Arkady
President
I engage in charity, but I'm skeptical about its efficacy as a way to address social problems. For one reason, you don't tend to get as good of economies of scale, since it tends to be lots of little inefficient measures. Also, I think charity is even more subject to corruption than state social services -- the aid tends to go not to the most needy but to the best actors (for example, the drug addict who is best at convincing the local church he has found God and will use the aid to get clean rather than to get high). And private charity is less able to deal with problems impacting a whole locality or region -- since private charities tend to be pretty local themselves, when an area gets hit by a problem (e.g., a hurricane in New Orleans or the collapse of the auto industry in Detroit), the very people and organizations that would be relied on for charity may be relatively impoverished, just like everyone else. National-level social services are better situated to cope with such issues.I totally get the "but for the grace of God go I", though suspect you and I might word it differently. Still, same thought and clearly the way to state the sentiment.
Of course, I see things differently. I've been poor. I've been irresponsible. As such, I associated with many people like me. A large majority of people I associated with had serious character flaws that kept them (and me) where they were (and I was) at. Personally, I made substances a priority. Others I knew did the same. Others were just lazy and didn't like to work.
To me, empathy is something an individual engages in. It is not a government action. This is similar to my view on charity. To me, charity is a spirit of giving that leads a person to want to help others. I won't sit here and toot my horn very much, but I'll give an example. When I hire day laborers, I always pay them a few bucks over the going rate, feed them lunch and offer them food from the pantry. I'm sure many people do that and more. Again, it's not about tooting my own horn. It's about realizing that government taking by force from one group and giving to another isn't charity nor empathy.
Regarding housing, why shouldn't poor people live with other poor people? If such a setup ends up with ghettos, that's the responsibility of the residents. I see no reason why we should infect nice neighborhoods with poor people who are far more likely to engage in crime and bring down the area they are moved to. It certainly doesn't lift people up.
I just prefer the idea of a big, informed, systematic approach to addressing problems in accordance with rational design, rather than small, often ignorant, and piecemeal approaches of flowing funds to whoever best flatters the egos of the charitable. And there's also the free-rider problem. With government social services, everyone with money pays part of the cost of mitigating the problems of poverty, but with private charity, some rich people can choose not to help, while still benefiting from the positive side effects of poverty mitigation by others.
As for why poor people shouldn't live with other poor people, it's a question of what works and what doesn't. When you get a community that's nearly all poor people, role models and economic networks tend to be confined mostly to fellow poor people. For example, a smart kid growing up in such a community won't tend to get exposed in the schools to a lot of academically minded peers, nor to examples of people who found prosperity through education and "playing by the rules." He won't tend to have many opportunities to be mentored by those who can help guide him out of poverty, because most of those he meets will be those who never made it out themselves. And he won't have the connections once he starts in the working world to get ahead -- though he will tend to have lots of connections in the criminal class who will try to draw him into that life.
Mixed-income housing (e.g., the kind you get when new luxury apartment complexes have to set aside a certain number of units for means-tested low-income residents in order to get a building permit), helps to prevent that kind of slum-formation. It means a greater share of poor kids will go to decent schools, where they'll have academically-minded peers (and maybe even more important, richer parents of peers who help to fund the schools and keep them on track academically). They'll have opportunities for wealthier mentors, they'll be located within walking distance of more job opportunities (even if just chances to mow the lawns of rich neighbors, etc.), and they'll be less tempted by a local culture of crime (since the upper- and middle-class neighbors will push the police to keep a tighter control hold on petty crime).
I think the greater Boston area is a good example of how it can work well. Boston used to have the usual problems you see with geographically concentrated poverty, back in the 70s and early 80s. There was a "combat zone" near downtown, and a lot of poor neighborhoods that were really awful (Roxbury, Dorchester, etc.) But now there's a really strong focus on preventing slum formation by having mixed-income settlement. There's not really a "combat zone" any more. Roxbury and Dorchester still aren't particularly nice, but they're not the kind of neighborhoods I'd hesitate to stroll through, anymore, either (at least in daytime). I think that helps to contribute to the Boston MSA having the lowest murder rate of any large MSA in the country. And I think it also helps explain why Massachusetts public schools are, year in and year out, the best in the country, in terms of NAEP scores. When each school has a sprinkling of poorer kids, those kids tend to be brought up towards the level of their more academically-minded middle- and upper-class peers, whereas when you have some schools that are almost exclusively poor kids, they can become such under-performers that they pull down the whole state. It's not so much that the good Massachusetts public schools are so much better than the good public schools in, say, West Virginia or Mississippi, but rather that there just aren't that many bad public schools in Massachusetts, since there aren't many localized pockets of poverty any more.