New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Surreal....

Well the House may not pass registration - today... but if they are forced to vote on it - it will cost them seats.

Not as many as if they passed it.

As for registration not being an infringement - SCOTUS has ruled that. As long as there is no restrictive requirement that limits access to registration, there is no interference with the right. Think about voting. Voting and voter id are all potentially infringements if they RESTRICT access (hence the appellate divisions ruling in PA) but as long as there is no practicable RESTRICTION there is no infringement. What applies to voting and representational rights applies to other rights.nope.

Degs -- I'm opposed to registration even if it is no violation of the 2nd Amendment.

Target shooting is not a UTILITY any more than car racing is a utility of cars. Firearms have one and only one purpose - to kill

Hunting is a utility. The readiness to participate in an unorganized militia (as sanctioned by both the Constitution and by U.S. law) is a utility. I disagree that target shooting isn't a utility -- it's what I use my guns for 90 percent of the time, so they meet the "usefulness" criteria for that purpose.

That in no way ascribes magical and unsupportable attributes to guns (btw guns do fire on their own in certain circumstances - need I remind you of the classroom injuries in CA?).

I'm unaware of the classroom injuries in CA, but a gun is an inert set of pieces of metal and/or composites. It can not fire on its own. To fire it requires external forces, either born by human beings (someone pulls the trigger), or by nature (a gun can discharge, once, if it is raised to a temperature sufficient to "cook off" the ammunition. It generally won't fire more than once, as a temperature high enough to cook off a chambered round will also detonate any ammunition in its magazine).
 
Bugsy... Trap is one of the few who takes the time to try and reason about issues and present them logically... Stop being a rude sh!t

I'm not being rude. I simply told him I was not interested in inane questions about obvious matters, he just keeps asking them (pretending they are brainteasers), and then declares "victory."

I'm simply trying to elevate the level of debate. People should make points and defend them - not engage in a game of 20 (Inane) Questions.
 
Well actually it might cost EXISTING Congresscritters their jobs - but perversely cost THE GOP as a party, fewer seats... that's the tradeoff. Hunting in the modern day is not a utility. Its a hobby. Furthermore hunting still is killing - so the sole utility of a gun is for killing. As for CA... think very clearly... because you and I had a specific discussion about the gun in the backpack that discharged injuring a classmate simply because it was roughly handled. and that does not address the Behavioural Psych aspect I mention. BOTTOM LINE... Guns have the sole utility of killing.
 
Boca, you should join ol' Sarge in the bitchin' pool. You two are so upset that Obama is going to be president of the United States of America for the next four years and you just can't stand that there's nothing you can do about it. Whine so more, it tickles my funnybone to see the right all outrageous over the possibility of not being able to purchase guns that will allow themto kill 20 children in about 5 minutes. Head for the bunkers Boca, the black copters are coming and the UN's 10,000 tanks hidden in Michigan are warming up!
 
Well actually it might cost EXISTING Congresscritters their jobs - but perversely cost THE GOP as a party, fewer seats... that's the tradeoff. Hunting in the modern day is not a utility. Its a hobby. Furthermore hunting still is killing - so the sole utility of a gun is for killing. As for CA... think very clearly... because you and I had a specific discussion about the gun in the backpack that discharged injuring a classmate simply because it was roughly handled. and that does not address the Behavioural Psych aspect I mention. BOTTOM LINE... Guns have the sole utility of killing.

That isn't what happened last time, Degs. Last time the GOP took over the House for the first time in 50 years.

It doesn't matter if you think hunting is a utility or not. It matters if hunters think that it useful. If the sole purpose of a gun is killing, what's the purpose of an Olympic target pistol? An air rifle? (and air rifle uses expanding gases to propel a projectile, just as non-air weapons do).

OK, now I remember the CA injuries -- and you have provided your own answer. The gun was roughly handled -- it fired because of incorrect human handling, not by itself. Guns don't fire spontaneously.
 
I'm not being rude. I simply told him I was not interested in inane questions about obvious matters, he just keeps asking them (pretending they are brainteasers), and then declares "victory."

I'm simply trying to elevate the level of debate. People should make points and defend them - not engage in a game of 20 (Inane) Questions.
\

Except that isn't what you do. You've offered a contention -- that superior mental health screening is possible. I have asked, now, multiple times, "How is it possible?" That is not an "inane" question nor is it a brain teaser -- unless you have no answer, and then I suppose your brain might be teased. You have made a point, that we can do more. Defend it by explaining how you would accomplish it. Otherwise, you're simply wanking, or alternatively, you're being the rude sh!t that Degsme described you as being.
 
\

Except that isn't what you do. You've offered a contention -- that superior mental health screening is possible. I have asked, now, multiple times, "How is it possible?" That is not an "inane" question nor is it a brain teaser -- unless you have no answer, and then I suppose your brain might be teased. You have made a point, that we can do more. Defend it by explaining how you would accomplish it. Otherwise, you're simply wanking, or alternatively, you're being the rude sh!t that Degsme described you as being.

Sorry, but I just don't believe you're not smart enough to figure out how to tighten up such laws. You just don't want such laws but you're not candid enough to simply state that.
 
Sorry, but I just don't believe you're not smart enough to figure out how to tighten up such laws. You just don't want such laws but you're not candid enough to simply state that.

It not my pervue to make your case for you. I asked how you would go about it, and you have offered precisely d!ck. And I have said right along that I don't want such laws, if they lead to registration.
 
It not my pervue to make your case for you. I asked how you would go about it, and you have offered precisely d!ck. And I have said right along that I don't want such laws, if they lead to registration.

Bingo. You don't want the laws. So stop wasting time pretending you care about how they would be worded.
 
Bingo. You don't want the laws. So stop wasting time pretending you care about how they would be worded.

You ignored what I said (big surprise) I said I don't want the laws IF they lead to registration.

It's possible you're not talking about a system that requires registration -- but I don't know because you have steadfastly refused to provide the method you'd like to use. If there is a way to provide better and more comprehensive background checks on dealer sales, I'm all for it. I don't think this will have much impact on crime, but accuracy is always better. But like most gun owners, I won't favor a scheme that entails registration, because I've seen the results of registration in other countries.

But really, we're chasing our tails here. I can't debate your facts because you won't provide them.
 
You ignored what I said (big surprise) I said I don't want the laws IF they lead to registration.

It's possible you're not talking about a system that requires registration -- but I don't know because you have steadfastly refused to provide the method you'd like to use. If there is a way to provide better and more comprehensive background checks on dealer sales, I'm all for it. I don't think this will have much impact on crime, but accuracy is always better. But like most gun owners, I won't favor a scheme that entails registration, because I've seen the results of registration in other countries.

But really, we're chasing our tails here. I can't debate your facts because you won't provide them.

How about if one had to see a shrink and get the shrink's OK before being able to buy a gun?

Could you approve of that?
 
How about if one had to see a shrink and get the shrink's OK before being able to buy a gun?

Could you approve of that?

I think I can see some problems with it, not the least being that I'd want to know how the gun dealer knows that I've been to see the shrink, and whether or not there's a record that I've done so.

I have to take a physical, for example, for my pilot's license, but it's essentially a "warm body" physical (if you can get around normally, you pass, for a non-commercial ticket), and any record of the actual visit is between me and my chosen flight surgeon.

I'm willing to compromise on some regulations, including a more detailed background check, but I also want my individual rights to privacy and firearms respected. One reason so many of those of us who own guns are so adamantly opposed to new regulations is that we are never given a line in the sand -- that the regulations will go this far, and no further. Without that guarantee, we feel compelled to fight each increment.
 
I think I can see some problems with it, not the least being that I'd want to know how the gun dealer knows that I've been to see the shrink, and whether or not there's a record that I've done so.

I have to take a physical, for example, for my pilot's license, but it's essentially a "warm body" physical (if you can get around normally, you pass, for a non-commercial ticket), and any record of the actual visit is between me and my chosen flight surgeon.

I'm willing to compromise on some regulations, including a more detailed background check, but I also want my individual rights to privacy and firearms respected. One reason so many of those of us who own guns are so adamantly opposed to new regulations is that we are never given a line in the sand -- that the regulations will go this far, and no further. Without that guarantee, we feel compelled to fight each increment.

I'll put you down as a "maybe."

But, as we see, your main bugaboo on this issue is not registration.
 
It's still registration if it's a "back door" registration where you can identify all the gun owners by surveying their medical records.

You really should consider simply stating your view as opposed to coming across as an indecisive waffler.

You don't want laws removing the loopholes. Period.
 
You really should consider simply stating your view as opposed to coming across as an indecisive waffler.

You don't want laws removing the loopholes. Period.

Medical privacy isn't a "loophole." Hell, private sales aren't a "loophole." One man's loophole is another man's compliance with the law as it exists.

Why won't you be honest, since you're insisting I'm not -- what you want is registration, so that you can then put further restrictions on guns until the rights of the gun owner no longer exist.
 
More waffling...

Medical privacy isn't a "loophole." Hell, private sales aren't a "loophole." One man's loophole is another man's compliance with the law as it exists.

Why won't you be honest, since you're insisting I'm not -- what you want is registration, so that you can then put further restrictions on guns until the rights of the gun owner no longer exist.
 
People most assuredly do NOT have to waffle when discussing issues of policy.

You choose to waffle.

No -- I am attempting to have a reasonable discussion of how we can address your safety concerns while addressing the rights of gun owners. These need not be mutually exclusive. So I say again, what compromise do you offer gun owners?
 
Back
Top