New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Was Aikin Really Wrong?

 
That depends I guess.

Is this rock-solid conservative belief that women should not have an abortion even after a rape?

or

Is this belief that a woman's body can reject a pregnancy in the case of an actual rape?

You see there's a MAJOR difference there??
 
Dino, if you think a cornerstone for a CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT TO BAN ABORTION RESTS ON THE PREMISE THAT A RAPED WOMAN SHOULD NOT HAVE THE CHOICE to have an abortion----- YOU are seriously delusional. Pal.
 
Of course I believe no such ridiculous notion, I reject the notion out of hand, and think Akin is a crackpot for saying so and should leave the race.

I fail to see where I could have given you any other impression.
 
Dino, if you think a cornerstone for a CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT TO BAN ABORTION RESTS ON THE SCIENCE THAT A RAPED WOMAN can somehow make her body reject the union of egg and sperm ----- YOU are seriously delusional. Pal.
 
Dino, if you think a cornerstone for a CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT TO BAN ABORTION RESTS ON THE PREMISE THAT A RAPED WOMAN SHOULD NOT HAVE THE CHOICE to have an abortion----- YOU are seriously delusional. Pal.

There.
 
Much ado has been made about Aikin's statements. And many many conservative political leaders have condemned what he has said. But frankly I'm not sure they were correct in doing so. Note I'm not advocating what Aikin said. Factually it is stupid, ignorant and demagogic.

That said, I think Aikin is acutally right. He "misspoke" to the extent that he said things he believed but which he knows to be politically toxic and not to be openly aired. I also think he is right that he actually DOES enjoy a lot of support from conservatives for these views. After all, Paul Ryan ONLY supports abortion to save the life of the woman. So fundamentally, Ryan actually DOES agree with what Aikin went on to say http://lybio.net/tag/todd-akin-victims-rarely-get-pregnant-transcription/

"There should be some punishment, but the punishment ought to be on the rapist and not attacking the child."
​
And this is 100% consistent with what Paul Ryan advocates. Its 100% of what social conservatives advocate.

So frankly the conservative leadership that is decrying Aikin's comments is being more than a touch dishonest and is clearly unwilling to stand by its principles.

He was only "wrong", in stating the Repub Party Platform out loud.

That's why they're freaking out.
 
There what?

Can you read??

Of course I believe no such ridiculous notion, I reject the notion out of hand, and think Akin is a crackpot for saying so and should leave the race.

I fail to see where I could have given you any other impression.
 
Do you contend that THIS represents the Republican Platform?


"If it's a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down,"

If so, please demonstrate such by linking to any other Republican saying it.
 
Of course I believe no such ridiculous notion, I reject the notion out of hand, and think Akin is a crackpot for saying so and should leave the race.

Then where does this leave you with Paul Ryan. Because that "crackpot" has sought to pass an Ovum Personhood law. Now while there are legal holes in such a law, the clear intent of such a law is to make ALL abortion - even in the case of rape, or incest - illegal (with only an "balancing test" exception for risk to the life - though not health - of the host woman).

If Aikin is a "crackpot" for believing this is the right approach, does that not also make Paul Ryan a "crackpot"? And that of course is the fundamentl point of discussion I was reaching for with the top post. Yes Aikin "misspoke" - in as much as he said things conservative anti-choice activists normally restrict to private gatherings of like minded folks. But Aikin's CORE BELIEFS - what he self describes as his "Heart on the matter" - is indistinguishable from that of Paul Ryan.

That Ryan is more glib publically - does that make him less of a "crackpot"? And if so, how?
 
Do you contend that THIS represents the Republican Platform?


"If it's a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down,"

If so, please demonstrate such by linking to any other Republican saying it.

Sure - Paul Ryan seeking to pass a law granting full legal personhood to a fertilized Ovum. that essentially says that a victim of rape that gets pregnant DESERVES to BE FORCED to carry to term against her will.
 
.
You are a minority conservative in that you are amoral when it comes to religion, but you are anti-intellectioal and anti-science which is part of the problem here.

First, I am by no means amoral. I'm not formally religious. There's a difference. Second, I'm not anti-intellectual (that would be foolish) and I am certainly not anti-science.


"studies" done by biased organizations with an interest in the outcome that are not peer reviewed in major journals are not "science"
.

I honestly can't remember, at this point, where I read the study regarding the Ph factor of rape victims. I've been seeking the study on-line, but I don't think I read it in an on-line source. I used to subscribe to Scientific American (their online archive doesn't have it that I can find), but in any case, the source wasn't political.
No, you are now conflating a THIRD issue - that of Immune reactions to sperm.

No, immune reactions are different subject. The study I recall was about the ph factor creating a "sperm unfriendly" environment -- it was a stress response. I don't blame you for not accepting my own faulty memory, but neither am I making this up.



YET - you and Mr. Aikin are CONFLATING these three DISTINCT phenomenon as one. As I said - anti-science conservativism.

Define "anti-science." I don't think you're using hte term correctly.
 
Trap, you are anti-science in so many ways. The most noticeable is how you approach climate science, but it shows up in how you structure your proof logic. You apply poltical reasoning to the science process. Sketicism is an important part of the scientific method. But there is a difference between skepticism and the biased cynicism that is how political analysis is done.

Now as to vaginal pH http://www.reproduction-online.org/content/33/1/69.short it is a sperm motility impact, not a sperm mortality impact.http://www.biolreprod.org/content/33/3/588.short

But if you search Scholar.google.com for sperm mortality impacts of Vaginal pH you don't get hits. But if you look for pH and sperm motility for GENDER SELECTION you get hits
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1469-185X.1995.tb01066.x/abstract


Now you are correct, this isn't probitive and we aren't reproductive biologists or obstetricians. But from this we can make a fairly informed assessment that Mr Aikin is "informed" about the biological science of reproduction about as well as Mr Ryan.
 
No, it doesn't. You're totally ignoring the wrong-minded and physiologically incorrect portion of the controversial sentence I posted. That's considered a fringe pseudoscientific archaic belief that is NOT reflected in the Republican platform.
 
Back
Top