Does the United States count?
The United States has never required national registration, which is what Degs and I were discussing.
For those men who were allowed to own guns, the Founders had their own version of the “individual mandate” that has proved so controversial in President Obama’s health-care-reform law: they required the purchase of guns. A 1792 federal law mandated every eligible man to purchase a military-style gun and ammunition for his service in the citizen militia. Such men had to report for frequent musters—where their guns would be inspected and, yes, registered on public rolls.
Yes, that was a provision of the Militia Act of 1792. You really see it as a gun control law? If so, I'm fine with it -- force me to buy and M-4 Carbine, the current weapon of U.S. forces, and I'll buy one (but it entails allowing me to have a legally owned fully-automatic weapon). But no, the Militia Act of 1792 did not require musters. That
The problem for gun rights advocates is that, if you look at the language and custom at the time the Second Amendment was written, laws like the
Militia Act of 1792 pop up.
The problem for anti-gun advocates is that these laws requried the individual to own firearms, because the militia was seen as no different from the armed populace.
"Systems akin to registration were quite common at the time of the framing of the Constitution and the time of the ratification of the Bill of Rights," says
Dennis Henigan, vice president for law and policy at the
Brady Campaign and author of the new book
Lethal Logic. "Even before that the state militia statutes had the same kind of requirements, so they can track how well the militia was armed."
These "registrations" were again, not at the national level. I think you have to remember also that the 13th Amendment would not be passed for another 89 years, and that the provisions of the Bill of Rights generally did not apply at the state level. Many of the states of the period had established churches, just for example. The federal government could not act to register or ban firearms (because of the 2nd Amendment), but the states could have done so. The states could also exercise prior restraint on newspapers, conduct searches and seizures without warrants, etc. If you want to return to that states-rights model, you'd be in the minority among those who otherwise favor stronger gun controls.