New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Violent Cities

I totally get the "but for the grace of God go I", though suspect you and I might word it differently. Still, same thought and clearly the way to state the sentiment.

Of course, I see things differently. I've been poor. I've been irresponsible. As such, I associated with many people like me. A large majority of people I associated with had serious character flaws that kept them (and me) where they were (and I was) at. Personally, I made substances a priority. Others I knew did the same. Others were just lazy and didn't like to work.

To me, empathy is something an individual engages in. It is not a government action. This is similar to my view on charity. To me, charity is a spirit of giving that leads a person to want to help others. I won't sit here and toot my horn very much, but I'll give an example. When I hire day laborers, I always pay them a few bucks over the going rate, feed them lunch and offer them food from the pantry. I'm sure many people do that and more. Again, it's not about tooting my own horn. It's about realizing that government taking by force from one group and giving to another isn't charity nor empathy.

Regarding housing, why shouldn't poor people live with other poor people? If such a setup ends up with ghettos, that's the responsibility of the residents. I see no reason why we should infect nice neighborhoods with poor people who are far more likely to engage in crime and bring down the area they are moved to. It certainly doesn't lift people up.
I engage in charity, but I'm skeptical about its efficacy as a way to address social problems. For one reason, you don't tend to get as good of economies of scale, since it tends to be lots of little inefficient measures. Also, I think charity is even more subject to corruption than state social services -- the aid tends to go not to the most needy but to the best actors (for example, the drug addict who is best at convincing the local church he has found God and will use the aid to get clean rather than to get high). And private charity is less able to deal with problems impacting a whole locality or region -- since private charities tend to be pretty local themselves, when an area gets hit by a problem (e.g., a hurricane in New Orleans or the collapse of the auto industry in Detroit), the very people and organizations that would be relied on for charity may be relatively impoverished, just like everyone else. National-level social services are better situated to cope with such issues.

I just prefer the idea of a big, informed, systematic approach to addressing problems in accordance with rational design, rather than small, often ignorant, and piecemeal approaches of flowing funds to whoever best flatters the egos of the charitable. And there's also the free-rider problem. With government social services, everyone with money pays part of the cost of mitigating the problems of poverty, but with private charity, some rich people can choose not to help, while still benefiting from the positive side effects of poverty mitigation by others.

As for why poor people shouldn't live with other poor people, it's a question of what works and what doesn't. When you get a community that's nearly all poor people, role models and economic networks tend to be confined mostly to fellow poor people. For example, a smart kid growing up in such a community won't tend to get exposed in the schools to a lot of academically minded peers, nor to examples of people who found prosperity through education and "playing by the rules." He won't tend to have many opportunities to be mentored by those who can help guide him out of poverty, because most of those he meets will be those who never made it out themselves. And he won't have the connections once he starts in the working world to get ahead -- though he will tend to have lots of connections in the criminal class who will try to draw him into that life.

Mixed-income housing (e.g., the kind you get when new luxury apartment complexes have to set aside a certain number of units for means-tested low-income residents in order to get a building permit), helps to prevent that kind of slum-formation. It means a greater share of poor kids will go to decent schools, where they'll have academically-minded peers (and maybe even more important, richer parents of peers who help to fund the schools and keep them on track academically). They'll have opportunities for wealthier mentors, they'll be located within walking distance of more job opportunities (even if just chances to mow the lawns of rich neighbors, etc.), and they'll be less tempted by a local culture of crime (since the upper- and middle-class neighbors will push the police to keep a tighter control hold on petty crime).

I think the greater Boston area is a good example of how it can work well. Boston used to have the usual problems you see with geographically concentrated poverty, back in the 70s and early 80s. There was a "combat zone" near downtown, and a lot of poor neighborhoods that were really awful (Roxbury, Dorchester, etc.) But now there's a really strong focus on preventing slum formation by having mixed-income settlement. There's not really a "combat zone" any more. Roxbury and Dorchester still aren't particularly nice, but they're not the kind of neighborhoods I'd hesitate to stroll through, anymore, either (at least in daytime). I think that helps to contribute to the Boston MSA having the lowest murder rate of any large MSA in the country. And I think it also helps explain why Massachusetts public schools are, year in and year out, the best in the country, in terms of NAEP scores. When each school has a sprinkling of poorer kids, those kids tend to be brought up towards the level of their more academically-minded middle- and upper-class peers, whereas when you have some schools that are almost exclusively poor kids, they can become such under-performers that they pull down the whole state. It's not so much that the good Massachusetts public schools are so much better than the good public schools in, say, West Virginia or Mississippi, but rather that there just aren't that many bad public schools in Massachusetts, since there aren't many localized pockets of poverty any more.
 
That is what the left always wants to ignore. The bad choices and character flaws that land people where they are. Some figure it out, and get out. But, there is nothing about being poor that means you don't take care of where you live. And, yet, ghettos are full of trash and vandalized and intentionally damaged. Why is that? Because of the kind of people that live there. Taking that kind of trash out of the ghetto and put it into nice neighborhoods only makes the nice neighborhoods bad.

If that were not the case then all this whining about "white flight" would never have caused communities to become crapholes. If everyone moving there, were good, with good morals, sense of pride in their community and valued cleanliness, organization, private property, etc. - then the neighborhoods would not have been trashed. But, its clear that allowing low income people in- brings with it the problems that keep the vast majority of them low income.

If instead, you are dedicated to improving your life you can. But, what does that mean? it means you likely don't actually associate with the trash you live around. you are busy, very very busy all the time, working as much as you possibly can and taking any learning opportunities you have. You therefore lack the time to get into trouble. You aren't in the wrong place at the wrong time, because you are never anywhere other than work or in bed. You don't have a child out of wedlock that you can't afford because not only do you not have the time to find someone to Fvck you don't actually have the time or energy to Fvck. If you do - then you are not trying hard enough to better yourself.

But, people - they don't try that hard. The let life happen to them, instead of developing a plan and specific goals and methodically working towards them. Some may not be inherrently bad people, but their inability to productively organize and order their lives, their associations, and thier aspierations means they will never get anywhere.

Very very very few people find themselves in poverty - by some horrible tragedy that occured to them overnight. Instead it is the result of systematically making poor choices. Plain and simple. The reason why they can't fix it - is that the left deny's the problem.

connie
http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2008/07/american-murder-mystery/306872/
From the link;
"In my visits with former Dixie Homes tenants who’d moved around the city, I came across the same mix of reactions that researchers had found. The residents who had always been intent on moving out of Dixie Homes anyway seemed to be thriving; those who’d been pushed out against their will, which was the vast majority, seemed dislocated and ill at ease.

I met 30-year-old Sheniqua Woodard, a single mother of three who’d been getting her four-year degree while living at Dixie. She was now working at a city mental-health clinic and about to start studying toward a master’s degree in special education. She’d moved as far out of the city as she could, to a house with a big backyard. She said, “The fact of being in my own home? Priceless.”

But I also met La Sasha Rodgers, who was 19 when Dixie was torn down (now she’s 21). “A lot of people thought it was bad, because they didn’t live there,” she told me. “But it was like one big family. It felt like home. If I could move back now, the way it was, I would.” She moved out to a house in South Memphis with her mother, and all the little cousins and nieces and nephews who drift in during the day. She doesn’t know anyone else on the block. “It’s just here,” she said about her new house. Rodgers may not see them right out her window, but she knows that the “same dope dealers, the same junkies” are just down the block. The threats are no less real, but now they seem distant and dull, as if she were watching neighborhood life on TV. At Dixie, when there were shots at the corner store, everyone ran out to see what was happening. Now, “if somebody got shot, we wouldn’t get up to see.”

Rodgers didn’t finish high school, although she did get her GED, and she’s never had a job. Still, “I know I have to venture out in the world,” she said, running through her options: Go back to school? Get a job? Get married? Have a baby? “I want more. I’m so ready to have my own. I just don’t know how to get it.”
"

Follow the link and read the whole thing; it's long but well worth it.
 
I engage in charity, but I'm skeptical about its efficacy as a way to address social problems. For one reason, you don't tend to get as good of economies of scale, since it tends to be lots of little inefficient measures. Also, I think charity is even more subject to corruption than state social services -- the aid tends to go not to the most needy but to the best actors (for example, the drug addict who is best at convincing the local church he has found God and will use the aid to get clean rather than to get high). And private charity is less able to deal with problems impacting a whole locality or region -- since private charities tend to be pretty local themselves, when an area gets hit by a problem (e.g., a hurricane in New Orleans or the collapse of the auto industry in Detroit), the very people and organizations that would be relied on for charity may be relatively impoverished, just like everyone else. National-level social services are better situated to cope with such issues.

I just prefer the idea of a big, informed, systematic approach to addressing problems in accordance with rational design, rather than small, often ignorant, and piecemeal approaches of flowing funds to whoever best flatters the egos of the charitable. And there's also the free-rider problem. With government social services, everyone with money pays part of the cost of mitigating the problems of poverty, but with private charity, some rich people can choose not to help, while still benefiting from the positive side effects of poverty mitigation by others.

As for why poor people shouldn't live with other poor people, it's a question of what works and what doesn't. When you get a community that's nearly all poor people, role models and economic networks tend to be confined mostly to fellow poor people. For example, a smart kid growing up in such a community won't tend to get exposed in the schools to a lot of academically minded peers, nor to examples of people who found prosperity through education and "playing by the rules." He won't tend to have many opportunities to be mentored by those who can help guide him out of poverty, because most of those he meets will be those who never made it out themselves. And he won't have the connections once he starts in the working world to get ahead -- though he will tend to have lots of connections in the criminal class who will try to draw him into that life.

Mixed-income housing (e.g., the kind you get when new luxury apartment complexes have to set aside a certain number of units for means-tested low-income residents in order to get a building permit), helps to prevent that kind of slum-formation. It means a greater share of poor kids will go to decent schools, where they'll have academically-minded peers (and maybe even more important, richer parents of peers who help to fund the schools and keep them on track academically). They'll have opportunities for wealthier mentors, they'll be located within walking distance of more job opportunities (even if just chances to mow the lawns of rich neighbors, etc.), and they'll be less tempted by a local culture of crime (since the upper- and middle-class neighbors will push the police to keep a tighter control hold on petty crime).

I think the greater Boston area is a good example of how it can work well. Boston used to have the usual problems you see with geographically concentrated poverty, back in the 70s and early 80s. There was a "combat zone" near downtown, and a lot of poor neighborhoods that were really awful (Roxbury, Dorchester, etc.) But now there's a really strong focus on preventing slum formation by having mixed-income settlement. There's not really a "combat zone" any more. Roxbury and Dorchester still aren't particularly nice, but they're not the kind of neighborhoods I'd hesitate to stroll through, anymore, either (at least in daytime). I think that helps to contribute to the Boston MSA having the lowest murder rate of any large MSA in the country. And I think it also helps explain why Massachusetts public schools are, year in and year out, the best in the country, in terms of NAEP scores. When each school has a sprinkling of poorer kids, those kids tend to be brought up towards the level of their more academically-minded middle- and upper-class peers, whereas when you have some schools that are almost exclusively poor kids, they can become such under-performers that they pull down the whole state. It's not so much that the good Massachusetts public schools are so much better than the good public schools in, say, West Virginia or Mississippi, but rather that there just aren't that many bad public schools in Massachusetts, since there aren't many localized pockets of poverty any more.
Wishful thinking. http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2008/07/american-murder-mystery/306872/
From the link;
"HOPE VI stands as a bitter footnote to this story. What began as an “I Have a Dream” social crusade has turned into an urban-redevelopment project. Cities fell so hard for the idea of a new, spiffed-up, gentrified downtown that this vision came to crowd out other goals. “People ask me if HOPE VI was successful, and I have to say, ‘You mean the buildings or the people?’” said Laura Harris, a HOPEVI evaluator in Memphis. “It became seen as a way to get rid of eyesores and attract rich people downtown.” Phyllis Betts told me that when she was interviewing residents leaving the housing projects, “they were under the impression they could move into the new developments on site.” Residents were asked to help name the new developments and consult on the architectural plans. Yet to move back in, residents had to meet strict criteria: if they were not seniors, they had to be working, or in school, or on disability. Their children could not be delinquent in school. Most public-housing residents were scared off by the criteria, or couldn’t meet them, or else they’d already moved and didn’t want to move again. The new HOPE VI developments aimed to balance Section8 and market-rate residents, but this generally hasn’t happened. In Memphis, the rate of former public-housing residents moving back in is 5 percent.

A few months ago, Harris went to a Sunday-afternoon picnic at Uptown Square, the development built on the site of the old Hurt Village project, to conduct a survey. The picnic’s theme was chili cook-off. The white people, mostly young couples, including little kids and pregnant wives, sat around on Eddie Bauer chairs with beer holders, chatting. The black people, mostly women with children, were standing awkwardly around the edges. Harris began asking some of the white people the questions on her survey: Do you lack health insurance? Have you ever not had enough money to buy medication? One said to her, “This is so sad. Does anyone ever answer ‘yes’ to these questions?”—Harris’s first clue that neighbors didn’t talk much across color lines. One of the developers was there that day surveying the ideal community he’d built, and he was beaming. “Isn’t this great?” he asked Harris, and she remembers thinking, Are you kidding me? They’re all sitting 20 feet away from each other!"
 
I engage in charity, but I'm skeptical about its efficacy as a way to address social problems. For one reason, you don't tend to get as good of economies of scale, since it tends to be lots of little inefficient measures. Also, I think charity is even more subject to corruption than state social services -- the aid tends to go not to the most needy but to the best actors (for example, the drug addict who is best at convincing the local church he has found God and will use the aid to get clean rather than to get high). And private charity is less able to deal with problems impacting a whole locality or region -- since private charities tend to be pretty local themselves, when an area gets hit by a problem (e.g., a hurricane in New Orleans or the collapse of the auto industry in Detroit), the very people and organizations that would be relied on for charity may be relatively impoverished, just like everyone else. National-level social services are better situated to cope with such issues.

I can understand your confusion. Your first problem is you don't even understand what charity is. The primary definition:

char·i·ty
ˈCHerədē/
noun
noun: charity; plural noun: charities
1
.
the voluntary giving of help, typically in the form of money, to those in need.

You see that? It's the VOLUNTARY giving of help. Money taken by force does not constitute anything voluntary. That said, I certainly understand your love of the almighty state. And with liberals running things, we can certainly expect that many people will end up in trouble. Katrina and Detroit are two fine examples of big government liberalism in action. Detroit was obviously destroyed by unions who thought nominally skilled labor was worth six figures. I still recall a puff piece about some poor schmuck who worked for Adelphi and how sad it was he couldn't make six figures driving a forklift anymore. Boo [Unwelcome language removed] hoo. Katrina? Can you imagine anything more stupid than people being told a Cat 4 hurricane is on the way, and so many of them stay in its path either because they're simply too stupid, so reliant on government that they didn't know what to do or wanted to stay behind to loot. And big government liberal George W. Obama, er, Bush wanting to continue pouring money into a city below sea level and in a hurricane zone? Then of course there's the fact the Obama cartel has resulted in 13,000,000 more people on food stamps and the poverty rate increased. Your solution? Throw more borrowed money at the problem!

I just prefer the idea of a big, informed, systematic approach to addressing problems in accordance with rational design, rather than small, often ignorant, and piecemeal approaches of flowing funds to whoever best flatters the egos of the charitable. And there's also the free-rider problem. With government social services, everyone with money pays part of the cost of mitigating the problems of poverty, but with private charity, some rich people can choose not to help, while still benefiting from the positive side effects of poverty mitigation by others.

You're getting funnier with each paragraph. The same drug addict you whined about can and probably does get aid from government welfare agencies. Of course, your hatred of religion is always seeping out as well. Whatsa matter, God didn't answer one of your prayers and you've been having a tantrum ever since?
As for why poor people shouldn't live with other poor people, it's a question of what works and what doesn't. When you get a community that's nearly all poor people, role models and economic networks tend to be confined mostly to fellow poor people. For example, a smart kid growing up in such a community won't tend to get exposed in the schools to a lot of academically minded peers, nor to examples of people who found prosperity through education and "playing by the rules." He won't tend to have many opportunities to be mentored by those who can help guide him out of poverty, because most of those he meets will be those who never made it out themselves. And he won't have the connections once he starts in the working world to get ahead -- though he will tend to have lots of connections in the criminal class who will try to draw him into that life.

Now you have illustrated the failure of our education system. You're making this quite easy. Of course, it's proven fact that when you move parasites into a nice neighborhood, it doesn't lift the parasites up. It drags the nice neighborhood down. But do let me know when you go to your next city council meeting to demand Section 8 Housing be built in your neighborhood.

Didn't think so.

Mixed-income housing (e.g., the kind you get when new luxury apartment complexes have to set aside a certain number of units for means-tested low-income residents in order to get a building permit), helps to prevent that kind of slum-formation. It means a greater share of poor kids will go to decent schools, where they'll have academically-minded peers (and maybe even more important, richer parents of peers who help to fund the schools and keep them on track academically). They'll have opportunities for wealthier mentors, they'll be located within walking distance of more job opportunities (even if just chances to mow the lawns of rich neighbors, etc.), and they'll be less tempted by a local culture of crime (since the upper- and middle-class neighbors will push the police to keep a tighter control hold on petty crime).

Again you point out the failure of government education. And as an extra added bonus, you make the assertion that poor kids aren't interested in academics (of course you really mean black people, so you're showing your racism). But why can't black people push the police to keep a tighter control on crime? Do you not think black people are worth listening to and need white people to speak for them? Apparently so.

I think the greater Boston area is a good example of how it can work well. Boston used to have the usual problems you see with geographically concentrated poverty, back in the 70s and early 80s. There was a "combat zone" near downtown, and a lot of poor neighborhoods that were really awful (Roxbury, Dorchester, etc.) But now there's a really strong focus on preventing slum formation by having mixed-income settlement. There's not really a "combat zone" any more. Roxbury and Dorchester still aren't particularly nice, but they're not the kind of neighborhoods I'd hesitate to stroll through, anymore, either (at least in daytime). I think that helps to contribute to the Boston MSA having the lowest murder rate of any large MSA in the country. And I think it also helps explain why Massachusetts public schools are, year in and year out, the best in the country, in terms of NAEP scores. When each school has a sprinkling of poorer kids, those kids tend to be brought up towards the level of their more academically-minded middle- and upper-class peers, whereas when you have some schools that are almost exclusively poor kids, they can become such under-performers that they pull down the whole state. It's not so much that the good Massachusetts public schools are so much better than the good public schools in, say, West Virginia or Mississippi, but rather that there just aren't that many bad public schools in Massachusetts, since there aren't many localized pockets of poverty any more.

Hilarious stuff which we've touched on before. Boston is double digits less blacks than Chicago, Dallas and Los Angeles. I suspect we'd find Boston has You think it's your liberal pipe dreams that are helping. The crime statistics by race show it's simply a matter of a lower concentration of the most violent race of people in America. Feel free to accuse the FBI of racism if you have a problem with that.

Then of course there's the fact Massachusetts is more white overall. So once again, you simply talk your talk of leftist, statist gobbledygook while ignoring the fact you simply have less of the groups that are the most prone to committing crime.

https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/table/PST045215/25
 
Wishful thinking. http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2008/07/american-murder-mystery/306872/
From the link;
"HOPE VI stands as a bitter footnote to this story. What began as an “I Have a Dream” social crusade has turned into an urban-redevelopment project. Cities fell so hard for the idea of a new, spiffed-up, gentrified downtown that this vision came to crowd out other goals. “People ask me if HOPE VI was successful, and I have to say, ‘You mean the buildings or the people?’” said Laura Harris, a HOPEVI evaluator in Memphis. “It became seen as a way to get rid of eyesores and attract rich people downtown.” Phyllis Betts told me that when she was interviewing residents leaving the housing projects, “they were under the impression they could move into the new developments on site.” Residents were asked to help name the new developments and consult on the architectural plans. Yet to move back in, residents had to meet strict criteria: if they were not seniors, they had to be working, or in school, or on disability. Their children could not be delinquent in school. Most public-housing residents were scared off by the criteria, or couldn’t meet them, or else they’d already moved and didn’t want to move again. The new HOPE VI developments aimed to balance Section8 and market-rate residents, but this generally hasn’t happened. In Memphis, the rate of former public-housing residents moving back in is 5 percent.

A few months ago, Harris went to a Sunday-afternoon picnic at Uptown Square, the development built on the site of the old Hurt Village project, to conduct a survey. The picnic’s theme was chili cook-off. The white people, mostly young couples, including little kids and pregnant wives, sat around on Eddie Bauer chairs with beer holders, chatting. The black people, mostly women with children, were standing awkwardly around the edges. Harris began asking some of the white people the questions on her survey: Do you lack health insurance? Have you ever not had enough money to buy medication? One said to her, “This is so sad. Does anyone ever answer ‘yes’ to these questions?”—Harris’s first clue that neighbors didn’t talk much across color lines. One of the developers was there that day surveying the ideal community he’d built, and he was beaming. “Isn’t this great?” he asked Harris, and she remembers thinking, Are you kidding me? They’re all sitting 20 feet away from each other!"
Reminds me of East Palo Alto. (Anything with "East" in front of it is crap. It was the 1994 murder capital of the US.) We lived in the "gentrified" section--good housing at cheap prices ($800k for 2200 sq ft. Cheap for the Bay Area but expensive if you just moved there or didn't have a job. We rented.) I had my wake up call and became a gun owner after two events in the neighborhood: I was assaulted on my bike, and a murder a block and a half from our house. I figured, "I'm an American. I don't have to put up with this bullshit. I can buy a gun." So I did.

And why not? Marksman in the Air Force. I had the training. And I have the 2nd Amendment. You wouldn't think of compromising your 1st Amendment rights so why compromise your 2nd Amendment rights? A right unexercised is a right wasted. I bought a Glock 21. Then we moved to Gilroy 40 miles away.

Never looked back since.
 
You're getting funnier with each paragraph. The same drug addict you whined about can and probably does get aid from government welfare agencies. Of course, your hatred of religion is always seeping out as well. Whatsa matter, God didn't answer one of your prayers and you've been having a tantrum ever since?

He answered his prayer. The answer was, "No." But he is a liberal intellectual so he thinks he knows better than God.
 
Wishful thinking. http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2008/07/american-murder-mystery/306872/
From the link;
"HOPE VI stands as a bitter footnote to this story. What began as an “I Have a Dream” social crusade has turned into an urban-redevelopment project. Cities fell so hard for the idea of a new, spiffed-up, gentrified downtown that this vision came to crowd out other goals. “People ask me if HOPE VI was successful, and I have to say, ‘You mean the buildings or the people?’” said Laura Harris, a HOPEVI evaluator in Memphis. “It became seen as a way to get rid of eyesores and attract rich people downtown.” Phyllis Betts told me that when she was interviewing residents leaving the housing projects, “they were under the impression they could move into the new developments on site.” Residents were asked to help name the new developments and consult on the architectural plans. Yet to move back in, residents had to meet strict criteria: if they were not seniors, they had to be working, or in school, or on disability. Their children could not be delinquent in school. Most public-housing residents were scared off by the criteria, or couldn’t meet them, or else they’d already moved and didn’t want to move again. The new HOPE VI developments aimed to balance Section8 and market-rate residents, but this generally hasn’t happened. In Memphis, the rate of former public-housing residents moving back in is 5 percent.

A few months ago, Harris went to a Sunday-afternoon picnic at Uptown Square, the development built on the site of the old Hurt Village project, to conduct a survey. The picnic’s theme was chili cook-off. The white people, mostly young couples, including little kids and pregnant wives, sat around on Eddie Bauer chairs with beer holders, chatting. The black people, mostly women with children, were standing awkwardly around the edges. Harris began asking some of the white people the questions on her survey: Do you lack health insurance? Have you ever not had enough money to buy medication? One said to her, “This is so sad. Does anyone ever answer ‘yes’ to these questions?”—Harris’s first clue that neighbors didn’t talk much across color lines. One of the developers was there that day surveying the ideal community he’d built, and he was beaming. “Isn’t this great?” he asked Harris, and she remembers thinking, Are you kidding me? They’re all sitting 20 feet away from each other!"
Yes, I'm sure that even in mixed-income areas, interaction among the classes is limited by the usual dynamics of social circles and self-segregation. But it's still going to be more than when people are sitting 2 miles away from each other rather than 20 feet.
 
I can understand your confusion. Your first problem is you don't even understand what charity is.

A society and a nation can choose things, too. The "consent of the governed" doesn't have to mean the consent of every individual who is governed.

The same drug addict you whined about can and probably does get aid from government welfare agencies.

Perhaps. But he does so in accordance with specific rules that treat all evenly, not by being the best at playing along with the superstitions of a church or flatting the ego of a rich person.

God didn't answer one of your prayers and you've been having a tantrum ever since?

Exactly like you, I have no evidence that there is a God. The difference is that I don't feel the need to pretend otherwise.

Of course, it's proven fact that when you move parasites into a nice neighborhood, it doesn't lift the parasites up. It drags the nice neighborhood down.

We're not talking about "parasites." We're talking about kids who had the misfortune of being born into poor families. I suppose your benighted religious outlook denies you the moral clarity to see that. But, regardless, you're wrong. Real-world results suggest strongly that when you integrate the poor into wealthier school systems, they tend to be pulled up, rather than others being pulled down. Take a look at the NAEP test results by state. Which states tend to dominate? Is it those that have segregated rich and poor, and thereby allowed a few top schools to excel without the "parasites." Or is it those that have integrated?

But do let me know when you go to your next city council meeting to demand Section 8 Housing be built in your neighborhood.

We don't have a city council. We have a town hall. And yes, despite being a wealthier town, we have affordable housing.

you make the assertion that poor kids aren't interested in academics (of course you really mean black people, so you're showing your racism)

If your read "poor" and think "black," whose racism is being revealed here?

Boston is double digits less blacks than Chicago, Dallas and Los Angeles

And they have a higher share of poor whites. Poverty exists in all big urban areas. But in greater Boston, it causes a whole lot less social problems. Perhaps other areas would be wise to look into what Boston does differently.

Then of course there's the fact Massachusetts is more white overall

Massachusetts is an exactly median state, when it comes to percentage of whiteness. A lot of racists simply assume Massachusetts is unusually white, because they know it's doing well and can't even imagine that being possible unless Massachusetts were one of the whitest states.
 
A society and a nation can choose things, too. The "consent of the governed" doesn't have to mean the consent of every individual who is governed.
And charity is a strictly individual matter. Clearly you don't understand charity.

Perhaps. But he does so in accordance with specific rules that treat all evenly, not by being the best at playing along with the superstitions of a church or flatting the ego of a rich person.

HA! As if fraud doesn't exist in government programs! Perhaps you don't understand them as well either!

Exactly like you, I have no evidence that there is a God. The difference is that I don't feel the need to pretend otherwise.

The case can easily be made that it takes more faith to NOT believe in God than it does to believe.

Which societies have flourished throughout history? Aztecs, Mayans, Hittites, Cannanites, Assyrians, Nazi Germany? No, their all dead. Jews, Western Civilization, Chinese and Indian cultures? Yep. What do the latter have that the former don't? Answer: Natural Law.

How does Natural Law in the Bible apply to the modern state? The cycle of bondage, faith, courage, freedom, abundance, apathy, dependence, and bondage again is in full swing in America. The colonials under George III cried out to God who heard their prayers and gave them great leaders like Washington to lead them to freedom which led them to abundance and apathy (with respect to the issue of slavery). Slavery instead of being wiped out, grew and the South became dependent on it. Slaves and abolitionists cried out to God who heard their prayers etc. Civil War and freedom. The cycle continues to this day where we are transitioning from apathy to dependence. Bondage is in our near future.

Quantum Mechanics. Einstein said, "God does not play dice." In fact He does play dice. Furthermore, He owns the dice. And He loads the dice as He sees fit. You don't believe in miracles whether they are detailed in history or in your own life so you are blind.

Furthermore, the very logic you claim to profess is merely faith in different direction. Twentieth century philosophers like Derrida blow logic away by urging us to "resist the tyranny of logic." An unintended consequence of a lot of 20th century nihilist philosophy is that it has correctly framed logic as merely another belief. Nobody HAS to believe in logic. It is an act of faith. Belief in logic is just another leap of faith.

I never said God can be proven. But with these examples and countless others that could fill volumes it is clear that it takes more faith to NOT believe in God than it takes to believe. You believe first, then you know. Ignore the obvious at your peril.
 
And charity is a strictly individual matter. Clearly you don't understand charity.

Incorrect. Historically, charity has often been a matter of groups. For example, you should have no problem locating references to charity by nations, clubs, corporations, teams, and churches. If you want to invent a new definition for the word, have fun with your private language, but in standard English, there's never been a necessary "individual" qualifier on the word.

As if fraud doesn't exist in government programs!

Here's what I said: "Also, I think charity is even more subject to corruption than state social services...."

You see that bit about "even more"? Obviously, I'm not trying to suggest fraud doesn't exist in government programs. It's bizarre I have to explain this stuff to adults. Step up your game.

The case can easily be made that it takes more faith to NOT believe in God than it does to believe.

No, no case can be made to that effect. Not believing in something requires no faith at all. Believing in something without any evidence takes faith. If it helps you understand the concept, just transpose this from the supernatural belief you have (the belief in God), to one you don't have (say, a belief in reincarnation, or in a pantheon of gods, or in magical flying dragons). Does it take faith for you not to believe in magical flying dragons? Or is non-belief simply the default in the absence of any supporting evidence?

Which societies have flourished throughout history?

No society has ever flourished "throughout history." Every social order that was around at the dawn of history has been completely disrupted at some point since then. The social orders around today showed up at some later point. For example, the two major religious factions that are flourishing most broadly today are the Christians and the Muslims, neither of which were around until well after the mid-point in recorded history.

Anyway, you can take a snapshot at any instant in history and argue that whatever cultures happen to be around at that instant must have something going for them, but it would be foolish to extrapolate a general rule from that. For example, let's say the year is 1300 BC. We could look around at the dominant civilizations at the time, and ask what they had in common. We'd find they were all polytheistic. Does that mean that polytheism is necessary for a civilization to thrive? Was the failure of monotheism in Egypt (where there was a disastrous experiment under Akhenaten) proof that monotheism is fated to fail? We know better now. But if we were to look at it without the benefit of hindsight, a great fool could try to extrapolate from what was seen in that one snapshot a general polytheistic rule.

What do the latter have that the former don't? Answer: Natural Law.

Every culture believes they embrace "natural law." For example, for the Mayans, it was natural that kings would serve as the intermediary for their ancestors to intervene in creating prosperity for their tribes.

The colonials under George III cried out to God who heard their prayers and gave them great leaders like Washington to lead them to freedom which led them to abundance and apathy (with respect to the issue of slavery)

Back in London they were calling out to God, too. There's no sign that God intervened one way or the other, or even that God exists.

Slaves and abolitionists cried out to God

So did the slavers, who were firmly convinced God favored slavery (and they had ample Biblical support for the notion).
 
Incorrect. Historically, charity has often been a matter of groups.
For example, you should have no problem locating references to charity by nations, clubs, corporations, teams, and churches.

You've conflated national "charity"--which is compulsory--with church charity--which is optional and exercised as a matter of free will. The difference between those two styles cannot be over emphasized. It is the difference between oppression and freedom--state and God. I suspect you know this and are being deceptive because as a Triple 9er you are too smart to be that stupid.

Do you feel "charitable" on tax day, April 15th? Of course not. Nobody who is honest with themselves feels that way. Because free will is not a part of that transaction. You are either paying for a war you don't agree with or the salary of a president who divides the nation with some community organizing bullshit, or Obamaphones and EBT cards that enslave the poor. You pay your taxes because if you don't you'll go to jail. If you resist, you'll be shot. Is your INDIVIDUAL heart changed by paying taxes? No.

Is it changed by freely giving? Yes. Because your heart is moved to give. That is a barrier which government can never cross. Ever try to force love? It doesn't work. Same thing here. Charity, love, they are pretty interchangible. Faith, hope and love or faith, hope, and charity. Take your pick.

Here's what I said: "Also, I think charity is even more subject to corruption than state social services...."
Why don't you shit me out some statistics and "prove" it?
No, no case can be made to that effect. Not believing in something requires no faith at all. Believing in something without any evidence takes faith. If it helps you understand the concept, just transpose this from the supernatural belief you have (the belief in God), to one you don't have (say, a belief in reincarnation, or in a pantheon of gods, or in magical flying dragons). Does it take faith for you not to believe in magical flying dragons? Or is non-belief simply the default in the absence of any supporting evidence?
My belief in God would be at odds with this belief in magical flying dragons. You RELY on some semblance of logic so you BELIEVE in logic. Next. Unless, of course, you were about to say all your posts slinging stats and "logic" are really just pretend and you don't believe what you've written in them.

Do you believe in logic?

No society has ever flourished "throughout history."
The Judeo-Christian society has survived and at times flourished since the dawn of civilization. You can't say that about Pharaoh, Moloch, Huitzilopochtli, Hitler, or their followers. You assume I took a snapshot in time when actually it is YOU who took the snapshot--another case of projection on your part.

Every culture believes they embrace "natural law." For example, for the Mayans, it was natural that kings would serve as the intermediary for their ancestors to intervene in creating prosperity for their tribes.
They also believed in human sacrifice like the Aztecs and Cannanites which is against Natural Law. How did that turn out for those civilizations?

Paganism does not equal Natural Law. I'm talking about the Natural Law of Aristotle, Thomas Aquinas, and John Locke. Real Natural Law. Not "nature." Not "survival of the fittest." Real Natural Law. Figure it out. Crack a book.

Back in London they were calling out to God, too. There's no sign that God intervened one way or the other, or even that God exists.

And how did the Revolutionary War turn out for the English oppressors when the colonials embodied Natural Law in their own Declaration of Independence and followed up with a Constitution that has Natural Law running through it?

So did the slavers, who were firmly convinced God favored slavery (and they had ample Biblical support for the notion).

Yes and how did the Civil War turn out for the slavers?

How did things go for the European kings who pointed to the Bible and justified the "Divine Right of Kings?" How did it go for them when Guttenberg brought the Bible to the masses and had them read the words of Romans 13: 1-7 for themselves? Have you seen my signature? Have you clicked on the link?

Not everyone who claims to support Natural Law actually supports it. And the consequences for those who don't are the more bloody parts of history.
 
Paganism does not equal Natural Law. I'm talking about the Natural Law of Aristotle, Thomas Aquinas, and John Locke. Real Natural Law. Not "nature." Not "survival of the fittest." Real Natural Law. Figure it out. Crack a book.

Great point. A little education would really benefit someone like @Arkady, who doesn't understand that natural, human and civil rights aren't granted by the government, and cannot be taken away by the government, either.
 
You've conflated national "charity"--which is compulsory--with church charity--which is optional and exercised as a matter of free will.

They're both a matter of free will. A person who doesn't want to donate through the church can leave the church. A person who doesn't want to donate through the nation can leave the nation. The difference is that the nation doesn't promise you'll be tortured for all eternity if you leave, whereas often the church insists that's exactly what will happen to someone who leaves them.

Do you feel "charitable" on tax day, April 15th?

I feel charitable on Election Day, in November, when we, the People, CHOOSE who to elect, because I vote morally and help elect people who will work to make the state more charitable, even as I know that will mean higher taxes for me.

Is your INDIVIDUAL heart changed by paying taxes?

Yes, of course it is. I know I have a choice in the matter. I don't do it to buy myself a ticket to some sanctuary in the sky or to spare myself a one way trip to a lake of fire. I'm not serving myself the way a religious person would be with his so-called charity. I'm acting selflessly. And, yes, doing so has a positive impact on me as an individual, in the spiritual sense, even if it makes me poorer in the material sense.

My belief in God would be at odds with this belief in magical flying dragons

Why? Just as you have no evidence that God exists, you also have no evidence that if God were to exist, he wouldn't have created magical flying dragons.

Do you believe in logic?

Of course. However, if I lived in a universe where there was no evidence that logic actually worked, I wouldn't.

The Judeo-Christian society has survived and at times flourished since the dawn of civilization

Incorrect. Civilization dates back around 7300 years, with the first cities settled by Sumer. Judaism in anything like its current form dates to the Babylonian captivity, around 600 BCE. Even if you go way back to proto-Judaism with their mythological origins in the story of Moses who first received the Law from Yahweh, that would put Judaism's origin in Egypt's eighteenth or nineteenth dynasty. If you date the Exodus to Ramses the Great, around 1800 years had passed between Egypt's first Pharaoh and the start of Judaism. And Egypt's first Pharaoh wasn't even the beginning of their civilization. He was merely the person who united the Upper and Lower Nile kingdoms into a single kingdom. Meanwhile, Christianity dates back only about 2000 years.

They also believed in human sacrifice like the Aztecs and Cannanites which is against Natural Law.

So did Judaism -- according to their own myths, the righteous Abraham was willing to make a human sacrifice of his own kid.

And how did the Revolutionary War turn out for the English oppressors when the colonials embodied Natural Law in their own Declaration of Independence and followed up with a Constitution that has Natural Law running through it?

The colonials and the English both thought they were enacting natural law.

Yes and how did the Civil War turn out for the slavers?

Poorly. Yet another example of how things can turn out badly for those who have convinced themselves natural law dictates whatever rules they personally have settled on.

How did things go for the European kings who pointed to the Bible and justified the "Divine Right of Kings?"

Quite well. The vast majority of them lived out unusually long and prosperous lives for their eras.

Not everyone who claims to support Natural Law actually supports it. And the consequences for those who don't are the more bloody parts of history.
Agreed. You're a great example. But that's the point. Everyone THINKS he supports natural law.
 
I feel charitable on Election Day, in November, when we, the People, CHOOSE who to elect, because I vote morally and help elect people who will work to make the state more charitable, even as I know that will mean higher taxes for me.

How many "charities" do you know besides the government that collect "contributions" at gunpoint?
 
http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2008/07/american-murder-mystery/306872/
From the link;
"In my visits with former Dixie Homes tenants who’d moved around the city, I came across the same mix of reactions that researchers had found. The residents who had always been intent on moving out of Dixie Homes anyway seemed to be thriving; those who’d been pushed out against their will, which was the vast majority, seemed dislocated and ill at ease.

I met 30-year-old Sheniqua Woodard, a single mother of three who’d been getting her four-year degree while living at Dixie. She was now working at a city mental-health clinic and about to start studying toward a master’s degree in special education. She’d moved as far out of the city as she could, to a house with a big backyard. She said, “The fact of being in my own home? Priceless.”

But I also met La Sasha Rodgers, who was 19 when Dixie was torn down (now she’s 21). “A lot of people thought it was bad, because they didn’t live there,” she told me. “But it was like one big family. It felt like home. If I could move back now, the way it was, I would.” She moved out to a house in South Memphis with her mother, and all the little cousins and nieces and nephews who drift in during the day. She doesn’t know anyone else on the block. “It’s just here,” she said about her new house. Rodgers may not see them right out her window, but she knows that the “same dope dealers, the same junkies” are just down the block. The threats are no less real, but now they seem distant and dull, as if she were watching neighborhood life on TV. At Dixie, when there were shots at the corner store, everyone ran out to see what was happening. Now, “if somebody got shot, we wouldn’t get up to see.”

Rodgers didn’t finish high school, although she did get her GED, and she’s never had a job. Still, “I know I have to venture out in the world,” she said, running through her options: Go back to school? Get a job? Get married? Have a baby? “I want more. I’m so ready to have my own. I just don’t know how to get it.”
"

Follow the link and read the whole thing; it's long but well worth it.

Wow, very interesting. Of course, it goes against the nonsense the vast majority of lefties would have us believe, but since we all know they are FOS - I guess that would make sense.

I think what really is sad about that great social experiment is how it ruined the lives of lower middle class people who were living in already transitional neighborhoods and drug them down. Of course too what it ignores is the the contribution the breakdown of the two parent family has had on the increase of families living in poverty.

The reality is is two parents stay together - both making 25K a year, they live middle class. But, when they break - and they each go off and make their 25 K. And one takes up with another person.. starts another family - now his 25K is spread betweeen two households ( assuming he even attempts to honor his obligations to the first). Now you have twice the number of people trying to live on 75K.... which drags them under the poverty line. Even if he goes and just makes his own household and is trying to to the right thing, he has less money to contribute to his family because now the same money has to pay two rents, two utilitiy bills, etc...... I have a lot of friends and family that circle the poverty line. None of them are married families with two parents in the home. They may be lower middle class, but they do not live in poverty. And, the homelives are better - simply for having two people to share the burdens.
 
Back
Top