New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Surreal....

There is NO chance that the government is going to confiscate all guns. None. You really should shake off the brainwashing that convinced you to the contrary.

And no one contends that gun control laws will completely end all gun carnage. There are simply too many guns in our society. The objective is to reduce the massacres.

And it's absurd to say Holmes would have passed any competent background check. He was a raging schizophrenic who was kicked out of school he was so ill.

Holmes would have passed any background check that we can do because our medical records are private, and mental health is considered part of our medical history.

Further, I'd agree that right now, today, there is zero chance of gun confiscation -- but there was zero chance of handgun confiscation in England in the 1970s, and it occurred in the 1990s. There was zero chance of semi-auto confiscation in Canada in the early 1980s, and it occurred in the 1990s. A similar state of affairs occurred in Australia. You think there are broad differences in the incremental approach used in those countries and what we're seeing here. I see the approaches as identical.
 
Holmes would have passed any background check that we can do because our medical records are private, and mental health is considered part of our medical history.

Further, I'd agree that right now, today, there is zero chance of gun confiscation -- but there was zero chance of handgun confiscation in England in the 1970s, and it occurred in the 1990s. There was zero chance of semi-auto confiscation in Canada in the early 1980s, and it occurred in the 1990s. A similar state of affairs occurred in Australia. You think there are broad differences in the incremental approach used in those countries and what we're seeing here. I see the approaches as identical.

Hence the need to tighten up the laws, which will be bitterly opposed by gun nuts.

Gun nuts do whatever they can to weaken laws, and then "defned" themselves by pointing to the weakness of the laws.
 
I disagree, but even if gun registration is not a 2nd Amendment violation, it is both currently illegal and a political non-starter.
It was politically a non-starter before Sandy Hook. Not convinced it is now.

the reason its not Unconstitutional is because it in no way Infringes the right to keep and bear. You can keep at your hearts will and bear... It just has to be registered. .

. There is a thriving market in the theft of whole cars for export.
Fine... stolen guns for export doesn't bother me in the least... reduces the volume of guns in the usa. .

Further, there is a largish difference between the registration of a car and the registration of guns -- no one wants to ban my ownership of a car.
So what? a car also has a utility to society which a fetishized gun does not
 
Hence the need to tighten up the laws, which will be bitterly opposed by gun nuts.

Gun nuts do whatever they can to weaken laws, and then "defned" themselves by pointing to the weakness of the laws.

Tighten up the laws to do what? Make it illegal for someone who is insane to get a gun? That's already illegal. Are you willing to have your mental health records on public display? If not, there's no way a background check can go much further than it does now.
 
It was politically a non-starter before Sandy Hook. Not convinced it is now.

Dream on, Degs. No way will registration make it through the House of representatives.

the reason its not Unconstitutional is because it in no way Infringes the right to keep and bear. You can keep at your hearts will and bear... It just has to be registered. .

That's according to the Supreme Court of what country?

So what? a car also has a utility to society which a fetishized gun does not

But there are lots of utilities for firearms that have nothing to do with fetishes, Degs. Attempting to smear all of us who own guns as irrational people who ascribe to the guns themselves powers they do not have will not strengthen your case, nor weaken mine (if anyone fetishizes guns, it is anti-gun activists, who seem to think guns pull their own triggers, and think that semiautos have the same sort of function as fully-automatic weapons).
 
Tighten up the laws to do what? Make it illegal for someone who is insane to get a gun? That's already illegal. Are you willing to have your mental health records on public display? If not, there's no way a background check can go much further than it does now.

To address the deficiency you identified in your last post.

This is a pointless discussion, eh? You critique the swiss-cheese nature of our gun control laws, I tell you we could eliminate the holes, and then you say we shouldn't do that.

You should just be honest and say you think we should do nothing to keep assault weapons away from lunatics.
 
To address the deficiency you identified in your last post.

This is a pointless discussion, eh? You critique the swiss-cheese nature of our gun control laws, I tell you we could eliminate the holes, and then you say we shouldn't do that.

You should just be honest and say you think we should do nothing to keep assault weapons away from lunatics.

How would you go about "tightening up" the law, so that someone who is getting treatment for, say, trying to quit cigarette smoking, doesn't have his treatment made public? What level of invasion of privacy would be sufficient? I do not say we should not do these things -- I say that there are people who will object to their being done and that at least some of their reasoning is sound.

I'm all for keeping all weapons away from lunatics -- I've yet to hear anything that could both do this and protect the privacy of others.
 
How would you go about "tightening up" the law, so that someone who is getting treatment for, say, trying to quit cigarette smoking, doesn't have his treatment made public? What level of invasion of privacy would be sufficient? I do not say we should not do these things -- I say that there are people who will object to their being done and that at least some of their reasoning is sound.

I'm all for keeping all weapons away from lunatics -- I've yet to hear anything that could both do this and protect the privacy of others.

I hope for your sake that you're just playing dumb, instead of really not being able to figure out how to tighten the laws.

And of course "some people" will oppose any laws designed to tighten things up. The NRA, gun nuts, and gun makers love the swiss cheese nature of our laws and they want to keep it that way.
 
I hope for your sake that you're just playing dumb, instead of really not being able to figure out how to tighten the laws.

And of course "some people" will oppose any laws designed to tighten things up. The NRA, gun nuts, and gun makers love the swiss cheese nature of our laws and they want to keep it that way.

I'm neither playing dumb, nor unable to figure out things. I am engaging in a dialectic. What do YOU propose as a means to ensure privacy of health records and ALSO have the background check that you desire?
 
You're also not very good at paying attention to what people tell you.

Stop being boring. Say something.

You'll thank me if you get the hang of that.

So basically, you're making the case that a more detailed mental health screening can be done, but failing to make a viable methodology for doing it. I have the temerity to say that without the latter, the former statement must fail as unsupported. Have a nice day.
 
Well the House may not pass registration - today... but if they are forced to vote on it - it will cost them seats. As for registration not being an infringement - SCOTUS has ruled that. As long as there is no restrictive requirement that limits access to registration, there is no interference with the right. Think about voting. Voting and voter id are all potentially infringements if they RESTRICT access (hence the appellate divisions ruling in PA) but as long as there is no practicable RESTRICTION there is no infringement. What applies to voting and representational rights applies to other rights.
But there are lots of utilities for firearms that have nothing to do with fetishes, Degs
nope. Target shooting is not a UTILITY any more than car racing is a utility of cars. Firearms have one and only one purpose - to kill And that is not a fetishization. That in no way ascribes magical and unsupportable attributes to guns (btw guns do fire on their own in certain circumstances - need I remind you of the classroom injuries in CA?). And we also have behavioural psych evidence that the very presence of a gun increases the level of violence that others are willing to tolerate and engage in. That's not a "fetishism" that's measured behavior.
 
So basically, you're making the case that a more detailed mental health screening can be done, but failing to make a viable methodology for doing it. I have the temerity to say that without the latter, the former statement must fail as unsupported. Have a nice day.

No one is very interested in your conclusions, much less your very boring tendency to ask inane questions. If you're not smart enough to figure our how to write laws saying what one wants them to say, that's gonna have to be your problem.
 
Bugsy... Trap is one of the few who takes the time to try and reason about issues and present them logically... Stop being a rude sh!t
 
Back
Top