New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Was Aikin Really Wrong?

Yuri,what you just posted is so true.

Democrats are called all kinds of names, but which party wants to go into your body and tell you what to do with it, when something happens you have no control over. A hideous crime that no woman should ever have to suffer through. And Cons want them to pay afterward,too.The crime is not bad enough.

MaryAnne. I don't mince words.

As many know I survived the plague of ignorance , political lying and brainwashing some time ago on different continent.
I can spot that growing filth here as well .
The new GOP is a bunch of scumbags , lying swine , shameless Taliban -like , Maoist tactical totalitarian in nature POSs.
If tomorrow some like Reince or Ryan and ilk will meet their creator for a judgment, I will pop up champagne to celebrate a good riddance the Americans will get from this dangerous plague and demagogues
 
Really? Rape is rape? What is it when it's a 16 year old boy and a 15 year old girl, and they've gotten drunk on their first-ever bottle of wine and had sex? In some places, that's rape. In others, it's not. What if it's a 23-year-old female teacher and a 17 year old male student? That's rape in most jurisdictions in the U.S.

Of course, those are "consensual" acts where there is doubt about the ability to give consent because of age, or intoxication or a combination thereof.

But what of what I think of as "morning after rape" -- the "victim" wakes up and yells rape? I know of one person who served jail time in such an incident.

The point is, there are multiple things the law defines as rape -- Obama is simply wrong if he said "rape is rape."

People who know my perspective within this forum know I'm in favor of abortion, I still want to make it clear that the upcoming example is not my own personal point of view.

If "rape is rape," then wouldn't it also be fair to say, "life is life," and that the progeny created via a rape has as much right to live as those created via consensual sexual activity?

The world is obviously a more complex place.

So you're trying to suggest there ARE legitimate definitions of rape and definitions that are NOT legitimate???

So how does a law define rape, then others suggest that a law that defines what rape is can be deemed illegitimate?

I think the point is, if it is considered rape, regardless of how it is defined by law, it is rape. It's like trying to say a white person really isn't human because their color doesn't fit someone's personal description of what a human is.

If any of the acts you listed are considered rape, how does one them suggest some are "legitimate", some are not? Even Aitken's response that he meant the word "forcible" does not really change what looks to be an intent to suggest that only forcible rape is "legitimate" all other forms are somehow, by some otherworldly definition, not recognized or considered rape, even if they are on the law books as being defined as rape.

It appears you may be confusing the definition of rape with legitimate proof that the definitions were met. I don't believe anyone here assumes that someone is not going to try to question the validity of anyone's charge if the evidence is nebulous and that is why abuse of the accusation of rape, by some is perhaps more heinous than rape itself as it only harms rape victims.

As has been pointed out, rapists would like nothing more than to have their crime considered to be illegitimate or stories made up by women intending to "put them away" and men who will always try to suggest that 'the woman asked for it' by their behavior, manner of dress or some other factor, forgetting that if a woman says no, that means NO!

While there might be gray areas where coercion, aside from the age difference and legal definition, may appear to be obvious. Some of them as you mentioned with two teenage kids who got drunk and had no clue about the law or were even attracted to one another and the younger one consented to sex, but the case was brought by the girl's parents, but there are areas which are not gray at all which fall under the same definition. I believe this is why we have a system of justice, people get their day in court and a judge or judge and jury get to hear all sides of the story, then pass judgment. Statuatory rape is still rape, although defined differently than forcible rape. It does not make it an illegitimate form of rape unless one believes the only legitimate form of rape is forcible rape.

http://www.crisisinterventioncenter...pes-of-rape&catid=37:sexual-assault&Itemid=77

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape
 
Got numbers? According to Gallup's presidential tracking poll dated Aug. 20, current figures show Romney at 47 percent and Obama at 46 percent. (Information available here: http://www.gallup.com/poll/election.aspx). It's a dead heat, in other words, and way to early for Obama supporters to declare victory.

All polls but two show President Obama ahead and one of those two is Rassy and it leans way right.


http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/2012/president/us/general_election_romney_vs_obama-1171.html
 
This overreaction to Akin's comments is quite likely fueled by the same sense of desperation exhibited by many RW PJ posters as they come to realize just how badly they are losing this election.

I think it's cute how Fox News has recently decided to "assist" the Obama campaign by recommending that they change their presidential and vice-presidential nominees, etc. I guess they figured that if all of their "helping" of the Romney campaign was backfiring so badly, then their best strategy would be to begin "helping" the Obama campaign instead?

I'm now just sitting back wondering how the comic tragedy of the 2012 Republican presidential campaign can possibly become even more bizarre than it has been thus far. ;)

Good observations.. NS..

Todd Akin Claims He's the Real Victim and Raises Money Off Legitimate Rape

The link in the tweet takes you to a website that contains a fundraising plea disguised as a petition.
Here’s the fundraising pitch,
The people from Missouri who elected me know I’m not perfect. They don’t make perfect people. We all make mistakes. When you make a mistake you tell people you’re sorry, you don’t try and hide it. I made a mistake and I’m sorry.
Unlike Claire McCaskill, I believe that working to protect the most vulnerable in our society is one of my most important responsibilities, and that includes protecting both the unborn and victims of sexual assault. We must move forward and work together to replace Claire McCaskill in the Senate.
But I can’t do this alone… I need your help

Excerpt:
The liberal media who is trying to force him out is none other than Fox News. The “liberals” who are calling for him to quit are people like Karl Rove, Paul Ryan, Mitt Romney, John Ashcroft, and just about every other Republican out there not named Mike Huckabee and the Family Research Council.
http://www.politicususa.com/todd-akin-claims-real-victim-raises-money-legitimate-rape.html
 
Republicans have trouble with women voters. There are a host of cultural reasons for this, and abortion is only the most publicized of them. That is why a lot of Republican leaders are trying to get someone who used the words "legitimate rape" to drop out -- they don't want to be associated with the terminology, no matter how innocuous the intent of the statement.

Akin is right, there are some studies that show women's bodies producing higher acidity/stronger base environments that reject sperm in cases of forcible rape, but he was wrong to cite it as scientific fact as the studies are too limited in nature to be applied generally.

There are some studies that show joining the republicon party immediately lowers a person's intelligence to that of a brain dead earthworm, so maybe Akin is on to something after all.
 
LeRoy: So I guess now, instead of distinguishing between 'legitimate rape' and 'non-legitimate rape', we are being asked to distinguish between 'forcible rape' and 'non-forcible rape'. Would non-forcible rape be equivalent to 'consensual rape'? I.e., some woman tells some man that he can go ahead and rape her, it's OK with her? Or maybe it's when some man starts raping some woman, and after a few strokes, she suddenly changes her mind, as is a woman's prerogative, and is 'cool' with it? And maybe she is suddenly 'into it'? Is that your thinking on this?

There are NO scientific studies that suggest women's bodies reject sperm in the case of rape. This is Republican junk science. If there were any truth to such 'studies', the rape camps that were set up by the Serbians in Bosnia during the ethnic cleansing in the 1990s would not have been successful at all. [The Serbians were raping Muslim women, in concentration camp like setups, and impregnating them in large numbers, and then forcing them to carry those fetuses to term.] And, yes, there were actually Republicans in the 1990s who were outraged that the United States moved to stop that.

Maybe now we know why.

Isn't it funny LeRoy that the right thinks it is more important for a rapist to have a child than it is for a woman to object to her body being violated?
 
trapdoor, you said "If "rape is rape," then wouldn't it also be fair to say, "life is life," and that the progeny created via a rape has as much right to live as those created via consensual sexual activity?".


That statement and many arguments on the subject do seem to forget a major point. A person who is a rapist of any type is pretty well bound to be someone with some sort of mental aberration. Many of those can be inherited. That's a big chance to take.
 
MaryAnne. I don't mince words.

As many know I survived the plague of ignorance , political lying and brainwashing some time ago on different continent.
I can spot that growing filth here as well .
The new GOP is a bunch of scumbags , lying swine , shameless Taliban -like , Maoist tactical totalitarian in nature POSs.
If tomorrow some like Reince or Ryan and ilk will meet their creator for a judgment, I will pop up champagne to celebrate a good riddance the Americans will get from this dangerous plague and demagogues

For now, I think what people are doing may perhaps be all they can do.
http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2012/08/what-to-do-with-political-lies/261189/

Perhaps even beyond that is to implore people to take a more active role in seeking the truth rather than accepting the "information" that is handed down by their favored news source or political affiliation. If the other side's people can lie, why can't our side's too?? It seems it is incumbent upon all people to look beyond what is pleasing to our ears and senses to seek the truth of the matter. Even then we are not going to have 100% proof that what we find is the indisputable truth, but as we seek, we discover a lot of things that "inform" and shape our opinions and that would seem to provide a more informed populous in the direction of the truth.

Unfortunately, as with people who abuse substances, in many cases to escape reality, the first step to recovery is recognizing and acknowledging they have a problem, the next HUGE step is wanting to do something about it, then seeking out help to do something about it.

People have to WANT to seek the truth in order to do so. If the truth hurts much of the time, they aren't going to be interested in seeking it, unless they are of higher character where rather than leap into denial and delusion, they like substance abusers who face their addictions and addiction related problems, face up to their problems and do something about them, even if it is a lot of hard work and takes a lot more fortitude than giving in to running away from the truth and the problem.

Very best Yuri!
Knot
 
Really? Rape is rape? What is it when it's a 16 year old boy and a 15 year old girl, and they've gotten drunk on their first-ever bottle of wine and had sex? In some places, that's rape. Well first it's underage drinking so someone broke a law and sold minors alcohol. Second if the girl was drunk and the boy wasn't, then it's forced rape, it they were both sober enough to know what they were doing, then it was statutory rape in most states. Don't like the law, then change them.
In others, it's not. What if it's a 23-year-old female teacher and a 17 year old male student? That's rape in most jurisdictions in the U.S.
The women would be a pedophile in my state and she would be quilty of raping him (no matter if he enjoyed it), but if the boy forced himself on the teacher, then it's rape and age doesn't matter.
Of course, those are "consensual" acts where there is doubt about the ability to give consent because of age, or intoxication or a combination thereof.
No, dumbazz, if you are too young, to impaired, or a combination of both, you can't give "consent". Just how freaking stupid are you?
But what of what I think of as "morning after rape" -- the "victim" wakes up and yells rape? I know of one person who served jail time in such an incident.
What the hell is "morning after rape"? The girl was gotten drunk and the guy had sex with her after she passed out or something? And when she woke up the next morning she realized what happened and told the law that she wa raped? Good for her, put the bastard behind bars and see how he likes it.
The point is, there are multiple things the law defines as rape -- Obama is simply wrong if he said "rape is rape."
Nope, rape is rape, regardless of how you want to spin it.

People who know my perspective within this forum know I'm in favor of abortion, I still want to make it clear that the upcoming example is not my own personal point of view.

If "rape is rape," then wouldn't it also be fair to say, "life is life," and that the progeny created via a rape has as much right to live as those created via consensual sexual activity?
No, life created by a criminal act against a woman should not be her burden to carry if she chooses not to. An embryo has no say in the matter.The world is obviously a more complex place.

Sure the world is a complex place, but we don't need to make women suffer for crimes committed against them. It sounds like you agree with the Taliban and other extremist Muslims on this issue.
 
Really? Rape is rape? What is it when it's a 16 year old boy and a 15 year old girl, and they've gotten drunk on their first-ever bottle of wine and had sex? In some places, that's rape. In others, it's not. What if it's a 23-year-old female teacher and a 17 year old male student? That's rape in most jurisdictions in the U.S.

Of course, those are "consensual" acts where there is doubt about the ability to give consent because of age, or intoxication or a combination thereof.

But what of what I think of as "morning after rape" -- the "victim" wakes up and yells rape? I know of one person who served jail time in such an incident.

The point is, there are multiple things the law defines as rape -- Obama is simply wrong if he said "rape is rape."

People who know my perspective within this forum know I'm in favor of abortion, I still want to make it clear that the upcoming example is not my own personal point of view.

If "rape is rape," then wouldn't it also be fair to say, "life is life," and that the progeny created via a rape has as much right to live as those created via consensual sexual activity?

The world is obviously a more complex place.

I'm sure you can understand the need to come out strong and say "rape is rape" in the face of republicans wanting to minimize the significance of the crime of rape as it pertains to the victims.....who just happen to be primarily WOMEN.....and who have long been demeaned by conservative men suggesting that they "were asking for it" or "women should just lay back and enjoy it" bullshit. and now we have republicans around the country - mainly men - playing doctor without a license with women's reproductive rights i.e. the republican war on women.
 
trapdoor, you said "If "rape is rape," then wouldn't it also be fair to say, "life is life," and that the progeny created via a rape has as much right to live as those created via consensual sexual activity?".


That statement and many arguments on the subject do seem to forget a major point. A person who is a rapist of any type is pretty well bound to be someone with some sort of mental aberration. Many of those can be inherited. That's a big chance to take.

not really. you seem to suggest most rapes are committed by truly crazy people. that's not the case.
 
Akin's insane babble and the Republican party's platform on rape and abortion ....are essentially the same........
 
trapdoor, you said "If "rape is rape," then wouldn't it also be fair to say, "life is life," and that the progeny created via a rape has as much right to live as those created via consensual sexual activity?".


That statement and many arguments on the subject do seem to forget a major point. A person who is a rapist of any type is pretty well bound to be someone with some sort of mental aberration. Many of those can be inherited. That's a big chance to take.

In addition, the suggestion that life, is life and that the only victim in the case of rape would be the product of it leaves the real victim out of the equation totally, the woman who was raped. Do we want to suggest her life and what she has suffered already counts for nothing?

On a literal basis, I can see the point of trying to suggest if life is life, then how it was formed should not matter. Once could also take that statement from there and suggest that if life is life on a matter of fact basis and is to not be harmed based on that, then it should also not matter what one life does to another, NO life should be harmed regardless of what that life does to another life. That is the basis for further debate about things like the death penalty and war. One could argue that humans doing harm to other humans should be halted, but halting by doing the very things one wants to halt, does not halt the offense in the long term, but offers reasons to perpetuate it, under the belief that the worst purveyor of the offense, can halt all others. (Might makes right). I think we're still working on how to stop humans who harm other human beings without doing the same thing to them, they are doing to others. It's a dilemma for sure, but where what goes on in a women's womb is concerned, the owner of the womb should have full jusrisdiction over what occurs within her own body and there should be no outside judgments as to what she decides to do.

I'm pro-life, but that leads me to my pro-choice position. I'm not sure how some who call themselves "pro-life" insist that a pregnancy must be carried through to term because it is a "life" (as defined by what exactly), then whine about "welfare mamas and babies" or believe health care should only be for "lives" that "earn it" or soldiers are heroes for defeating an enemy by killing more of the enemy than the enemy killed "us".

I think we struggle enough to feed the mouths of children that parents desire to have, love and nurture, why spend so much time trying to force the birth of more who are unwanted? Can we imagine a world where all the children born are actually wanted by their parents to be loved and nurtured? Why are some so adamant about trying to force birth upon those who, for whatever reasons, decide they do not want to give birth at a particular time in their lives?

If life is life, why not consider all life and stop pitting human life against human life, adding to the struggle for survival by adding competition for limited resources that are often squandered and wasted by some of those who claim life is so precious, at least in the womb, or at minus 196 degrees celcius, if not anywhere else.
 
Really? Rape is rape? What is it when it's a 16 year old boy and a 15 year old girl, and they've gotten drunk on their first-ever bottle of wine and had sex? In some places, that's rape. In others, it's not.
Nope... in ALL places that is not rape. Both are minors. It can only LEGALLY be rape if one of them is over 18.


But what of what I think of as "morning after rape" -- the "victim" wakes up and yells rape? I know of one person who served jail time in such an incident.
No you know that a person serving jail time CLAIMS that's what took place. That's very different

If "rape is rape," then wouldn't it also be fair to say, "life is life," and that the progeny created via a rape has as much right to live as those created via consensual sexual activity?

And as KAF pointed out - that is the REAL offensiveness of Aikin's statement. And that is precisely why the condemnation of the GOP leadership is so hypocritical since that is EXACTLY the position of their Vice Presidential nomineee and that of many others. And it is a call to violating the Constitutions prohibition against involuntary servitude by ignoring the rights of the woman who was raped.
 
I'm not sure you understand what Degsme is saying. I can't speak for Degs, but what I see Degs discussing is WHO aside from Democrats have condemned Aiken and asked him to step down. That WHO are members of his own party, including Mitt Romney who suggested he should take the advice of others and abandon his bid for office.

The point is that members of Aiken's party know what he was trying to say even with his mistaken "choice of words", yet they have asked him to not run. Most people don't condemn him for his mistaken choice of words, but for his follow-up which still suggests rape can somehow be divided into lesser and higher degrees of suffering by minor or adult women who suffer it. [/quote\
Spot on KF.
 
The RNC has shown their true colors in too many ways for me to ever want to believe them on anything.
I feel largely the same about the Democratic Party.
Yes you do FEEL that way.

Yet when challenged for a factual basis of such feelings, you seem to keep coming up short and instead respond with strawmen.
 
Back
Top