why would one need a 4.0? Why couldn't they give up...say 0.3 to help bring someone else up to a higher level?

Which of my premises is flawed?
 
Number_58: Luck had nothing to do with them becoming my children.

LeRoy: Huh?!?? How do you figure that? It's often referred to as the genetic lottery of life.
 
If you are trying to get into, say, the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, or the Naval Academy (the MOST selective instititution of higher education in America), sorry, but a 3.5 is not going to cut it. They only take the cream of the crop.

And besides that, you're missing the point he was making. When it comes to GPA, there IS an upper limit....even if it's not exactly 4.0 (as I explained). In the income distribution, there is NO upper limit. Theoretically, we could have a trillionaire someday. Bill Gates almost became the world's first centi-billionaire (worth $100 billion), before the dot.com crash.
 
Confusion! He THOUGHT you were arguing that there WERE no essays in physics or astronomy classes. He was disagreeing with that. It may have been triggered by your own confusion re: objective vs subjective.
 
I understand this is inresponse to polls showing that student arent for Redistributtion and I am willing to guess those students are not willing to redistribute thier income but those they deem wealthy Republicans...Not the Warren Buffets ofthe world who have the Majority of their money locked in a charitable trust and wont be paying taxes on that money.

Americans Oppose Income Redistribution to Fix Economy
Half say the government is doing too much, 43% too little to solve country's problems
by Dennis Jacobe, Chief EconomistPRINCETON, NJ -- When given a choice about how government should address the numerous economic difficulties facing today's consumer, Americans overwhelmingly -- by 84% to 13% -- prefer that the government focus on improving overall economic conditions and the jobs situation in the United States as opposed to taking steps to distribute wealth more evenly among Americans.

080627WealthRedistibution1_djp2sljxa.jpg

http://www.gallup.com/poll/108445/Americans-Oppose-Income-Redistribution-Fix-Economy.aspx


How ever I am willing to support student with 4.0 to give up their college credits so that others can have college degrees it would even out the playing field and no more valedictorians they others feel inferior!
 
I don't care what it's referred to...is there a possibility my son could have been born to someone else? Is there a chance that my daughter is actually your daughter but was just born to me? Luck had nothing to do with it.
 
So, if I'm born the son of a King, that means I get to be King next, right?

I thought we threw a little revolution some 240 years ago to get rid of those odious ideas. But maybe you want to set the clock back, and find a feudal aristocracy more congenial.

Your children may end up peasants, you know.

Because I don't think you're part of the 'natural' aristocracy.
 
And I call BS...I earned every penny I made, every promotion that I got, every degree that I earned.

that is especially true amongst conservatives who support organizations that implement racist policies for the sake of garnering votes.

Now, tell me which organization I support "that implement racist policies"...I'm conservative and since you've decided all conservatives think and act the same...tell me the name of the organization.
 
I already admitted that I read what I wanted instead of what it said...I apologized for that action...check above.
 
Ah, now you want to throw oranges in amongst the apples...YOU said Paris Hilton was lucky for being born a Hilton. To which I replied that luck had nothing to do with it.

btw, my kids probably wouldn't be high royalty...but rest assured, they would qualify for nobility. And, no, I don't believe in aristocracy...but, this country isn't the same as Old England either.
 
Ah, but you forget...my original post was a video of college students...not high school students. And, I don't care about "limits" this has nothing to do with limits since you enter the highest tax bracket whether you earn $388,350 or $7,000,000,000. Just like you have an A whether you get a 90% course grade or 100% course grade.

Spin it anyway you want...these college kids are okay when someone else is effected in a way they wouldn't want to be effected themselves. Same as the 90% don't concern themselves about screwing over the 10% because it doesn't effect them.
 
At MY school, 90% is an A MINUS.

But I still think you're missing the point with this:

Number_58: this has nothing to do with limits since you enter the highest tax bracket whether you earn $388,350 or $7,000,000,000.

LeRoy: Almost any 'progressive' would argue that someone earning $7,000,000,000 should be taxed at a substantially higher rate than someone making $388,350 per year. That is the whole point of progressive taxation. It is not the fault of the progressives that those two incomes are taxed at the same rate. I think you know who you should blame for that.
 
How can they not be compatible? Why would one need a 4.0 GPA when others only have a 2.0? The majority of employers that pay attention to GPAs only require a 3.2 or 3.3...the highest I've seen required is a 3.5...so why would one need a 4.0? Why couldn't they give up...say 0.3 to help bring someone else up to a higher level?

Which of my premises is flawed?

Because there is no upper limit on income and there is an upper limit on GPA.

Now if question in the video included your claim that a 3.5 is all that GPA score any of those questioned would ever need. I bet the interviewer would have received and different answer.
 
Paris Hilton couldn't choose to be born a Hilton; she couldn't work really hard to be born into a rich family. She did nothing to earn the wealth she will inherit; she essentially won a genetic lottery, with no need to buy a ticket. I call that luck.
 
Tell me...what have the progressives in Congress suggested the new tax system be? Obama himself limits it to $250,000...anyone above that is rich...regardless of your geographic location. I would suggest that I would live better on $150,000 where I live than what someone making $300,000 would in New York City, Chicago, Miami, or Los Angeles...

btw, link me to a university that grades on a scale that includes A-, B+, etc. I have attended three and as long as I got above a 89.9%, I got an A in the class.
 
So, your kids are lucky to have you as parents...because they could have been born to someone else? The were just fortunate that the numbers that came up matched the numbers YOU had selected? Going with the genetic lottery idea...I had as much of a chance to become the son of Hilton's parents as she had...she just had the right numbers on her ticket?
 
I seriously doubt it...the same experiment was offered in one of my philosophy classes...everyone who got an A on the exam was asked it they would give up the number of points above 90% to the rest of the class...they would get to keep their A, but it would also mean that others would earn the same grade after the point distribution. The results were the same as in the video...my professor preformed the experiment in several different classes and found none willing to do that. He's actually including these results in a book he is writing.
 
Back
Top