Colorforms
Senator
Some people don't believe it's meaningless. It's a reflection of values, and these days values are more important than ever.Maybe I'm not, but to me it's just a academic debate. I stopped saying it in 1968. It's meaningless.
Some people don't believe it's meaningless. It's a reflection of values, and these days values are more important than ever.Maybe I'm not, but to me it's just a academic debate. I stopped saying it in 1968. It's meaningless.
That's part of what I don't think most of those here have thought through. This country is getting less and less Christian with time. It won't be long until individual school districts start to be majority Muslim majority Hindu of majority atheist. And at some point the entire country might be. The rules that they are establishing now when they happen to benefit them, will be the same rules available to be used against them and their children and grandchildren, when somebody else is in the majority. Heck, already, there are majority Catholic districts where, if Catholics were as obnoxious in asserting their peculiar religious views as montheists are as a whole, they could have a pledge with words including something about the infallibility of the Pope -- and screw the Protestant minority.
I always wondered what "under God" meant. Does it imply that we as a nation have special favor in God's eyes? Or does it mean that as a people we uniformly revere God?
Personally, I really don't think God really cares too much about our puny human geopolitical organizations.
Why not? I don't like people who push false or forced patriotism.
Unfamiliar with the history?
...The premium department of The Youth’s Companion sold not only annual subscriptions but ran a thriving mail order business. One of its more popular items was the U.S. flag. Partially to increase sales (and partly due to patriotic sentiment the magazine launched a campaign to get every school in the country to install a flag pole on which to fly their flag, preferably purchased from The Youth’s Companion, in 1888. At the time very few if any schools had a flag pole or displayed the flag in any manner, which up to that time was deemed the province of the government, particularly the federal government.
As part of their campaign, Ford and Upham also lobbied for laws making flag poles at school compulsory. The campaign spread to target private homes, encouraging people to fly the flag on national holidays.
By the beginning of 1892, the premium department had sold over 26,000 flags at $10 per flag, for a total of $260,000 over the four years. Seeing an opportunity in the 400th anniversary of Columbus’ “discovery” of the Americas, the magazine and the National Education Association (NEA) organized a committee promoting the National Celebration of the Public Schools for Columbus Day. Its chairman was none other than Edward Bellamy’s cousin Francis.
To make the occasion more ceremonial, Francis, composed a pledge to the flag and the republic, choosing words through which he hoped to impart a spirit of comrade citizenship and civic responsibility. Nation versus Capital, in a subtle way. The pledge he initially wrote was this: “I pledge allegiance to my Flag and the Republic for which it stands, one Nation, indivisible, with Liberty, Equality, Fraternity, and Justice for all.”
With this wording, the emphasis on Nation and the Republic was clear. The words “liberty, equality, fraternity” were borrowed from France, which had so recently given us the Statue of Liberty, for whom they were the national slogan, adopted from the Cordeliers Clubs during their own revolution. The stress on “indivisible” and “one” Nation was twofold: first, that the country would never again be divided, and two, that the time for lingering animosities was long past.
The words “equality, fraternity” were struck out before the Pledge of Allegiance was even published. It would have been rather embarrassing to call for equality at the height of Jim Crow, and part of the goal was to sell flags.
http://www.chattanoogan.com/2012/7/11/230070/The-Surprising-Story-Of-The-Pledge-Of.aspx
Apparently he did back when he was bitch slapping Egypt.I always wondered what "under God" meant. Does it imply that we as a nation have special favor in God's eyes? Or does it mean that as a people we uniformly revere God?
Personally, I really don't think God really cares too much about our puny human geopolitical organizations.
Some people don't believe it's meaningless. It's a reflection of values, and these days values are more important than ever.
Unfortunately, Craig, I think you have a point. But then, if a person abandons light when all they see are darkness, then they become part of it. Just because others devalue intelligence or justice, that doesn't mean I have to. I am not them, I am me.Values is a crap word. It always has been and it always will be. It, like the pledge, is meaningless. Values? Greed is a value and a highly praised one these days. Intelligence is a value that too many discount.
Justice is a value we say we seek, yet I see injustice everywhere. Liberty is a value we seek, but restrictions to liberty abound; the drug war one the greatest attacks on liberty ever devised.
Unfortunately, Craig, I think you have a point. But then, if a person abandons light when all they see are darkness, then they become part of it. Just because others devalue intelligence or justice, that doesn't mean I have to. I am not them, I am me.
In Massachusetts, our public school system is thriving. We lead the nation in almost every indicator of educational excellence, and we stack up very nicely against the international competition. If we were a nation, we'd rank second in the world, behind only Singapore, in our students' science performance, and we'd rank sixth in math, behind only Korea, Singapore, Taiwan, Hong Kong and Japan.Exacly why the public school model is dead/dying. Vouchers are going to be the solution.
What makes you think God did anything of the sort?Apparently he did back when he was bitch slapping Egypt.
That may be, just like I know where many of the Catholic religious ceremonies come from, so my partaking in them is pointless. But there are many who still believe in them. It's part of their light, and because of that, they have the power to inspire. Not me, but them.Yes...and I am me.
Don't abandon light, just understand what the pledge of allegiance really is and why it was created in the first place.
We have a tendency to not forget history, but to not even care about it. Marketing geniuses know this...and play into it. Another example is all the Ten Commandment plaques found all over the nation. Many (estimates vary) were given to the communities just prior to the release of the movie...The Ten Commandments. Remarkable, no? Cecil B. DeMille orchestrated that one.
In Massachusetts, our public school system is thriving. We lead the nation in almost every indicator of educational excellence, and we stack up very nicely against the international competition. If we were a nation, we'd rank second in the world, behind only Singapore, in our students' science performance, and we'd rank sixth in math, behind only Korea, Singapore, Taiwan, Hong Kong and Japan.
We didn't do it with vouchers. Nor did we do it by de-unionizing the teaching profession. We did it by funding our schools well and creating a culture that emphasizes the value of academic performance. This isn't the kind of state with lots of creationists and climate-change deniers, much less those who find a president's use of malapropisms to be a charming sign of down-home authenticity. We expect excellence, and so we produce it.
I'm open-minded about vouchers. If someone can show me evidence that the top-performing educational systems, are having great success with them, then that would be very interesting to me. But, so far, most of the "evidence" I've heard to support vouchers amounts to little more than boilerplate right-wing attacks on the government and unions.
Really? Your asking someone who told you that they don't believe in God why they think God bitch slapped Egypt?What makes you think God did anything of the sort?
In Massachusetts, our public school system is thriving. We lead the nation in almost every indicator of educational excellence, and we stack up very nicely against the international competition. If we were a nation, we'd rank second in the world, behind only Singapore, in our students' science performance, and we'd rank sixth in math, behind only Korea, Singapore, Taiwan, Hong Kong and Japan.
We didn't do it with vouchers. Nor did we do it by de-unionizing the teaching profession. We did it by funding our schools well and creating a culture that emphasizes the value of academic performance. This isn't the kind of state with lots of creationists and climate-change deniers, much less those who find a president's use of malapropisms to be a charming sign of down-home authenticity. We expect excellence, and so we produce it.
I'm open-minded about vouchers. If someone can show me evidence that the top-performing educational systems, are having great success with them, then that would be very interesting to me. But, so far, most of the "evidence" I've heard to support vouchers amounts to little more than boilerplate right-wing attacks on the government and unions.
I'm not sure what to make of your non-sequitur.... unless it wasn't a non sequitur, but rather an assertion that non-white people are the reasons some places struggle so much, academically. Given that Singapore is majority non-white, and outperforms Massachusetts, I'm not sure what to make of that. Anyway, there are states that are a lot whiter, like West Virginia, that are academic train wrecks.
Arkady,
Yes, your schools are well funded and the "culture" is of one of placing a priority on academic performace. But, there is nothing that "created" that other than the relative size of the state and the number of leading academic institutions.
You are part of a small state, that has a lot of really smart people by virtue of having some world class institutions at your door. That is ALSO why Maryland has very good schools and is according to some rankings #1 in the country. Like Mass - we are a small state, with a lot of higher learning institutions, some extremely well respected, and we have a disporporation number of really smart people who come here to work in high tech fields. It is why schools near Silicon Valley are very good.
Smart educated people - place a lot of emphasis on education. Wherever you have a concentration of them - you will likely have good public schools.
That is great - it helps keep our public school systems good. But, that isn't something that we did. It happens by virture of our geography and of our historical and political singificance. There is nothing about what people in Mass or people in MD did, that can be transported to Louisianna.
There is simply not the economy, not the higher education draws, not the industry that drives a lot of really smart, highly educated people there ( or other similiar places). Yes there are some, really smart and highly educated people there - but unlike where you or I live they are outnumbered. Seriously outnumbered. And, so what you have in those places, like in the DC public schools, some parents who do take their kids education very seriously and they really want them to succeed and they know to do that - they have to actually seperate them from the other riff raff who don't care.
You and I and our school systems benefit from this natural separation already. We do it because we live in relatively high COL areas - that essentially push the poor and uneducated into their own little enclaves or out of the state all together. But, when you are poor but not ignorant and everyone around you is the poor and ignorant kind -the only way your kids have a shot is - to get away from the "and ignorant". The only way they can do that is by using vouchers or charter schools and essentially separating the poor from the poor and ignorant. There isn't ever going to be some considerable culture shift in any o these places. Its like the middle east - the culture of ignorance and of praising ignorance is too well entrenched. It just is almost who they are - so if you don't want to be like them - you have got to be able to separate yourself and allows those who do embrace ignorance to stew in their own juices.
I'm not sure what to make of your non-sequitur.... unless it wasn't a non sequitur, but rather an assertion that non-white people are the reasons some places struggle so much, academically. Given that Singapore is majority non-white, and outperforms Massachusetts, I'm not sure what to make of that. Anyway, there are states that are a lot whiter, like West Virginia, that are academic train wrecks.
Arkady,
Yes, your schools are well funded and the "culture" is of one of placing a priority on academic performace. But, there is nothing that "created" that other than the relative size of the state and the number of leading academic institutions.
You are part of a small state, that has a lot of really smart people by virtue of having some world class institutions at your door. That is ALSO why Maryland has very good schools and is according to some rankings #1 in the country. Like Mass - we are a small state, with a lot of higher learning institutions, some extremely well respected, and we have a disporporation number of really smart people who come here to work in high tech fields. It is why schools near Silicon Valley are very good.
Smart educated people - place a lot of emphasis on education. Wherever you have a concentration of them - you will likely have good public schools.
That is great - it helps keep our public school systems good. But, that isn't something that we did. It happens by virture of our geography and of our historical and political singificance. There is nothing about what people in Mass or people in MD did, that can be transported to Louisianna.
There is simply not the economy, not the higher education draws, not the industry that drives a lot of really smart, highly educated people there ( or other similiar places). Yes there are some, really smart and highly educated people there - but unlike where you or I live they are outnumbered. Seriously outnumbered. And, so what you have in those places, like in the DC public schools, some parents who do take their kids education very seriously and they really want them to succeed and they know to do that - they have to actually seperate them from the other riff raff who don't care.
You and I and our school systems benefit from this natural separation already. We do it because we live in relatively high COL areas - that essentially push the poor and uneducated into their own little enclaves or out of the state all together. But, when you are poor but not ignorant and everyone around you is the poor and ignorant kind -the only way your kids have a shot is - to get away from the "and ignorant". The only way they can do that is by using vouchers or charter schools and essentially separating the poor from the poor and ignorant. There isn't ever going to be some considerable culture shift in any o these places. Its like the middle east - the culture of ignorance and of praising ignorance is too well entrenched. It just is almost who they are - so if you don't want to be like them - you have got to be able to separate yourself and allows those who do embrace ignorance to stew in their own juices.
She never mentioned whiteness.I abbreviated what Connie said. I thought it was self-evident with a smart cookie like you.