New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

SYG

If you diligently search the internet, you could probably find a dozen or more of these situations.... in a country of 300 million+ people. :rolleyes: That's nothing compared to the number of folks victimized by predatory criminals everyday; the same folks who have to worry about whether they are going to be charged if the vicious little animal who got shot while trying to rob, rape, or murder them was a darker skin tone than they are.
 
If you diligently search the internet, you could probably find a dozen or more of these situations.... in a country of 300 million+ people. :rolleyes: That's nothing compared to the number of folks victimized by predatory criminals everyday; the same folks who have to worry about whether they are going to be charged if the vicious little animal who got shot while trying to rob, rape, or murder them was a darker skin tone than they are.

Are you aware of SYG in any greater degree? Florida unlike other states does not have the need to retreat. That is what made this so horrific. SYG cancels out manslaughter so any dingbat can chase a kid down or approach with aggression and if a fight comes from it ONLY focus on the fight. Even you should realize that is a cocktail for disaster. Kids are dying here. Hell even drug dealers are benefitting when a drug deal goes bad and they kill someone they claim SYG AND WIN. This is mad nuts.
 
Are you aware of SYG in any greater degree? Florida unlike other states does not have the need to retreat. That is what made this so horrific. SYG cancels out manslaughter so any dingbat can chase a kid down or approach with aggression and if a fight comes from it ONLY focus on the fight. Even you should realize that is a cocktail for disaster. Kids are dying here. Hell even drug dealers are benefitting when a drug deal goes bad and they kill someone they claim SYG AND WIN. This is mad nuts.

Some people are [Unwelcome language removed]; when that blows up in their face they reach for every justification they can find for the shit they cause. Don't be an [Unwelcome language removed], and don't start shit..... you probably won't have anything to worry about. You have a better chance of being killed by a falling meteorite than of running into someone who will kill you and then claim SYG law as a justification.
 
Are you aware of SYG in any greater degree? Florida unlike other states does not have the need to retreat. That is what made this so horrific. SYG cancels out manslaughter so any dingbat can chase a kid down or approach with aggression and if a fight comes from it ONLY focus on the fight. Even you should realize that is a cocktail for disaster. Kids are dying here. Hell even drug dealers are benefitting when a drug deal goes bad and they kill someone they claim SYG AND WIN. This is mad nuts.

And BTW, nobody cares if drug dealers kill one another as long as no innocents get hit. The term is "[Unwelcome language removed] vs. [Unwelcome language removed], no humans involved".
(and you might want to edit your post before someone starts giving you shit about the "mad nuts" typo...)
 
This is the simple fact of SYG and there is no way in some cases to establish who did what when a killing took place:

http://www.tampabay.com/stand-your-ground-law/fatal-cases

"One hundred thirty-three people in the state of Florida have used a 'Stand Your Ground' defense. Of these claims, 73 were considered 'justified' (55 percent), while 39 resulted in criminal convictions and 21 cases are still pending."

So more than half, in other words, were definitely valid cases of self-defense, and that figure could be higher because of the undetermined cases. And across the U.S., the number of shootings and the amount of violent crime have been on a steady downward trend for more than 20 years.
 
Some people are [Unwelcome language removed]; when that blows up in their face they reach for every justification they can find for the shit they cause. Don't be an [Unwelcome language removed], and don't start shit..... you probably won't have anything to worry about. You have a better chance of being killed by a falling meteorite than of running into someone who will kill you and then claim SYG law as a justification.

Don't give me that Frey, SYG Florida and Texas style is an excuse for murder. Trayvon was not an [Unwelcome language removed], he was a kid walking home from the grocery store. I am never an [Unwelcome language removed] that has nothing to do with it. The Castle Doctrine was bastardized in Florida to allow dingbats to attack anywhere they want in any situation with no duty to retreat and fully cancels out manslaughter that looks at your actions. And now the toll count starts.

How the hell can a normal unarmed person ever defend themselves from these aggressive killers who know the law is on the side of murder with SYG Florida style?
 
I know exactly why I don't get messed with; 1. I don't drink. Stay away from bars, nightclubs, and parties where people are drinking, and you'll be amazed at how little grief you get. 2. Show respect to all, but fear to no one.... 3. I just happen to look meaner than shit; it's not on purpose, it's just my default facial expression.... I've worked hard to change that so as to not scare folks. But it comes in handy..... jackal's don't **** with lions. The gun on my hip doesn't have anything to do with it, because no one knows I have it.

That's my point. The gun has nothing to do with it. But...I think you'd agree that the little 5 feet/ 90 lb. gal who looks like she's 16 and has a voice like Minnie Mouse, probably can't pull off what you're suggesting.

Although....you're right about the alcohol thing. I say I've never been confronted, but I should've said that I've never been confronted sober! As a young man, I used to relish the odd brawl. But, I'm a little old for that silliness now. So, I have a trick. I quietly suggest to my confronter, that it would probably be better for us all, if we just dropped it. I don't suggest it as a bombastic threat and I try not let his buddies hear me, lest he be provoked to prove his mettle. Of course, I'M the only one who knows what I'm capable or not capable of doing to him. But if you do it right, he always figures out that his better part of valor is to not take the risk.
 
So more than half, in other words, were definitely valid cases of self-defense, and that figure could be higher because of the undetermined cases. And across the U.S., the number of shootings and the amount of violent crime have been on a steady downward trend for more than 20 years.

To be found not guilty via SYG does not mean that without the SYG they would not have been found guilty of manslaughter. Manslaughter has been neutered by Florida's SYG. Just keep your ears open as that is where the fire is going to be aimed as a result of Florida law.

No person dead is a statistic so I won't go there with you. Point is there is a real conflict with Florida's version of SYG and it has to be fixed. Carry a gun, it is legal but no law should be created that allows you to use it after chasing people and causing the situation - that is what manslaughter used to be for when it was allowed to be used in practical applications that some of these murders represent.
 
Don't give me that Frey, SYG Florida and Texas style is an excuse for murder. Trayvon was not an [Unwelcome language removed], he was a kid walking home from the grocery store. I am never an [Unwelcome language removed] that has nothing to do with it. The Castle Doctrine was bastardized in Florida to allow dingbats to attack anywhere they want in any situation with no duty to retreat and fully cancels out manslaughter that looks at your actions. And now the toll count starts.

How the hell can a normal unarmed person ever defend themselves from these aggressive killers who know the law is on the side of murder with SYG Florida style?

Well, bullshit..... but if you're that worried about being attacked maybe you should arm yourself. Of course when you react inappropriately because you don't seem to understand self-defense law, you may want to have a good defense lawyer on retainer.... ;)
 
And BTW, nobody cares if drug dealers kill one another as long as no innocents get hit. The term is "[Unwelcome language removed] vs. [Unwelcome language removed], no humans involved".
(and you might want to edit your post before someone starts giving you shit about the "mad nuts" typo...)

Typo? I am not responsible for dirty minds! LOL

Drug dealers killing each other is what they do but now they can legally do it and walk to sell more drugs and kill more people - and that would not have to be limited to other drug dealers.
 
Last edited:
That's my point. The gun has nothing to do with it. But...I think you'd agree that the little 5 feet/ 90 lb. gal who looks like she's 16 and has a voice like Minnie Mouse, probably can't pull off what you're suggesting.

Although....you're right about the alcohol thing. I say I've never been confronted, but I should've said that I've never been confronted sober! As a young man, I used to relish the odd brawl. But, I'm a little old for that silliness now. So, I have a trick. I quietly suggest to my confronter, that it would probably be better for us all, if we just dropped it. I don't suggest it as a bombastic threat and I try not let his buddies hear me, lest he be provoked to prove his mettle. Of course, I'M the only one who knows what I'm capable or not capable of doing to him. But if you do it right, he always figures out that his better part of valor is to not take the risk.
Always leave a man a face-saving exit....
 
To be found not guilty via SYG does not mean that without the SYG they would not have been found guilty of manslaughter. Manslaughter has been neutered by Florida's SYG. Just keep your ears open as that is where the fire is going to be aimed as a result of Florida law
.

Neither does it mean they would have been found guilty of manslaughter. They may well have not ever been charged because of justifiable homicide. What COULD have happened in the imaginary legal climate where SYG had not already been passed is merely a matter of speculation.

No person dead is a statistic so I won't go there with you. Point is there is a real conflict with Florida's version of SYG and it has to be fixed. Carry a gun, it is legal but no law should be created that allows you to use it after chasing people and causing the situation - that is what manslaughter used to be for when it was allowed to be used in practical applications that some of these murders represent.

Well, the FBI, the Brady Campaign and the Violence Policy Center all find it useful to cite statistics, and the statistics do not show a great calamity anywhere in the nation as a result of self-defense, SYG, or concealed carry.
 
Well, bullshit..... but if you're that worried about being attacked maybe you should arm yourself. Of course when you react inappropriately because you don't seem to understand self-defense law, you may want to have a good defense lawyer on retainer.... ;)

I am actually going to do whatever it takes to get that exception they placed into SYG removed in the area where the jury instructions all say that a jury must only look at the fight and cancels out manslaughter. Don't know how much good it will do but it isn't about me, I really am horrified that a child walking home from a store or school can be chased down and killed with no legal obstacle for doing it.
 
.

Neither does it mean they would have been found guilty of manslaughter. They may well have not ever been charged because of justifiable homicide. What COULD have happened in the imaginary legal climate where SYG had not already been passed is merely a matter of speculation.

I agree but we'll never know since here in Florida it is still an option that can't be used in these cases. SYG doesn't care if someone does anything to provoke, trap, corner or chase someone before killing them if that frightened person fights back for their life. None of that matters here.

Well, the FBI, the Brady Campaign and the Violence Policy Center all find it useful to cite statistics, and the statistics do not show a great calamity anywhere in the nation as a result of self-defense, SYG, or concealed carry.

The Castle Doctrine is almost as old as history and that part is not an issue. Only the couple states who bastardized it are seeing the negative results play out by their customizing it to allow irresponsible behavior and canceling out manslaughter. It just needs to be fixed, not removed. Most states do not have this version of SYG. Take conceal and carry out of the formula as that is only important where any state has made being the aggressor fully legal. Conceal and carry is likely very different in states where limitations are clear and where the Castle Doctrine is at play.
 
I am actually going to do whatever it takes to get that exception they placed into SYG removed in the area where the jury instructions all say that a jury must only look at the fight and cancels out manslaughter. Don't know how much good it will do but it isn't about me, I really am horrified that a child walking home from a store or school can be chased down and killed with no legal obstacle for doing it.
I belong to several other forums, and many of them are gun forums where discussions of self-defense cases are common. The common consensus is that if you have to shoot someone in self-defense, you can expect it to cost you in the neighborhood of 50K in legal fees at a minimum, and that's with no guarantee that you won't do time for some kind of wrongful death. No responsible person wants to have that happen, but there are a lot of irresponsible people out there and I should not be held responsible for their actions.
 
I agree but we'll never know since here in Florida it is still an option that can't be used in these cases. SYG doesn't care if someone does anything to provoke, trap, corner or chase someone before killing them if that frightened person fights back for their life. None of that matters here.

I don't think pursuit will stand up in most SYG defense cases.



The Castle Doctrine is almost as old as history and that part is not an issue. Only the couple states who bastardized it are seeing the negative results play out by their customizing it to allow irresponsible behavior and canceling out manslaughter. It just needs to be fixed, not removed. Most states do not have this version of SYG. Take conceal and carry out of the formula as that is only important where any state has made being the aggressor fully legal. Conceal and carry is likely very different in states where limitations are clear and where the Castle Doctrine is at play.

Even without SYG, there has not been a traditional legal requirement for people to retreat in the U.S. SYG merely codifies what had been customary before.
 
I belong to several other forums, and many of them are gun forums where discussions of self-defense cases are common. The common consensus is that if you have to shoot someone in self-defense, you can expect it to cost you in the neighborhood of 50K in legal fees at a minimum, and that's with no guarantee that you won't do time for some kind of wrongful death. No responsible person wants to have that happen, but there are a lot of irresponsible people out there and I should not be held responsible for their actions.

You aren't held responsible. My only hope in all this is that Gov Scott and lawmakers roll back the insanity and replace it with the Castle Doctrine like other states with the right to defend yourself to at least have manslaughter still have teeth. If you look at these cases I suspect most are not worried about a 50k cost as the state or donors pay their way. Someone who has built their life successfully is not going to sacrifice it all by acting out as a general rule I suspect.
 
Oh bullshit.... :rolleyes:

Yes it bullshit and Minnie's been shoveling it ever since the verdict and maybe before.

Stand Your Ground is a stupid ass nickname for a self-defense law similar to self-defense laws in many states, but the nickname carries the connotation of beligerent Mr. Tough Guy which pisses off people that don't know what they're talking about.

This Florida law did two things...it extended the "no duty to retreat", Castle Doctrine concept to include anywhere you have a legal right to be outside your home, including your vehicle. Secondly, and more importantly I think, it removed the burden of having to "prove" you feared for your life or might suffer great bodily harm. How do prove what you feel and why, as a defendant, should you have to prove anything?

As for "no duty to retreat".....I have a conceal carry license. It was made very clear to our class by the former law enforcement officer now instructor, that despite the words "no duty", you better damn well have good reasons why you didn't. That's because lawyers and judges aren't too predictable. He cited a case of a Florida man in his vehicle at a stop light who shot and killed a man through the window who was beating on the window, cracking it, and demanding he get out...a carjacking in other words. The shooter's child was in a car seat in the back as well. Nevertheless he was charged with 2nd degree (not premitated) murder because the state argued he could have gone around the car in front of him and run the red light. The jury had common sense and acquitted him. The instructor's point being that while you may win the case, your life is going to be hell if there is any question you could have "retreated".

Minnie's "now being able to kill no matter what" is just more bullshit.
 
I don't think pursuit will stand up in most SYG defense cases.

According to the jury it did. They could not go with manslaughter due to the SYG statement effectively canceling it. That is the scary part.

Even without SYG, there has not been a traditional legal requirement for people to retreat in the U.S. SYG merely codifies what had been customary before.

The Castle Doctrine most states use most people don't realize is centered around home. Believe it or not it has a second name called: Defense of Habitation Law

The state of Florida took it outside the perimeters of home and allowed it anywhere unlimited but that wasn't the real problem, the real problem is that their version forces the court to only look at the fight or struggle and nothing that led up to it which has pretty much removed manslaughter where it may be present and ties up juries. Manslaughter can be used if you chase or go after someone and cause them to have a heart attack or cause them to fall and die, or shoot a gun in the air and it kills someone you did not aim for. Picking a fight or being reckless and causing a death can be manslaughter. Manslaughter in Florida is just not applicable when someone does the same thing but in the process shoots the victim after initiating the fight with careless disregard. They are forced to only look at the fight where someone they chased and cornered fights back and is killed. It is not a good recipe.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top