New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Under God

Certainly the presence of so many good universities nearby helps. And I'll grant that it's not like that can be replicated everywhere, because there isn't enough demand to support a Massachusetts-style, or even Maryland-style concentration of academic institutions on a nation-wide basis. But it's not like a concentration of great school guarantees good results. North Carolina has quite a concentration, yet is an academic "also ran," on the whole (tied for 33rd in the nation on 8th grade reading proficiency, for example). In the other direction, New Jersey ranks just after Massachusetts, overall, and yet is particularly noteworthy for its universities. Yes, it has Princeton, but after that it's a huge fall to Rutgers (unlike Massachusetts, where after Harvard you've got MIT, then BC, BU, Tufts, Wellesley, Brandeis, etc.) So, I think it's possible to develop a strong school system without having a small states built around higher education.

The state also has to have the cojones to take Big Dig and Federal subsidy Romneycare monies.

Again, whiteness in regards to NC also matters. And it isn't racial as much as it is cultural the difference.
 
The point of school is to indoctrinate children. Liberals know that and have used it to their advantage for decades. It's why we have "labor studies" and "liberal arts" courses.


Ok...I am trying to figure out what the hell you're talking about. What so liberal teach children? My god, you are a paranoid scared little boy....just the way the right wants you.
 
Certainly the presence of so many good universities nearby helps. And I'll grant that it's not like that can be replicated everywhere, because there isn't enough demand to support a Massachusetts-style, or even Maryland-style concentration of academic institutions on a nation-wide basis. But it's not like a concentration of great school guarantees good results. North Carolina has quite a concentration, yet is an academic "also ran," on the whole (tied for 33rd in the nation on 8th grade reading proficiency, for example). In the other direction, New Jersey ranks just after Massachusetts, overall, and yet is not particularly noteworthy for its universities. Yes, it has Princeton, but after that it's a huge fall to Rutgers (unlike Massachusetts, where after Harvard you've got MIT, then BC, BU, Tufts, Wellesley, Brandeis, etc.) So, I think it's possible to develop a strong school system without having a small state built around higher education. And we certainly see that abroad. Places like Singapore and Finland aren't exactly known for their elite institutions of higher learning, but do a fantastic job educating kids.

You are discounting the economics and relative urbanization of the area. Yes, NC has some very good institutions. But, compared to the concentration of those highly educated to the rest of the state -the highly educated - are sorely outnumbered. Yes, NJ only has Princeton. But, it is close to NY and borders Philly - so it benefits by having people who are educated and economically well off close by and oftentimes they will choose to live in that state - and work somewhere else. Additionally, NJ is HUGE in the pharmaceutical industry which is full of scientists and researchers -etc. Again - a concentrated group of well educated people. Who then, value education. Finland and Singapore the same thing. A concentrated group of well educated people who value education. There may be pockets like that in states whose overall educational rankings are awful.

Its not that you have the higher learning institutions that make it great - its that you are small and that you have a disproportionately large number of really smart well educated people living there. For Mass - that is largely because Boston is a large historic city important for commerce and all your institutions. For MD - it is our institutions AND our defense contractors/ technology industry concentration. For Silicon Valley - its the techies... for Seattle, its the engineers and designers that work for Boeing. But, like I said, you can't replicate that everywhere without some type of high tech industry or institutions of higher learning. For MD and MASS and Singapore, it works out that we are both very concentrated and have a disproportionate number of highly eduated people. In other ares which are not so concentrated - you will only have good performing schools centered around those little pockets of people who are dedicated to advancing education. And, in those cases - if you are stuck in such an area - your only hope is to distance yourself from the riff-raff.
 
You are discounting the economics and relative urbanization of the area. Yes, NC has some very good institutions. But, compared to the concentration of those highly educated to the rest of the state -the highly educated - are sorely outnumbered. Yes, NJ only has Princeton. But, it is close to NY and borders Philly - so it benefits by having people who are educated and economically well off close by and oftentimes they will choose to live in that state - and work somewhere else. Additionally, NJ is HUGE in the pharmaceutical industry which is full of scientists and researchers -etc. Again - a concentrated group of well educated people. Who then, value education. Finland and Singapore the same thing. A concentrated group of well educated people who value education. There may be pockets like that in states whose overall educational rankings are awful.

Its not that you have the higher learning institutions that make it great - its that you are small and that you have a disproportionately large number of really smart well educated people living there. For Mass - that is largely because Boston is a large historic city important for commerce and all your institutions. For MD - it is our institutions AND our defense contractors/ technology industry concentration. For Silicon Valley - its the techies... for Seattle, its the engineers and designers that work for Boeing. But, like I said, you can't replicate that everywhere without some type of high tech industry or institutions of higher learning. For MD and MASS and Singapore, it works out that we are both very concentrated and have a disproportionate number of highly eduated people. In other ares which are not so concentrated - you will only have good performing schools centered around those little pockets of people who are dedicated to advancing education. And, in those cases - if you are stuck in such an area - your only hope is to distance yourself from the riff-raff.

Wisconsin and Minnesota do pretty good. Explain them.
 
Have you thought about the moral question? If the shoe were on the other foot would you want the society doing unto you and unto your children as you are doing unto the people and the children who do not believe in God? In what way do you excuse your immoral behavior?

immoral? Ha!

Let me put it to you this way..

If I went to India, and let's assume for a moment that India has the same government as America, I wouldn't put on a performance of being offended if I saw a Hindu reference in government. As long as it's not forcing the practice of Hinduism, it's just cultural.

What if a kid has never been exposed to the IDEA of a god, and it opens their thoughts new possibilities and wonder?

The question "What if there is something greater than man" is true free thinking, yet, today's self-titled "free-thinkers" want to silence it.
 
Majority rule and the minority "will be fine", right, Jen?

Yet, if the majority is against your obsession, the GOP, then it is suddenly TRULY about "Majority Rule", isn't it?

and you won't assume they'll "be fine". Based on your history, you'll tell them to "shut the F*^k up" and take it.

I usually don't infer like this, but it's easy here.
 
I suspect that Eisenhower felt that, for political reasons, he had to appease the evangelical Christians. Remember that in 1953 he also conveniently converted to Presbyterianism and had himself baptized.
They added under god...to show the commies that we are a god fearing country...
 
The phrase "under God" does not violate the Amendment that says that government may not force a religion on its people. It is NOT going to cause writhing (or any other form of) pain on any one of the tiny percent of the people who are atheists.

If that is deemed worthy of a fight to atheists then they are certainly lucky that they don't have any truly important things to fight about.


what an incredibly stupid post.

Exactly what do atheists have to fight about as a group with such narrow interests but those of this sort?

The poll, called “The Global Index of Religiosity and Atheism,” found that the number of Americans who say they are “religious” dropped from 73 percent in 2005 (the last time the poll was conducted) to 60 percent.
At the same time, the number of Americans who say they are atheists rose, from 1 percent to 5 percent.
The poll was conducted by WIN-Gallup International and is based on interviews with 50,000 people from 57 countries and five continents. Participants were asked, “Irrespective of whether you attend a place of worship or not, would you say you are a religious person, not a religious person, or a convinced atheist?” http://articles.washingtonpost.com/...519_1_new-atheism-atheist-groups-new-atheists
​
and I'd say that "tiny" number of 5-6% is likely to increase given the number of faux xtians like you around to turn the younger crowd off.
​
 
what an incredibly stupid post.

Exactly what do atheists have to fight about as a group with such narrow interests but those of this sort?

The poll, called “The Global Index of Religiosity and Atheism,” found that the number of Americans who say they are “religious” dropped from 73 percent in 2005 (the last time the poll was conducted) to 60 percent.
At the same time, the number of Americans who say they are atheists rose, from 1 percent to 5 percent.
The poll was conducted by WIN-Gallup International and is based on interviews with 50,000 people from 57 countries and five continents. Participants were asked, “Irrespective of whether you attend a place of worship or not, would you say you are a religious person, not a religious person, or a convinced atheist?” http://articles.washingtonpost.com/...519_1_new-atheism-atheist-groups-new-atheists
​
and I'd say that "tiny" number of 5-6% is likely to increase given the number of faux xtians like you around to turn the younger crowd off.
​

You've benefited from the Christian nature of this nation. The country is coasting on that residual faith. When it does stop you and yours are in for some deep shit.

Do you ever get tired of writing the word stupid or is that as creative as you can get?
 
what an incredibly stupid post.

Exactly what do atheists have to fight about as a group with such narrow interests but those of this sort?

The poll, called “The Global Index of Religiosity and Atheism,” found that the number of Americans who say they are “religious” dropped from 73 percent in 2005 (the last time the poll was conducted) to 60 percent.
At the same time, the number of Americans who say they are atheists rose, from 1 percent to 5 percent.
The poll was conducted by WIN-Gallup International and is based on interviews with 50,000 people from 57 countries and five continents. Participants were asked, “Irrespective of whether you attend a place of worship or not, would you say you are a religious person, not a religious person, or a convinced atheist?” http://articles.washingtonpost.com/...519_1_new-atheism-atheist-groups-new-atheists
​
and I'd say that "tiny" number of 5-6% is likely to increase given the number of faux xtians like you around to turn the younger crowd off.
​

Um.. okay?

Hooray you?

Are you asking for some sort of gold star?

I don't think 5-6% is any sort of movement worthy of demanding much anything. Kudos to you for an upswing in numbers, the atheist religion is certainly finding its niche here in America.
 
When I was 5-6-7 and compelled to recite "The Pledge", I took two issues with it, neither relating to the "under God" part. And, that's not to suggest some sort of qualitative judgment on those who DO take issue with that part! It's simply to suggest what occurred to me at 5-6-7.

First...this was the era when we're being taught the difference between democratic America and authoritarian USSR. So, it seemed odd that we were being called upon to "pledge our allegiance" to anything. I thought that was set us apart from the non-democracies, was that we couldn't be compelled to "pledge" stuff.

And second...this was at the height of our American civil rights travails. So....the part about "liberty and justice for ALL", didn't ring too true with me.
 
The state also has to have the cojones to take Big Dig and Federal subsidy Romneycare monies.

Again, whiteness in regards to NC also matters. And it isn't racial as much as it is cultural the difference.
Perhaps, but if so, that puts the emphasis on the need of some states to alter their cultures. I think in much of the South, the powerful feel its OK to ignore the troubles of the poor because the poor are mostly black and the powerful mostly white. In places where the upper class looks more like the lower class, racially, that kind of neglect doesn't happen as much and so things turn out better.
 
immoral? Ha!

Let me put it to you this way..

If I went to India, and let's assume for a moment that India has the same government as America, I wouldn't put on a performance of being offended if I saw a Hindu reference in government. As long as it's not forcing the practice of Hinduism, it's just cultural.

What if a kid has never been exposed to the IDEA of a god, and it opens their thoughts new possibilities and wonder?

The question "What if there is something greater than man" is true free thinking, yet, today's self-titled "free-thinkers" want to silence it.
Ok, lets talk India. If your kid was at an Indian school would you want him led in a daily pledge that called for him to acknowledge being under "all the gods"? Or would you rather the school treat that theology as a matter for the church or the home, and stick to teaching math, science, etc.? I'm not asking whether you'd "put on a performance" about it. I'm asking about what you'd want done unto your family in that situation. Why is that simple, central moral question difficult for you to answer?
 
You've benefited from the Christian nature of this nation. The country is coasting on that residual faith. When it does stop you and yours are in for some deep shit.

Do you ever get tired of writing the word stupid or is that as creative as you can get?
Considering that most indicators in this country have been improving over the last few decades (e.g., violent crime peaked in 1992), and the ugliest things in our history are a lifetime or more ago (slavery, Jim Crow, over half the population having no right to vote), I'm actually quite drawn to the idea we're a formerly Christian nation that has gradually been losing that religious momentum. That would explain much about what a horrible country we were in the past and how much better we've gotten, as the polluting influence of Residual faith gradually worked its way out of our system.
 
Um.. okay?

Hooray you?

Are you asking for some sort of gold star?

I don't think 5-6% is any sort of movement worthy of demanding much anything. Kudos to you for an upswing in numbers, the atheist religion is certainly finding its niche here in America.
Atheism, by its very definition, isn't a religion. So don't try to pull it down to your level. There are no atheist priests or churches, no inspired atheist scriptures, no dogmas ascribed to some higher power, no supernatural beliefs or holy taboos, no ceremonies, etc. If you are calling it a religion, you're throwing out the entire historical basis for the word. You might as well call democracy a religion, or a bowling league a religion.
 
Where is this? DC? Atlanta? Philadelphia? Detroit? New Orleans?
No. They suffer largely from the cities being neglected because they look so different, racially, from the tax base in the suburbs. In places where cities look more like the suburbs, racially (Massachusetts, Japan, Scandinavia), there's less urban neglect and fewer problems.
 
Atheism, by its very definition, isn't a religion. So don't try to pull it down to your level. There are no atheist priests or churches, no inspired atheist scriptures, no dogmas ascribed to some higher power, no supernatural beliefs or holy taboos, no ceremonies, etc. If you are calling it a religion, you're throwing out the entire historical basis for the word. You might as well call democracy a religion, or a bowling league a religion.

Atheists in the military want atheist chaplains. Atheism is also based on faith. You can't disprove God and yes a negative is proven in mathematics and logic all the time.
 
No. They suffer largely from the cities being neglected because they look so different, racially, from the tax base in the suburbs. In places where cities look more like the suburbs, racially (Massachusetts, Japan, Scandinavia), there's less urban neglect and fewer problems.

They spend $20K + per student per year in DC? How much neglect is that? Atlanta has a great tax base on business properties. The busiest (?) airport in America. Arky, you make a lot of stuff up. It's always whitey's fault is patently absurd.
 
Back
Top