New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Tom Brokaw

My intent wasn't to change your mind. Although as to this particular subject, your "forest for the trees" line is ironic.
 
Nothing will change my mind on this subject, so baloney me all you want. Some can't see the forest for the trees.

Lilly...you owe me at least one point! After all....how often do you think I lead off with "baloney"...instead of one of its alternatives?
 
No, Knot,we went to Afghanistan because we were attacked,and that country was harboring those who attacked us.

We went to war with Iraq because a small group of Neocons led by Cheney and his thugs wanted to go to war.They lied, used every trick in the book to go.

President Obama pulled us out of that cess pool and is now trying to get us out of Afghanistan.

I despise all war and killing in our name,but if modern weapons get us out then I trust this President to do it the best way he can.
Sorry. I have no problem with you thinking different.

We did not go to war with Afghanistan, we went into Afghanistan in part because of what you said, but to bring OBL to justice, an act few had objections to. What happened is that we got bogged down in the internal affairs of Afghanistan, this time overtly with our military as opposed to our covert participation in Afghanistan when the Soviets were the foreign military force in Afghanistan instead of us.

My point was only in part about how terrible some weapons are, but because of how terrible they are, while they might "get us out" of one situation in the short term, they may throw and have thrown us into another problem or simply shifted the same problem. If people attack us for using such horrible weapons, the use of the horrible weapons, while stopping something is negated because they are also causing or creating the same enemies we believe we're destroying with them.

Hopefully, you can recognize and realize that concern. I guess what I'm thinking and saying is that we don't necessarily "get out" in the longer term when we create enemies by use of our weapons and those enemies want the same weapons to use on us. In the longer term, have we really or necessarily "saved our own"?
 
No MaryAnne, Obama is wrong for allowing the drone attacks to have continued this long. He above all people knows it's wrong. I don't know a single President that has ever been perfect and he is not either. However if we don't speak up when we see something wrong, we are nothing but puppets.

I think this has been a very civil discussion and would never have dreamed it could have been.

I agree with you about drones lilly. Here are some related reasons why, aside from the notion of what works for us, can also work against us and thinking of both, not just one when making decisions.


http://www.doug-long.com/quotes.htm

"Eisenhower was known as a harmonizer, a man who could get diverse factions to work toward a common goal... Leadership, he explained, meant patience and conciliation, not "hitting people over the head."
-David M. Oshinsky, in A Conspiracy So Immense : The World of Joe McCarthy‎, (2005), p. 259


Interesting coming from a man who had been the Supreme Commander of Allied Forces in Europe, but of those with experience or in the position to know some things about war and leadership, perhaps Eisenhower was one.
 
As to drones, I have nothing but the utmost respect for anti-droners who come from a lefter place. I may not agree with them, but I "feel" them.

But..rightkooks who're now shouting drone-hate? Gimme a break. They'd hate on Obama IF he employed drones and they'd hate on him if he didn't employ drones, and they'd hate on him again if he changed his mind and started using them again!
 
And what are we really doing to win the hearts and minds of people around the world? Is it wrong to question our policies, is it wrong to want our country to do better?

That was a tired statement, Jen, when all the righties claimed that those who questioned our policies "must hate America". And it still hasn't gotten any rest today.
 
And yet, as far as I can tell, Lefties are getting a pass from you when they say that all righties hate America.
It works both ways.
I don't think anyone hates America (even though I have a lot of trouble wrapping my mind around thinking that the blame America first people love America). It is clear that what has happened is that there are some very stark differences between peoples' ideas of what America is and should be.



And what are we really doing to win the hearts and minds of people around the world? Is it wrong to question our policies, is it wrong to want our country to do better?

That was a tired statement, Jen, when all the righties claimed that those who questioned our policies "must hate America". And it still hasn't gotten any rest today.
 
And you've seen me give someone a pass when they paint anybody with a wide brush? That's interesting, but I don't know where it shows up.

Think about it this way. What reason would anyone want to attack us, if not for our past history and policies? Because we drive nice cars and go to nice restaurants? Or for the way we dress? I seriously doubt it.
 
You've mirrored many of my thoughts. Drones are a terror weapon, and they kill indiscriminately. The make more enemies for us. That said, what's the alternative?

Kill indiscriminately? Really? Flying a plane into a skyscraper is indiscriminate. Drones kill exactly who we aim them at. If people are near by, they may also be killed or wounded. If the enemy uses their families, friends and neighbors as sheilds, they may become casualties. It really is too bad that we can't pursuade the enemy to stay away from innocent bystanders....
 
But I will say this, and then I'm off to bed. Look at all the posts, on this board, and count the number of times 'Lefties' or 'Librats' is used. I'm not at all surprised there is so much negativity here. And a number of posters here came from KFS, where there was a constant barrage of that kind of crap.

"There has yet been any evidence of WMD brought forward"

"You must hate America"

"Has anybody considered that this war is the wrong war?"

"You must hate America"

And on

And on

And on

And on.....
 
I wouldn't say drones kill indiscriminately, I would say they are no more capable of reducing collateral damage, injury and death than manned craft perhaps even less so because there is no skin in the "game". I agree they are terrorizing for the same reason, no skin in the "game",an invasion onto someone else's soil and basically thinking what most Americans would think of drones of other nations targeting their American enemies from American skies and what our "acceptance" and "understanding' would be of their collateral damage, injury and death.

Anyone ever heard of the Golden Rule? How about ethics of reciprocity?

Would we really have others do unto us as we have done unto them when it comes to drones or any of our actions?

The further we're removed from our targets, what happens to our accountabilty? How many people posting here would speak to one another face to face in the same manner they "speak" to one another here?

The founders of this nation felt well-regulated Miliita of each state comprised of citizen soldiers were more trustworthy than standing militaries comprised of professional soldiers why?

No one doubts that drones reduce risk to American personnel in the immediate term. When remote control robots are used to "take out" targets, personnel that would otherwise man the crafts are "saved", but are they or are American citizens saved, when the use of such weapons creates more fear, more angst, more anger and more bitterness toward those sitting comfortably without risk, launching weapons that maim and kill? When they return the same, will we accept it as we now expect they should?
 
Back
Top